Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do men become better boyfriends when they fall in love?

94 replies

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 19:47

I’m a heterosexual woman so will position this from my own perspective but it could apply to any relationship.

If you meet a guy who has previously been a useless boyfriend. Perhaps he lied, cheated, was lazy or just didn’t commit. If he meets the love of his life, how likely is he to change and become a good boyfriend?

I think I overlook men’s flaws because I naively or perhaps arrogantly think that they just haven’t had their right / best / forever relationship yet and it will be different with me!

YABU - men don’t change. If he was a crap boyfriend to his ex, he’ll be a crap boyfriend to you too.

YANBU - of course men can change and they frequently do change when they meet the love of their life, even if it took them 40 years to do so!

OP posts:
PelvicFlora · 22/04/2023 08:27

The best indicator of future behaviour is past behaviour.

Leopards don't tend to change their spots unless they spend a lot of time working on themselves and gaining insight and self-awareness.

Most don't bother.

SkyandSurf · 22/04/2023 02:08

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 22/04/2023 00:10

I don't know why so many posters seem not to believe that a man might act completely differently towards somebody they want to marry/date vs somebody they just want a quick shag with.

A man who has a lack of respect or holds contempt for women in general will show his colours in time, no matter how 'in love' he is.

If he's fine mistreating a woman he wanted a quick shag with, then he will absolutely be the kind of husband who has no issues mistreating his wife.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 22/04/2023 00:10

I don't know why so many posters seem not to believe that a man might act completely differently towards somebody they want to marry/date vs somebody they just want a quick shag with.

SkyandSurf · 21/04/2023 23:45

Absolutely men change when they fall in love- in movies.

In real life- no. In fact bad men falling in love just means they then feel entitled to mistreat one more person.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 21/04/2023 23:33

Whilst I agree it's not a great idea thinking you can 'fix' a man, it's definitely the case that some (a lot?) of men won't treat a woman as well if they're a bit meh about the relationship.

CheersForThatEh · 21/04/2023 23:24

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 21:59

What is the psychology behind not being able to end a relationship? My most recent guy was like this. Tells anyone who will listen how unfulfilled he is in his current relationship but won’t actually break up with her (no kids or ties). Is it because they’re scared of being alone? Don’t want to be the bad guy? Or something else?

For men i think it's less hassle. They dont have to plan a hard conversation and where they will live. A lot of men are quite passive and will leave a relationship without declaring it hy checking out.

I did it once when I was in a bad toxic relationship by finding a job opportunity miles away from home that I knew he wouldnt move away with me for and i knew it would fizzle out then. I stuck around until then because by then he had isolated me from friends and family and I was scared of being alone and depressed and the fall out from actually ending it rather than letting it fizzle out and starting over somewhere new.

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 23:20

ashitghost · 21/04/2023 23:17

They only change when they get too old for it all. Like lazy wildebeest eyeing up gazelles.

The guy I was seeing was 43. Maybe he’ll give up being a cheat when he’s 63.

OP posts:
ashitghost · 21/04/2023 23:17

They only change when they get too old for it all. Like lazy wildebeest eyeing up gazelles.

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 23:16

brunettemic · 21/04/2023 23:10

Do women who were previously useless girlfriends change when they fall in love? People can, and do, change but a fundamental change is unlikely unless their original personality was a lie in the first place.

Ooh. I’m not sure. All of my female friends are good girlfriends and wives!
I do know one woman who was unhappily married who cheated on her husband and left him. Now she is married to the new guy and they have a baby. She seems very happy with the new guy. I can’t see her cheating on him.

OP posts:
mrwalkensir · 21/04/2023 23:15

yep - to be fair, a lot of people (not just men) are bastards - I have a narc mother :) I was thinking about young (ish) men ie under 35

brunettemic · 21/04/2023 23:10

Do women who were previously useless girlfriends change when they fall in love? People can, and do, change but a fundamental change is unlikely unless their original personality was a lie in the first place.

MMMarmite · 21/04/2023 22:53

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:26

Because I treat people with kindness and respect, I hoped they would treat me that way in return. Nope!

I reckon people don't work that way.

I each person have a basic level of kindness and respect that they pay to everyone. For some that is a very high level of decency, for others very low.

Then people will pay above that level if they can get something out of it. So if you have high boundaries and high power and social status, shit people will treat you less shittily. But they are still shit people overall.

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:48

mrwalkensir · 21/04/2023 22:45

Have a couple of very attractive male schoolmates (who were also nice blokes) who were seen as not settling down/being shallow. The minute the right girl entered the room, they were besotted and in love. And have remained so for 30+ years. Being good-looking, they attracted everybody. But of course, it had to be the right person for them too.

I think this is what I had in mind. I think I thought men were like this until the right woman came along.
I guess I just didn’t take into consideration that there are plenty of selfish men around too, who cheat and just take what they want.

OP posts:
MMMarmite · 21/04/2023 22:48

Very good post @Thepeopleversuswork

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:46

BranchGold · 21/04/2023 22:42

Do you think he’s kind about you?

No. I’m not with him. He had a girlfriend the whole time he was with me and I had no idea. It just blew up on Sunday. I was his secret bit on the side and I didn’t know. I presume he never told anyone about me. Or if he did he probably said I was a crazy single mother who was really into him.

OP posts:
mrwalkensir · 21/04/2023 22:45

Have a couple of very attractive male schoolmates (who were also nice blokes) who were seen as not settling down/being shallow. The minute the right girl entered the room, they were besotted and in love. And have remained so for 30+ years. Being good-looking, they attracted everybody. But of course, it had to be the right person for them too.

MMMarmite · 21/04/2023 22:44

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:34

No he wasn’t particularly full of regret. He has said insightful things over the months like

  • I seem to have not treated women very well
  • I think I have been a selfish person
  • I think I need to think about others more
  • I’m reflecting on my behaviour
  • Maybe I’m just a terrible narcissist

I’m a decent person myself and yes I want to be with a decent person too. I just don’t know where these decent single men are!

I don't think those are wildly insightful things. Those were him speaking his guilt outloud!

Insightful would be like "I think I have been a selfish person. I did A and B. I think the impact they had on the other person is C. This caused them to respond in D way, which meant E for that relationship. I think that I learnt to be selfish because my father treated my mother that way when I was younger, but I can see now how destructive that was. I really want to be different, so I am going to do F and G on a practical level, and also talk to someone to explore more what's been driving this behaviour."

BranchGold · 21/04/2023 22:42

Do you think he’s kind about you?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/04/2023 22:42

I think because he so brazenly admitted cheating on his ex, in such a matter of fact way, it didn’t hit home properly. I thought he just didn’t like her very much.

That’s exactly the sort of thing my friend would say. It’s just finding a way to excuse the shitty behaviour over and over and over again, because it’s what she/you want to believe.

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:41

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/04/2023 22:38

I overlook men’s flaws because I naively or perhaps arrogantly think that they just haven’t had their right / best / forever relationship yet and it will be different with me!

This isn’t arrogance as much as just wilful ignorance and seeing everything through a socially conditioned “romantic” filter.

It’s a bit worrying that you think “love” (by which you basically mean sexual attraction dressed up with romance) is some magic bullet which turns bad men good, like Cupid’s arrow. It doesn’t work like that (although a whole cultural industry has grown up to convince women it does).

Love is a conscious act of deciding that someone else is important enough that their needs are equal to yours and that there’s enough common ground to work together in a meaningful partnership. You have to have compatibility and respect and sexual attraction but there isn’t one special person who has the power to magic away a person’s faults through being the “right” one. That’s hogwash.

As a general rule a person who is arrogant or selfish or immature is not capable of real love. They are capable of thinking they need someone or wanting to control them and wanting to have sex with them to the point of obsession and doing everything in their power to “win” the person round. And they may be able to sustain a competent illusion of being “romantic” for a few months. But that’s not what love is.

If you see yourself as on a perpetual quest to be the “right” one for somebody who basically lacks the emotional tools for love you’re setting yourself up for failure.

You’re right. This guy wasn’t capable of love. The woman he’s in a relationship with now isn’t getting that kind of love from him. He seems to take what he needs from her (emotional intimacy, cinema partner, sex) but he’s very unkind about her.

OP posts:
Againstmachine · 21/04/2023 22:40

If a man's a dick he is that no matter what you ain't going to change him once a cheater always a cheater.

Aim higher .

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/04/2023 22:40

No he wasn’t particularly full of regret. He has said insightful things over the months like

  • I seem to have not treated women very well
  • I think I have been a selfish person
  • I think I need to think about others more
  • I’m reflecting on my behaviour
  • Maybe I’m just a terrible narcissist

All that shite just means that they’ve learned the right words to say to make you think that they’ve changed and excuse away their continuing abuse.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/04/2023 22:38

I overlook men’s flaws because I naively or perhaps arrogantly think that they just haven’t had their right / best / forever relationship yet and it will be different with me!

This isn’t arrogance as much as just wilful ignorance and seeing everything through a socially conditioned “romantic” filter.

It’s a bit worrying that you think “love” (by which you basically mean sexual attraction dressed up with romance) is some magic bullet which turns bad men good, like Cupid’s arrow. It doesn’t work like that (although a whole cultural industry has grown up to convince women it does).

Love is a conscious act of deciding that someone else is important enough that their needs are equal to yours and that there’s enough common ground to work together in a meaningful partnership. You have to have compatibility and respect and sexual attraction but there isn’t one special person who has the power to magic away a person’s faults through being the “right” one. That’s hogwash.

As a general rule a person who is arrogant or selfish or immature is not capable of real love. They are capable of thinking they need someone or wanting to control them and wanting to have sex with them to the point of obsession and doing everything in their power to “win” the person round. And they may be able to sustain a competent illusion of being “romantic” for a few months. But that’s not what love is.

If you see yourself as on a perpetual quest to be the “right” one for somebody who basically lacks the emotional tools for love you’re setting yourself up for failure.

FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:38

BrightYellowDaffodil · 21/04/2023 22:34

Should I have run a mile when he first made that admission?

No. you should have run MANY miles.

I have a friend who is desperate for a loving relationship. The result is that she attracts every lying, cheating, creepy, controlling scumbag from here to Christmas - they can scent her willingness to excuse away and accept the most appalling behaviour at 50 paces.

She hopes that every single one of them will be different from the last one. That they will change from their horrific relationship history. That she will be the one to save the bad boy from himself and he will find true love with her.

It never happens, but she won’t recognise the pattern even when she’s giving evidence against them. I have to admire her (horrendously misplaced) optimism but I’m just waiting for the phone call to say one of them has killed her.

Do the Freedom Programme. Don’t be like her, please.

I think because he so brazenly admitted cheating on his ex, in such a matter of fact way, it didn’t hit home properly. I thought he just didn’t like her very much.

OP posts:
FeelingSad99 · 21/04/2023 22:37

BranchGold · 21/04/2023 22:33

It’s interesting the language you use. Twice you said he turned into a cheat, when you knew all along he was a cheat. You didn’t expect him to do it to you, based on what?

What I mean is that I found out after seeing him casually for 14 months that he was in a secret committed relationship with someone else. That’s how the story ‘turned out’. For those 14 months I thought he was a reasonably decent person. Until I found out he wasn’t. I should have been more attuned to the red flags from how he treated his ex.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread