Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take this job despite negative impact on DC?

241 replies

MumGuilt3000 · 22/04/2023 08:42

NC for this as have also posted elsewhere and apologies for slightly dramatic title, I don't really think this would be detrimental to DC per se, I just couldn't think of a better way to word it!

I'm currently on mat leave with 1 yo DC, due to return at the end of May. I like my job in the sense that I love my colleagues, but the quality of work is crap and things have apparently changed a lot since I've been on mat leave. Targets have gone up, pay has not increased relatively and expectations are generally getting bigger without much in return. I've been wanting to move on for some time, but the pandemic and then pregnancy put that all on hold for a while.

I've been looking for a new job for a while but nothing suitable has come up. I've agreed 3 days a week on my return with my current employer and in the office once or twice a week. Overall they're pretty flexible about how and when I work, so long as client needs are met - along with targets.

Last week a potential new role came up which would be a huge payrise (think £30k FTE) with better benefits and very similar targets and expectations. Also a huge improvement in quality of work. It's also comforting because I know someone who works there and I'm confident I'd be happy there because she is and I know her personality. They're happy for me to start on 3 or 4 days BUT the catch is they'd want me to go full time from September.

This wasn't the plan - DC is going to nursery 3 days a week and I thought this would be the perfect balance for us. However, this is a really great opportunity and given the huge improvements in all areas of the job, I feel I'd be really stupid to miss out. At the same time, I feel so guilty for putting DC into nursery full time and missing so much time with them when they're so little. It's likely they'll be an only child and I worry I'd regret the decision later on. I'd be in the office 2 days a week and I'd be out of the house from 7.30-7.30 at least on those days, so basically won't see DC.

Now I know I'm incredibly privileged to be in this position and many people have no choice but to work full time and utilise full time childcare, so this post isn't meant to be insensitive and I certainly don't judge anyone who puts their DC in full time, but this wasn't what I'd planned for.

So, AIBU to go for a new role which would make a huge difference to both my career and our finances, even though it would mean DC being in FT childcare, rather than 3 days a week?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 23/04/2023 10:36

it's women who are as bad or worse than other men at making mothers working FT feel inferior

That's a really good point too.

EarringsandLipstick · 23/04/2023 10:36

in your post you said that posters telling OP that she would be missing out are ridiculous

They are - because stating as a fact is inaccurate & ridiculous, as I demonstrated. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 10:30

@whumpthereitis

While some will absolutely believe what they’re saying, there will also be those that would use those tropes to encourage OP not to take it because they don’t want to see someone else advance if they can’t.

Maybe. I can't speak for people's motives and I think a lot of it is just social conditioning and muddled thinking. I just feel really strongly that children benefit more by leagues of magnitude from having mothers with financial independence and agency in the workplace and in the family than they do from observing some homespun notion of hands-on motherhood seeped in moral tropes from the immediate postwar era.

Most small children barely remember this period. A traumatic and neglectful upbringing is of course awful and to be avoided at all cost, but this isn't what we're talking about. With a good, trusted caregiver it literally makes no difference. I do understand the emotional wrench that a mother experiences going back to work when they have a small child as I've done it myself but indulging this for a few more months isn't usually a good reason for passing up a step change in financial wellbeing for a family.

As a single mother also I didn't have these choices open to me and I thoroughly resent the idea that I've harmed my child by putting her in the care of a professional and thoroughly well research childminder while I went out to earn money which she needed to keep a roof over her head.

Of course the OP is entitled to consider whether she's ready to go back to work and to try to manage the work/life balance as best as possible for herself and her child (and with the support of her partner). But this constant drip drip of "you'll really regret it" or "you'll never get the time back" is so damaging. And it makes many of us angry because it is never directed at the father in the family.

Let's be really honest about the risk/reward benefit: few women regret massively enhancing their financial strength and quite a lot live to regret becoming financially dependent on a man for a few extra months of looking after a small child.

whumpthereitis · 23/04/2023 10:14

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 09:50

@ladymaiasura almost all mothers want to be there for their small children. That’s motherhood and apple pie (forgive the pun). It’s so obvious it doesn’t need stating.

But the OP’s dilemma is: is a few more months of hands on FT childcare really worth passing up a life changing amount of money? I would say the family will benefit far more from the extra money (and the longer term benefit to the OP’s earning power) than a few extra months of her singing “wind the bobbin up” and going around the park

I’m not being dismissive about this btw. Good care of young children is hugely important but the idea that all of this has to be done by the biological parent or the family will suffer is routinely used as a way to hold women back from achieving critical financial independence. And there’s no credible evidence that a working mum does any harm to the children. So why keep banging on and making women feel shit about advancing themselves?

While some will absolutely believe what they’re saying, there will also be those that would use those tropes to encourage OP not to take it because they don’t want to see someone else advance if they can’t.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 09:50

@ladymaiasura almost all mothers want to be there for their small children. That’s motherhood and apple pie (forgive the pun). It’s so obvious it doesn’t need stating.

But the OP’s dilemma is: is a few more months of hands on FT childcare really worth passing up a life changing amount of money? I would say the family will benefit far more from the extra money (and the longer term benefit to the OP’s earning power) than a few extra months of her singing “wind the bobbin up” and going around the park

I’m not being dismissive about this btw. Good care of young children is hugely important but the idea that all of this has to be done by the biological parent or the family will suffer is routinely used as a way to hold women back from achieving critical financial independence. And there’s no credible evidence that a working mum does any harm to the children. So why keep banging on and making women feel shit about advancing themselves?

ladymaiasura · 23/04/2023 09:40

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 08:29

OP is part of a society where sexism is ingrained from birth which leads to many women worrying that working full time will have a negative impact on their child. They are made to believe that they should feel guilty for wanting a career.

Men are raised to be 'providers', they are expected to work so don't get asked why they bother having children if they were just going to work/not see them/not look after them.

This. I find it pretty shocking that a bunch of people have tipped up here to actively discourage someone from taking a job which could hugely improve their family’s economic wellbeing because of some martyrdom complex about mothers having to be there at every waking moment of children’s early lives and the same is never applied to the father. It’s profoundly depressing.

Everyone getting on their high horse about a women’s right to work and societal expectations - that is not the issue here!

These concerns are valid, we have a long long way to go before we are anywhere near gender equality and no woman should be made to feel guilty about wanting a career.

But OPs concern is that she will regret her choice because she WANTS to be there for her small child. Not because she feels she has to be. She has explicitly stated she doesn’t think her child will suffer if she works full time. Why are people so worked up about the suggestion that a mother may want to spend the bulk of her time with her child and might have some regrets if she doesn’t do that? (And I am saying mother because OP is a mother and this is a post about her feelings. Not because I don’t think fathers should want that too.)

Pipsquiggle · 23/04/2023 09:38

Dilemma19 · 23/04/2023 08:23

Your mentality is exactly what's so damaging to women. What if op was a single parent and used ft childcare? Would that make her a bad mother? And what about women in other countries where ML is only 3 months, what do you think of all of them? Bad mothers too, poor abandoned children? Op has an amazing opportunity for her career which will benefit the family in the long term, a supportive dh who will be able to cover flexibility, but yes let's make the op feel shit and guilty. Pathetic, have a word with yourself.

@Dilemma19

Well said.

I can't stand it when women don't support each other. @Guiltridden12345 I hope you realise that your opinions are incredibly damaging to some women. Don't be naive to think this entrenched thinking over generations have held women back in the workplace.

Personally I am a great believer of doing what's best for the family unit. One of the most basic of these is contributing towards accommodation, warmth, food etc.

Also some women (& men) don't like the early years of parenthood but come into their own in later stages e.g. primary or secondary school. Personally, I was skipping back into work, however, I recognise it's not the same for everyone.

