Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sell my car to avoid 3 way car sharing?

209 replies

3WayCarShareNoThanks · 22/04/2023 16:14

I own a car, but it used to be my dads car, he sold it to me when he retired on the agreement that he could use it when needed.

It’s worked out fine between us as he only needs it once a week or for appointments, so then I either WFH or he drives me to work and picks me up or we come to another agreement. There’s never been a time when we haven’t managed to find some solution when we’ve both needed the car. We basically live together so it’s been fine (we live on the same road, but he has a garden and I don’t so I often pop round with my DC to use his garden and he pops to mine to use things he doesn’t have like a dishwasher)

That was until December. My brother split with his wife and moved back to our town from a few hours away.

He had to sell his car as he couldn’t afford it on his own. He also had to quit his job as it was a few hours away and he can’t get there without a car.

Now he’s constantly borrowing my car and my dad just says he can. Every job interview or everytime he wants to do anything; meet friends or do a hobby or anything he borrows my car, no consultation with me he just takes it, no thought as to how I’ll get to work or get my DC (I’m a single parent) to their activities or to their dads or to school, I just get told I should “Have more sympathy as I’ve not had to give everything up” or should “Organise to wfh then”.

And my brother never repays the fuel costs either, he literally uses ½ of a tank of fuel and doesn’t even offer to repay me or take it to petrol station and refill it, he just uses it.

I’ve told my dad it needs to stop and he just said it’s his car to so he’ll let my brother use it if he wants to.

I’ve offered to sell it back to them as I can now borrow the money from work to buy myself a slightly newer car anyway but both say they can’t afford it.

I’m tempted to just sell it and buy myself a newer car and not put either of them on the insurance (could even change insurance company to make it easier) but WIBU to do this?

I’m not so bothered about having to WFH, but I’d rather have notice so I can organise to speak to clients by phone or video call rather than having to cancel face to face meetings, and so I can organise for my DC to get to their dads house or hobbies etc by other means - ExH will pick up from me but then I have to collect so it does need to be arranged as we share transport between us, school friends will pick them up on the way passed but I try to then repay the favour, similarly hobbies.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
Nevermind31 · 22/04/2023 19:03

Hello dad, this arrangement doesn’t work for me anymore, I’m in trouble at work and DC is missing out on stuff. I cannot afford to pay for DB’s petrol, and I need to have reliable transport. I will therefore sell the car and buy myself one - do you want to buy it back for X amount - you and DB can share?
and then don’t give them a key, put a steering lock on, and don’t lend it out - sorry, the previous arrangement didn’t work for me

PrtScn · 22/04/2023 19:02

@3WayCarShareNoThanks short term definitely get a steering wheel lock and either put it on your car all the time, or only when you need to use the car to stop your brother leaving you in the lurch.
Then basically tell them they need to top the fuel up when they use it as you’re not made of money and you’re struggling to pay the bills/pay the food shop (even if you aren’t). Then depending on now they react to that sell the car and buy a new one. Maybe give them one last chance to buy the car before you do. If they realise you mean business they may well just find the money for it.

Iwillhavethefullenglishplease · 22/04/2023 18:56

sittingonacornflake · 22/04/2023 16:26

Missing point of thread but your dad brings his dirty dishes round to your house to clean?

I had to read that part twice too!

babyproblems · 22/04/2023 18:56

If you bought the car, it’s your car, not your dads. Put a steering lock on it and take back all keys. What will he do. Sod them- they’re taking the absolute piss!!
or sell it and buy your ‘own’ car and do not share it with anyone. Your brothers problems aren’t your responsibility and if your dad needs a car maybe he shouldn’t have sold the one he had!!! I could not handle this I would move away and take the car ha. X

MyrrAgain · 22/04/2023 18:54

mybeautifuloak · 22/04/2023 17:34

For the love of God can people not read? The OP does not live with the dad. The dad says he can’t afford to buy the car. Why are you discussing stuff that makes no sense? How do people survive with such little comprehension?

Calm down dear. It's just a message board 🙄

aloris · 22/04/2023 18:53

He could stop you using the garden if you stop lending him the car and actually that would be perfectly fair. So that may figure into how you handle this.

I think the bigger picture here is that you were having what appeared to be a nice, mutually supportive relationship, by having these porous boundaries between your car, his garden, your dishwasher, etc.

But then your brother has appeared and this has revealed that actually it is not so much about mutual support. If you start making a habit of not showing up in-person to work appointments, or inconveniencing work/clients by last-minute rescheduling of meetings to online format, etc, then this is a material risk to your children via the risk to your job. And this is all so that your brother can feel like the top-dog who can use his sister's car whenever he wishes, and that his dad will defend him over his sister's right to access to her own car!

In addition, the money your father and brother expect you to spend on your brother's petrol, is money taken from your little children's mouths, so your brother, a whole grown-up man, can be more comfortable.

So you would have to decide how to prioritize your children having access to the garden, vs their financial security, in terms of your father's willingness to use your relationship to pull strings without consideration for your children's welfare.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 18:50

....sorry, loads of typos and missing words there!

Therealjudgejudy · 22/04/2023 18:47

Your dad and brother are outrageous.

They are both taking advantage of you

Gemcat1 · 22/04/2023 18:47

Try explaining to your Dad that the agreement was between him and you and did not include your brother. Your Dad must understand that you need the car and that YOU are the priority and that your brother needs to ask you before he takes it. Also do what we do when someone borrows a car in my family, brim it and he has to brim it on return.

If, after this conversation, nothing changes then remove your brother from the insurance and tell him that he is not legally entitled to drive it. Alternatively, or as well, tell your brother that he does not have permission to drive your car and even if your Dad says that he can drive it he is not the legal owner. If he takes the car then report him to the police for theft. If you feel that removing him from the insurance or reporting him for theft is not something that you can do then sell the car and buy a different one. This will stop your Dad thinking that the car is still his and should encourage him to stop lending it to your brother.

Make sure that, if you lend it to your Dad, that he does not keep the key, tell him that there is only one with the car (often happens with second hand cars although additional ones can be bought or cut) and that you need to keep it so it must come straight back to you. Also, although your brother borrows your current car, is he actually insured to drive it? If not, be aware that if he has an accident and damages the car then you will not be able to claim to have to pay to have it repaired or replaced. In the event that he damages another car and/or someone is hurt or killed, he will be financially responsible but be unlikely to pay out to someone even a young child who becomes an orphan and ends up in a wheelchair.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 18:47

You know your very close 'friend' from school - the one with the six very noisy, energetic children that she's constantly shouting at? I think you need to tell her about this garden (at your Dad's house, but it's effectively 'yours') that would be perfect for her needs; make sure you stress oto her profusely that she should make full use of it as often as she possibly can - and that she must feel completely free to just turn up unannounced every single time the fancy takes her....

This reminds me of the old joke who gives the neighbour permission to borrow their lawnmower, but on condition that they can only use it on their (the owner's) lawn!

You're in a position where you're paying the full price for the privilege of having your own private car, but you're actually worse off than just getting the bus - as you then have to work to somebody else's schedule and route, but at least it will always be there with a seat for you to make the journey.

I can see how this would have been fine before when, ignoring the fact that he sold it to you in the first place, your Dad was borrowing your car on occasion when you didn't need it; but this is absolutely outrageous. Do I understand that your Brother not only earned good wages for many, many years, without having to pay major/any housing costs, and is still too broke to afford himself a runaround?

Even married couples who share a car still arrange between themselves who is going to use it when. The only way to avoid this is to have your own car for your own exclusive use - which is indeed what you pay for, but you are somehow believed not to even have an equal crack at it, much less exclusive/priority.

rockpoolingtogether · 22/04/2023 18:44

Tell him to buy it back!

KTheGrey · 22/04/2023 18:30

Ooh @MatildaTheCat I love the way your mind works. Excellent plan.

TempName247 · 22/04/2023 18:30

I would say ‘Dad, who owns the car?’ If he replies that he owns it then you ask what was the 2k for then, have you effectively been renting the car?

the trouble is if you really kick up a fuss about it then he could stop you using his garden

bellabasset · 22/04/2023 18:27

@YellowHatt I'm imagining Dad using the car to ferry the pots back and forth 🍽🤣

I think for a start you need to keep a mileage log of the journeys for the next 2 weeks to demonstrate the usage your dad and db have of the car. If you know what the annual running costs are including depreciation and the cost of fuel ie mph you can demonstrate how much their usage is costing you. Or you could look up the mileage allowance

I agree with offering it back to your df and doing as another poster says and selling it. It's quite simple with your needing it for work and the dc's activities you need it most days. It sounds as Dad is subsidising db with housing and OP is subsiding his transport when she has her own responsibilities.

ChickenDhansak82 · 22/04/2023 18:24

@3WayCarShareNoThanks

So the agreement that your dad sells you the car then he can use it - I assume he sold it to you cheap?!?!

You're going to have to be assertive here! Tell your dad that the agreement was that HE can use it, not your brother.

I'd perhaps park the car somewhere else so they can't find it! Have you got a friend nearby-ish that could "borrow" the car, then park it on his/her drive so your dad and brother can't use it??

Or tell your brother he can use it but only if he pays 40p per mile.

KTheGrey · 22/04/2023 18:22

So - you paid your dad for the car.
Your name is on the keeper's book.
You paid the insurance.
And they borrow the car without asking or filling up.

If they can't afford to buy it back between the two of them, you should part exchange it and get a new one, because they are taking the Mickey now.

furryfrontbottom · 22/04/2023 18:21

Taking a vehicle without the owner's consent is an offence. Point this out to your brother and be prepared to report him next time he does it.

aloris · 22/04/2023 18:18

It doesn't sound as if your dad gave you a discount on the car's value when he sold it to you, why was he able to get such a good deal from you where he is allowed to use it whenever he wants? I suspect as someone said upthread, this was the only way you were going to get back the money he owed you. It all just sounds very enmeshed, as if he doesn't respect you and treats you as if you are behaving very entitled when you expect basic rights such as your having full access to YOUR car for which YOU paid full price.

You pay the insurance, the petrol, I presume you pay the maintenance, but your dad gets free use of the car. It's already taking advantage of you.

Now, you need to get to work to retain the job by which you support your children, but your father is willing to jeopardise that so that your brother can have free use of a car YOU pay for.

This just seems like another example of men thinking women exist for no other reason than to serve them.

BeverForget · 22/04/2023 18:09

Get it sold, get your own car, with just you on the insurance.
They are taking the piss out of you.
And get yourself a nice cake too, just because x

Whatthediddlyfeck · 22/04/2023 18:05

MumToBeOf2 · 22/04/2023 17:53

He needs to watch out for IHT. It could easily be seen as a gift with reservation of benefit, especially if he didn't ask full market value for the car. It's a really common thing to do.

Only on mumsnet 😂😂

MargotBamborough · 22/04/2023 18:04

3WayCarShareNoThanks · 22/04/2023 16:36

I am sympathetic to my brothers situation, I do understand it's hard but it wouldn't take much for him to say "I have a job interview on X day could I borrow the car?" would it?

My dad and brother are both on the insurance as named drivers, hence why I said I'd change insurer if it makes it easier to remove their names.

Dad sold it to me at full sale price minus an amount of money he owed me, I probably got it £1k cheaper than if I'd bought the same age and milage car from a dealer - it was worth about 3k when I bought it and I paid £2k which is a lot of money to me. I'd sell it back to them for half of it's worth.

OP, even before your brother arrived on the scene this was outstanding cheeky fuckery from your dad.

I could sort of understand agreeing to this arrangement if he had sold the car to you at a substantial discount. But he didn't. Reading between the lines, the only benefit to you from this arrangement was getting him to "pay you back" money he owed you, which otherwise you would probably never have seen again.

Selling you a car at full price should come with no strings attached at all. It's yours. You bought it. Nobody gets to use it unless you say so. Certainly nobody else should be keeping one of the keys and lending it out to other people without your permission.

Go to your dad and say, "This arrangement isn't working. I'm giving you two months notice that I intend to sell the car and buy another one. If you want it, you can buy it back off me for the same price I bought it from you for. Any wear and tear has been mostly caused by you and DB anyway. If you don't want it or can't afford it, you and DB have two months to look into alternative modes of transport. Neither of you will be insured to drive my new car."

chocolatehoovering · 22/04/2023 18:00

I would tell them the arrangement is not working and that you need a car solely for your own use so you will be selling the car. Give them first refusal.
If they don't want to buy it then sell it to someone else and get your own car.
I had a similar carry on with my ex and his parents taking ex's car (which we were sharing) but they were doing it deliberately to cause me problems. They had their own fucking car! It meant me missing appointments so I said this isn't working for me and bought a car within a week. Ex was furious as he did not want me to have my own car.... but that's a whole other story!

Moral of the story is, if the arrangement doesn't work for you, find a different solution and in this case it's to sell this blasted car and have one solely for your own use!

JudgeRudy · 22/04/2023 17:56

mybeautifuloak · 22/04/2023 17:34

For the love of God can people not read? The OP does not live with the dad. The dad says he can’t afford to buy the car. Why are you discussing stuff that makes no sense? How do people survive with such little comprehension?

You got me. I skimmed over and saw 'we basically live together'. There's further info now about dad not being able to afford yo buy it back, but still, those are the two reasonable choices. The insurance issue has now been addressed too. I still think it's an odd arrangement to say l can borrow your car whenever i like. That's really controlling. I can borrow the car when ever I like then pass it on to a 3rd person (brother) to borrow is crackers!

billy1966 · 22/04/2023 17:56

Luckynumbereight · 22/04/2023 17:43

You’ve been had, OP. Your father has zero respect for you and your intelligence.

This.

Both your father and brother being very disrespectful of you.

One final offer for your father to buy back the car and return the money.

If not, then sell it and put neither of them on YOUR insurance.

Your brother is a Cf and your father the same.

It is YOUR car.

Moser85 · 22/04/2023 17:54

You should be able to take them off the insurance easily by phoning or logging in online.

They want to use your car that you paid for, and to be on your insurance and for you to pay for fuel 😂It sounds like you're the parent and they're teenagers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread