Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if literally anyone feels they are paid adequate child maintenance? I'm feeling desperate

282 replies

hadenlugff · 21/04/2023 15:39

Just that really. I’m paid 570 but it won’t even cover half of the nursery fees let alone wrap around care and everything else.

Not only that but it’s not even guaranteed so I can’t rely on it… and that’s fucking awful as I should be able to have some
assurance that I won’t be left entirely to raise a child that is half someone else’s.

I know people have it worse, it’s not a race to then bottom. I’m just dreading dc starting nursery in autumn and dont know how I will manage. Is anyone happy with what they get for maintenance? Ever? It feels so shit.

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 21:30

Every case is different. We are primarily discussing NRPs who avoid paying, or pay the minimum and choose to do fuck all. As I said above, the only way to create a fair system is to sufficiently fund the CMS with enough well trained personnel to look into things.

Lastnamedidntstick · 23/04/2023 19:27

As said above, this would be easily solved if more men were willing to genuinely take on 50/50 care but they rarely are, either during or after a relationship

even this isn’t practical.

dh genuinely did 50:50. Not a high earner but flexi hours so did school runs, bedtimes etc. his mum did all pre school childcare so she could work.

when his ex had an affair and manipulated him into leaving, he had nowhere to go except his mums one bed flat.

so even if he’d wanted to continue 50:50, no where to sleep, no space for toys, no garden etc.

when the divorce went through she’d “disappeared” 15k of joint savings, and there was barely any equity in the house. So he got nothing, she kept the house and car.

so there he was, paying his mum board, having to pay to take his kids out when he saw them, having to buy a car to do so, paying cms. He didn’t have enough disposable income to rent anywhere other than a shared house.

so again, if one household won’t split to provide two adequate living arrangements, how does 50:50 work?

taxpayer1 · 23/04/2023 18:19

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/04/2023 17:58

One thread (two with this one) is hardly “always” given how frequently you regurgitate your misogynistic bollocks.

Classy lady.🤔

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/04/2023 17:58

taxpayer1 · 23/04/2023 17:35

You always make comments on my posts. Are you one of the minimum wage partners that sacrificed your stellar career and want to be supported for life as if you have any option?

One thread (two with this one) is hardly “always” given how frequently you regurgitate your misogynistic bollocks.

taxpayer1 · 23/04/2023 17:35

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/04/2023 16:23

it’s always like bingo when you appear on threads

You always make comments on my posts. Are you one of the minimum wage partners that sacrificed your stellar career and want to be supported for life as if you have any option?

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 17:17

Well biology is a bit of an issue if the mother wants to breastfeed..yes there are ways around this but they require a lot of planning and organising, all of which fall on the mother. I think it's disingenuous to claim that a woman chooses, years in advance to operate as a single parent, doing 95% of everything when she had planned children, within a marriage or at least a partnership with a shared mortgage etc. I actually think you'd struggle to find a woman on here who would argue that the male NRP should pay MORE than 50% of costs, unless there was a really huge disparity of income, and that's for the child's sake, not the mother's. As said above, this would be easily solved if more men were willing to genuinely take on 50/50 care but they rarely are, either during or after a relationship.

Lastnamedidntstick · 23/04/2023 17:08

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 16:28

@taxpayer1 how do you know that? Seriously..what is your basis for that statement? I've read plenty of posts from graduate women, on similar career paths to their male partners who then stepped back to enable the father to work unencumbered by childcare concerns..to stay late, travel overseas, schmooze clients, with no issues about child's sickness or inset days or nativity plays. Yes, you could argue that was their choice but I can totally see how it would have seemed like the obvious one in the context of a seemingly stable marriage . I think that's starting to change but still some considerable way to go.

It is their choice.

women are not support humans. If they take that role it’s on them.

if two parents have equal careers how is it “the obvious choice” for the female half to become a support system for the male half.

there are plenty of other options, they can both reduce hours, they can both continue working, they can both change jobs to make it more flexible.

but if you give up your job or career you should do it in the full knowledge that chances are, should it end, you’re stuffed. Even if he’s a great father and does 50:50 or pays 50% of the kids costs, the other 50% is on you. If you have been out of work your lifestyle is going to take a huge hit.

Skybluepinky · 23/04/2023 17:01

Sounds reasonable, a lot more than others.

Flowersun6 · 23/04/2023 16:32

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 15:20

@Flowersun6 I assume the pint being made is that he wouldn't be a father and have achieved what he did without a willing partner doing all the regular and ad hoc childcare. He might be CEO or whatever but not AND an adequate parent.

I strongly disagree. It's a man's world. All I can say is if I ever had a DD I won't be pushing that narrative.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 16:28

@taxpayer1 how do you know that? Seriously..what is your basis for that statement? I've read plenty of posts from graduate women, on similar career paths to their male partners who then stepped back to enable the father to work unencumbered by childcare concerns..to stay late, travel overseas, schmooze clients, with no issues about child's sickness or inset days or nativity plays. Yes, you could argue that was their choice but I can totally see how it would have seemed like the obvious one in the context of a seemingly stable marriage . I think that's starting to change but still some considerable way to go.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/04/2023 16:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

it’s always like bingo when you appear on threads

taxpayer1 · 23/04/2023 16:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 15:20

@Flowersun6 I assume the pint being made is that he wouldn't be a father and have achieved what he did without a willing partner doing all the regular and ad hoc childcare. He might be CEO or whatever but not AND an adequate parent.

milafawny · 23/04/2023 14:29

I get £29 as its deducted from benefits since he stopped working. From when he was working im owed nearly £9k which ill never see and hes not forced to make payments towrads as hes in benefits.

Thats for 3 teenagers. £29 doesnt even buy them a takeaway once a month these days. I work all hours to provide everything they need and some of what they want.

The system is broken.

dizzygirl1 · 23/04/2023 14:25

I don't get anything, he thinks that is why i receive UC and CB. I pay all costs for them, all clothes (some cheap bits bought for his house by him or Christmas presents). He has them 5 nights over 14 but pays nothing for school, sports, or anything else.
When the youngest started secondary, I went uniform shopping, he had to take me as I wasn't able to drive. £190 in the uniform shop and not even a 'do you want anything towards it'
I looked at CMS, in theory he should pay £340 a month 🤣
That would make my life a lot easier!

Flowersun6 · 23/04/2023 14:12

tatteddear · 23/04/2023 11:08

I get just under what the csa tell him he should pay. But he is a high earner so I get a lot £950, for two children. I'm happy with it.
People say 'you are so lucky' and I am in that there is no issue with the payment but I don't feel lucky to get that amount (though I do rely on it), I very much enabled him to become the high earner he is (and still do by cutting my less well paid hours to look after dd2 who has had some troubled years), and the amount is commensurate to our relative situations.

Do you honestly think your ex wouldn't of been a higher earner without you?

MrsChuckBass · 23/04/2023 14:01

I have 2DC in primary school
ExH pays
£400 maintenance standing order
All school dinners into the online account
Random cash each week (usually between £25-£50 depending if he's done extra hours at work)
He has them 2 nights every week and half the holidays

I'm happy with that, I have no childcare costs and earn more than enough on my own before factoring maintenance etc in

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 11:22

There are so many differences in the financial positions of the two parents. Off the top of my head, the RP, in order to fulfill their parental duties must:
Have sufficient bedroom and living space for the majority if not all of the time
Ideally have some decent outside space
Live in a safe neighbourhood
Live in catchment of good schools
Live in proximity to good nurseries or where there is good childcare provision
Live near enough to work that drop offs and pick ups are feasible
Live near family support
Run a car or have good public transport links
Heat, light and broadband for children all the time
Food, snacks, bus fare, social activities, hobbies, clothes, kit, tech, toys.
Limit their earning potential due to availability
Limit their pension contributions to provide all of the above
Pay for childcare (over and above any UC they may or may not get)
Pay for ad hoc childcare to have any kind of social life of their own

The NRP if they are EOW types must:
Provide a bed and heat, food, light for 4 days a month - no other requirements really necessary for such short times
Ideally, (but many dont) provide clothes, shoes, toys, books, outside space
Pay 20% of their gross income which they can legally reduce with pension contribution increases )ie directly taking money from their child to keep for themselves).

