Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take this job despite negative impact on DC?

241 replies

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 08:42

NC for this as have also posted elsewhere and apologies for slightly dramatic title, I don't really think this would be detrimental to DC per se, I just couldn't think of a better way to word it!

I'm currently on mat leave with 1 yo DC, due to return at the end of May. I like my job in the sense that I love my colleagues, but the quality of work is crap and things have apparently changed a lot since I've been on mat leave. Targets have gone up, pay has not increased relatively and expectations are generally getting bigger without much in return. I've been wanting to move on for some time, but the pandemic and then pregnancy put that all on hold for a while.

I've been looking for a new job for a while but nothing suitable has come up. I've agreed 3 days a week on my return with my current employer and in the office once or twice a week. Overall they're pretty flexible about how and when I work, so long as client needs are met - along with targets.

Last week a potential new role came up which would be a huge payrise (think £30k FTE) with better benefits and very similar targets and expectations. Also a huge improvement in quality of work. It's also comforting because I know someone who works there and I'm confident I'd be happy there because she is and I know her personality. They're happy for me to start on 3 or 4 days BUT the catch is they'd want me to go full time from September.

This wasn't the plan - DC is going to nursery 3 days a week and I thought this would be the perfect balance for us. However, this is a really great opportunity and given the huge improvements in all areas of the job, I feel I'd be really stupid to miss out. At the same time, I feel so guilty for putting DC into nursery full time and missing so much time with them when they're so little. It's likely they'll be an only child and I worry I'd regret the decision later on. I'd be in the office 2 days a week and I'd be out of the house from 7.30-7.30 at least on those days, so basically won't see DC.

Now I know I'm incredibly privileged to be in this position and many people have no choice but to work full time and utilise full time childcare, so this post isn't meant to be insensitive and I certainly don't judge anyone who puts their DC in full time, but this wasn't what I'd planned for.

So, AIBU to go for a new role which would make a huge difference to both my career and our finances, even though it would mean DC being in FT childcare, rather than 3 days a week?

OP posts:
UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 22/04/2023 14:33

Twizbe · 22/04/2023 08:55

I went back full time after my eldest and in many ways I think it was better than part time.

My DC likes structure and routine so that suited him a lot. He liked his caregivers.

It forced DH and I to work as a team. Both working full time in 'big jobs' meant we had to split the pick ups and drop offs, sick days etc.

We worked together to make sure all chores were done in the week (and we hired a cleaner) so that weekends could be spent on family / individual recharge time.

I don't regret full time at all. Even better than you're getting to work up to full time so can settle in a bit first.

This!

SchoolTripDrama · 22/04/2023 14:29

@KarmaStar what was the point of having her then returning to work

What a vile thing to say to a new mum

G5000 · 22/04/2023 13:20

There’s a lot of research suggesting that socioeconomic status is the single biggest predictor of a child’s life outcomes.

Money is a dirty word on MN, what kind of cold hearted mother would exchange those special memories of nappy-changes against cash. But I'm certain that being financially comfortable is much better for my DC than strugging but with more memories (mine, not theirs) from when they were 12 months old.

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 22/04/2023 13:17

So in your shoes I'd go for it! And try to negotiate some flexibility later on, once you've gained some favour by being there

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 22/04/2023 13:15

We both work full time with a 14 month old. Nursery is honestly amazing for him, and I was so nervous about it before. He loves his key worker, and they do so many activities with him and day trips out etc - we get videos, photos, a write up of his day, and food etc. He likes being with the other children.

We both work two days a week in the office, but that means someone is nearly always at home. Which sounds similar to your set up. So we can drop him just before 9am, and pick him up just after 5pm. Means he gets 3+ hours with us on the morning, and 2 hours with us in the evening before bedtime. To be honest we don't both need to work now, but like you say, it opens up so many opportunities for him later. We are thinking pay the mortgage down, and take a career break when he's older and will remember it. Maybe do some travelling, live abroad for a bit etc, and ease up then. As people say, I think the early school years are going to be the toughest and more flexibility then will be good

IAmTheWalrus85 · 22/04/2023 13:14

I don’t think there’s a right or wrong answer. But £30k a year extra is an enormous amount of money. It’s a whole other salary. And as much as people like to make working mothers feel bad, there’s a lot of research suggesting that socioeconomic status is the single biggest predictor of a child’s life outcomes.

And if your DH’s job is precarious surely it makes sense for you to earn as much as possible now?

ChocChipHandbag · 22/04/2023 13:11

@lifesnotaspectatorsport I was going to say something similar- my DS went to nursery 4 days a week (8am to 6pm), is now 6 and hardly remembers any of it either! He's a well adjusted child, I am not worried about it having had some invisible effect on him that will put him in therapy when he's 21.

He's too young to be aware now that it's 5 days on the trot, they just take each day as it comes at least until they are about 3.

That said OP, full time will feel like quite a lot to hi I am sure in terms of the time that you would like to spend with him. I haven't worked more than 4 days a week since DC (also an only) was born, but I was lucky in that my role was very suited to that. I did used to enjoy our Friday outings together. On the other hand, once he goes to school you'll be free to work full time because he'll be there 5 days a week. So we are only talking about what to do in the next 3 years. In your position I think I'd go for it now and suck up what they want just to cement my work reputation. but try to gain my employer's trust so I could get down to 4 days a week by the time he is 3, moving back to 5 again after school starts.

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 22/04/2023 13:07

@pinachina Cross-post! You're obviously on my wavelength Wink

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 22/04/2023 13:06

Oh and 100% get a cleaner. It was and is a big benefit of us both working FT that we never spend our weekends doing chores.

pinachina · 22/04/2023 13:05

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 22/04/2023 13:00

Go for it! It's only two days in the office and the rest WFH so you'll see DC plenty. Also they are already 1, so most of the big 'firsts' have already happened?

I went back FT in the office when DS1 was 16 months. It was really totally fine. I did the nursery drop-off and saw him for 1-2 hours in the evening, always did bedtime etc. Had a wonderful time with him every weekend.

He really enjoyed his nursery and it gave him a lot of social skills especially as he was an only child at the time. I did have a part-time nanny in the afternoons so he wasn't at nursery all day and could nap at home - but I think full time nursery would have been ok too. He had lovely relationships with his nursery teachers.

I was also ready to go back, and much as I loved being with him, I needed adult company and to use my brain too! It worked well.

And also - in the nicest possible way - he is now 6 and doesn't remember a bloody thing about any of it! As long as he's happy and well looked after, and you're happy and fulfilled, then all good Smile

This is a great response. I'd also add with the payrise you'll be able to afford a cleaner, if you wanted, to further free up weekends. Go for it!

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 22/04/2023 13:00

Go for it! It's only two days in the office and the rest WFH so you'll see DC plenty. Also they are already 1, so most of the big 'firsts' have already happened?

I went back FT in the office when DS1 was 16 months. It was really totally fine. I did the nursery drop-off and saw him for 1-2 hours in the evening, always did bedtime etc. Had a wonderful time with him every weekend.

He really enjoyed his nursery and it gave him a lot of social skills especially as he was an only child at the time. I did have a part-time nanny in the afternoons so he wasn't at nursery all day and could nap at home - but I think full time nursery would have been ok too. He had lovely relationships with his nursery teachers.

I was also ready to go back, and much as I loved being with him, I needed adult company and to use my brain too! It worked well.

And also - in the nicest possible way - he is now 6 and doesn't remember a bloody thing about any of it! As long as he's happy and well looked after, and you're happy and fulfilled, then all good Smile

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 12:59

@Typeheretosearch

Does your oh also work part time?

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 12:58

@toomuchlaundry

Sounds like ops job could be fairly flexible

3 days wfh. Potential to reduce hours

Sounds like a great compromise

My job meant potentially not seeing the kids 3 days a week when they were small.

It was fine. I never missed out on anything because of how flexible it was.

Typeheretosearch · 22/04/2023 12:58

I work 3 days per week with a 3yo and a 1yo. I am pretty good at my job and i am routinely asked by my company to be promoted to a full time role, but i refuse every single time.
This is the time for me to be at home with them. To enjoy them. To be bored with them. This time will never come back.

toomuchlaundry · 22/04/2023 12:53

@Botw1 DH had a job with reasonably long hours but tried to always be home for DS’s bedtime. He would never have taken a job which meant for 2 days a week he wouldn’t see DS at all.

His job was also flexible enough so he could make sports day, plays and parents’ evening, take DS to clubs occasionally. He would not have wanted to miss those opportunities. Might have meant he took slightly longer to progress his career but these are things to think about when looking at career paths and having a family

G5000 · 22/04/2023 12:38

Go for it. Yes there might be many threads about tired working parents, but there are way more about people financially struggling. Children can live on fresh air and happy memories only for so long.
This money will allow you to outsource some boring tasks - I never spend my Saturdays cleaning the house, I have a cleaner who makes sure the house is sparkling. And as pp said - part time is often the worst of both worlds. Work sees you as someone not interested in career even if you do full time work for less of the money. And everybody else sees you as 'only working part time' so almost a SAHM; therefore you end up doing all that a SAHM does as well, as the full time working DH needs to rest and relax.

whumpthereitis · 22/04/2023 11:56

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 11:37

Thanks for all your replies so far.

I won't be doing what @bumpytrumpy suggests, that's a fast way to piss off an employer, my contact and probably a one way ticket to dismissal. They aren't stupid, they aren't going to agree to three days on a permanent basis in the contract.

However I am hoping there might be scope to negotiate 4 days in 5 so I'll have 5 shorter days, as I think this could make a real difference. Also looking at option to go back down to part time after Sep 2024. Although I'm not sure how willing they'll be to commit to this in writing and of course there's always the risk they'll say yes now and no later.

The money would make a huge difference to us. We certainly aren't badly off now, but this could open up private school for DC and we could even maybe consider a nanny, which might work better. Although judging by the other nanny and WFH thread going on at the moment, I'm wary this may not work well as DH is pretty much FT WFH and I'd be at home 3 days. Previously I've not been keen on childminders for us. There's a history of CSA in the family and I feel nursery is safer. This is probably completely over the top and I'm sure people will be telling me this very quickly! Although I'm torn because I obviously recognise the benefits of being in a home from home setting. GPs not an option unfortunately.

DH and I have some talking to do. I wish I had a crystal ball!

To answer a point made by PP, I love my DC to the ends of the earth but she is a high needs baby and I've found the last year very tough. I'm looking forward to using my brain and finding myself again!

Fwiw my parents both worked full time in high paying jobs, and it provided my brother and I with a great quality life with a lot of opportunities and experiences. We’ve never been anything other than appreciative of them for that, and neither of us feel like we missed out by them doing that. The opposite, in fact.

I see no reason why you shouldn’t go for it.

GoodChat · 22/04/2023 11:46

Skybluepinky · 22/04/2023 10:11

Send yr child to a childminder for the extra days so they benefit from the home from home experience, rather than being institutionalised from a young age.

Institutionalised? JFC.

Tarantella6 · 22/04/2023 11:43

Nursery is a much easier option from the pov of sickness and holidays. Also they feed dc 3x a day so you're not having to fit in breakfast or make pack lunches.

OP, once you've been there a few months it'll be easier to see what is and isn't possible from a flex working perspective. I do 33 hours over 5 days which is 2 long days and 3 days I finish at 2.30. I honestly don't think 2 long days a week is the end of the world and it's good for dc to see Dad is just as capable of cooking tea, doing bedtime etc.

If there's concerns about redundancy for DH absolutely you should take this job. Working PT for less money won't feel like a treat when you're eating baked beans on toast every day!

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 11:37

Thanks for all your replies so far.

I won't be doing what @bumpytrumpy suggests, that's a fast way to piss off an employer, my contact and probably a one way ticket to dismissal. They aren't stupid, they aren't going to agree to three days on a permanent basis in the contract.

However I am hoping there might be scope to negotiate 4 days in 5 so I'll have 5 shorter days, as I think this could make a real difference. Also looking at option to go back down to part time after Sep 2024. Although I'm not sure how willing they'll be to commit to this in writing and of course there's always the risk they'll say yes now and no later.

The money would make a huge difference to us. We certainly aren't badly off now, but this could open up private school for DC and we could even maybe consider a nanny, which might work better. Although judging by the other nanny and WFH thread going on at the moment, I'm wary this may not work well as DH is pretty much FT WFH and I'd be at home 3 days. Previously I've not been keen on childminders for us. There's a history of CSA in the family and I feel nursery is safer. This is probably completely over the top and I'm sure people will be telling me this very quickly! Although I'm torn because I obviously recognise the benefits of being in a home from home setting. GPs not an option unfortunately.

DH and I have some talking to do. I wish I had a crystal ball!

To answer a point made by PP, I love my DC to the ends of the earth but she is a high needs baby and I've found the last year very tough. I'm looking forward to using my brain and finding myself again!

OP posts:
Treacletoots · 22/04/2023 11:14

Depends on how much you enjoy spending time with DC. No I'm not being facetious! I genuinely found the early years a complete struggle and really didn't enjoy it. I suffered from PND and a few other painful health issues when DC was under 2 and I was personally relieved to go back to work when DC was 6 months.

I did 4 days initially, and DH did his shared parental leave, when DC reached 1 I went back full time as did DH. Whilst we didn't strictly need the money, the fact that I significantly earn more than we paid nursery for a day's care meant that we were several hundreds of pounds better off for working FT.

DC is now 6, and a very socially confident happy child, so clearly being in nursery FT had no negative effect on their development. I think you really do have to consider long term OP what is best for you? More money, more opportunity and with potential long term redundancy on the cards I'd want to be in as best financial situation as possible.

toomuchlaundry · 22/04/2023 11:14

@EarringsandLipstick if you work FT, unless your employment is flexible, you do miss loads especially when they are in the first years at school. There are many opportunities when parents can be involved then. Those things might not interest you, so won't bother you if you miss them, but for other parents they are things that they will want to have some involvement in, and so try to either work PT or have flexible working. It is something to consider when considering FT working. School holidays are also something to consider. It is actually much easier to be FT when children can be in FT childcare, finding childcare for school holidays can be a nightmare depending where you live, or after school care too if you work long hours/have long commute. Where I live there is only one provider of holiday club, and that is only 10 - 4 so doesn't actually help many working parents!

OP has said that 2 days of the week she won't see DC at all, that can be tough

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 11:01

bumpytrumpy · 22/04/2023 10:50

I'd take it and agree to review the hours in September but not commit to definitely going FT. Make sure your contract says 3 days. Then refuse to amend it saying the role is as much as you can manage; let them bring in a job share if they need more hours.

Honestly employers try this shit all the time, stand your ground. If you're good at the job then by September they'll have invested in you and won't want to lose you.

Terrible terrible advice.

Imagine intentionally setting your employer up like this 🤦🏻‍♀️

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 11:00

OP, it's clear from your post that you would really welcome this opportunity, plus it offers a significant salary increase & additional benefits.

Definitely go for it - you being happy and fulfilled is the best indicator of family happiness including your DC's!

You also have a supportive & involved spouse and the ability to pay for a cleaner. Really helpful.

I am a single parent, have worked full time nearly always and find it really hard because I've no support but from a work point of view, f/t is better than p/t in my experience.

The posters talking about missing out are being ridiculous - OP will see plenty of her DC, and be a great parent, there when it matters.

samqueens · 22/04/2023 10:52

If it were 4 days I would do it but (if affordable) I wouldn’t do it f/t. I would however let them down in the most polite and reasonable way possible to leave the door open to future opportunities.

working a demanding role full time saps a lot from you - it’s not just the hours out of the house. Pre-school years can be magic if you’re not pushed to the wall.

it’s a difficult decision though - good luck