Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think civil servants should be easily sackable for misconduct?

34 replies

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:19

Apparently one of the Dominic Raab bullying incidents in the foreign office went like this:

Negotiations over Gibraltar border arrangements

Raab to Ambassador: no Spanish troops on Gibraltar under any circumstances.
Ambassador to Spanish diplomats: Spainsh border troops will be allowed permanently on Gibraltar
Other British diplomats to Spanish diplomats: No Spanish border troops will be allowed on Gibraltar
Spain: WTF
Raab to Ambassador: Why did you say what you did? I issued a very clear ministerial directive?
Ambassador to Raab: [unclear response]
Raab to Ambassador: erupts in seething rage

Now the last step is what was wrong, and what was classified as bullying (though it's not clear exactly what happened).

However, if the account is true, then surely the ambassador has committed gross professional misconduct, trying to give away British sovereignty in direct contrast to a ministerial decision? To me going against the explicit instructions of your boss on such an important matter would be a sackable offence in pretty much any line of work - and yet it seems he's still the ambassador to Spain to this day.

As I've said on a previous thread, it's unclear whether Raab was actually a bully or not - the report makes it clear that at the least he was overly rude and demeaning. It's fairly obvious he was not effective, which to me is a genuine reason to get rid of him irrespective of the bullying.

However I see the civil service acting this way with impunity as an even bigger scandal.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IamAlso4eels · 22/04/2023 16:29

The tory-bots are out in force this weekend trying to minimise the report and tweak the narrative. I don't like all these seeds being planted about the civil service being out of control, about them being activists, working against the government, etc. It's creating a narrative against the civil service and painting them as treasonous enemies plotting to bring down the government.

Murdoch1949 · 22/04/2023 16:29

Raab is a bullying intimidating boss. Some complaints were not proven, that doesn't make them untrue, just insufficient evidence. I've read the whole report, as I'm sure the OP has, he's a workaholic who typically expected too much from his staff. Any boss who is at his desk from 7.30 am to 10 pm, Mon to Thurs, is demanding of himself (or inefficient) and no doubt will be miffed if staff clock off at 6 pm. Very senior civil servants - Sir Gus McDonald, for one - advised him about his behaviour, he ignored all entreaties to change.

MiddleParking · 22/04/2023 16:02

It’s not clear what processes for accountability/employment policies you think civil servants should be subject to that they aren’t already? Do you mean officials should be easily sackable by ministers?

DirectionToPerfection · 22/04/2023 15:44

Hmm, not the first thread the OP has posted trying to minimise the allegations against Raab.

Seems quite clear he's a nasty bully and it can only be a positive thing that he's suffering the consequences of that.

SinnerBoy · 22/04/2023 15:34

donquixotedelamancha · Today 14:27

Yes but the issue is that it's Dominic Raab's account and many, many people have said that he 'erupts with rage' over fuck all.

The Guardian reports him as looming over people, pointing his finger close to their faces, banging tables with rage, when they don't capitulate etc.

Simon McDonald, who was permanent undersecretary at the Foreign Office between 2015 and 2020, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “Frankly, I witnessed somebody whose methods did not help him to achieve what he wanted to do, and that I raised with him more than once.”

The high threshold for filing a formal complaint against ministers meant that civil servants were hesitant about reporting specific grievances, he said, which, without evidence, Raab “was able to deflect”.

A five-month investigation by a leading employment barrister found that Raab, as foreign secretary, had engaged in “abuse or misuse of power” to undermine or humiliate staff. He was “intimidating and insulting” in meetings at the Ministry of Justice.

Tolley confirmed that top officials at the Foreign Office and Ministry of Justice had warned Raab about his behaviour. He said Raab’s manner – which the MP himself described as “inquisitorial, direct, impatient and fastidious” – was not in every case intentional, but he was a “highly intelligent man” who ought to have realised the impact on officials, and made changes.

As justice secretary, Tolley said, Raab had “acted in a manner which was intimidating” by going further than appropriate in “delivering critical feedback”, and insulting officials by making “unconstructive critical comments” about their work.

At the Foreign Office, Raab also had to be spoken to by the permanent secretary for acting in an intimidating way, said Tolley. Raab’s fit of frustration when he questioned whether officials were breaching the ministerial code constituted “an abuse or misuse of power” in a way that undermined and humiliated them.

AP5Diva · 22/04/2023 15:31

“However, if the account is true, then surely the ambassador has committed gross professional misconduct, trying to give away British sovereignty in direct contrast to a ministerial decision?”

It isn’t true as it was rumour only and the civil servant was actually removed from his position as lead negotiator on the basis of this “may have” rumour alone.

The British stance had always been that no Spanish troops would ever be stationed permanently in Gibraltar. Perplexed at the complaints from Spain, Mr Raab investigated and heard that the ambassador to Spain, Hugh Elliott, may have gone beyond the official position agreed by the Cabinet and offered to have Spanish 'boots on the ground' permanently, the Telegraph reported.
The minister then ordered Mr Elliott back from Spain to London to give an account of his actions. But his explanations were not specific enough, according to supporters of Mr Raab. Raab replaced Mr Elliott in negotiations with the former ambassador Simon Manley, although Mr Elliott remained the top British diplomat in Spain.

noblegiraffe · 22/04/2023 15:27

Restforabit · 22/04/2023 14:41

OK - unless I’m very thick, the OP is NOT saying Raab is wronged or the victim of a miscarriage of justice. Rather, she is raising an important point about the civil service. Which is hard to discuss because of people accusing her of being Dominic Raab, and it’s a bit tedious, tbh.

