Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Steve Barclay taking legal action against nurses

169 replies

Gigihadr · 21/04/2023 19:35

Reasonable or unreasonable?

my opinion is Steve Barclay is utter human garbage

Steve Barclay taking legal action against nurses
OP posts:
TheHoover · 23/04/2023 20:10

*Medicine yes, though i'm not sure i'd want the entry requirements to drop but regardless, who will run their placements?

As for Nursing & AHP courses, like Teaching, they are not attracting student numbers, drop the entrance requirements and we get poor quality nurses, AHP's.

But anyhow, none of what you say (or what Labour says) addresses the basic fact that there are not enough young people in this country to be trained up to do the multitude of jobs we require.

So where do we get HCP's from? *

I don’t quite agree. Plenty of fabulous nurses are just simply not academic. The unexploited market is existing HCSWs desperate to get qualified but still needing protected time off the rota as a student (and therefore needing to be backfilled which costs money which the government could provide). This used to be a valuable source of nurses till the tories stopped funding the scheme 10 tears ago

MissyB1 · 23/04/2023 19:39

BluebellBlueballs · 23/04/2023 18:55

And how exactly do you know that? All of them willing to just move to another country, really? None of them with family or other ties here and happy to take a job in a private setting or even change career?

Wherever they go who do you think will replace them?

Gigihadr · 23/04/2023 19:12

I don’t think we’re going to have any doctors/ nurses left thanks to this government

OP posts:
7yo7yo · 23/04/2023 19:01

Well it would be a shame if there was a mass sick day of doctors and nurses.

BluebellBlueballs · 23/04/2023 18:55

secretmumoffour · 23/04/2023 11:18

Except @BluebellBlueballs the nhs staff leave... it won't be for posts on the private sector it will be for posts overseas... how do you propose they are filled once they have left?

And how exactly do you know that? All of them willing to just move to another country, really? None of them with family or other ties here and happy to take a job in a private setting or even change career?

Howpo · 23/04/2023 14:57

sleepyscientist · 23/04/2023 10:16

Would it be tho? Medicine and nursing are very competitive attracting student with grades above and beyond what is required to do the job. If you had more places the entrance requirements would likely drop and more people would go to uni overall.

Medicine yes, though i'm not sure i'd want the entry requirements to drop but regardless, who will run their placements?

As for Nursing & AHP courses, like Teaching, they are not attracting student numbers, drop the entrance requirements and we get poor quality nurses, AHP's.

But anyhow, none of what you say (or what Labour says) addresses the basic fact that there are not enough young people in this country to be trained up to do the multitude of jobs we require.

So where do we get HCP's from?

Very competitive international market out there.....

SinnerBoy · 23/04/2023 11:24

caringcarer · Today 07:54

Not sure why unions could not have planned a strike a few days earlier to fall within the 6 months, or do another ballot.

They voted six months ago and wanted to use it as threat of last resort; they don't actually want to strike, but they feel that they have no other option. They have been trying to be reasonable, but the Government has ignored them.

Regarding another strike, there are a number of legal requirements, which must go through outside checks, to ensure the validity of members being still members and the like. It's a time consuming process.

secretmumoffour · 23/04/2023 11:18

Except @BluebellBlueballs the nhs staff leave... it won't be for posts on the private sector it will be for posts overseas... how do you propose they are filled once they have left?

BluebellBlueballs · 23/04/2023 11:09

secretmumoffour · 23/04/2023 10:33

@BluebellBlueballs
"Work done in harsh conditions for low pay" by definition

www.thefreedictionary.com/slavery
Yep, all resign and leave the health service with nothing? What a brilliant idea 🙄

It actually is a brilliant idea, as this would force the govt to increase the pay to over that of competitors to get the staff back.
It's called market forces.

Happygirl79 · 23/04/2023 10:43

Shows Steve Barclay and this government in a really bad light. Uncaring. People cannot afford to live. People are dying. But the government doesn't care. This is the absolute worst government that I have ever witnessed in 40 years
They need to be voted out.

secretmumoffour · 23/04/2023 10:33

@BluebellBlueballs
"Work done in harsh conditions for low pay" by definition

www.thefreedictionary.com/slavery
Yep, all resign and leave the health service with nothing? What a brilliant idea 🙄

BluebellBlueballs · 23/04/2023 10:20

secretmumoffour · 22/04/2023 12:07

Aside from SB ridiculous antics.... all the people commenting with "it's their job" or "people are going to die"... whilst this is true to an extent this government with their new laws are essentially making entering our health service volunteering to going into slavery by definition of not being able to withdraw one's labour. If one can't withdraw their labour they are a slave.... who's going to want to work for an organisation like that with poor conditions and poor pay requiring a minimum of a degree qualification that gives numerous transferable skills? It's almost like people are happy for this government to kill off the NHS and the poor who can't afford private health cover to die 🙄

Volunteering to go into slavery?

What an Insult to actusl slaves

Ever heard of the concept of resigning? That's what I usually do if I don't like my job. There are plenty of private health care employers now.

sleepyscientist · 23/04/2023 10:16

Howpo · 23/04/2023 08:55

@TheHoover

Look, i want the Tories gone, dust, oblivion!

But equally i do not like empty promises and the UK has an aging workforce, there is a great deal of competition for A level grade students, 10k extra in healthcare means 10k less in engineering, law etc etc.

So we need a frictionless way to attract HCPs from the EU instead from countries that are in desperate need of HCP's themselves.

Labour do need to commit to higher wage increases and one way to fund this would be taxes on un earned income, they ve started with nom dom, lets see it extended to invest gains?

Unless they find a way to increase retention, all we will do is provide a steady stream of HCP's for Australia.

Lets see Labour put some clear blue water between themselves and the Cons on this issue.

Would it be tho? Medicine and nursing are very competitive attracting student with grades above and beyond what is required to do the job. If you had more places the entrance requirements would likely drop and more people would go to uni overall.

Howpo · 23/04/2023 08:55

@TheHoover

Look, i want the Tories gone, dust, oblivion!

But equally i do not like empty promises and the UK has an aging workforce, there is a great deal of competition for A level grade students, 10k extra in healthcare means 10k less in engineering, law etc etc.

So we need a frictionless way to attract HCPs from the EU instead from countries that are in desperate need of HCP's themselves.

Labour do need to commit to higher wage increases and one way to fund this would be taxes on un earned income, they ve started with nom dom, lets see it extended to invest gains?

Unless they find a way to increase retention, all we will do is provide a steady stream of HCP's for Australia.

Lets see Labour put some clear blue water between themselves and the Cons on this issue.

TheHoover · 23/04/2023 08:47

@Howpo
i have more faith. The workforce modernisation plan is about new pathways/growing your own which is there now but has not been funded. Placement capacity can be increased with additional money for practice/education supervisors and backfill. It’s a strong statement and I believe they will hold to it.

If they committed now to higher wages they will need to show how they can afford it which they will not be able to do with any credibility.

Howpo · 23/04/2023 08:12

@TheHoover

These are aims not really plausible.

Why? because the UK has not enough A level grade students to fill these places and not leave skills shortages in other sectors.
Labour have not promised to increase pay substantially, to aid retention/make the profession more attractive or restore the Bursary for nurses and AHP's

Plus without FOM/or SM membership (which Lab have ruled out) attracting HCPs from the EU, we will have to continue the practice of taking workers from developing countries, which is exactly what the Tories are doing.

UK pay will not attract workers from Aus Canada NZ etc, its going the other way.

On Med school places, double them? how? there isn't the placement capacity.

They need to be a lot more ambitious, lead the country instead of following a focus group.

FishFingerWrap · 23/04/2023 08:05

This is so stupid.

Regardless of the legalities, he would do well to put equivalent energy into appearing to want to reach a resolution and acknowledging the issues behind the strikes.

Just engaging with disciplinary legal action and of kring the rest will excerabte all the issues behind the strikes anyway.

Who on EARTH would want to work for the NHS? Rubbish pay, horrendous conditions, and a health secretary who only appears to be able to take action when it's to stop you standing up and trying to enact change.

I have first hand recent experience of being extremely unwell, off work for months and receiving next to no healthcare in that time because everything my GP referred me to said they were overwhelmed. I've had to pay for private, piecemeal healthcare that's been very underwhelming. I was an inpatient and barely cared for. I've complained but PALS say complaints can't be dealt with in their previous timescales.....

