Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if literally anyone feels they are paid adequate child maintenance? I'm feeling desperate

282 replies

hadenlugff · 21/04/2023 15:39

Just that really. I’m paid 570 but it won’t even cover half of the nursery fees let alone wrap around care and everything else.

Not only that but it’s not even guaranteed so I can’t rely on it… and that’s fucking awful as I should be able to have some
assurance that I won’t be left entirely to raise a child that is half someone else’s.

I know people have it worse, it’s not a race to then bottom. I’m just dreading dc starting nursery in autumn and dont know how I will manage. Is anyone happy with what they get for maintenance? Ever? It feels so shit.

OP posts:
taxpayer1 · 25/04/2023 21:13

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/04/2023 16:10

@taxpayer1 nowhere have I or any of the other single mothers on here said we are perfect. However, facts are facts. We are doing the day in day out care for our children, which we assumed we'd be sharing with the fathers as we did not have a random shag with a stranger. We are also shouldering the vast majority of the cost, while taking a massive hit to our own long term careers and futures. Our exes are paying either diddly or the legal minimum and doing fuck all meaningful parenting. Certainly in my case, my ex chose to leave, move away and move in with his affair partner. He reduced his income. I would very happily hand him 50/50 but he doesn't want it. Please tell me WHY you think, given those objective facts, that I shouldn't feel that I am morally in the right and he's not.

And I quote "
IAmCinderella · Yesterday 16:36
And to top it all off put up with this endless crap vilifying single mothers.

We are the heroins, the responsible ones, the superhuman ones doing the job of two people. Society should put us up on a pedestal not constantly attack us and direct all of this spite at us."

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 19:09

Tes exactly. The point I made was about substance, that your comments and those like them are setting the bar for what is acceptable parenting much too low.

I also had an entire post where I stated clearly that obviously if parents are both providing a separate home, 50% of childcare, children living in each one 50% of the time so both parents doing 50% of actual parenting and by definition paying half of the costs because they look after and house the child(ren) for half of the time them that is different and no transfers of money either way should be necessary. I was explicit that my comments related to largely or completely absent parents who do little or no parenting so expect the resident parent to do most/ all parenting AND then are so useless and pathetic and irresponsible they can't or won't even pay 50% of their child(ren)'s living costs.

All of this I stated clearly if you had bothered to read it. None of it was a personal attack, i just disagreed with you.

You then started posting rude and personal comments and disparaging comments to me personally and about other women in general.

It's really tiresome. It would probably be best if you stop and have a rethink.

Flowersun6 · 25/04/2023 17:34

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 17:40

I don't see any logic in setting the bar so high. People can't pay what they don't have if someone paid £350 and that was all they could afford I'd accept that it is unfair you are absolutely right. You can't get blood out of a stone though.

All they could afford based on what? Like with tax, the provision of 50% of your child's living costs should not be optional. Your disposable income to fund the rest of your life is what is left AFTER you've done that. If that makes you not have a very nice lifestyle, tough. Why should a single parent who is doing all of the work of actually raising the children have to do that and also pay the other parent's share of costs? Don't like the idea of paying your half of your child's upbringing? Then don't have children.

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough, that's what they need to do. They can do a part time degree or retrain to earn more. They have plenty of time on their hands, unlike the parent doing the parenting. Perhaps they should focus on earning more rather than starting new relationships and having yet more children. The idea that they should be able to say "oh, I'd be a bit poor if I paid my share so it's fine for me not to", and that society thinks this is acceptable is vile and needs to change.

The issue isn't setting the bar too high. It's that people like you set it far, far too low.

These were your words. People like me have a bar too low and hoe I am the issue. That is not disagreeing you were being insulting at best.

Your opinion doesn't trump others, I too have you a different angle to look from. You even suggested that a father should house share and another posted stated this isn't a reasonable solution. As I've said it's not just about money it's about EFFORT too.

I'm not sure why you can't see YOU were the offensive person first now your up in arms because I gave you the same tone you spoke to me I'm. Perhaps one should reflect on one self.....

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 17:09

Whiskeypowers · 25/04/2023 16:26

This debate is only raging because there are a critical mass of men who are abject failures as fathers and also the for the most part the CMS is a joke. absent feckless fathers or men who can’t see their children and don’t want to pay absolutely should pay the price in every sense. Their behaviour should be treated as criminal because for the most part it is. It would serve them right to be prosecuted and face the consequences in terms of their jobs and lifestyle etc. Society should condemn fathers that damage their children. The legacy of their behaviour is colossal.

Funny though that there are always a few morons who try and divert responsibility to the mothers left to do it all alone.

I’m just hoping not many of you ranting about poor choices / should have picked a better man etc are single mothers. These men are laughing at you even more than the women on the receiving end of their appalling behaviour in the first place.

Absolutely agree.

And sadly some of these claim they are single mothers. 🙄

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 17:07

You started insulting me first. I gave it back. Why were you insulting me first? You started getting personal to me first!

This is not true. I engaged with your argument and said I disagree. I think the closest I came to any type of "insult" was to say that what you were suggesting was reasonable (that if a man shrugs his shoulders and says it "doesn't work for him" or "isn't realistic" for him to pay 50% of his child's living costs then that's not good enough and that anybody who thinks that's ok - including you, if you do - is setting the bar of minimum acceptable requirements for parents far too low. This is not a personal insult, it was me disagreeing with your argument.

You then proceeded to make personal attacks about how I should have chosen a better man to be my children's father - i.e. victim blaming and shaming me and other women for situations you know nothing about - and how I shouldn't have "had multiple children" and with him - again victim blaming women although irrelevant in any case as I told you, given I have two only and they are twins and the abuse began afterwards.

I think any woman attacking other women personally in this way simply because they didn't like someone challenging their view should be ashamed. Disagreeing with an opinion is not the same as making personal insults or shaming other mothers in general with disparaging comments implying they are responsible for the behaviour of bad fathers. "You started it" just sums it up: you don't like someone challenging your view, robustly but respectfully, and think this justifies you resorting to personal insults. It doesn't. It's childish behaviour,

I don't need you to point out anything not do I expect you to agree with me you have utter cheek playing victim because I told you straight after you rudely started making DIGS, personal digs at me.

Play victim? What? People are allowed to speak about their experiences. Why are you trying to shut other women down?

You are the person who has been making personal comments and judging people whose lives you know nothing about, not me.

Whiskeypowers · 25/04/2023 16:26

This debate is only raging because there are a critical mass of men who are abject failures as fathers and also the for the most part the CMS is a joke. absent feckless fathers or men who can’t see their children and don’t want to pay absolutely should pay the price in every sense. Their behaviour should be treated as criminal because for the most part it is. It would serve them right to be prosecuted and face the consequences in terms of their jobs and lifestyle etc. Society should condemn fathers that damage their children. The legacy of their behaviour is colossal.

Funny though that there are always a few morons who try and divert responsibility to the mothers left to do it all alone.

I’m just hoping not many of you ranting about poor choices / should have picked a better man etc are single mothers. These men are laughing at you even more than the women on the receiving end of their appalling behaviour in the first place.

Flowersun6 · 25/04/2023 16:14

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 15:46

YOU started it. Don't dish what you can't give.

How old are you?

This is a discussion.

People may disagree with you and point out flaws in your reasoning. That does not mean it's ok for you to start making personal comments about the lives specific posters who you know nothing about. Why do you have to insult people who don't agree with you? How childish.

You started insulting me first. I gave it back. Why were you insulting me first? You started getting personal to me first!

I don't need you to point out anything not do I expect you to agree with me you have utter cheek playing victim because I told you straight after you rudely started making DIGS, personal digs at me.

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/04/2023 16:10

@taxpayer1 nowhere have I or any of the other single mothers on here said we are perfect. However, facts are facts. We are doing the day in day out care for our children, which we assumed we'd be sharing with the fathers as we did not have a random shag with a stranger. We are also shouldering the vast majority of the cost, while taking a massive hit to our own long term careers and futures. Our exes are paying either diddly or the legal minimum and doing fuck all meaningful parenting. Certainly in my case, my ex chose to leave, move away and move in with his affair partner. He reduced his income. I would very happily hand him 50/50 but he doesn't want it. Please tell me WHY you think, given those objective facts, that I shouldn't feel that I am morally in the right and he's not.

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 15:46

YOU started it. Don't dish what you can't give.

How old are you?

This is a discussion.

People may disagree with you and point out flaws in your reasoning. That does not mean it's ok for you to start making personal comments about the lives specific posters who you know nothing about. Why do you have to insult people who don't agree with you? How childish.

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 15:43

OK what? I only put that commennt because you started giving me attitude saying the problem was me and how it's because my bar is low.

So now other posters aren't just responsible for useless men's behaviour but also responsible for yours? 😆 Woe betide anybody disagree with you because apparently that justifies you being rude and making personal comments?

Nobody forced you to write misogynistic comments just because you didn't agree with my opinion that you were wrong to assert that if an absent parent finds it difficult to meet half of the cost of raising their child that is their problem to solve and that setting the payment threshold at the level they feel they can pay comfortably with no detrimental impact on their life" is too low, given the resident parent has no such option. That is, objectively and based on systems in comparable countries, an extremely low bar.

