Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take this job despite negative impact on DC?

241 replies

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 08:42

NC for this as have also posted elsewhere and apologies for slightly dramatic title, I don't really think this would be detrimental to DC per se, I just couldn't think of a better way to word it!

I'm currently on mat leave with 1 yo DC, due to return at the end of May. I like my job in the sense that I love my colleagues, but the quality of work is crap and things have apparently changed a lot since I've been on mat leave. Targets have gone up, pay has not increased relatively and expectations are generally getting bigger without much in return. I've been wanting to move on for some time, but the pandemic and then pregnancy put that all on hold for a while.

I've been looking for a new job for a while but nothing suitable has come up. I've agreed 3 days a week on my return with my current employer and in the office once or twice a week. Overall they're pretty flexible about how and when I work, so long as client needs are met - along with targets.

Last week a potential new role came up which would be a huge payrise (think £30k FTE) with better benefits and very similar targets and expectations. Also a huge improvement in quality of work. It's also comforting because I know someone who works there and I'm confident I'd be happy there because she is and I know her personality. They're happy for me to start on 3 or 4 days BUT the catch is they'd want me to go full time from September.

This wasn't the plan - DC is going to nursery 3 days a week and I thought this would be the perfect balance for us. However, this is a really great opportunity and given the huge improvements in all areas of the job, I feel I'd be really stupid to miss out. At the same time, I feel so guilty for putting DC into nursery full time and missing so much time with them when they're so little. It's likely they'll be an only child and I worry I'd regret the decision later on. I'd be in the office 2 days a week and I'd be out of the house from 7.30-7.30 at least on those days, so basically won't see DC.

Now I know I'm incredibly privileged to be in this position and many people have no choice but to work full time and utilise full time childcare, so this post isn't meant to be insensitive and I certainly don't judge anyone who puts their DC in full time, but this wasn't what I'd planned for.

So, AIBU to go for a new role which would make a huge difference to both my career and our finances, even though it would mean DC being in FT childcare, rather than 3 days a week?

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 21:50

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 21:46

I didn’t say full time working parents are never at pick up, just not often (true in my experience). There is more flexibility these days with increased working from home post-covid but it doesn’t apply to every job. I don’t personally know anyone who works full time and manages both drop off and pick up. Great that you did but I suspect that’s quite rare. And I am well aware that not all jobs are Mon-Fri 9-5 but it sounds like OPs would be. And she has stated that she’ll be out of the house for at least 12 hours on days she has to go into the office. Her situation sounds quite different to yours…

That's 2 days. The other 3 days it sounds like she'd be working from home which could be flexible enough in several years time to do drop offs and/or pick ups.

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 21:46

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 18:28

@ladymaiasura

I worked just less than full time and had gone back up to full time when they went to school.

I did drop offs and pick ups, helped out.

Not everyone who works works Mon to fri 9 to 5

I didn’t say full time working parents are never at pick up, just not often (true in my experience). There is more flexibility these days with increased working from home post-covid but it doesn’t apply to every job. I don’t personally know anyone who works full time and manages both drop off and pick up. Great that you did but I suspect that’s quite rare. And I am well aware that not all jobs are Mon-Fri 9-5 but it sounds like OPs would be. And she has stated that she’ll be out of the house for at least 12 hours on days she has to go into the office. Her situation sounds quite different to yours…

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 21:34

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 17:25

@ladymaiasura

So. Many. Assumptions. (Mostly wrong, naturally)

If you are working full time you are with your child less

Less time. Not necessarily less quality or meaningful time. It also depends on the children. Mine liked their creche / ASC (though I had one awful year with a terrible ASC, where they were unhappy, and so was I. I didn't have a choice though, and that's definitely a hard position to be in for sure)

It’s not the full time working parents who help on school trips or go into school each week to help listen to kids read etc is it?
Wrong again. I have always helped out at cane sales and trips. We don't do the reading thing in Ireland but I am the parent who does Christmas & summer collections for the teachers, and I've been on the PTA in both primary & secondary schools many times. I do this because I want involvement in my DC's world and I make the time. I know plenty of SAHM who don't get involved at all - I don't judge that at all, it's entirely a matter of choice.
In my experience, parents who want to do, and it has relatively little to do with their employment status.

Full time working parents aren’t often at school pick up either as their kids will be going to after school club or picked up by childminders. That’s not to say their kids will suffer for it but the parents will miss things.
This is true. Certainly in younger years it's hard when this happens & I tried to balance it - make sure I could do school drops, if not collections.
However, for everything there is a positive as well as a challenge. My DC are independent & capable and while they sometimes wish I could be there at some points, they realise my work is a necessity, but also something that's important to me, and that's a good thing too.

And it’s quite true to say some people will be upset to miss these things and some won’t.
I didn't dispute that (my objection to @toomuchlaundry post was their assumption about f/t working parents 'missing loads' and that it didn't bother them. Most caring parents will be 'bothered' if they miss events. Sometimes they'll have no choice. Many times, like me, they can, admittedly with a lot of effort, make those key events, so no-one is missing out.

Ultimately parents need to do what's best for them & their DC. And that looks different for every family.

Posts like yours make simple inaccurate assumptions and are infuriating.

Sorry, I’m not sure what was inaccurate about what I said. I didn’t say children couldn’t enjoy their time in child care or that they wouldn’t have quality time with a working parent. I said that if you are working full time you are with your child less. Unless you can be in two places at once, this is true. That’s not to say full time work can’t work well for families. Of course it can. I stated in a previous post that my sister went back to work full time when my nephew was 6 months old. They have a great relationship and he certainly hasn’t suffered for it.

That’s great that you organise collections for your kids’ teachers and are on the PTA. Those are not things that the kids are involved in though. I was talking about spending time with the children.

You agree with my next two points and then say I’ve made inaccurate assumptions. Makes no sense.

I absolutely agree that people need to do what‘s best for them. Working parents may well make it to most key events in their kids’ lives but they won’t be there for the little things that happen daily. For someone like OP, who has the choice financially, it really is a case of deciding what your priorities are. And yes, that does look different for every family. There is no universal right or wrong. You are inferring judgement in what I have said when there was none intended.

Mariposista · 22/04/2023 20:36

Go for it OP. Sounds like a great career opportunity for you.

Urghfedup · 22/04/2023 20:32

My friend had a similar job while hers were little and she paid for a housekeeper who also prepared an evening meal and did their shopping. She had a gardener and had her PA do all the paperwork for the house. On Friday she would kick off her shoes and just be with kids till Monday morning. She was the most relaxed out of all of us…and her kids are awesome too.

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:31

@SouthLondonMum22 because I think that there is something to be learnt by having to make your own way, to some extent.

University fees and other expenses I would pay, but after that...no.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 20:29

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:20

@whumpthereitis we are all different. And even if I was a millionaire I wouldn't be giving my kids a house deposit.

Why not?

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:20

@whumpthereitis we are all different. And even if I was a millionaire I wouldn't be giving my kids a house deposit.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 22/04/2023 20:19

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 18:31

Funny how the oh how could you, its awful you'll miss so much and never will never get this time backers, dont care that their kids dads are missing out on this precious time they'll never get back.

Yeah, I can never quite square this circle. But I married a man who actually wanted to parent.

whumpthereitis · 22/04/2023 20:17

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:07

@whumpthereitis yes I'm not saying the OP is wrong for wanting treats etc, thats up to her and her DH. Treats etc weren't as important to us as having me at home to look after the kids. We were young when we had DD so not fully established yet, but over the years DH has had decent payrises and we are certainly not scraping by anymore.

There’s many ways children can benefit from their parents, and whether people like to acknowledge it or not, money is a significant and not at all unimportant factor.

My parents working hugely benefited my brother and I throughout our childhoods, and benefits us now into adulthood. Money pays for travel, schooling and/or tutoring, and hobbies. It can mean getting through university with little or no debt, house deposits etc. like I said, neither my brother nor I have ever resented my parents from working (working away at times), and are hugely appreciative of them having done so. I wouldn’t have swapped the life we had and have for one which would have meant us scraping by but with a sahp.

UndercoverCop · 22/04/2023 20:17

I'd try and negotiate 5 in 4 and if possible DH do the same. It's how we have done it. Means DC are still only in childcare 3 days and you have two full time salaries. We both work a long day 11+ hours on the other's NWD , so you don't have to worry about pick up drop off etc, so the other three days are only slightly longer than normal days (both 37 his FT) , and one of us will do drop off and the other pick up. I tend to start early and finish around 5:30, DH will do the opposite.

sarahsarahsara · 22/04/2023 20:16

@MumGuilt3000 I'd take the role. Delegate some of the life admin and get a cleaner. Be disciplined about switching off when you're home. Many many of us work full time and I'm proud my children see me thriving, financially independent and deeply unquestionably close and committed to them.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 22/04/2023 20:10

elodiesmith · 22/04/2023 17:24

Also to add. Not to "scare" you.. but because I don't work now and I started DS at daycare, I hang around there for 30mins and drop off and 30 mins at pickup (staff welcome me to hang around plus at times every educator is too occupied with other babies so there's no one available immediately to hand over my baby).

So many babies cry and just cannot get attended to at every cry. This means I've seen babies cry in a cot for 5-10 mins before the staff can attend to them. It's normal for a baby to wail 5-10 mins before anyone can attend to them due to 1 person looking after 4 babies.