Imagine only springing in to action now.

caringcarer · 23/04/2023 07:54

Not sure why unions could not have planned a strike a few days earlier to fall within the 6 months, or do another ballot. If it's illegal then it is reasonable to take legal action.

TheHoover · 23/04/2023 07:33

@Howpo
here is labour’s pledge: https://labour.org.uk/press/labour-to-deliver-10-year-plan-for-change-and-modernisation-of-the-nhs/
what else would you like to see?

@sleepyscientist
I really wish the trust CEO's would sort it by just paying us properly
NHS pay grades are negotiated nationally not locally by Trust CEOs. There isn’t a single trust CEO in the country that doesn’t want to pay nurses, junior docs and other healthcare staff what they deserve

Labour to deliver 10-year plan for change and modernisation of the NHS - The Labour Party

The next Labour Government will deliver a new 10-year plan for the NHS, including one of the biggest expansions of the NHS workforce in history, higher standards for patients, and a new model of care. Labour will ensure fewer patients need to go to hos...

https://labour.org.uk/press/labour-to-deliver-10-year-plan-for-change-and-modernisation-of-the-nhs/

Howpo · 23/04/2023 07:02

At the end of the day if people want the NHS to the extent it exists now it's got to be paid for, other wise at the rate we are losing staff it simple won't exist

But we can't dictate that, if Sunak choses not to fund the NHS to the long term averages of say France Germany etc, for the people that care, there is precious little we can do about that.

Despite the mess the govt has made of the NHS/Social care, the polls have closed quite a bit between Lab/Con recently.

I'm really not seeing Labours plans to recruit 10k extra nurses each and every year as plausible at all, which is a such a shame because the NHS really could be a vote winner for Lab but they are just too timid.

Many people really do believe the NHS is properly funded and staffed but badly run and no amount of extra staff or money will change this.

sleepyscientist · 22/04/2023 14:53

Disco2023 · 22/04/2023 14:29

Or maybe just maybe NHS employers/Barclay could actually listen to healthcare staff. I’m a healthcare professional and it’s a shit show. It’s not just about pay, it’s so unsafe and staff risk their pins and registrations daily. Patients die daily because of poor care due to lack of staff. Nevermind the strike.

Threatening court action doesn’t really encourage staff to stay now does it. But it’s ok because the government don’t really use the NHS do they? They can afford with their pay and generous expenses to go private.

Remember those claps three years ago and how many staff were under no illusion this would happen after the pandemic

I wonder if they went back out to ballot how many more would vote to strike. I really wish the trust CEO's would sort it by just paying us properly and going into a deficit. At the end of the day if people want the NHS to the extent it exists now it's got to be paid for, other wise at the rate we are losing staff it simple won't exist.

SerendipityJane · 22/04/2023 14:29

Brieandcamembert · 22/04/2023 10:51

You are paid to do a job. You can't leave people to die because you want more money.

Nursing and AHP salaries and benefits (A/L, sick pay, job security) are quite good comparative to some private sector posii.

Striking is the adult equivalent of a toddler tantrum and shoes what happens if you run a socialist organisation.

People die all the time.

A death is a tragedy. A million a statistic. I am mildly amused the government weren't told this by their paymasters advisers

Disco2023 · 22/04/2023 14:29

Or maybe just maybe NHS employers/Barclay could actually listen to healthcare staff. I’m a healthcare professional and it’s a shit show. It’s not just about pay, it’s so unsafe and staff risk their pins and registrations daily. Patients die daily because of poor care due to lack of staff. Nevermind the strike.

Threatening court action doesn’t really encourage staff to stay now does it. But it’s ok because the government don’t really use the NHS do they? They can afford with their pay and generous expenses to go private.

Remember those claps three years ago and how many staff were under no illusion this would happen after the pandemic

mrcow · 22/04/2023 14:23

He’s an idiot.

Just negotiate a settlement for goodness sake. It’s going to happen in the end anyway. The longer he spins this out, just makes him look even more incompetent.

He’s going to be out of a job and looking for positions come the next general election. Who is going to employ him (or Gillian Keegan come to that!) when he can’t even negotiate with a bunch of nurses - in one of the most caring, understanding and reasonable professions we have!

Swipe left for the next trending thread