Not really even is it? I totally disagree that an NRP will have all the associated living costs that an RP does even when the kids are not with them - as shown above there are many disparities. Couple that with the inequality of earning POTENTIAL and its not hard to see how unequal it is. Oh also, the NRP is far more likely to be able to form and foster a new relationship that may lead to cohabitation which halves their rent etc, and they may even get to reduce the CMS at that point for kids that the new partner already has. Another "advantage".

tatteddear · 23/04/2023 11:08

I get just under what the csa tell him he should pay. But he is a high earner so I get a lot £950, for two children. I'm happy with it.
People say 'you are so lucky' and I am in that there is no issue with the payment but I don't feel lucky to get that amount (though I do rely on it), I very much enabled him to become the high earner he is (and still do by cutting my less well paid hours to look after dd2 who has had some troubled years), and the amount is commensurate to our relative situations.

SueVineer · 23/04/2023 10:35

IAmCinderella · 21/04/2023 21:04

I don't totally disagree but the child's housing costs are also your housing costs and a paying parent will also have their own housing costs to cover.

The non-resident parent should be paying 50% of the additional housing cost necessitated by the child. I.e. if one child the monthly cost of their home - the housing cost the resident parent would pay to live alone, divided by two.

Whether the non-resident finds that expensive or not should be irrelevant. They should have considered that before having children. Their child should come first and they should pay 50% of the costs of housing and raising that child. Why should the resident parent do most of the work and pay a disproportionate share of the child's costs? It's indefensible.

Because the nrp may not be able to afford to pay anything. Equally the rp may not be able to afford it but they will get benefits to pay rent which includes the child if that’s the case. I’d like to see better enforcement and culture around men paying for their kids but we have to be practical too.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/04/2023 08:36

The only thing that’s needed is proper funding in CMS and political will to use their powers.

I worked there briefly and as a RP who’d had to really fight I knew more of their powers on the first day than the guy training me…

Itslookinggood · 23/04/2023 08:29

CMS really needs reform. It only seems to work in strqightforward cases where NRP is on PAYE (and even then not always).

my ex is self-employed, then went to a limited company. He pays a pittance, despite having 7-figure assets and making £40,000 a year pension contributions.

I appealed, but after a year, and after a complaint from me, he was not required to pay more due to the above.

i am still recovering after 15 yrs of DA - including financial. Feels like being financially abused all over again, but this time by the system and EXH combined.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/04/2023 08:24

@milkysmum I read back during lockdown that people who did this missed out on furlough payments...made me smile at the time that some of these twats had it backfire on them. It really is appalling and says a lot about how our society (doesn't) value women in the workplace that they sooner hand out UC than enforce maintenance. Ultimately, I think two main things are needed:

  1. Make CMS a part of HMRC with the same approach to avoidance / evasion. True earning info would be much easier to collect and non payment easier to deal with.
  2. Huge investment in training and personnel so each individual case could be scrutinized and allocated a specific person who wasn't overwhelmed with caseload and who could get the measure of pisstakers on either side.
Even without root and branch reform of the actual percentages or penalties, those two things would , I think, have a huge impact on its efficacy as an agency.
worried4698643 · 23/04/2023 08:14

No. Absolutely nothing and no contribution to uniform or trips etc. he sees them one night a month.

milkysmum · 23/04/2023 08:08

I get £0 for 2 children. Ex is self employed builder. I tried to go through child maintenance services and they worked out I was entitled to £7 per week. I know ex earns between £500-750 per week but that obviously isn't going through the books. Cancelled the claim as it's an insult and pointless.