Again, it's not the end of the world and babies will be fine. But I wouldn't want the whole working week for my kid. (If I had the choice. I know some working mothers have to go back full time)

I really don’t understand why you’ve put a baby in ‘daycare’ if you don’t work when it’s clearly a terrible setting. Typically staff at nurseries don’t invite adults with no DBS checks to ‘hang around’ for an hour a day for a start. Plus the legal ratio for caring for babies in England is 1 adult to 3 babies.

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:09

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 20:08

I couldn't agree more.

It's how I grew up, scraping by so my mum could be a SAHM. It isn't something I want for my DC.

I want him to have treats, I want to be able to have savings for him, I want to be able to afford clubs and nice holidays for him.

It isn't so I can buy the fanciest house, car or handbag.

We have all these things for our children. But in the early days there was no spare cash cos it all went on the mortgage.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 20:08

whumpthereitis · 22/04/2023 20:02

“We had no treats and no spare cash for a long while.”

it’s fine for OP to want to have spare cash and to provide treats. The money OP would make would also benefit her children, and provide them with opportunities and experiences they wouldn’t otherwise have. That has significant value in itself, and isn’t inherently lesser than staying home.

I’m not sure why scraping by is considered preferable to being able to support her children with a comfortable quality of life.

I couldn't agree more.

It's how I grew up, scraping by so my mum could be a SAHM. It isn't something I want for my DC.

I want him to have treats, I want to be able to have savings for him, I want to be able to afford clubs and nice holidays for him.

It isn't so I can buy the fanciest house, car or handbag.

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:07

@whumpthereitis yes I'm not saying the OP is wrong for wanting treats etc, thats up to her and her DH. Treats etc weren't as important to us as having me at home to look after the kids. We were young when we had DD so not fully established yet, but over the years DH has had decent payrises and we are certainly not scraping by anymore.

whumpthereitis · 22/04/2023 20:02

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 19:43

My husband worked FT, I stayed at home til the kids went to school. Now im PT and kids are 16 and 10.

He had modest income at the time and we bought our first house (12.5 years ago) on his income alone because we'd both saved up a decent deposit and were realistic about the house we could afford on one income. We had no treats and no spare cash for a long while.

I wanted to look after my own kids so made the necessary sacrifices. Some people want to look after their own kids and can't afford to (no matter how many sacrifices they make), which is sad.

“We had no treats and no spare cash for a long while.”

it’s fine for OP to want to have spare cash and to provide treats. The money OP would make would also benefit her children, and provide them with opportunities and experiences they wouldn’t otherwise have. That has significant value in itself, and isn’t inherently lesser than staying home.

I’m not sure why scraping by is considered preferable to being able to support her children with a comfortable quality of life.

Cherryblossoms85 · 22/04/2023 20:02

I did this and regretted it. Yes, stacks of money, but we had enough. I've missed that time with small children and will never get it back. Still, you never know, maybe I'd have hated it.

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 20:00

@Dacadactyl

No the op says out of the house 12 hours days a week.

It will be fine

And the point of having kids os ti be a family and watch them grow into independent adults with lives of their own

Not to martyr yourselves to them 24/7

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 19:59

@SouthLondonMum22 yes I realised that and commented as such at 19.58

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 19:58

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 19:55

@Botw1 you've misread the OP. My understanding is she will be expected to go FT from September, away from the child for 12 hours a day, 5 days a week.

I think you have actually misread.

From OP

''I'd be in the office 2 days a week and I'd be out of the house from 7.30-7.30 at least on those days''

Sissynova · 22/04/2023 19:58

It's normal for a baby to wail 5-10 mins before anyone can attend to them due to 1 person looking after 4 babies.. @elodiesmith

The legal ratio in the uk is 1:3 for under twos so there would not be 1 person looking after 4 babies.

If you apparently see babies being left to wail for 10 mins and still send your child there then that says more about you, particularly as you’ve no need for your child to be there. Really weird to pick such a shit nursery when you don’t even work and then try to make an assumption on all childcare.

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 19:58

@Botw1 just rechecked it and she will be FT but in office 2 days a week, away for 12 hours on those days.

Not seeing your small children for 12 hours is a long time for THEM. And it's not something I'd personally want for them either.

Croissantsandpistachio · 22/04/2023 19:58

@Dacadactyl she will only be in the office 2 days a week. The other days wfh so no commute.

I look after my children by earning money so they can have things like 'a house' and 'food'. There are lots of ways to look after children.

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 19:57

@toomuchlaundry

Well obviously you can't have a physical impossibility

A sahp isn't the ideal. It's not something I was ever trying to achieve.

So yeah, I can have it all.