Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take this job despite negative impact on DC?

241 replies

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 08:42

NC for this as have also posted elsewhere and apologies for slightly dramatic title, I don't really think this would be detrimental to DC per se, I just couldn't think of a better way to word it!

I'm currently on mat leave with 1 yo DC, due to return at the end of May. I like my job in the sense that I love my colleagues, but the quality of work is crap and things have apparently changed a lot since I've been on mat leave. Targets have gone up, pay has not increased relatively and expectations are generally getting bigger without much in return. I've been wanting to move on for some time, but the pandemic and then pregnancy put that all on hold for a while.

I've been looking for a new job for a while but nothing suitable has come up. I've agreed 3 days a week on my return with my current employer and in the office once or twice a week. Overall they're pretty flexible about how and when I work, so long as client needs are met - along with targets.

Last week a potential new role came up which would be a huge payrise (think £30k FTE) with better benefits and very similar targets and expectations. Also a huge improvement in quality of work. It's also comforting because I know someone who works there and I'm confident I'd be happy there because she is and I know her personality. They're happy for me to start on 3 or 4 days BUT the catch is they'd want me to go full time from September.

This wasn't the plan - DC is going to nursery 3 days a week and I thought this would be the perfect balance for us. However, this is a really great opportunity and given the huge improvements in all areas of the job, I feel I'd be really stupid to miss out. At the same time, I feel so guilty for putting DC into nursery full time and missing so much time with them when they're so little. It's likely they'll be an only child and I worry I'd regret the decision later on. I'd be in the office 2 days a week and I'd be out of the house from 7.30-7.30 at least on those days, so basically won't see DC.

Now I know I'm incredibly privileged to be in this position and many people have no choice but to work full time and utilise full time childcare, so this post isn't meant to be insensitive and I certainly don't judge anyone who puts their DC in full time, but this wasn't what I'd planned for.

So, AIBU to go for a new role which would make a huge difference to both my career and our finances, even though it would mean DC being in FT childcare, rather than 3 days a week?

OP posts:
Botw1 · 22/04/2023 18:31

Funny how the oh how could you, its awful you'll miss so much and never will never get this time backers, dont care that their kids dads are missing out on this precious time they'll never get back.

DisquietintheRanks · 22/04/2023 18:29

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 17:04

I’ve yet to hear anyone raise this to a father though. It’s always, always aimed at mothers.

But that doesn't mean that father's dont miss out or don't regret that in later years. Its a very personal decision as to what to prioritise but no one can have it all.

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 18:28

@ladymaiasura

I worked just less than full time and had gone back up to full time when they went to school.

I did drop offs and pick ups, helped out.

Not everyone who works works Mon to fri 9 to 5

EsmeSusanOgg · 22/04/2023 18:23

I found part time harder work. I effectively did full time work in a shorter time period for less pay and did childcare. Not helped by the pandemic tbh.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 18:23

NewNovember · 22/04/2023 18:15

In what world is one year old not a baby?

I imagine they mean not a small baby, almost a toddler.

Like compared to mine who is 4 months.

GoodChat · 22/04/2023 18:22

@NewNovember a 1 year old is generally a toddler and certainly shouldn't be spending time in a cot aside from nap time

MiniOreo90 · 22/04/2023 18:17

I would never put a child in full time childcare unless it was absolutely essential for financial reasons and by that I mean if we were on our asses for money. They’re only young for a very short period of time. There’ll be other jobs but you’ll never have this time back

NewNovember · 22/04/2023 18:15

GoodChat · 22/04/2023 18:02

OP's child is one. Not a baby. And if my child was attending a nursery where I saw multiple babies crying in cots regularly I'd withdraw them.

In what world is one year old not a baby?

NewNovember · 22/04/2023 18:14

You title was correct as you will pretty much only see your baby awake at weekends.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 18:12

Me too.

I have a baby in nursery and what I most often see is a baby on someone’s hip.

Babies crying in cots isn’t my experience at all.

GoodChat · 22/04/2023 18:02

elodiesmith · 22/04/2023 17:24

Also to add. Not to "scare" you.. but because I don't work now and I started DS at daycare, I hang around there for 30mins and drop off and 30 mins at pickup (staff welcome me to hang around plus at times every educator is too occupied with other babies so there's no one available immediately to hand over my baby).

So many babies cry and just cannot get attended to at every cry. This means I've seen babies cry in a cot for 5-10 mins before the staff can attend to them. It's normal for a baby to wail 5-10 mins before anyone can attend to them due to 1 person looking after 4 babies.

Again, it's not the end of the world and babies will be fine. But I wouldn't want the whole working week for my kid. (If I had the choice. I know some working mothers have to go back full time)

OP's child is one. Not a baby. And if my child was attending a nursery where I saw multiple babies crying in cots regularly I'd withdraw them.

Pipsquiggle · 22/04/2023 18:01

With your DH retiring soon, I would definitely take the job.

His hours will taper off in a couple of years and he will be able to do more childcare

GoodChat · 22/04/2023 18:00

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 17:26

I’ve yet to hear anyone raise this to a father though. It’s always, always aimed at mothers

Absolutely.

And then we complain about the gender pay gap - but it's women who are as bad or worse than other men at making mothers working FT feel inferior

toomuchlaundry · 22/04/2023 17:53

@EarringsandLipstick in your post you said that posters telling OP that she would be missing out are ridiculous. I was just pointing out if you are in a FT job with little flexibility including 2 days a week when you don’t get home until 7pm you will miss out on things, and the ‘you’ wasn’t aimed at you it was aimed at parents who don’t mind missing those things, other parents do. And if you are a parent who does want to attend those things then you need to consider them when a new job/career is a possibility. Some parents will run screaming from the school gates and are quite happy to pass that joy onto childminders, others love the chance to chat with other parents.

Obviously, some parents don’t have a choice (and notice I use parents not mums) but in this case the OP has a choice. If I was her I would be checking what flexibility there is. If she is getting a pay rise of £30k I would assume the employer is keen to take her on, so some more negotiation of terms may be on the cards. I’ve also pointed out that the early years of school can be actually harder to cover if both parents are FT, especially in areas where holiday clubs are few and far between, than the nursery years. In the OP’s case this hopefully won’t be a problem as her DH will be retired by then (which OP mentioned after this consideration was raised)

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 17:31

toomuchlaundry · 22/04/2023 17:20

@SouthLondonMum22 I’ve said that my DH changed his role so he would have more flexibility and time at home once DS was on the scene, also meant he could attend events when DS was at Primary School. He wouldn’t have considered a job where he would not have seen DS 2 days a week because he didn’t get home in time. His previous job did entail working until 10pm or later when he was working on deals, but he wasn’t going to carry on with that role once we had a family. I say exactly the same thing to anyone looking at careers, if you are planning to have a family, consider what flexibility there may be once you have children, whether you are male or female. DH was a very hands on dad and he wanted to be as involved as possible, and he tries to make that possible for all his staff who are parents or who have other commitments (even allowed an office dog!)

You are a very small minority. Men aren’t made to feel guilty or that they don’t raise their child or don’t love them enough when they continue to work full time after becoming a parent.

Women are. All of the time.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 17:26

I’ve yet to hear anyone raise this to a father though. It’s always, always aimed at mothers

Absolutely.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 17:25

@ladymaiasura

So. Many. Assumptions. (Mostly wrong, naturally)

If you are working full time you are with your child less

Less time. Not necessarily less quality or meaningful time. It also depends on the children. Mine liked their creche / ASC (though I had one awful year with a terrible ASC, where they were unhappy, and so was I. I didn't have a choice though, and that's definitely a hard position to be in for sure)

It’s not the full time working parents who help on school trips or go into school each week to help listen to kids read etc is it?
Wrong again. I have always helped out at cane sales and trips. We don't do the reading thing in Ireland but I am the parent who does Christmas & summer collections for the teachers, and I've been on the PTA in both primary & secondary schools many times. I do this because I want involvement in my DC's world and I make the time. I know plenty of SAHM who don't get involved at all - I don't judge that at all, it's entirely a matter of choice.
In my experience, parents who want to do, and it has relatively little to do with their employment status.

Full time working parents aren’t often at school pick up either as their kids will be going to after school club or picked up by childminders. That’s not to say their kids will suffer for it but the parents will miss things.
This is true. Certainly in younger years it's hard when this happens & I tried to balance it - make sure I could do school drops, if not collections.
However, for everything there is a positive as well as a challenge. My DC are independent & capable and while they sometimes wish I could be there at some points, they realise my work is a necessity, but also something that's important to me, and that's a good thing too.

And it’s quite true to say some people will be upset to miss these things and some won’t.
I didn't dispute that (my objection to @toomuchlaundry post was their assumption about f/t working parents 'missing loads' and that it didn't bother them. Most caring parents will be 'bothered' if they miss events. Sometimes they'll have no choice. Many times, like me, they can, admittedly with a lot of effort, make those key events, so no-one is missing out.

Ultimately parents need to do what's best for them & their DC. And that looks different for every family.

Posts like yours make simple inaccurate assumptions and are infuriating.

elodiesmith · 22/04/2023 17:24

Also to add. Not to "scare" you.. but because I don't work now and I started DS at daycare, I hang around there for 30mins and drop off and 30 mins at pickup (staff welcome me to hang around plus at times every educator is too occupied with other babies so there's no one available immediately to hand over my baby).

So many babies cry and just cannot get attended to at every cry. This means I've seen babies cry in a cot for 5-10 mins before the staff can attend to them. It's normal for a baby to wail 5-10 mins before anyone can attend to them due to 1 person looking after 4 babies.

Again, it's not the end of the world and babies will be fine. But I wouldn't want the whole working week for my kid. (If I had the choice. I know some working mothers have to go back full time)

toomuchlaundry · 22/04/2023 17:20

@SouthLondonMum22 I’ve said that my DH changed his role so he would have more flexibility and time at home once DS was on the scene, also meant he could attend events when DS was at Primary School. He wouldn’t have considered a job where he would not have seen DS 2 days a week because he didn’t get home in time. His previous job did entail working until 10pm or later when he was working on deals, but he wasn’t going to carry on with that role once we had a family. I say exactly the same thing to anyone looking at careers, if you are planning to have a family, consider what flexibility there may be once you have children, whether you are male or female. DH was a very hands on dad and he wanted to be as involved as possible, and he tries to make that possible for all his staff who are parents or who have other commitments (even allowed an office dog!)

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 17:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

elodiesmith · 22/04/2023 17:17

OP, I'm in a similar situation and feel like I have to respond as I am one step ahead of you and you might not like what you read now.

I'm 'ahead' in a way that DS has started nursery one month ago. I have a luxury of doing that to get him settled in before I go back to work on 31 may.

I roughly do 8am-2pm days as obviously I'm not working so I can just get him whenever. A few times I did 7.30am-4pm days and let me tell you, it's quite intense. You see them for an hour and they're tired/cranky before it bedtime routine. It's not quality time. You barely see them. The contrast of spending 7 days with him to just 2 days, is full on. And my DS is a high needs baby so I do love a break from him! But 5 days is a lot. Your child is very little. They're your baby. The only one you'll have.

Your baby is high needs just as mine. Mine took time to settle in and still often cries at drop off with tears running down his face and screaming for me. It's f hard. I'm SO glad I then can just pick him up in 4 hours or so. Consider walking away from your crying baby reaching out with his arms to you, as you walk away for 10 hours. You'll be thinking of him all day.

Daycare sickness - oh dear. You're likely to both get sick and even when you're not sick, it's quite brutal. Baby vomiting.. diarrhoea... Stuffed nose where they can't eat. Adding up the pressures of new role (and no sick days accrued) will be tough.

So this is my similar situation with one step ahead. We've decided I will only go back 3 days.
Those who say 'babies won't remember' this but you will. And this is your only baby, you'll never have this again. You'll have other jobs.

The main caveat in my story is that we're financially well off so we can already afford private school and my pension is sorted as we have several properties. BUT it doesn't sound like you're struggling either.

Ultimately you decide what to do. But I wanted to give me side of the story on this. After starting daycare and seeing what 'that life' is like, I wouldn't do it. Good luck.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 17:04

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 16:47

Don’t be silly. It’s not patronising or rude, it’s honest. If you are working full time you are with your child less. That’s just fact. It’s not the full time working parents who help on school trips or go into school each week to help listen to kids read etc is it? Full time working parents aren’t often at school pick up either as their kids will be going to after school club or picked up by childminders. That’s not to say their kids will suffer for it but the parents will miss things. There’s no way around that. And it’s quite true to say some people will be upset to miss these things and some won’t.

I’ve yet to hear anyone raise this to a father though. It’s always, always aimed at mothers.

LeFeu · 22/04/2023 16:55

I think long term being in this role will be great for your family. It might feel hard now but think about the benefits in a few years - you’re happy and satisfied in your work, you have the finances to really enjoy your time off together, and potentially going 4 days or 4 in 5 in a year sounds perfect (I went back very part time when my kids were small but I’m so much happier now doing 4 days a week and my kids get a much better me for it which also influences my advice!)

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 16:47

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 16:23

Oh my gosh, what a patronising assumptive post!

I've 3 DC. I'm a single parent with no help. So I do everything.

In my case, I have to work full time so it's bit different but I also want to for various reasons - one being it's actually easier to work f/t than trying to catch up when working p/t (shouldn't be the way, but it is). And I get personal satisfaction from my work.

I can't say I've made every event for my DC, but pretty nearly - shows, concerts, sports days, matches, p/t meetings.

How do I do that? Annual leave mostly, and I do have some flexibility - however the work needs to be done regardless & I work in an academic role in a University so I'm limited by teaching / term time.

OP has a spouse who is involved, and can afford help like a cleaner.

Of course she will be fine! One or other parent can be there when needed. She'll see plenty of her kids & will be an involved parent.
Honestly the rudeness of your post amazes me. 😡

Don’t be silly. It’s not patronising or rude, it’s honest. If you are working full time you are with your child less. That’s just fact. It’s not the full time working parents who help on school trips or go into school each week to help listen to kids read etc is it? Full time working parents aren’t often at school pick up either as their kids will be going to after school club or picked up by childminders. That’s not to say their kids will suffer for it but the parents will miss things. There’s no way around that. And it’s quite true to say some people will be upset to miss these things and some won’t.

Gcsunnyside23 · 22/04/2023 16:38

Skybluepinky · 22/04/2023 10:11

Send yr child to a childminder for the extra days so they benefit from the home from home experience, rather than being institutionalised from a young age.

I had the opposite experience, my children much preferred nursery setting over childminder