Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children should be encouraged to stay in sport?

89 replies

pontipinemum · 22/04/2023 08:55

I'm not saying 'everyone gets a medal' sort of situation. But everything should be done to encourage kids to stay in sport, I think the stat's for girls are even worse.

I am just remembering back to when I stopped going to a proper running/ athletics club, it was a really good club with several people that either made team GB or got well on at national level. The coach left a voice mail on our landline that I heard. I was 13yrs old. She said something along the lines of 'pontipine is useless, she will never win anything, she is too slow." it was a very nasty message.

Apparently the coach thought I was talking about her behind her back or that's what I heard from someone else anyway. I didn't talk about her behind her back!

I never went back I was too embarrassed. I knew I was never going to be amazing but I was OK and I enjoyed it. Now I am not saying that event changed the trajectory of my life but I never went back to running

YABU - If kids are bad tell them
YANBU - Encourage them to keep it up regardless

OP posts:
lljkk · 22/04/2023 17:27

This thread is an actual competition in whinging.
Stop moaning and do something about it instead.

btw,
if you have matches then you have winners and losers.
If you have "a league" then you'll still have winners and losers.
Most "sports" won't be fun if you don't make them competitive. So you want to find a way to make the competition fun.

Also, those of you who think dance is not pressured, are you nuts. I'm saying that as the teenager with poor sense of rhythm who looked terrible at the (filmed) recital because I kept moving out of sync with everyone else. So embarrassing. I'd rather come dead last in a race than ever again be so obviously publicly terrible at a dance recital <shudder>.

You need to think about how to design the "play for fun league" entirely differently. For instance, a footie side could train regularly together but when they go to a match, the 2 sides are always mixed. Nominated captains could take turn picking players from either side, throw on coloured vests, play as competitively as they like but there is no actual "league": just a competitive match for fun. The weak players will still get less ball time, but every one should get a look in most weeks. End of the league season everyone would be invited to vote for 3 especially impressive / most-valuable players NOT on their own side. So those good players can be celebrated, but still have an inclusive for-fun league.

Similarly, with individual sports, you could have handicapped races: eg., slowest runner goes off first, fastest (documented) runner goes off last. The only possible "winner" is the person who improved their PB most over the distance that day, and over the season.

I have literally no skin in this game but at least I have offered wildly more ideas what a successful alternative "sport experience" could be like, than most PP.

So crack on with it gals. I look forward to hearing all about your creative efforts in the news in coming years. Won't that be funner achievement than I swear moaning is the number one favourite British sport pastime moaning on Mumsnet?

MargaretThursday · 22/04/2023 17:23

I don’t think the answer to wider participation in team sports is more mixed ability teams- the kids quickly work out who the weak links are and it’s horrible for them.
I agree there. As a very slow runner, I hated the group events because I was always aware of letting the team down. I don't think anyone ever said that to me, but I knew that.

In my dc's secondary they streamed for PE. My dds were far happier once in the lowest stream where they could have fun without feeling they were letting people down, than in the mixed one. PE went from being a lesson they dreaded to one they enjoyed.

illiterato · 22/04/2023 16:35

I don’t think the answer to wider participation in team sports is more mixed ability teams- the kids quickly work out who the weak links are and it’s horrible for them.

The answer must therefore be more teams. The problem there is that there are only so many coaches/ referees, the vast majority of whom are volunteers. To field more teams requires more coaches/ referees than there are. It also requires numbers across a geographic area which is often lacking. It’s often the case that clubs have too many for one team but getting numbers for two is really difficult. Also, I think commitment tends to be lower in the less competitive teams, which is kind of understandable but at the same time, if you want to have a fun league you need to show up just as much as the competitive league or matches keep getting forfeited/ played with skeleton teams.

carriedout · 22/04/2023 15:58

Mortimercat · 22/04/2023 09:12

I agree with the above poster, perhaps there could be more about fitness and enjoyment, rather than competition. I was not very good at sport, so there really was nothing for me, it is shame there was not more focus on just doing something for exercise and for fun.

Agree.

School PE is shit, the work I've had to put in to undo the negative messages.
Sports clubs can be quite toxic.

Exercise is important, but sport is often quite unenjoyable.

NoTouch · 22/04/2023 15:54

lljkk · 22/04/2023 13:34

imho, "sport" = competitive by definition.

You can practice a physical activity for pleasure, hobby or fun, but shouldn't call it "doing sport" if there's no competitive element.

Of course "sport" involves competing, we know the definition. It would be no fun if you didn't play against another team/person! It is still "sport" regardless of ability, I absolutely do think children should be encouraged enough to do sport for fun - it has so many life long development and wellbeing positives.

Keep the serious competition for elite sports groups and sort out the amateur side so coaches cannot just irresponsibly dump kids, not caring about the damage they do, who have played with a team for 6-7 years because someone else comes along who is just a tiny bit better and coach fancies a change.

Bk1000 · 22/04/2023 14:38

I think it’s strange how with children they are often only encouraged to do a sport if they are good at it, will make the team etc. if you aren’t good at it then you have somehow ‘failed’ As adults it’s more acceptable to do sports just for the hell of it, I’ve run my whole adult life without ever thinking I would win anything or seriously compete but I do it because I enjoy it.

My oldest dd does a sport she really enjoys but she’s not very good at and I feel the exasperation from her instructor during lessons, sometimes I think they are wondering why she still comes to the classes but she just enjoys taking part. My other dd does a sport which she has a huge natural talent for and could compete seriously if she wanted to but she doesn’t, she likes going to classes, practices all the time and enjoys her own personal accomplishments in the sport but doesn’t ever want to compete and her coaches seem to have a very hard time understanding that!

If it was more acceptable for kids to be able to just enjoy sport for the sake of it then I think a lot more would keep doing it.

WhoBird · 22/04/2023 14:21

I think there isn’t enough money in sport generally so what is there is targeted towards goal oriented training. So adults who can organise themselves can participate in self run groups at all levels, but teenagers relying on a structured club etc there isn’t enough provision for.

I have a child that does elite level
gymnastics training. They train 5 days per week, which is very demanding, but there is no in between - it’s either one hour session recreational or hours and hours of competitive. Many of the coaches are unpaid or marginally paid ex gymnasts.

thesmee · 22/04/2023 14:15

lljkk · 22/04/2023 13:34

imho, "sport" = competitive by definition.

You can practice a physical activity for pleasure, hobby or fun, but shouldn't call it "doing sport" if there's no competitive element.

It can be competitive at a club level - competing against each other etc on a weekly basis. It doesn't necessarily need to go beyond that.

thesmee · 22/04/2023 14:14

lljkk · 22/04/2023 12:55

there should be clubs that....

So what are you all doing to create such clubs, get them running, make them attractive, recruit members and volunteers, conform with safeguarding, insurance, etc? Tell us about the clubs you run like that NOW for children, adults and anyone. Share the benefit of your experience.

I'm a teacher and run an after school club every week for no pay and usually no thanks either, whilst paying for my own children to be in childcare. That's me doing my bit. But I was talking about professionally run clubs. Some gymnastics academies for example run recreational groups for beginners age 8+ or 13+ and some just don't so if you're a 14 year old who fancies trying it for fun and fitness your options are limited. Clubs will do what is commercially viable though, so I'm not sure what the answer is.

Lolaandbehold · 22/04/2023 14:13

I think sport for children is incredibly important. Both for physical and mental wellbeing. I strongly encourage it among my children and if they look like they're giving up for no good reason as they approach the teenage years, I'll take a fairly hard stance. By that I mean, they won't be substituting it with social media, youtube or video games. And team sports teach so many valuable life skills.

illiterato · 22/04/2023 14:05

thesmee · 22/04/2023 11:35

Exactly this. Why are there so many adult options for non-competive sport and taking something up from scratch, but as a teenager it's hard to find anything unless you want to be in a league and, often, need to have started the sport at a relatively young age.

Because organising things for adults is multiple times easier than organising the same for kids. With kids you need to worry about supervision ratios, safeguarding, age groupings etc. Often adult provision is set up by someone who wants to do that themselves- my friend set up a fun 5 a side soccer league in London. All he did was hire the pitches, send the captains the fixtures and tally the results. You can’t do that with kids. The level of input would be so much higher.

Paq · 22/04/2023 13:35

@doingitforyorkshire I agree it's about finding the right club but if you are like me and live rurally there's absolutely no choice. We have one running club, one swimming club, one hockey club etc.

I worked in sports development for some years and stories about how unwelcoming some clubs can be are common. Especially to less able people, or people who in some way don't fit their clique.

lljkk · 22/04/2023 13:34

imho, "sport" = competitive by definition.

You can practice a physical activity for pleasure, hobby or fun, but shouldn't call it "doing sport" if there's no competitive element.

Children should be encouraged to stay in sport?
Children should be encouraged to stay in sport?
EnthENd · 22/04/2023 13:21

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 22/04/2023 09:10

I don't think there's enough sports classes aimed at just having fun and getting fit.

It seems to all be about matches, competitions and performances - but not all children will make that level and they won't all want to either.

I don't think there's any benefit in forcing a child along to classes that they don't enjoy or where they're struggling, but unfortunately there often isn't any alternative. It's almost like if you're not good enough to compete then the door gets firmly closed on you.

This. We need more emphasis on physical activity outside a competitive sporting context. Honestly, I don't think sport is entirely healthy. Exercise is healthy, but pushing yourself until some part of your body literally breaks?

doingitforyorkshire · 22/04/2023 12:59

I can see the OP's point to a degree, sport can be enjoyed and doesn't need to be competitive, you can have a kick about, enjoy the experience of a half marathon, do stuff for a personal challenge etc. Without feeling the need to win.

However, I think there are different clubs out there, I was a club runner and involved in two very different clubs, one was very social, and they loved the races but there was never any focus on performance, it was a good day out with food and a pint afterwards. The other was more performance-based, races were trained for specifically and training was structured/traditional etc. Two very different environments the first club I loved and my running really progressed, as there was no pressure and the focus was on enjoyment, the other I hated, I worried in case I ran poorly in a race and let the team down, I felt I had to try as hard as I could in training and got worse due to trying too hard, got injured more. I stopped training with them in the end and began enjoying running again.

A lot of it comes down to finding the right club.

Trickleg · 22/04/2023 12:56

Should point out that much sport at youth level is volunteer run. Many of the volunteers have never actually played the sport. If you want more teams, volunteer - don’t wait for someone else to do it. It’s not just coaching - there are dozens of other jobs that need doing too.

BogRollBOGOF · 22/04/2023 12:56

I was hopeless at sport at school, but fortunately did dance (badly) which at least kept me going and made things like aerobics and step in my 20s seem accessible. I also got into DoE, fell in love with hiking, and learned how to swim which has also opened up opportunities itself, and the realisation that I can learn new, random things.
Fortunately those positives have meant that the ritual humiliation of PE did not define my attitude to being active in adulthood.

With my background, I got my DCs doing a range of sports early, and try to keep it to a participation level rather than competitive level. My dyspraxic 12yo still continues with swimming lessons, more for the routine of a weekly structured swim than anything else. He also continues with karate and parkruns. Because he's fit and can run, he's less of a liability in school team sports than I was and that helps cover some of his skill gaps and avoid the ritual ridicule that I had to put up with.

Parkrun is a brilliant illustration to the importance of participation over prowess. I've been lapped by elite athletes, but unlike in PE, they don't goad slower participants. Generally I run mid-pack, but if I go slow or walk for whatever reason, it's about the joy of participating not the athletic pace.
At junior parkrun, we watch the regulars grow up over the years. The congratulating is equal between the first and final participants. The timed nature means you can be competitive with yourself or other regulars, but there's no exclusion or not being good enough. That's important for being active for life.

There is a big gap in opportunities for participation sport for non-competitive older children who aren't inclined or don't meet the standards for competitive sports.

lljkk · 22/04/2023 12:55

there should be clubs that....

So what are you all doing to create such clubs, get them running, make them attractive, recruit members and volunteers, conform with safeguarding, insurance, etc? Tell us about the clubs you run like that NOW for children, adults and anyone. Share the benefit of your experience.

PuttingDownRoots · 22/04/2023 12:43

In Rugby all the team must play a certain percentage of the game (half minimum I believe). While I'm sure there are some clubs who just don't take the really weak players, the club my DD plays at allows any child to play as soon as they are safe to do so (i.e have the basics of throwing, catching and tackling sorted)

NoTouch · 22/04/2023 12:38

Crazycrazylady · 22/04/2023 10:42

It's very hard to balance it really. I have three boys all of varying abilities , the oldest is 12 now and plays on a number of different teams and at this age it's getting far more competitive and the. Coaches are fielding their best teams and only playing the weaker players when the team are way behind or way ahead. I know it can't me kumbya for ever but it breaks my heart to see boys little faces on the sideline ( even acknowledging that some of them really can barely kick a ball)
I'd love to know what the answer is.

The answer is to stop allowing coaches to treat children that way. Have football for children for fun not to feed the egos of grown men. Especially when you get to teen ages where some boys fall behind purely because puberty and being stronger and more athletic comes later for them. As long as the children are attending training and giving their best a childrens coach should be working to get the best out of the children he already has in the team.

The club should be loyal to the boys that have been in the team for years and only bring in new players if they have a space.

PhotoDad · 22/04/2023 12:13

Completely agreed, @2reefsin30knots! Our local club has a free-for-members basic campsite for those who are staying for a weekend (and that's not unusual). At club level, watersports are a wonderful and cheap sport/activity. You do need to spend a lot of money if DC get into the competitive side of things. I don't know how that compares to other sports, to be honest, and I do worry about how that is a barrier to entry. (And good luck to your sailor! Are you expected to take your own boats to championships? At least we can throw boards on top of a car without trailers etc.)

2reefsin30knots · 22/04/2023 12:06

PhotoDad · 22/04/2023 11:45

@2reefsin30knots, interesting to read a sailor's perspective; my DS is a windsurfer and it's just the same, with a lovely supportive community. Same governing body and pathway, but also plenty of recreational opportunities!

We get him second/third-hand kit. He's off to the world championships just after his GCSEs this summer, but there's never been any pressure to compete and lots of the kids at his club don't. (The kids' programme starts at local level with something called "T15" if this intrigues anyone enough to google, and most clubs have kit for members to borrow.)

The only problem is that races (and training for regional teams if people do that level) are all over, so there's a lot of travel.

@PhotoDad 👋 We are also off to World Championships in July.

Agreed, there is a huge amount of travel involved in the pathway. However you look at it, it is really expensive too. DS has about 10ks worth of kit (2 boats) and one weekend of either 'open' or squad training is over £100 before travel etc. So, although there is a really lovely, healthy atmosphere once you are in, the costs mean that participation in pathway stuff is not inclusive.

Club sailing can be done super cheaply though.

Paq · 22/04/2023 12:05

We have a completely warped idea of sport and exercise in this country. Of course children should be active, either through sport or something else. Moving your body regularly, exercising your heart and lungs, is the foundation of healthy growth, long term health protection and mental well-being.

Instead we treat PE as punishment, sport as something for elite athletes and exercise as only something to do to look good.

However, sport is chronically underfunded: facilities are lacking and volunteers are of variable quality so it's not surprising people are turned off.

ChaToilLeam · 22/04/2023 12:04

Can’t there be two tracks? One for achievement athletes and one for hobbyists. I was very much put off PE at school by the focus on team games and winning, I hated it. I much more enjoyed trampolining and gymnastics, was never any good but it was more fun than the ritual humiliation of being picked last for teams for games I had no interest in playing anyway. Perhaps if it had been more for fun I might have summoned up a bit more enthusiasm.

Being expected to wear shorts or gym skirts was also ridiculous for teenage girls with changing bodies and surprise periods, leggings or sweat pants would have been so much better.

These days I’m pretty active, but only doing the things I want. I will never play a team sport again and that thought makes me very happy.

KennyMousetits · 22/04/2023 11:54

I believe there needs to be more focus on less traditional sports along with the need to be part of a club to take part. My DC hate football/rugby/tennis/cricket but will skateboard and BMX for hours on end and love basketball. They also don't want it organising for them, organised fun is their idea of hell! School PE for them is being forced to play football for 75% of lessons, no fun at all for them! They would love a lesson doing wheeled sports.

I also hated PE and sports at school, I did love when we were allowed to do trampolining, aerobics or dance but it wasn't often as wasn't seen as 'proper' sport.

Encouraging children to move for enjoyment and fun is so important for building long lasting habits that will keep them active into adulthood.