Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To sell my car to avoid 3 way car sharing?

209 replies

3WayCarShareNoThanks · 22/04/2023 16:14

I own a car, but it used to be my dads car, he sold it to me when he retired on the agreement that he could use it when needed.

It’s worked out fine between us as he only needs it once a week or for appointments, so then I either WFH or he drives me to work and picks me up or we come to another agreement. There’s never been a time when we haven’t managed to find some solution when we’ve both needed the car. We basically live together so it’s been fine (we live on the same road, but he has a garden and I don’t so I often pop round with my DC to use his garden and he pops to mine to use things he doesn’t have like a dishwasher)

That was until December. My brother split with his wife and moved back to our town from a few hours away.

He had to sell his car as he couldn’t afford it on his own. He also had to quit his job as it was a few hours away and he can’t get there without a car.

Now he’s constantly borrowing my car and my dad just says he can. Every job interview or everytime he wants to do anything; meet friends or do a hobby or anything he borrows my car, no consultation with me he just takes it, no thought as to how I’ll get to work or get my DC (I’m a single parent) to their activities or to their dads or to school, I just get told I should “Have more sympathy as I’ve not had to give everything up” or should “Organise to wfh then”.

And my brother never repays the fuel costs either, he literally uses ½ of a tank of fuel and doesn’t even offer to repay me or take it to petrol station and refill it, he just uses it.

I’ve told my dad it needs to stop and he just said it’s his car to so he’ll let my brother use it if he wants to.

I’ve offered to sell it back to them as I can now borrow the money from work to buy myself a slightly newer car anyway but both say they can’t afford it.

I’m tempted to just sell it and buy myself a newer car and not put either of them on the insurance (could even change insurance company to make it easier) but WIBU to do this?

I’m not so bothered about having to WFH, but I’d rather have notice so I can organise to speak to clients by phone or video call rather than having to cancel face to face meetings, and so I can organise for my DC to get to their dads house or hobbies etc by other means - ExH will pick up from me but then I have to collect so it does need to be arranged as we share transport between us, school friends will pick them up on the way passed but I try to then repay the favour, similarly hobbies.

So AIBU?

OP posts:
Codlingmoths · 22/04/2023 23:40

The astonishing thing is not that your brother is divorced but that someone married him in the first place.
just prepare a few sentences ‘I was missing going into work as brother had taken my car and my dc are missing out on activities because is taking my car. He’s threatening my income while expecting me to pay his petrol. This situation is a disaster for me, you haven’t listened so I am ending it while I still have a job and can feed my children. I don’t see brother offering to feed and house my children so he doesn’t get a say here.’

GabriellaMontez · 22/04/2023 23:08

Absolutely cheeky fuckers.

One of the weirdest situations I've read on here, and there's quite a high benchmark.

I can only imagine what it must have been like growing up with these 2 men.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 22:59

If you are willing to sell it to them for £1000 I would rather write the money off , give it to them and then they will have to split the insurance and running costs themselves . The freedom would be worth it .

But they've thought this through carefully: they don't just want a free to get car; they want a free to run car.

The purchase price is only one part of the story - becoming less relevant as a car gets older and worth less - it's all the other many costs that are a killer. Our old car costs us far more each year in insurance, tax, MoT, service, repairs, petrol etc. than its basic market value.

This was the original meaning of the phrase 'white elephant' - where you would give one to somebody you hated, knowing that their considerable ongoing costs to pay for it will be far more significant than your own cost in buying it as a one-off.

Unsure33 · 22/04/2023 22:43

If you are willing to sell it to them for £1000 I would rather write the money off , give it to them and then they will have to split the insurance and running costs themselves . The freedom would be worth it .

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 22:40

As I said I do have sympathy for my brothers situation, but if he'd approached it as a "Can I borrow it on X date?" thing rather than dad lending it whenever I might need it, I'd have been fine with it.

Yes, it's not really the wanting to borrow it if you're not using it; it's the assumption, the not asking and the mansplaining to you that he needs YOUR car more than you do!

