Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a GP doesn't understand antibiotics

139 replies

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:29

I mean of course she would right?

Two days ago woke up and had such pain in back of my throat. My baby has had a bad cold recently. But my throat was swollen and eating and drinking hard

Went to GP. Confirmed tonsillitis and lots of inflammation

She then went onto a website and put in my symptoms and prescribed 10 days of antibiotics

I said but I thought most tonsillitis was caused by virus so antibiotics wouldn't work. she said she'd looked online and antibiotics were right way to go.

I have started taking them but the more I read online the more it's clear that antibiotics really aren't effective for majority of tonsillitis

Am I being an Internet idiot? Surely GP is right? But I'm sure I've just caught a cold virus off the baby and it's developed into tonsillitis but GP didn't listen and just kept saying the website said antibiotics

OP posts:
BitchFaceResting · 22/04/2023 10:10

tuvamoodyson · 22/04/2023 08:16

I’m subject to tonsillitis…I’d kill for antibiotics when I have it!!

Except there is no point if it is not bacterial tonsilitis

SoftCoeur · 22/04/2023 10:07

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 09:48

I'm sorry. I shouldn't have doubted the GP knew what she was doing.

I keep saying I was being a dick and shouldn't have posted.

I would stop apologising and forget the thread if I were you, as it seems to have attracted an unusually high number of raging arseholes, for some reason. Of course doctors aren't infallible.

You've had some really bizarrely nasty replies here.

countbackfromten · 22/04/2023 10:05

@Jazsimone aciclovir is an anti-viral medication not an antibiotic. Metronidazole is twice a day or three times a day depending on what is it being used to treat, amoxicillin is 3 times a day, penicillin V is 4 times a day.

ShowUs · 22/04/2023 10:03

If you didn’t want the antibiotics then you should have refused them/not picked up the prescription.

No one is forcing you to take them.

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 10:02

Embelline · 22/04/2023 09:37

I don’t dispute there is an issue with over prescribing. We get prescribed antibiotics for our three year old at the drop of a hat it seems. But I think they are more cautious with small children especially after Covid when a lot of usual viral infections have turned into secondary bacterial infections commonly / in our case anyway.

I just think it’s ridiculous that the OP was suggesting all the GP did was look it up on the internet as though they had no further qualification than she did. And to the poster who saw a doctor google, I can’t argue that because I wasn’t there but every doctor I’ve been to that has looked something up it’s been on specialist clinical scoring sites.

I think the pressure on OP here that you should never question or doubt a doctor and that should always do exactly what they say even if you are unsure is dangerous. A tthe end of the day, it is your body and your health and you have a right to speak up and ask questions. Dcotors have expertise but they make mistakes - including overprescribing antibiotics.

I had a GP years ago that did google some things - she was a fantastic GP and open about the fact that she didn't know everything and when I had a condition that wasn't responding well to the regular treatment, she did google to try and see what else might be out there. You can find a lot of scientific information via google.

I worked in health care so I do not in any way have these rose coloured glasses that doctors are perfect and should never be doubted or questioned and you should always just do exactly what they say even if it doesn't seem right.

Posters could have given OP information about what systems use and what the GP was likely doing without all the name calling and hero worship of doctors leading her to post multiple times about what an awful person she is and how she was wrong to ever doubt a doctor. And she is still being criticized.

ApplesandOrangesandPears · 22/04/2023 10:01

I used to get bacterial tonsilitis constantly, it was never swabbed and I needed antibiotics every single time. I eventually had my tonsils removed but believe me I needed those antibiotics - I was so unwell. More recently my daughter had severe tonsilitis that landed her in hospital, again no swab but they only had to look in her mouth for a second to know exactly what was making her so unwell and give antibiotics. Bacterial tonsilitis tends to result in white patches on the tonsils and enlarged lymph nodes, as well as high fever. I always used to get nausea and vomiting as a child too, and my daughter was so lethargic when she had it that she couldn't even watch watch TV.

kittensinthekitchen · 22/04/2023 09:53

@Freefall212

Where is the suggestion that the GP has prescribed the antibiotics needlessly?

The GP prescribed a treatment, based on assessment of the patient and the information they have been provided with.

Killingmytime · 22/04/2023 09:50

I suffered for years with tonsillitis. Always got antibiotics.
it can lead to other problems.
only once was i not prescribed them, it got worse so i gp ended up having to give them anyway.

Jazsimone · 22/04/2023 09:49

DeadOrchid · 22/04/2023 09:42

@Jazsimone any luck finding an antibiotic given orally five times a day?

Amoxicillin (many variants of penicillin)
Aciclovir
Metronidazole

And many many more that treat bacterial and viral infections

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 09:48

I'm sorry. I shouldn't have doubted the GP knew what she was doing.

I keep saying I was being a dick and shouldn't have posted.

OP posts:
polkaday · 22/04/2023 09:47

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 08:02

OK OK. I'm being a dick. Can I blame lack of sleep/feeling v unwell/not eating/getting my period all in the last few days?

Absolutely not.

You know if the GP was in your shoes - which given she sees a lot of people with sore throats etc is very likely to catch one herself - and given shes a woman so likely gets a period every month - and lack of sleep given she works in the NHS.......... she would very likely have to still go to work and deal with the likes of you.

polkaday · 22/04/2023 09:45

FakePlanet · 22/04/2023 07:32

She's prescribed me antibiotics that I need to take 5 times a day on an empty stomach for 10 days. I'd really rather not do that if I can help it.

Same GP who prescribed me antidepressants when I went in with a rash she said was caused by stress.

Lol. CaN No LoNgEr TaKe yOu SeRiOuSlY. Because I know a thing or two about antibiotics. I call BS.

polkaday · 22/04/2023 09:44

Why did you go to the GP @FakePlanet ? What a collosal waste of everyone's time and use of resources.

Guidelines change all the time (which we all know too well with regards to the recent pandemic!) So the GP was probably just following the latest guidance.

Even if she did "Google it". It wouldn't be the same as you googling it. You and I could both google search minutiae of a certain genomics - you wouldnt know what to do with that info whereas the GP could sift through and get to the relevant bit in seconds. Its more a jog of their memory.

If for example, you forgot what the capital of France is and you googled it, you could pick up the correct answer out of Rome, London, Paris, Cardiff, Lisbon quite quickly whereas someone that doesnt speak the language etc probably couldnt.

Nobody is forcing you to take the antibiotics. Dont take them if they dont suit you but wish youd said it at the time - what a waste of GP, Pharmacy and tax payers resources.

No they dont "test" every single person with a sore throat.

Also the GP would have had 10 mins tops with you and likely more like <5mins given her next patient may have terminal cancer or something else more complicated than your sore throat who she'd also only get 10 minutes for.
You and I have each easily spent more than 10 mins talking about this.

DeadOrchid · 22/04/2023 09:42

@Jazsimone any luck finding an antibiotic given orally five times a day?

Conkersinautumn · 22/04/2023 09:41

I developed psoriasis after several bouts of sore throat in a year with no prescription. I've a lot of aoubt about your post tbh

Embelline · 22/04/2023 09:37

I don’t dispute there is an issue with over prescribing. We get prescribed antibiotics for our three year old at the drop of a hat it seems. But I think they are more cautious with small children especially after Covid when a lot of usual viral infections have turned into secondary bacterial infections commonly / in our case anyway.

I just think it’s ridiculous that the OP was suggesting all the GP did was look it up on the internet as though they had no further qualification than she did. And to the poster who saw a doctor google, I can’t argue that because I wasn’t there but every doctor I’ve been to that has looked something up it’s been on specialist clinical scoring sites.

Gistbury · 22/04/2023 09:34

I used to get tonsillitis a lot and it was always bacterial. Often the GP would not give me antibiotics as they suspected viral but I would get incredibly poorly and need antibiotics to clear it

notveryspeedy · 22/04/2023 09:30

Regarding "she went into a website" she would have been looking at clinical guidelines and protocols, not just Googling. Back in the day she would have looked in a book, or maybe at index cards.

Glad you've accepted you were being a dick, OP. I'm curious which abx you're on though?

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 09:28

This is actually an issue that has been researched pretty extensively. For those of you who don't believe that overprescribing of antibiotics is an issue, you can find mnay studies that talk about the issue on Google Scholar. Here is one that is UK based.

"Overprescribing of antibiotics in primary care is one of the important drivers of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) internationally.1 Previous studies estimated that one-fifth to one-third of UK antibiotic prescriptions in primary care are unnecessary or inappropriate.2 The study by van Staa and colleagues3 published in this issue of BMJ Quality & Safety delivers additional insights into prescribing practices by primary care physicians (general practitioners, GPs) in the UK. Analysing data from more than 6000 GPs in 466 general practices between 2012 and 2017, they found large variability in prescribing practices as measured, for example, by the overall antibiotic prescribing rate per consultation, the percentage of patients receiving repeat prescriptions and the use of broad-spectrum antibiotics. The percentage of repeat prescriptions (ie, antibiotics that were prescribed within 30 days of another antibiotic prescription) ranged from 13.1% to 34.3%, with a mean of 23.2%."

https://qualitysafety.bmj.com/content/31/11/782

CornishGem1975 · 22/04/2023 09:26

Massive drip feed because the thread isn't going the way you wanted.

UnicornsHaveDadsToo · 22/04/2023 09:26

Irritateandunreasonable · 22/04/2023 09:11

Are you ok love? I’ve literally seen a GP use google, fairly new GP but still.

It’s tonsillitis - my 11 year old could diagnose it 🤣

Local infection and resistance to antibiotic therapy patterns change, so for things like tonsillitis, there's often a locally maintained website to score symptoms, decide whether to prescribe an antibiotic and of so, which one (it's not always a penicillin, and it won't be bog standard pen V either, it will be a "penicillin type" antibiotic).

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 09:21

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 09:14

Why didnt you just go to the chemist and buy it then?

Honestly no wonder I cant get an appointment when I want one.

Because I had another covid related symptom that I needed assessed but unreated to my sore throat and antibiotics.

Badbudgeter · 22/04/2023 09:21

If there’s white stuff in your tonsils it’s generally bacterial. I think what happens is most tonsillitis is viral but when your tonsils are inflamed it’s much easier for bacteria to settle in and you have a secondary bacterial infection which needs antibiotics.

My GP says some people once they’ve had a nasty bout of tonsillitis have permanently inflamed tonsils which make them much prone to bacterial tonsillitis. My eldest used to develop bacterial tonsillitis quite a lot although he uses an anti bacterial mouthwash now which has helped. I was the same as a teenager and had them whipped out at 16.

Mrsjayy · 22/04/2023 09:18

Freefall212 · 22/04/2023 09:11

I couldn't swallow so I was hoping for a numbing spray or a medicated mouthwash or something to make swallowing possible. I did get a prescription for that as well and used it and it did help slightly.

I mean Boots sell those no need to bother a Gp when a pharmacist could give you these,

kittensinthekitchen · 22/04/2023 09:17

bellac11 · 22/04/2023 09:14

Why didnt you just go to the chemist and buy it then?

Honestly no wonder I cant get an appointment when I want one.

Exactly!