Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a GP doesn't understand antibiotics

139 replies

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:29

I mean of course she would right?

Two days ago woke up and had such pain in back of my throat. My baby has had a bad cold recently. But my throat was swollen and eating and drinking hard

Went to GP. Confirmed tonsillitis and lots of inflammation

She then went onto a website and put in my symptoms and prescribed 10 days of antibiotics

I said but I thought most tonsillitis was caused by virus so antibiotics wouldn't work. she said she'd looked online and antibiotics were right way to go.

I have started taking them but the more I read online the more it's clear that antibiotics really aren't effective for majority of tonsillitis

Am I being an Internet idiot? Surely GP is right? But I'm sure I've just caught a cold virus off the baby and it's developed into tonsillitis but GP didn't listen and just kept saying the website said antibiotics

OP posts:
Jazsimone · 22/04/2023 08:49

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:34

@Madamecastafiore yeah that's what I had...ear ache, very hot at night, and swallowing v painful. That's what I booked GP. Then read online most tonsillitis caused by virus and antibiotics ineffective.

But obviously the GP thought good chance it is bacterial because of those symptoms that I described

I'm being a dick. Being grumpy and hastily wrote a silly post on MN. I'm taking the course of AB.

Unbelievable...

So you decided to come on MN slander your GP ... who was in fact correct with her diagnosis.

Maybe in future you should listen to your doctor or don't bother going and wasting what little time they have

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:49

SallyWD · 22/04/2023 08:45

My DH had antibiotics for tonsillitis. It definitely cleared it up but took about 3 days to work. She must have thought it was bacterial if she prescribed them. Doctors don't always give detailed reasoning but that was her opinion.

Or it might have cleared up on its own in 3 days. That is partly why so many people want antibiotics. Viral infections clear up too but if you took anticbiotics for a viral infection, you will associate that clearing up with the antibiotic. It is the old correlation doesn't equal causation.

And people want them / doctors prescribe them because then it feels like you are doing something and taking action to manage the symptoms. Feels much better than leaving an appointment empty handed.

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:45

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 22/04/2023 08:32

It must be a cheaper option than doing bloods or swabbing. What else are they meant to do if someone has a severe sore throat?

Read up on antibiotic resistance. Giving everyone antibiotics if they have symptoms that could be viral or bacterial is terrible and will lead to much bigger problems in the not so distant future.

And the idea that doctors are infallible and their decisions should never be questioned has led to a lot of deaths. Medical errors are not rare. Doctors are human and if you have ever worked in the health care world or in quality assurance in health care - you will quickly lose the rose coloured classes that doctors can't or don't make mistakes because they have years of training.

SallyWD · 22/04/2023 08:45

My DH had antibiotics for tonsillitis. It definitely cleared it up but took about 3 days to work. She must have thought it was bacterial if she prescribed them. Doctors don't always give detailed reasoning but that was her opinion.

Jazsimone · 22/04/2023 08:43

DeadOrchid · 22/04/2023 07:52

Five times a day - really? There are no oral antibiotics give 5 times a day.

Clearly you're not a doctor

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 08:43

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:35

I thought firstly I wanted to confirm it was tonsillitis and not something else as I've never had it before

And secondly to test if it was bacterial to see if antibiotics would help.

When I asked "so you think it's bacterial"

She replied "as I said, I can see they're inflamed badly"

Which wasn't an answer to my question really but I just doubted myself and shut up

Tonsillitis just means inflammation of the tonsils, so if they were inflamed its tonsillitis, you dont need a GP for that

Either take the medication or dont, you dont have to take everything you're given by a GP or agree with taking the prescription from them, Ive refused medication before

Although it does annoy me that GPs dont routinely test for whether things are bacterial or viral.

ThanksForYourHelp · 22/04/2023 08:39

Dontcutthedaisies · 22/04/2023 08:15

You had a sore throat for 2 days, managed to get through to your GP surgery, get an in person appointment and a prescription? You can't possibly be in the UK.
I've suffered dozens of bouts of tonsillitis and am never given antibiotics until I've had it for over a week 'to see if it's viral'.

Definitely not in the US. Americans mostly get sore throats. Sometimes they get strep throat, and that's when doctors might prescribe antibiotics.

BitchFaceResting · 22/04/2023 08:36

You don't seem to agree with the GP on anything. Clearly, Dr Google is your go-to health care professional.
Suggest you leave your current practice and use Tom, Dick and Harry's until you find a doctor who tell you what you think you already know

ChocHotolate · 22/04/2023 08:36

I expect the GP will have used either FEVERPain or Centor score which is a grading tool for tonsillitis to aid prescribing decisions

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 22/04/2023 08:34

Without a swab it’s impossible to tell.

I once used to get tonsillitis quite badly about once a year. On the last occasion (over 20 years ago now) it was the worst ever, I was really ill, and the ABs the GP gave me didn’t work. I went back, and thank goodness he prescribed different ones, to be taken for at least 10 days.

I have never once had it since. You can carry that bug in your throat - as I evidently did - and have it flare up now and then - not to mention passing it on to dcs or anyone else. So that 2nd lot of ABs evidently killed it off once and for all.

If I were you, OP, I’d just be grateful - take them, and be sure to finish the course.

I remember reading in Victorian novels about people dying of a ‘putrid sore throat’!

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:34

@Madamecastafiore yeah that's what I had...ear ache, very hot at night, and swallowing v painful. That's what I booked GP. Then read online most tonsillitis caused by virus and antibiotics ineffective.

But obviously the GP thought good chance it is bacterial because of those symptoms that I described

I'm being a dick. Being grumpy and hastily wrote a silly post on MN. I'm taking the course of AB.

OP posts:
NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 22/04/2023 08:34

GP was following guidelines:

https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/sore-throat-acute/diagnosis/diagnosing-the-cause/

There's no way of knowing whether it's bacterial or viral without taking swabs for microbiology. But by the time you get the results back the infection will be well on the way to resolving itself anyway. All they will tell you is whether you could have avoided some of the patient's pain and malaise if you'd prescribed penicillin 3 or 4 days ago. You have to make a clinical judgement on whether it's more likely to be bacterial or viral. That is a doctor's job.

Diagnosing the cause | Diagnosis | Sore throat - acute | CKS | NICE

Diagnosing the cause, Diagnosis, Sore throat - acute, CKS

https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/sore-throat-acute/diagnosis/diagnosing-the-cause

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 22/04/2023 08:32

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:29

I mean giving you something at the end of the appointment so you leave happy like giving candy to children. They want patients to leave feeling they did something and so they prescribe antibiotics for things that could or are viral. Not all GPS but some GPs. Does OPs GP know for sure she has a bacterial infection that requires antibiotics? Without blood work or a swab? Being able to eyeball a red inflamed tonsil and determine viral or bacterial infection is quite a skill.

It must be a cheaper option than doing bloods or swabbing. What else are they meant to do if someone has a severe sore throat?

Madamecastafiore · 22/04/2023 08:30

Bacterial tonsillitis will give you white spots on your tonsils, for this you will need antibiotics. The doctor will most likely be looking at which antibiotics to give you on her PC rather than googling "What illness causes large white spots on tonsils?."

I had mine out at 30 and 2 DSs at young age, I feel like half our lives were affected by tonsillitis. Just take antibiotics now, it will very probably get worse until you are unable to swallow your own saliva, have a raging temperature and your ears hurt too.

Or gargle with hydrogen peroxide solution (cheap from chemist, dilute as instructed) and it'll roughly do the same job, just a more topical way of dealing with the problem.

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:29

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 08:24

Very few GPs 'hand out antibiotics like candy' 🙄

I mean giving you something at the end of the appointment so you leave happy like giving candy to children. They want patients to leave feeling they did something and so they prescribe antibiotics for things that could or are viral. Not all GPS but some GPs. Does OPs GP know for sure she has a bacterial infection that requires antibiotics? Without blood work or a swab? Being able to eyeball a red inflamed tonsil and determine viral or bacterial infection is quite a skill.

lemonsugarsnap · 22/04/2023 08:24

I had bacterial tonsillitis (confirmed by blood test) and it was horrendous. GP kept fobbing me off as I didn't have a fever and the website you're talking about advised to 'wait and see' so it's obviously not 100% accurate. I'd hold on to the antibiotics and take them if you start feeling worse.

EarringsandLipstick · 22/04/2023 08:24

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:22

GPs are humans and not all are great at their jobs. I had a GP prescribe me antibiotics for a sore throat when I had covid. I didn’t take them and the sore throat was gone in 3 days. It was the worst sore throat I have ever had but it was clear my sore throat was a symptom of covid. I think some feel that they need to give you something but handing out antibiotics like candy is terrible in the long run.

Very few GPs 'hand out antibiotics like candy' 🙄

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 22/04/2023 08:23

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:35

I thought firstly I wanted to confirm it was tonsillitis and not something else as I've never had it before

And secondly to test if it was bacterial to see if antibiotics would help.

When I asked "so you think it's bacterial"

She replied "as I said, I can see they're inflamed badly"

Which wasn't an answer to my question really but I just doubted myself and shut up

Unless they swab which they don't do neither they or you will know if it's viral or bacterial. You have a severe sore throat,take the anti B's.

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:22

GPs are humans and not all are great at their jobs. I had a GP prescribe me antibiotics for a sore throat when I had covid. I didn’t take them and the sore throat was gone in 3 days. It was the worst sore throat I have ever had but it was clear my sore throat was a symptom of covid. I think some feel that they need to give you something but handing out antibiotics like candy is terrible in the long run.

GospelAccordingToMum · 22/04/2023 08:21

I used to get recurrent tonsillitis and often had problems getting antibiotics because the GPS always said ‘it’s usually viral’. However, antibiotics were the ONLY thing that ever cleared it up, so it was obviously bacterial.

I’d persist with what you’ve been prescribed.

CecilyP · 22/04/2023 08:19

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:02

OK OK. I'm being a dick. Can I blame lack of sleep/feeling v unwell/not eating/getting my period all in the last few days?

Or you could blame having tonsillitis which would got better rapidly if you’d taken those antibiotics!

tuvamoodyson · 22/04/2023 08:16

I’m subject to tonsillitis…I’d kill for antibiotics when I have it!!

Dontcutthedaisies · 22/04/2023 08:15

You had a sore throat for 2 days, managed to get through to your GP surgery, get an in person appointment and a prescription? You can't possibly be in the UK.
I've suffered dozens of bouts of tonsillitis and am never given antibiotics until I've had it for over a week 'to see if it's viral'.

Reallyareyousure · 22/04/2023 08:13

So you basically wasted a valuable doctor's appointment? You didn't think you needed anything prescribed but you went anyway? What's the point.

nomoredriving · 22/04/2023 08:12

My son used to suffer with tonsillitis a lot, always got antibiotics and always worked!