Not to mention the fuel issue: not just not paying for what he's used, which is disgraceful enough, but also leaving you to get into your car (when he deigns to allow you to use it) and then having to factor in the time for an unexpected diversion to the fuel station.

Nevermind31 · 22/04/2023 22:32

I think you should be clear in your mind…

  • you didn’t get the car for cheap - deducting an amount owed from the price is not letting you have it cheap
  • you are doing your dad a favour by letting him borrow it
  • it is your car, you paid your dad for it, so your dad does not have a say in it
you should really make that clear to your dad. Does he think if he had sold the car to someone down the road he would have free access over it? your dad has been taking advantage, and your brother the p…
Peapodburgundybouquet · 22/04/2023 22:17

Sell it. And get something of your own that neither of them have a key for. And guard your new key with your life.

Fuck them both over, they’re being outrageous. Your dad can’t sell you a car and then act like he still owns it. No.

Is it typical for them for the men in your family to right roughshod over the women? I can’t imagine why your brother’s marriage died on its arse…

Remagirl · 22/04/2023 22:12

This is the most bonkers post I've read to date. It's so bizarre I find it hard to believe.

Badbudgeter · 22/04/2023 22:06

AppallinglyReheated · 22/04/2023 22:04

There is no discount though as her DF owed her that 1K anyway!

Apologies I missed that. Put a wheel lock on it. Tell them neither of them get to drive it anymore as have taken the piss.

AppallinglyReheated · 22/04/2023 22:04

Badbudgeter · 22/04/2023 22:02

I’d sell the car give your Dad the 1k discount you bought it off him for so you don’t feel beholden. Used cars are retaining their value so probably still worth 2-3k. Get a new (to you) car. Never add either of them to the insurance or let them borrow.

They are the epitome of cf.

There is no discount though as her DF owed her that 1K anyway!

AppallinglyReheated · 22/04/2023 22:03

I don't quite grasp why you can't say to your dad:

'I agreed to share the car with you - the car I paid full market value for from you when you take into account the money you owed me - on the basis that we'd discuss when you needed it in advance, and your use was minimal.

The current situation is of no benefit to me whatsoever, I can't rely on having the car, I certainly can't rely on it having an fuel in it when it is there, and this is not the agreement we made between us initially. I will be selling this car and buying a car that suits me, for my sole use going forward. If you would like to buy this car from me, the price is X, take 24 hours to think it over if you like.'

I can believe you think it wouldn't work but have you actually said this to him at any point?

Badbudgeter · 22/04/2023 22:02

I’d sell the car give your Dad the 1k discount you bought it off him for so you don’t feel beholden. Used cars are retaining their value so probably still worth 2-3k. Get a new (to you) car. Never add either of them to the insurance or let them borrow.

They are the epitome of cf.

3WayCarShareNoThanks · 22/04/2023 21:58

I won't be running two cars don't worry, but I'm not going to do myself out of a car for their sake. I will look into the loan and at the same time look at getting a wheel lock or similar.

As I said I do have sympathy for my brothers situation, but if he'd approached it as a "Can I borrow it on X date?" thing rather than dad lending it whenever I might need it, I'd have been fine with it.

OP posts:
choochooandspook · 22/04/2023 21:56

so you've basically paid yourself the money that your dad owes you plus given him another lump sum of 2k, and all you get is the use of the car now and then after he and your brother get first dibs. I can't believe how disrespectful he is to you.

DahliaMacNamara · 22/04/2023 21:56

Please tell me you don't literally mean you intend to go to the expense of running two cars when there's only one driver in your household? Just to keep your dad and brother sweet?

Bluebellbike · 22/04/2023 21:26

chocolatehoovering · 22/04/2023 19:50

No, you don't need to sell the car to afford the new one, but you do need to sell it to get rid of the damn thing so that you are not responsible for any repairs on it, while Dad and brother drive around in it willy nilly and as soon as it breaks down it's suddenly your problem.
Reminds me of the neighbour downstairs who stole another neighbour's cat basically, but when the cat became ill the neighbour went round to the original owner with cat in arms and said "Your cat's ill so you'll need to take it to the vet". Fucking cheeky fucker.
I just don't know how people can be such knobs.
Oh I'll just use a car which doesn't belong to me whenever the fuck I like and return it with no fuel in it.

Also OP if your Dad and brother are still driving the old car after you get a new one you will be insuring and taxing it for them? Sorting the MOT?
Any speeding or other driving offences will be on you as the registered keeper as well.

LoobyLobbyLou · 22/04/2023 20:47

I’d give it back to your Dad, sign everything over so he’s responsible for insurance, MOT etc and get a new one. Then don’t let them anywhere near the new car keys!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 20:39

If she buys a new car, they won't have the keys so that's surely the end of the discussion. They can try to buy themselves some kind of insurance policy as you describe for her car, but how the fuck are they going to drive said car if they don't have the keys?????

A new car will put an end to all of this.

It can't be much fun, though, ensuring that your car key is constantly on your person - never in a bag, a bowl near the door, coat pocket, always take it in to the shower with you. I wouldn't put anything past entitled people like that.

PlanningTowns · 22/04/2023 20:36

Total aside.

if work does this as a salary sacrifice, be mindful that if you are made redundant it will have an impact on your payout. In other words just check everything through carefully.

but YANBU and your dad is

Blamunge · 22/04/2023 20:22

Sell it. As long as you have that particular car your Dad will continue to see it as his, and so will your brother. You need a new car that he’s never owned and has no claim on.

Muu · 22/04/2023 20:16

I don’t know what kind of work you’re in but for a lot of us the last minute chopping and changing of face to face to online meetings would land us in trouble pretty quickly.

I would prepare for some emotional blackmail, but sell the car and tell them it’s because you’re putting your job at risk with the current set-up.

mybeautifuloak · 22/04/2023 20:14

3WayCarShareNoThanks · 22/04/2023 19:40

Thanks everyone.

Will look into the loan from work to get a new car, at least I can choose whichever car I want. Work will pay the whole amount up to I think £10k, I can put my own money into it if I want to but don't have to, i just pay back from my wages so I'm not even missing the money as it goes out before I get my pay if that makes sense?

So I don't need to sell this car to get a new one.

So you'll carry on paying insurance,MOT, servicing etc for the old car? Why? You paid your dad for the car and now you are basically giving it back to him and your db but paying for it ? By all means people can do this if they want but it seems like you are pandering to their unreasonableness

mybeautifuloak · 22/04/2023 20:11

@JudgeRudy you are the most adult person on here. You took my angry menopausal rant and diffused like a boss 🤣. Thank you for showing me how to behave!

chocolatehoovering · 22/04/2023 20:07

If it was just a case of telling them 'tough' and not caring about offending them, OP could already have taken them (or even just the brother) off the insurance. You can make amendments to drivers (other than the main driver) at any time during the policy

If she buys a new car, they won't have the keys so that's surely the end of the discussion. They can try to buy themselves some kind of insurance policy as you describe for her car, but how the fuck are they going to drive said car if they don't have the keys?????

A new car will put an end to all of this.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 22/04/2023 20:02

In which case, if there's an emergency, the OP just says no, because the Dad and brother won't be on the insurance for the new car so they can't use it. End of story. They can be offended and not accept the new circumstances with good grace, but tough. It at least solves the issue of the OP not having access to her own car when she needs it.

If they're determined, you can buy a separate policy on a car that's owned by a family member or friend - you don't have to go on the same one. I did that when a good friend very kindly offered to lend us one of theirs, when they were abroad on holiday and ours was temporarily out of action, but at no point did the insurer ask me if I had express permission from the car owner to use this car that I was getting insurance on.

If it was just a case of telling them 'tough' and not caring about offending them, OP could already have taken them (or even just the brother) off the insurance. You can make amendments to drivers (other than the main driver) at any time during the policy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread