Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a GP doesn't understand antibiotics

139 replies

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:29

I mean of course she would right?

Two days ago woke up and had such pain in back of my throat. My baby has had a bad cold recently. But my throat was swollen and eating and drinking hard

Went to GP. Confirmed tonsillitis and lots of inflammation

She then went onto a website and put in my symptoms and prescribed 10 days of antibiotics

I said but I thought most tonsillitis was caused by virus so antibiotics wouldn't work. she said she'd looked online and antibiotics were right way to go.

I have started taking them but the more I read online the more it's clear that antibiotics really aren't effective for majority of tonsillitis

Am I being an Internet idiot? Surely GP is right? But I'm sure I've just caught a cold virus off the baby and it's developed into tonsillitis but GP didn't listen and just kept saying the website said antibiotics

OP posts:
Qilin · 22/04/2023 08:11

The gp won't be able to,tell if it's bacterial without testing a swab. But this takes time to do and for results to come back. In the meantime, if bacterial, you can become much more poorly quickly.

I've had a nasty case once where I wasn't given ABs. A day later I was hallucinating and in a really bad state. I was given IV ABs to get me sorted out.

My dd has had tonsillitis many times when growing up. They didn't use to give her AB initially but it almost always got much worse, leading to us having to return and take up more gp time. Only once did they swab - it was bacterial. After that they always prescribed ABs.

Never had oral ABs which are 5 times a day though - normally 3 or 4 here got 5, 7 or 10 days,

FeltedDogs · 22/04/2023 08:09

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:02

OK OK. I'm being a dick. Can I blame lack of sleep/feeling v unwell/not eating/getting my period all in the last few days?

Just please don't start under medicating your baby. This is a cultural sickness not physical matter. A bit like banging saucepans, you think you are taking responsibility for not bothering the lovely NHS while it kills hundreds of people a day. If you want to get second opinions or a quirky lifestyle either move abroad, which I recommend, or earn enough to fund it.

PrangKdcu · 22/04/2023 08:08

I guess she thought there was a chance it’s bacterial.

I’ve had tonsillitis many many times and my GP once told me there is a scoring system they use to decide if you need antibiotics.

  • Did it start suddenly (no cold or other illness before)
  • Do you have a temperature
  • Are there white patches in your throat
If you score yes for two of these than he will prescribe antibiotics. Without testing it can be hard to know for sure if bacterial. Saying that though I’ve also been given antibiotics when I don’t meet this criteria as a ‘just in case’ and held off from taking them unless it gets worse. If you don’t think your tonsillitis is bacterial then hold off taking them and see how it goes. Get dissolvable paracetamol and gargle that, throat sprays are good too. (Although probably best to follow the doctors advice as this is the first time you’ve had it. I get it multiple times a year so know what I’m looking for).
Prescottdanni123 · 22/04/2023 08:04

I'm confused. Why does it matter if you've never had tonsillitis before? There is no limit to the amount of times you can get it.

GPs do not prescribe antibiotics lightly these days. If its bacterial tonsillitis you need to take the whole course.

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:02

OK OK. I'm being a dick. Can I blame lack of sleep/feeling v unwell/not eating/getting my period all in the last few days?

OP posts:
ThirstyMeeples · 22/04/2023 08:01

We use FeverPain score (I complete the online proforma when with a patient) It gives us a risk of the infection being bacterial eg if you meet all the criteria then it gives you a risk score of 62-65% from memory. So this is the percentage of the throat infection being caused by a bacteria. I explain this the the patient and say we may be giving an unnecessary course of ABx. Most people score lower than this and we usually agree to do a delayed prescription or no prescription at all. Hope you feel better soon.

Charliebrow · 22/04/2023 08:00

You should have just left it a while, self care to see if it was self limiting rather than having a GP appt and then expecting them to carry out a laboratory test before then prescribing you a med if needed. We have such limited funding for nhs at mo, and so many virus’s going around while are self limiting. I think it’s unreasonable to be carrying out testing on everyone as soon as they feel ill. I suspect if it was a virus you likely wouldn’t have made a GP appt unless you’re attending the GP for every little thing so if there’s no history of you being a regular attender at GP then I think it’s fair to presume it’s bad and Abs warranted. Although by your response to the Abs I’m wondering whether your symptoms aren’t that bad at all and you probably wasted a rare GP appt

pbdr · 22/04/2023 07:56

Where I work we use the centor criteria to determine whether antibiotics are appropriate for tonsillitis. It's scored out of 4 points, and if you have 3 or more then there is a reasonable enough chance of bacterial infection to justify antibiotic use. The criteria are;

  • Absence of a cough +1 point
  • Presence of white spots on tonsils +1 point
  • Enlarged cervical lymph nodes +1 point
  • Fever +1 point

So it's possible she did this assessment in her head and established that antibiotics were appropriate. It's also possible she just did a slapdash job and threw an antibiotic at you.

I don't agree with other posters disparaging the GP for looking something up however. Local guidelines and prescribing formularies vary around the country and based on local antibiotic sensitivities. I would always want my GP to do their due diligence and check guidelines for anything they are not entirely sure about, rather than being too proud and feeling they should already know everything off the top of their head.

paulinesmithson · 22/04/2023 07:54

tonsillitis is not one single pathogen
and trust the gp with years of medical training instead of google

CorsicaDreaming · 22/04/2023 07:53

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:32

She's prescribed me antibiotics that I need to take 5 times a day on an empty stomach for 10 days. I'd really rather not do that if I can help it.

Same GP who prescribed me antidepressants when I went in with a rash she said was caused by stress.

Five times a day on an empty stomach.

That's a weird one - five times a day is an awful lot, usually it is three times. And doing that on a truly empty stomach is going to be almost impossible to achieve and be able to eat...

You sound like you've got v little confidence in your gp after this and the prescription for depression (which also sounds odd to me FWIW)... could you move GP practices for the future?

DeadOrchid · 22/04/2023 07:52

Five times a day - really? There are no oral antibiotics give 5 times a day.

backstreetsbackallright · 22/04/2023 07:50

@MissTrip82 Fair enough

AlexisR · 22/04/2023 07:46

GPs will often look up conditions and medications on a database during your appointment. She's not just googling it/ 'looking it up online'.

If you've been prescribed antibiotics and have started taking them then you need to finish the course. Not doing so can result in antibiotic resistance and they will be less effective if you need them in future.

If you had doubts you shouldn't really have started them.

You might have bacterial tonsilitis anyway so it might well help.

fortheloveofflowers · 22/04/2023 07:45

There’s templates we follow that are attached to your notes that we put your symptoms in, this then indicates whether abx, delayed abx or does not require abx.
It’s the microbial prescribing guidelines, maybe that is what she was using rather than just google 🙄

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 22/04/2023 07:45

I always have antibiotics when I get it because it can progress to rheumatic fever and leave permanent damage your heart valves.

Yes, your being an Internet twat 🙄

MissTrip82 · 22/04/2023 07:45

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

It’s both standard and expected practice to review guidelines on the best antibiotic for particular infections- the advice changes depending on the nature of the infection, the severity, the co-morbidities of the patient, the expected source of the infection, and your location. These guidelines are evidence-based and change as new evidence becomes available.

Where I live we prescribe antibiotics in this instance for particular groups of vulnerable people, or where there is evidence pointing to bacterial infection.

I have prescribed antibiotics multiple times a day for 15 years (not in general practice). I still use guidelines and also seek advice from infectious disease physicians regularly. The most common antibiotics for the most common infections have changed tremendously over that time, in line with emerging evidence:

Your concern is misplaced and foolish.

borntobequiet · 22/04/2023 07:44

The bouts of tonsillitis I’ve had have all been bacterial and I’ve been prescribed antibiotics, which cleared them up rapidly.
Long before the Internet, GPs used a book (the British National Formulary, or BNF) to look up medications and doses. Why wouldn’t they? They can’t hold all the detailed information in their heads, and there are new medications available all the time. It’s now available online, of course.

https://bnf.nice.org.uk/

BNF content published by NICE

Online access to the BNF (British National Formulary) content within the UK, provided by NICE

https://bnf.nice.org.uk/

FeltedDogs · 22/04/2023 07:44

Am I being an Internet idiot

And I can't believe these people are allowed to have children either ffs 🙄

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 22/04/2023 07:44

There’s a NICE decision tree for this. A GP can’t possibly hold everything about everything in her head so I can’t see it’s a problem for her to have looked it up. That said, I can’t think of an antibiotic with 5x daily dosing. Perhaps it’s a typo from OP.

curcurbita · 22/04/2023 07:44

FFS. She was probably looking up something called CENTOR criteria or similar which give you a score for how likely, based on your symptoms, it is for it to be bacterial tonsillitis. GPs can't remember every scoring system off the top of their heads, wouldn't you rather she got it right?

Also, if you're convinced you don't need antibiotics why did you go to the GP after two days?

FeltedDogs · 22/04/2023 07:42

Is there a mumsnet prize for not taking medicine like there is for not eating any real food and no screens ever? Meanwhile in the rest of the world, we get ill we see a doctor and get medication, eat carbs and watch TV on our phones. How ridiculous. I would be dead without antibiotics for what started as a UTI. The British consultant ( ran away from NHS) said if I was still in the south east I would definitely have died as there would have been no GP treatment, no ambulance, no beds, no CT scan, no surgeon etc etc etc. Just take the bloody medicine if you want to and don't if you don't. But piss off with the endless trophy deprivation.

cathyandclare · 22/04/2023 07:40

What tonsillitis ab are they? Five times a day is not common.

Shivermytimber · 22/04/2023 07:40

She might have been looking up the FeverPain score ( it’s good practice to fill this in and add it to your notes) it’s a decision tool on prescribing in tonsillitis.

HarperElla · 22/04/2023 07:40

How can we possibly advise if we haven't seen your tonsils? If you don't want the antibiotics then don't take them.

BertieBotts · 22/04/2023 07:39

Was it just a random website? Surely more likely to be some kind of database or website showing the clinical guidelines?

Swipe left for the next trending thread