Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if literally anyone feels they are paid adequate child maintenance? I'm feeling desperate

282 replies

hadenlugff · 21/04/2023 15:39

Just that really. I’m paid 570 but it won’t even cover half of the nursery fees let alone wrap around care and everything else.

Not only that but it’s not even guaranteed so I can’t rely on it… and that’s fucking awful as I should be able to have some
assurance that I won’t be left entirely to raise a child that is half someone else’s.

I know people have it worse, it’s not a race to then bottom. I’m just dreading dc starting nursery in autumn and dont know how I will manage. Is anyone happy with what they get for maintenance? Ever? It feels so shit.

OP posts:
Flowersun6 · 24/04/2023 19:14

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 17:40

I don't see any logic in setting the bar so high. People can't pay what they don't have if someone paid £350 and that was all they could afford I'd accept that it is unfair you are absolutely right. You can't get blood out of a stone though.

All they could afford based on what? Like with tax, the provision of 50% of your child's living costs should not be optional. Your disposable income to fund the rest of your life is what is left AFTER you've done that. If that makes you not have a very nice lifestyle, tough. Why should a single parent who is doing all of the work of actually raising the children have to do that and also pay the other parent's share of costs? Don't like the idea of paying your half of your child's upbringing? Then don't have children.

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough, that's what they need to do. They can do a part time degree or retrain to earn more. They have plenty of time on their hands, unlike the parent doing the parenting. Perhaps they should focus on earning more rather than starting new relationships and having yet more children. The idea that they should be able to say "oh, I'd be a bit poor if I paid my share so it's fine for me not to", and that society thinks this is acceptable is vile and needs to change.

The issue isn't setting the bar too high. It's that people like you set it far, far too low.

I've bitten my tongue with you and a couple of other posters. I think have really jumped the gun.

I am a single parent myself I have no horse in the race to be pulling others down. Why exactly are you down my throat? Perhaps you should of picked a better father?

Why did you continue to have multiple kids to someone who is so immoral.

Don't be lecturing me about morals. I don't get the most money but I am interested in my Son seeing his father also so whilst your spouting about a shared roo that would mean NO overnights in my case which would then mean I couldn't do my 2nd job!

You and others need to try and see the bigger picture. I am not asking you to agree. However I am entitled to my opinion so back up!!

Throwing your personal digs!

60degreecycle · 24/04/2023 19:11

Are you one of the minimum wage partners that sacrificed your stellar career and want to be supported for life as if you have any option?

I'm just one of the boring ones who was earning more than my DH when we met, but now find myself despite his enthusiastic and convicing cries of 50/50 in the divorce, shouldering the vast majority of the childcare and it looks more like 5/95 if the wind is blowing in the right direction and he doesn't have to be anywhere more fabulous that month.

I'm getting the barest minimum child support, while he prioritises luxury holidays without the kids, new cars, £50k campervans, and renovates his new five bedroomed detatched house to exacting standards with the money he conveniently sidestepped in the divorce and that he continues to squirrell away due to him being self employed. Either way, he doesn't even give the kids pocket money.

I don't want to be supported for life. I would like him to help me to support our kids. That would be a great start.

He didn't leave me because I hate everything. I left him because he was a selfish dickhead and he has proved me right ever since.

Seas164 · 24/04/2023 18:49

How should it work? @taxpayer1

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 17:40

I don't see any logic in setting the bar so high. People can't pay what they don't have if someone paid £350 and that was all they could afford I'd accept that it is unfair you are absolutely right. You can't get blood out of a stone though.

All they could afford based on what? Like with tax, the provision of 50% of your child's living costs should not be optional. Your disposable income to fund the rest of your life is what is left AFTER you've done that. If that makes you not have a very nice lifestyle, tough. Why should a single parent who is doing all of the work of actually raising the children have to do that and also pay the other parent's share of costs? Don't like the idea of paying your half of your child's upbringing? Then don't have children.

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough, that's what they need to do. They can do a part time degree or retrain to earn more. They have plenty of time on their hands, unlike the parent doing the parenting. Perhaps they should focus on earning more rather than starting new relationships and having yet more children. The idea that they should be able to say "oh, I'd be a bit poor if I paid my share so it's fine for me not to", and that society thinks this is acceptable is vile and needs to change.

The issue isn't setting the bar too high. It's that people like you set it far, far too low.