I think SAHP are amazing because I know I couldn't do it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/04/2023 08:29

OP is part of a society where sexism is ingrained from birth which leads to many women worrying that working full time will have a negative impact on their child. They are made to believe that they should feel guilty for wanting a career.

Men are raised to be 'providers', they are expected to work so don't get asked why they bother having children if they were just going to work/not see them/not look after them.

This. I find it pretty shocking that a bunch of people have tipped up here to actively discourage someone from taking a job which could hugely improve their family’s economic wellbeing because of some martyrdom complex about mothers having to be there at every waking moment of children’s early lives and the same is never applied to the father. It’s profoundly depressing.

Dilemma19 · 23/04/2023 08:23

Guiltridden12345 · 22/04/2023 22:58

I think full time nursery care for small babies is so sad. 12 hour days without a parent is a long time. Your child with be with other people for most of their waking hours. You will miss so much. If you absolutely have to, it’s a no brainer, but if you have a choice then why would you not want to spend more time with what you say might be your only child?

Your mentality is exactly what's so damaging to women. What if op was a single parent and used ft childcare? Would that make her a bad mother? And what about women in other countries where ML is only 3 months, what do you think of all of them? Bad mothers too, poor abandoned children? Op has an amazing opportunity for her career which will benefit the family in the long term, a supportive dh who will be able to cover flexibility, but yes let's make the op feel shit and guilty. Pathetic, have a word with yourself.

Orangello · 23/04/2023 08:17

if you have a choice then why would you not want to spend more time with what you say might be your only child?

If you have the choice, why don't you want to give your children a comfortable life, opportunities and financial security? Especially if DH's job is not secure and he's close to retirement?

And about the deathbed regret - how many posts are here on MN: 'I can't afford to heat the house'. 'DC really want to go on the school trip, but we can't afford'. 'DH is abusive but I cannot leave as I don't earn enough' etc etc. Just put 'can't afford' in MN search and you'll see. Pretty sure those people regret not earning more.

Pipsquiggle · 23/04/2023 08:07

Guiltridden12345 · 22/04/2023 22:58

I think full time nursery care for small babies is so sad. 12 hour days without a parent is a long time. Your child with be with other people for most of their waking hours. You will miss so much. If you absolutely have to, it’s a no brainer, but if you have a choice then why would you not want to spend more time with what you say might be your only child?

@Guiltridden12345
Just because you think 'it's so sad' to have DC in childcare doesn't mean it is.

I have done FT job, PT job and SAHP and I am a better mother when I have a job I really enjoy - this is /was a FT role.

Both my DC were in nursery from 10 months every day. They are both great (now 11 and 8) and I genuinely have not regretted it.

I have quite a few friends who have been out of the workplace for 10 years and are struggling to see how they can return and make decent money.

G5000 · 23/04/2023 07:12

Maybe the way to look at it is what would you regret more.

indeed - would you rather appreciate the memories, or the extra income when DH is made redundant or retires.

GoodChat · 23/04/2023 06:31

Guiltridden12345 · 22/04/2023 22:58

I think full time nursery care for small babies is so sad. 12 hour days without a parent is a long time. Your child with be with other people for most of their waking hours. You will miss so much. If you absolutely have to, it’s a no brainer, but if you have a choice then why would you not want to spend more time with what you say might be your only child?

Firstly, he's not a small baby. Secondly, it won't be 12 hours without a parent, just 12 hours without his DM two days a week. His DF will still pick him up from nursery.

Phoebo · 22/04/2023 23:00

Personally I wouldn't, you won't get that time back with DC but you will get other job opportunities. Maybe the way to look at it is what would you regret more.

Guiltridden12345 · 22/04/2023 22:58

I think full time nursery care for small babies is so sad. 12 hour days without a parent is a long time. Your child with be with other people for most of their waking hours. You will miss so much. If you absolutely have to, it’s a no brainer, but if you have a choice then why would you not want to spend more time with what you say might be your only child?