From the OP "Now the last step is what was wrong, and what was classified as bullying (though it's not clear exactly what happened)." And "As I've said on a previous thread, it's unclear whether Raab was actually a bully or not"

If she didn't want any discussions about Raab being a bully or not, it was foolish to include those bits of commentary.

Littlewhitecat · 22/04/2023 15:25

Civil servants can be sacked and disciplined just like any other worker. Your understanding of policy development and working with ministers is woeful. Utterly ridiculous to state that "Overall it seems that the civil service is really ineffective. As a whole it seems to severely lack quantitative/data analysis skills in order to facilitate good decisions, and seems to value process much more than outcomes". What empirical evidence are you basing that on? Civil servants are not allowed to discuss what they do in work so can't defend themselves against the crap Raab is coming out with.

HappyHolidai · 22/04/2023 15:21

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:58

@HappyHolidai I wouldn't ever work in the civil service - the pay cut would be horrendous, and it seems like an organisation which adores process and despises performance and outcomes, which is the direct opposite of what I want in a career.

Yes, it's funny how many people who say how much better the Civil Service would be if they ran it wouldn't lower themselves to actually work there.

I did for 10 years. It has its positives and negatives as do all jobs.

Staticgirl · 22/04/2023 15:05

Civil servants don't have a job for life. That kind of life vanished by the end of the 80s. If someone has messed up, they will have to suffer the consequences. The vast majority of whom are paid less than £25K and are working extremely hard to deliver their objectives no matter what they may vote for privately. It is beyond insulting and they can't fight back.

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:58

@HappyHolidai I wouldn't ever work in the civil service - the pay cut would be horrendous, and it seems like an organisation which adores process and despises performance and outcomes, which is the direct opposite of what I want in a career.

OP posts:
LostAtTheCrossRoad · 22/04/2023 14:58

The CS also has excellent quantitative and analytical skills in its members and has separate streams for its economists and statisticians, but if I had a pound for every time a policy lead or minister rejected or overrode evidence advice, I'd be a rich woman...

Notonthestairs · 22/04/2023 14:54

"Rather, she is raising an important point about the civil service."

Well that's not true either.

There is no evidence that they can't sack him.

They just haven't chosen to.

LostAtTheCrossRoad · 22/04/2023 14:54

Having worked in the civil service, civil servants including senior ones, are as sackable as any other type of employee. V senior members tend to get moved sideways or agree to resign for "personal reasons" rather than outright sacked, but believe me, they go.

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:53

Thank you @Restforabit . Yes I am making no comment (here) on whether Raab is a bully or not. I think he was correct to resign for many reasons, and should have resigned or been sacked earlier.

But the civil service can only work if it actively tries to implement what ministers want. Overall it seems that the civil service is really ineffective. As a whole it seems to severely lack quantitative/data analysis skills in order to facilitate good decisions, and seems to value process much more than outcomes.

However being ineffective is one thing; doing the direct opposite of what you are instructed to do is quite another.

I am amazed that people find it OK.

I would be just as annoyed if e.g. a Labour foreign secretary said that an Israeli counterattack after a Hamas attack should be diplomatically condemned, and instead the ambassador to Israel praised it. This is despite me disagreeing with this (hypothetical) policy.

OP posts:
EuripidesEumenides · 22/04/2023 14:49

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:33

@EuripidesEumenides Could you give more details about the process if you know?

Depends on the specific context but generally and roughly officials will get a mandate signed off by their junior minister, secretary of state or Cabinet (depending on the significance) setting out in broad terms what they want to achieve and what they are willing to concede.

Officials will try to get negotiations as far along as they can and either get a ready made deal for the minister to sign or at least sort most of the technical points and the overall shape of agreement sorted and leave any outstanding political points for the minister to negotiate with their counterpart.

Mandates are often not black and white though. It's also not too rare for an official to use their judgement to go beyond their mandate for the sake of getting the best overall deal they think they can get. But such an "agreement" would only ever be provisional and it's not unheard of for an official to have to come back with their tail between their legs and backtrack when their Capital says no. It's not great but it happens.

Sirius3030 · 22/04/2023 14:49

It would be perfectly acceptable for the ambassador to say something like ´Would the presence of Spanish police on the UK side of the border help to resolve our current impasse?´(as I think is the case with French douane in Dover?), which might have helped moved discussion along. Raab´s red-line of no permanent presence of Spanish troops would not have been affected.

Restforabit · 22/04/2023 14:41

OK - unless I’m very thick, the OP is NOT saying Raab is wronged or the victim of a miscarriage of justice. Rather, she is raising an important point about the civil service. Which is hard to discuss because of people accusing her of being Dominic Raab, and it’s a bit tedious, tbh.

Sunnysunbun · 22/04/2023 14:38

Dominic quit posting.

Notonthestairs · 22/04/2023 14:34

Well, I guess there will be a reason why they haven't sacked him.

Nothing you've written indicates they can't - just that they haven't.

LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:33

@EuripidesEumenides Could you give more details about the process if you know?

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 22/04/2023 14:31

@donquixotedelamancha Yes, if Raab's making it up (which is quite possible given how narcissistic he is) then the question is moot.

However, it should be easy to establish the facts here. If the ambassador said to Spain that border troops can be on Gibraltar then he should have been sacked.

OP posts:
EuripidesEumenides · 22/04/2023 14:31

Ambassadors can't give away sovereignty. If they offer something in a negotiation beyond their mandate cleared by ministers or Cabinet all that happens is they look a bit of a pillock when they have to backtrack.