Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a GP doesn't understand antibiotics

139 replies

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:29

I mean of course she would right?

Two days ago woke up and had such pain in back of my throat. My baby has had a bad cold recently. But my throat was swollen and eating and drinking hard

Went to GP. Confirmed tonsillitis and lots of inflammation

She then went onto a website and put in my symptoms and prescribed 10 days of antibiotics

I said but I thought most tonsillitis was caused by virus so antibiotics wouldn't work. she said she'd looked online and antibiotics were right way to go.

I have started taking them but the more I read online the more it's clear that antibiotics really aren't effective for majority of tonsillitis

Am I being an Internet idiot? Surely GP is right? But I'm sure I've just caught a cold virus off the baby and it's developed into tonsillitis but GP didn't listen and just kept saying the website said antibiotics

OP posts:
CornishGem1975 · 22/04/2023 09:15

ABs worked like a dream on my tonsillitis but if you didn't want ABs why go to the doctors in the first place! What were you expecting to happen?

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 09:14

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 09:11

I couldn't swallow so I was hoping for a numbing spray or a medicated mouthwash or something to make swallowing possible. I did get a prescription for that as well and used it and it did help slightly.

Why didnt you just go to the chemist and buy it then?

Honestly no wonder I cant get an appointment when I want one.

gentlemum · 22/04/2023 09:11

GPs cannot remember absolutely everything, every drug formulation and dosage and know it off the top of their head. They have resources available to them during appointments (specific websites). She didn't just randomly google treatment for tonsillitis.

With strep a (which can cause tonsillitis) being a problem recently she may be be taking a more cautious approach. I've had antibiotics for tonsillitis before, diagnosed just from a GP visual exam of my throat.

Irritateandunreasonable · 22/04/2023 09:11

Embelline · 22/04/2023 09:07

@Irritateandunreasonable they don’t Google it ffs they have different sites that GP use as previous posters have stated that show different scores for things seeing as they can’t keep every single condition and all its varying symptoms in their head at all times.

jesus this site sometimes

Are you ok love? I’ve literally seen a GP use google, fairly new GP but still.

It’s tonsillitis - my 11 year old could diagnose it 🤣

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 09:11

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 09:01

I dont really understand why people are turning up to the GP if they know what they've got and dont think they require ABs anyway?

The poster who knew their sore throat was covid, why go to the GP, what did they think the GP was going to give them apart from painkillers?

I couldn't swallow so I was hoping for a numbing spray or a medicated mouthwash or something to make swallowing possible. I did get a prescription for that as well and used it and it did help slightly.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 22/04/2023 09:11

saltwater1985 · 22/04/2023 07:34

We're there white spots on your tonsils?

If not, not abx, if yes, then penicillin required.

That's not pathognomonic of bacterial vs viral tonsillitis, many studies have shown that it's just as common in viral infections so that statement is about 20+ years out date.

There's been a significant rise in bacterial upper respiratory tract infections of all varieties. Even if something starts as a viral infection, you can get a secondary bacterial infection in addition. If I've gone to the effort of going to the GP, I'd follow their advice, even if, as has recently happened, they hadn't even been born yet when I started medical school myself.

moonspiral · 22/04/2023 09:09

Why did you bother going to the GP

GiltEdges · 22/04/2023 09:08

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:02

OK OK. I'm being a dick. Can I blame lack of sleep/feeling v unwell/not eating/getting my period all in the last few days?

Of course you can't. You're an adult, start taking responsibility for your own actions.

Mrsjayy · 22/04/2023 09:08

Good god I bet the Dr's eyes nearly rolled out of their head with that nugget of info, what treatment did you want for your virus tonsillitis?

Embelline · 22/04/2023 09:07

@Irritateandunreasonable they don’t Google it ffs they have different sites that GP use as previous posters have stated that show different scores for things seeing as they can’t keep every single condition and all its varying symptoms in their head at all times.

jesus this site sometimes

vivainsomnia · 22/04/2023 09:07

Its well known in the NHS peofessio al world that GP over prescribe antibiotics. They do it because its safer for them and mean it stops the patient possibly coming back. They also do it under pressure from patients who would argue for hours (and xi plain) if not handed them.

The impact of the population losing the positive impact of antibiotics is well known and adds significant pressure on the nhs.

Irritateandunreasonable · 22/04/2023 09:06

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:32

She's prescribed me antibiotics that I need to take 5 times a day on an empty stomach for 10 days. I'd really rather not do that if I can help it.

Same GP who prescribed me antidepressants when I went in with a rash she said was caused by stress.

Why did you go to gp if you’re convinced it’s viral, she can’t do anything for viral.

I thought you should wait a bit to see if it clears up on its own before starting antibiotics. The GP once prescribed my attention seeking mother antibiotics over the phone for a chest infection, she has a cold.

Im unsure why they are prescribing antibiotics so freely when we as a society are becoming immune to them.

I would also really be untrusting if a GP that needed to google how to treat tonsillitis… eh???

PippaF2 · 22/04/2023 09:05

Hey OP, you're allowed to be grumpy. You're poorly.

Some of the keys ways to tell the difference between viral and bacterial tonsillitis are:

Viral - comes on slower, is accompanied by other symptoms- generally runny nose, cough, mild fever, watery eyes and basically feeling like you have a heavy head cold. You can very sore throat but it tends to get better after about 4 days.

Bacterial - comes on quicker, usually but not always would come with a high fever, have severe pain, and there would be an absence of general viral symptoms - it also tends to get worse and worse.

Now that's not a slam dunk way of diagnosising because people can start with a general viral infection that can lead on to a bacterial infection - meaning you'd have the snotty nose too. Some people can have a very severe sore throat with a viral infection. But in an adult anything that comes with a higher fever is usually suspected as more serious, particularly if the fever doesn't really come down or stay down after taking paracetamol or ibuprofen.

I am slightly concerned about the antibiotics and I do think it would be wise for you to look at the leaflet that came with them, or Google them. Most bacterial antibiotics will be prescribed amoxicillian which is 3 a day for 7 days.

5 a day for 10 days seems extreme. But this is generally easy enough to double check online. Alternatively you can ask a pharmacist.

The other way you might know if it's bacterial is whether your symptoms start to resolve quite dramatically within 48hrs after starting the antibiotics. If it's viral the antibiotics will do nothing. If it's bacterial you should get relief quite quickly. So if by Sunday your symptoms are resolved then you know it was bacterial and to continue the course. If by Monday you still feel just as bad - call your GP back, because could be two things - one it's just viral, or she's given you an incompatible antibiotic for the type of bacteria you have and you need a different one.

Bacterial tonsillitis doesn't always come with white spots. It frequently does but not always at first. But if you look on the roof of your mouth and you see red spots (Google images red spots - strep A) then antibiotics would also be given - even if there's no white puss. Red spots don't always mean bacterial but it's a strong indicator for strep A.

I'm not a doctor! But I've had kids and tonsillitis about 15 times over my life - bacterial and viral - so this is a bit of a combination of information I've been given by doctors at various appointments! Hope you feel better soon!

Embelline · 22/04/2023 09:03

don’t take them then OP if you feel you know better. But do know that bacterial tonsilitis won’t go away on its own and can actually turn into what we’ve all been referring to as “strep A” as it’s the same bacteria. I would bear that in mind if you have a small child at home.

it happened to me recently I left it and left it as thought it was just a sore throat but it got so bad I couldn’t swallow properly. I ended up with Strep A and all the antibiotics then needed a second course to properly clear it.

of course a doctor understands antibiotics.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 22/04/2023 09:03

Hope you and baby are both feeling better soon OP Flowers

DeadOrchid · 22/04/2023 09:02

Jazsimone · 22/04/2023 08:43

Clearly you're not a doctor

Show me one then? I am a pharmacist.

Saxendastarter · 22/04/2023 09:02

I'm abroad and often suffer from tonsillitis - we have. too names for it here

Angine rouge ( red tonsillitis - viral)
Angine blanche (white tonsillitis- bacterial)

The doctor can either prescribe antibiotics or not - but they add a swap test to the prescription most of the time you then go to the pharmacy where you do the swab test ( that has the lovely name of TROD angine). The results take around 5 minutes. If the swab is positive you get the antibios and if it's negative you get sympathy and advice to deal with the virus.

I get tonsillitis 3/4 times a year unfortunately - I've now started going to the pharmacy first, the swab test can be done without a prescription - only if it is positive do I go and get a script for antibiotics.

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 09:01

I dont really understand why people are turning up to the GP if they know what they've got and dont think they require ABs anyway?

The poster who knew their sore throat was covid, why go to the GP, what did they think the GP was going to give them apart from painkillers?

Knackeredhamster · 22/04/2023 08:58

Op had said she's being a dick, fair enough eh?
Op which antibiotics were u given?

TroysMammy · 22/04/2023 08:58

BeverlyBrook · 22/04/2023 08:50

Noone in UK gets tested for type of tonsillitis
You are lucky she didn't tell you to come back in a week if it doesn't improve. Or prescribe the wrong type of antibiotics.

YABU sorry!

Some pharmacies in my area swab and provide antibiotics and advice under the Local Health Board Sore Throat Scheme. It's trying to get people to use it and not contact the GP is the battle.

TroysMammy · 22/04/2023 08:55

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 08:29

I mean giving you something at the end of the appointment so you leave happy like giving candy to children. They want patients to leave feeling they did something and so they prescribe antibiotics for things that could or are viral. Not all GPS but some GPs. Does OPs GP know for sure she has a bacterial infection that requires antibiotics? Without blood work or a swab? Being able to eyeball a red inflamed tonsil and determine viral or bacterial infection is quite a skill.

GPs don't usually give patients medication so the patient thinks the GP has done something worthwhile. It's more than likely the patient demands something because they believe they need it.

ChocChipHandbag · 22/04/2023 08:54

Are you 100% sure it's 5 times a day on an empty stomach?

They do make mistakes on the label sometimes. I once got HRT patches with a label that said "apply two patches once a day".

It was supposed to say "apply one patch twice a week!"

Fortunately I already knew the dose as had had them before, and the leaflet inside the box also said twice a week.

When I got my repeat the pharmacist saw what was on the system and was horrified and very relieved when I said I'd ignored the instructions.

Thisbastardcomputer · 22/04/2023 08:51

I had constant tonsillitis before I got them taken out, the only relief I had was when on antibiotics

Peapodburgundybouquet · 22/04/2023 08:50

If there’s white slough on your tonsils, it’s likely bacterial.

BeverlyBrook · 22/04/2023 08:50

Noone in UK gets tested for type of tonsillitis
You are lucky she didn't tell you to come back in a week if it doesn't improve. Or prescribe the wrong type of antibiotics.

YABU sorry!

Swipe left for the next trending thread