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 22:53

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 22:33

OP states that she doesn’t think her working will have a detrimental effect on her child. She is worried that she will regret not spending the time with her child because she will have missed out. Not that her child will negatively impacted. She’s weighing up whether she wants this career enough to allow it to reduce the time she spends with her child.

My experience of our society is that women are made to feel guilty for not wanting a career. Childrearing is not at all valued and we should all have high powered careers as well as having kids.

As for men, I think expectations are starting to shift there too. While a man is unlikely to be questioned or shamed for working full time, I’ve seen plenty of posts from women complaining their husbands don’t do their fair share when it comes to looking after the kids and, yes, even questioning why they became fathers. So it’s not as black and white and you seem to suggest.

Lots of posts here reassuring OP that her child will be fine. But that’s not what she’s worried about.

We clearly have had very different experiences but generally, regardless of personal experiences women are the ones who are expected to be the default parent.

Expectations aren't shifting fast enough. For as many complaints I see, I see just as many if not more ''he helps when he can but he's worked all day'', ''He has never had the DC alone so he'd need help'', ''I can't leave him alone with DC because they probably wouldn't get fed'' etc.

Passthewine45 · 22/04/2023 22:49

Your child will most likely be fine either way. I have plenty of friends whose children are in nursery full time 8 until 5pm every day and they are thriving, love their nursery, confident - no issues at all. It depends what you want. I'm a SAHM and I do some part time remote work sporadically, so it's easy to fit in.
I sent my DS to nursery 4 mornings a week when he was 10 months old and it took him another 16 months before he settled (stopped crying at drop off - now he loves it & runs in) - all kids are different. You won't know until you try. Also like others have said the first 4 months of nursery he was sick so much, it was horrendous. But now it's obviously alot better but you & DH will need to factor that in & how you will manage.
Personally I would stick to the 3 days in current job and see how you find working and parenting before making any decisions. I loved being able to spend so much time with my DS but the ages of 18 months to 2.5 have been horrific (tantrums etc) that I would happily have worked full time - now he's nearly 3 it's been lovely to have quality time together and he really does change day by day.
I would not have wanted to miss out but that's me and I'm not you. Plenty of parents work full time without issues. Most important thing for a kid is a happy parent.
Part time work can sound like the best of both worlds but there's a risk you end up doing a full weeks worth of work in 3/4 days and more stressed out. If you take the full time job, you can always quit, find something else. I'd advise getting a cleaner/help so that you & DH time off is not eaten up by chores.

blueshoes · 22/04/2023 22:44

DahliaRose3 · 22/04/2023 22:23

I would definitely take the role, if anything you may have the opportunity to keep those hours if you prefer or may decide to stay as you are. I would try to negotiate your days in the office down if possible for a better work life balance. You can always see how you feel by the time Sep comes around. They may love you so much they agree to be more flexible.

Crucially, the salary bump will allow you to move into another role paying on par or the same; and put some money away.

I agree with this.

Nowadays, working ft is so much easier if you can WFH for part of it. I have to pinch myself my company is paying me to do this from home. Parent of young children can do drop offs, pick ups and easily make up time or get extra sleep because you save yourself the commute. I wish I had this when dc were young. The young mothers who work for me take this as given.

My office is hybrid 3 weeks in the office but almost no one does this unless they actually prefer to work in the office. When I go in on Wed/Thu, about half of the office is in. Your office may not be strict on the 3 days in the office and if they are, you can negotiate down, if needed.

The money makes a big difference when your dcs are teenagers. You can pay for tutors, activities, private school (if needed), university top ups. In addition, you can retire earlier with such a big pay jump over 2 decades. There is much to be said for financial security for you and your family and a second earner who pulls her weight.

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 22:33

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 22:00

Of course it's relevant.

OP is part of a society where sexism is ingrained from birth which leads to many women worrying that working full time will have a negative impact on their child. They are made to believe that they should feel guilty for wanting a career.

Men are raised to be 'providers', they are expected to work so don't get asked why they bother having children if they were just going to work/not see them/not look after them.

OP states that she doesn’t think her working will have a detrimental effect on her child. She is worried that she will regret not spending the time with her child because she will have missed out. Not that her child will negatively impacted. She’s weighing up whether she wants this career enough to allow it to reduce the time she spends with her child.

My experience of our society is that women are made to feel guilty for not wanting a career. Childrearing is not at all valued and we should all have high powered careers as well as having kids.

As for men, I think expectations are starting to shift there too. While a man is unlikely to be questioned or shamed for working full time, I’ve seen plenty of posts from women complaining their husbands don’t do their fair share when it comes to looking after the kids and, yes, even questioning why they became fathers. So it’s not as black and white and you seem to suggest.

Lots of posts here reassuring OP that her child will be fine. But that’s not what she’s worried about.

DahliaRose3 · 22/04/2023 22:23

I would definitely take the role, if anything you may have the opportunity to keep those hours if you prefer or may decide to stay as you are. I would try to negotiate your days in the office down if possible for a better work life balance. You can always see how you feel by the time Sep comes around. They may love you so much they agree to be more flexible.

Crucially, the salary bump will allow you to move into another role paying on par or the same; and put some money away.

EverydayParis · 22/04/2023 22:14

@MumGuilt3000 firstly, sign up to the extra days at nursery now, you might lose a deposit but better than them not being available when you need it.

Absolutely send them to nursery for 5 days. They love the routine and having their pals. If you live in an area with people similar to you, older dads etc, it’s likely they will have similar peers there (parents older, FT working, only child). That’s what I’ve found where I live. As an only child, I actually think them being in nursery with peers will be nice for them. Take the FT job and make use of unpaid parental leave that you’re entitled to on top of annual leave, and do stuff 121 then, nice days out etc. “You’re entitled to 18 weeks’ leave for each child and adopted child, up to their 18th birthday.” https://www.gov.uk/parental-leave/entitlement Use the money to do short trips with them 121 to cities and Europe.

It is really hard as a mummy, I feel like I miss out, I had to take weeks off recently due to a childcare issue and was bereft when started new setting. Toddler couldn’t care less! I wake up early and make sure I have breakfast and playtime with them each morning.

However this is your life and only you can decide if you want to live it with the current job and more time with your child or the better job and slightly less time. The way I made peace with my decision is by imagining them when they’re 11yo and I’m not their world anymore - the life I want to enjoy with my child and the person I want to be is achieved by me working full time and taking promotions. I don’t think I’d be a happy person in 10 years if I’d been working PT and hadn’t progressed in my career like I could have done otherwise. I might even be resentful. But that is me.

whumpthereitis · 22/04/2023 22:11

Dacadactyl · 22/04/2023 20:20

@whumpthereitis we are all different. And even if I was a millionaire I wouldn't be giving my kids a house deposit.

No one said you had to. Some parents however would like to have the option.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 22:00

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 21:53

OP is a mother. She is worried that she will regret working full time while her child is young. She raised she issue about her own feelings. No one raised it to her.

I understand where you are coming from but not sure of the relevance to this post.

Of course it's relevant.

OP is part of a society where sexism is ingrained from birth which leads to many women worrying that working full time will have a negative impact on their child. They are made to believe that they should feel guilty for wanting a career.

Men are raised to be 'providers', they are expected to work so don't get asked why they bother having children if they were just going to work/not see them/not look after them.

Rainbowqueeen · 22/04/2023 22:00

@Croissantsandpistachio is right. Get DH to drop to 4 days and get yourself in a position where you have earns the right to be more flexible when DC start school so that you can go to school events etc. When the DC are little they are ok with being well cared for but when they are older it’s you they want to be able to go to things.

ladymaiasura · 22/04/2023 21:53

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 17:04

I’ve yet to hear anyone raise this to a father though. It’s always, always aimed at mothers.

OP is a mother. She is worried that she will regret working full time while her child is young. She raised she issue about her own feelings. No one raised it to her.

I understand where you are coming from but not sure of the relevance to this post.