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 17:04

@taxpayer1 you really are deeply unpleasant aren't you? Which part of @IAmCinderella's post do you have a problem with? Could you explain why you think men SHOULD be allowed to do what her and mine and so many others have done? Even if we were all awful bitches, that still wouldn't excuse them abandoning their kids, to all intents and purposes. Or would it? In your view?

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:46

I'm sure you're right, all of that must have been because of me. My bad, for being such an awful human being that living with me turned somebody into a gambling addict and philanderer. Charging hotel stays with young women to MY credit card while I looked after two babies, one of whom was so sick she was in and out of hospital by ambulance. And him later moving on to those even younger. Him becoming a paedophile must be because I was just such an unbearable wife.

I don't know what sort of misogyny brainwashing course you went on but it appears to have been very effective.

It MUST be the woman's fault. It couldn't possible be that someone who walks out on their wife and children is actually just an horrific person. Poor man. Let's all weep for his plight.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 24/04/2023 16:44

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:36

And to top it all off put up with this endless crap vilifying single mothers.

We are the heroins, the responsible ones, the superhuman ones doing the job of two people. Society should put us up on a pedestal not constantly attack us and direct all of this spite at us.

It's disgusting frankly and I'm so done biting my tongue and being polite about it.

The people who need vilifying are the people who don't provide for their children. Society needs to shame them. And anybody who accepts them as a friend or family member or even worse starts a relationship with someone who doesn't even provide for their existing children or - even more stupid - has yet more with that person who has shown themselves to be incapable of being a responsible adult or parent.

Those are the people that should be shamed and penalised, the ones who abandon their children or try to weasel out of paying for their upbringing. Not the ones who stick around and do the hard work.

Well said!

I've done the vast majority of the child rearing, with no practical or financial input from their father. My mental and physical health has suffered as a result.

But according to society I'm the "bad" person. Fuck that. I'm a freaking hero.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:39

Have you considered that your ex left because of your hate for everything and everyone that doesn't agree with you?

Yeah, well done.

This is exactly what I mean.

It must be the woman's fault, of course. 🙄

taxpayer1 · 24/04/2023 16:38

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:36

And to top it all off put up with this endless crap vilifying single mothers.

We are the heroins, the responsible ones, the superhuman ones doing the job of two people. Society should put us up on a pedestal not constantly attack us and direct all of this spite at us.

It's disgusting frankly and I'm so done biting my tongue and being polite about it.

The people who need vilifying are the people who don't provide for their children. Society needs to shame them. And anybody who accepts them as a friend or family member or even worse starts a relationship with someone who doesn't even provide for their existing children or - even more stupid - has yet more with that person who has shown themselves to be incapable of being a responsible adult or parent.

Those are the people that should be shamed and penalised, the ones who abandon their children or try to weasel out of paying for their upbringing. Not the ones who stick around and do the hard work.

Have you considered that your ex left because of your hate for everything and everyone that doesn't agree with you?

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:36

And to top it all off put up with this endless crap vilifying single mothers.

We are the heroins, the responsible ones, the superhuman ones doing the job of two people. Society should put us up on a pedestal not constantly attack us and direct all of this spite at us.

It's disgusting frankly and I'm so done biting my tongue and being polite about it.

The people who need vilifying are the people who don't provide for their children. Society needs to shame them. And anybody who accepts them as a friend or family member or even worse starts a relationship with someone who doesn't even provide for their existing children or - even more stupid - has yet more with that person who has shown themselves to be incapable of being a responsible adult or parent.

Those are the people that should be shamed and penalised, the ones who abandon their children or try to weasel out of paying for their upbringing. Not the ones who stick around and do the hard work.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 16:29

It is their choice.

women are not support humans. If they take that role it’s on them.

if two parents have equal careers how is it “the obvious choice” for the female half to become a support system for the male half.

there are plenty of other options, they can both reduce hours, they can both continue working, they can both change jobs to make it more flexible.

but if you give up your job or career you should do it in the full knowledge that chances are, should it end, you’re stuffed. Even if he’s a great father and does 50:50 or pays 50% of the kids costs, the other 50% is on you. If you have been out of work your lifestyle is going to take a huge hit.

Many of us have made no such choice. I did not decide to be a "support human".

My ex-husband decided to fuck off when our children were babies. He does not see them at all. I always worked full time and earned as much as him even when we were married.

Explain to me please why I should do all of the work of raising our children as a lone parent AND he shouldn't even pay 50% of the costs of raising them? AND I should also pay more tax than a two parent household with the same earnings as me and subsidise their children even though they have two parents to split earning and time at home between them?

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 15:17

I'm not picking a fight, just I hear that phrase a lot and it irks me. Most NRPs, could, if they chose, do a lot more to balance the parenting and costs but choose not to, and our current "system" not only enables it but penalises those of us on the sticky end of the wicket. There's zero political will to get into this or make it an election issue.

Flowersun6 · 24/04/2023 15:08

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 15:03

@Flowersun6 but it's not "blood out of a stone". A stone is incapable of giving blood and cannot change that. A human is capable of improving their earnings, or parenting more to allow the RP to work more. If I didn't have my kids 26/30 days I'd be doing 2 or 3 evening shifts a week on top of what I do all day just to build up savings. I could tutor, do bar work, work weekends. And I'd have significantly more income to myself than I do now. But I can't, because ex sees them actually less than eow. But he chooses not to earn what he could. He's actually on 20k less now than when we were together because he decided he'd like an easier life...nice for some.

I'm not here to argue with you. I'm a single parent myself

Seas164 · 24/04/2023 15:05

OnlyFannys · 21/04/2023 15:56

I'm paid exactly £0 by self employed ex

Sounds familiar...

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 15:03

@Flowersun6 but it's not "blood out of a stone". A stone is incapable of giving blood and cannot change that. A human is capable of improving their earnings, or parenting more to allow the RP to work more. If I didn't have my kids 26/30 days I'd be doing 2 or 3 evening shifts a week on top of what I do all day just to build up savings. I could tutor, do bar work, work weekends. And I'd have significantly more income to myself than I do now. But I can't, because ex sees them actually less than eow. But he chooses not to earn what he could. He's actually on 20k less now than when we were together because he decided he'd like an easier life...nice for some.

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 14:58

@IAmCinderella 👏👏👏👏 exactly. Of course any lower earning nrp could choose to step up and parent, or use his free time to study and become a higher earner, or work a second job. Funny how they don't though...oh because they don't have to. The RP picks it up, either through sacrificing a damn sight more than 20% of salary or running themselves ragged doing childcare and a full-time decent job, or using UC and damaging her own long term prospects (as well as being slagged off for being a feckless lazy single mum). Frankly, an Eow NRP, even if he was paying a full 50% of costs would still be getting off easy as the RP is providing him with 24/7 childcare for the 13 days (half of the 26) every month he is not seeing his child. I worked it out once, years, ago, after ex left. Using my childminder's rates, it would have cost him a couple of grand a month had he been charged for that.

Flowersun6 · 24/04/2023 14:56

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:50

If someone's genuinely doing 50% of parenting and providing a separate home for that child and covering 50% of sick days and childcare/ childcare costs because they live with half of the time, and therefore also paying half of their holidays and trips and activities and food and utilities, then fine. That is different, and no transfers of money between the parents will be required.

My comments are primarily about absent, non-resident fathers who do little if any parenting and see their children very little if at all. Damn right they should pay 50% of their living costs. The mother is then still doing all parenting and paying her 50%. It's pathetic to claim that it's unreasonable to expect a father at least to cover his half of the cost of raising his child and yes, he should be forced to make whatever lifestyle changes he has to in order to do it. It's the absolute minimum we should expect from even the shittest parent, to cover half of their child's costs. If anyone's bar is so low they think this is too much to expect then they should not be having children.

I didn't claim it was an unreasonable expectation. I'm just thinking what is realistic there is a huge difference!

I think most of us are mothers on the thread and as you can read most people will be lest holding the kids despite some of us getting £0 or much larger amounts.

I think you have misunderstood what I'm pointing out to you, I know what hard slog goes into being a parent..... I don't see any logic in setting the bar so high. People can't pay what they don't have if someone paid £350 and that was all they could afford I'd accept that it is unfair you are absolutely right. You can't get blood out of a stone though.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:50

If someone's genuinely doing 50% of parenting and providing a separate home for that child and covering 50% of sick days and childcare/ childcare costs because they live with half of the time, and therefore also paying half of their holidays and trips and activities and food and utilities, then fine. That is different, and no transfers of money between the parents will be required.

My comments are primarily about absent, non-resident fathers who do little if any parenting and see their children very little if at all. Damn right they should pay 50% of their living costs. The mother is then still doing all parenting and paying her 50%. It's pathetic to claim that it's unreasonable to expect a father at least to cover his half of the cost of raising his child and yes, he should be forced to make whatever lifestyle changes he has to in order to do it. It's the absolute minimum we should expect from even the shittest parent, to cover half of their child's costs. If anyone's bar is so low they think this is too much to expect then they should not be having children.

Flowersun6 · 24/04/2023 14:41

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:28

It's not about being a decent human being its about being realistic. 50% just doesn't work because of so many reasons.

Tough. The resident parent doesn't have the option to just opt out and say it's "not realistic" or "doesn't work" to pay their half. People should think before having children and be forced to pay for half of their living costs if they are such crap people they won't do it out of choice.

It's not just about money is it? Not everyone earns enough to pay 50% on a low salary it is simply not possible. It's about effort and intentions because if a father is genuinely bringing to the table what he can such as doing more over night stays, school runs and pulling his weight during the school holidays it wouldn't even be an argument about paying half because he would have his child in the 1st place.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:36

OhamIreally · 22/04/2023 09:43

So why don’t more women hand over residency to their exes if it’s such a cushy deal?

one household simply doesn’t split into two financially. @Lastnamedidntstick because the exes don't want them is the simple answer. They walk away and often dick about with the limited contact they do have.

Your argument that one household simply doesn't split into two financially is nonsensical- the RP also has housing costs AND the cost of bringing up the child. It appears you are saying that the sacrifice the NRP is being asked to make is too great whereas the RP can be asked to sacrifice their earning potential, financial well-being, health and freedom and that's fine.

Logical if you consider that women are simply support humans and their labour should be free.

Exactly. Poor little menz who might find they struggle financially if they have to support their own children by paying their half of costs. I mean, WTAF?

But the mother should expect to pay most of the father's half of expenses for them AND do all parenting AND higher childcare costs as a result of being a lone parent AND pay more tax than a two parent household with the same earnings AND woe betide any who complain about it.

Yeah, sounds fair.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:33

gogohmm
For the most part I think people should push for 50/50 and no maintenance, would mean so much less agro when they won't cooperate

Many ex-husbands do not see their children at all. Why should the mother do all of the work AND pay more than 50% of the costs of raising the children?

Because the poor man might find it a struggle to have to manage financially if he met his financial responsibilities? Let me find a tiny violin. Let's let the mothers doing the work struggle financially on top instead and make up his share of expenses shall we, and then tax them more than two parent households with the same earnings as well to compound the disadvantage. 🙄

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:28

It's not about being a decent human being its about being realistic. 50% just doesn't work because of so many reasons.

Tough. The resident parent doesn't have the option to just opt out and say it's "not realistic" or "doesn't work" to pay their half. People should think before having children and be forced to pay for half of their living costs if they are such crap people they won't do it out of choice.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 14:21

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 22/04/2023 07:09

So if you add my 50%

This comes up a lot and it bugs me - maintenance isn’t meant to be 50%.

That, imo, is why people struggle when bothers get a high amount. Or should get a high amount.

It meant to be a proportional portion of your income.

A footballer and a cleaner or a CEO and a bin man are not going to be paying 50% each of the lifestyle the child should have based on their parents combined incomes.

Of course they should be. They need to pay 59% of their child's costs as a minimum. Why on Earth should the other parent subsidise their half of the expenses for their own child after a divorce?

AnneLovesGilbert · 23/04/2023 21:59

dizzygirl1 · 23/04/2023 14:25

I don't get anything, he thinks that is why i receive UC and CB. I pay all costs for them, all clothes (some cheap bits bought for his house by him or Christmas presents). He has them 5 nights over 14 but pays nothing for school, sports, or anything else.
When the youngest started secondary, I went uniform shopping, he had to take me as I wasn't able to drive. £190 in the uniform shop and not even a 'do you want anything towards it'
I looked at CMS, in theory he should pay £340 a month 🤣
That would make my life a lot easier!

Have you applied through the CMS?

BertyMyrtle · 23/04/2023 21:47

I get £180 a month for two children. Ex has them 4 days a month and gets to do all the exciting things with them that I can’t afford then - takeaways, meals out, cinema, theme parks. He earns £46k a year and has been on holiday to Mauritius in the past year, Amsterdam and Italy, with his new girlfriend, lucky him…..

Swipe left for the next trending thread