Me having pointed that out doesn't entitle you to heap vitriol on me and other mothers and imply that we are to blame for the behaviour of the men who walked out on their children and do not do their share of parenting, practically or financially. And then pretend huge levels of offence and assert that someone disagreeing with you justifies personal attacks on other mothers?

One has nothing to do with the other. Totally irrational. 🙄

HelpIcantfindaname · 25/04/2023 15:10

£20 a week for one child. When he left I couldn't afford childcare so had to move her to the school I taught in. He doesn't pay anything extra. He doesn't give her much for birthdays or Xmas. He hasn't made her room at his nice...6 years till he even put curtains up, & she still doesn't have a proper quilt. She very very rarely stays at his now. (Her choice, she's 14). He doesn't earn a lot but DD is way down his list of priorities, even though she's his only child.
My first H paid nothing for our 3, in fact he didn't get a legitimate job till the youngest was 18. He always had cash in hand jobs so he didn't have to pay.
So at least I get something for DD.

NCforthis123456 · 25/04/2023 15:02

I was paid £720 for our one DD4.. after a few months he claimed he moved in with his new partner who has 2 children so this reduced to £350... then after that he went self employed and now I received the princely sum of £51 a week..

He earns in excess of £75,000

It's a joke - but I have just learnt to try not to be dependent on that money and include it in my overall finances.

I hope he's proud of the wonderful father that he is to our daughter...

Flowersun6 · 25/04/2023 14:59

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 09:01

Really? When you're telling people they should have chosen a better father and making out that it's women's fault for not predicting that men would become abusive? Ok then.

YOU started it. Don't dish what you can't give.

I was telling you in return for your comment to me. Let's be clear, I repeat I said that yo you not others on the thread.

Flowersun6 · 25/04/2023 14:58

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 09:01

Really? When you're telling people they should have chosen a better father and making out that it's women's fault for not predicting that men would become abusive? Ok then.

OK what? I only put that commennt because you started giving me attitude saying the problem was me and how it's because my bar is low.

FFS reas your OWN comments.

Flowersun6 · 25/04/2023 14:51

popsypretty · 25/04/2023 09:25

@Flowersun6 the 20% was off his wages at the time we split, I used his payslip to work it out. He rounded it up a little to £250 and it's stayed at that for the last 5 years.

Go through CMS.

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 14:47

The lack of self-awareness and entitlement is mind-blowing

Indeed.

Clearly some people haven't even become sufficiently capable adults to manage to purchase a mirror.

Shanksponyorbust · 25/04/2023 14:39

£330 month for two. Been that level for about 8 years as ex moved abroad so solicitor got a court order as can’t use cms. Ex is too tight to put it up. £165 per month per child does not go far and I’m struggling.

taxpayer1 · 25/04/2023 14:36

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/04/2023 17:04

@taxpayer1 you really are deeply unpleasant aren't you? Which part of @IAmCinderella's post do you have a problem with? Could you explain why you think men SHOULD be allowed to do what her and mine and so many others have done? Even if we were all awful bitches, that still wouldn't excuse them abandoning their kids, to all intents and purposes. Or would it? In your view?

I find it amusing that all posters in here are perfect human beings, martyrs, heroines, and selfless and the ex is misogynistic, narcissistic, controlling, blah blah, blah. But the truth is always somewhere in the middle. The lack of self-awareness and entitlement is mind-blowing. Very few people (men or women) are as perfect as the posters in here pretend to be.

taxpayer1 · 25/04/2023 14:29

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/04/2023 06:34

@taxpayer1 whilst part of me wants to just ignore you, I'd like to ask how you'd respond to the posters on here who "got pregnant" to their husbands of some years, on good, sometimes 6 figure salaries but who have still been left to deal with things largely alone because our system does not enforce that father adequately provides for the child that is biologically 50% his. These women weren't reckless,or hasty or making poor choices. There was nothing to indicate when I had mine that ex would fuck off with ow. But he did. Why shouldn't he be equally responsible?

I never said that a father should not pay. I was replying to a hilarious comment that I was an idiot done by some man-hater MN poster. I was just highlighting the fact that I didn't choose to get pregnant from a minimum-wage man and then complain that the CMS is too low. A person on minimum wage can hardly cover his/her basic needs so it was always the case that the maintenance would be low in case of a split.

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 10:37

@MillicentTrilbyHiggins your comment was spot on and shouldn't have been deleted.

thethreemuskateers · 25/04/2023 10:22

My ex was due to pay his 100 maintenance for our 2 boys on Saturday still no sign of it.

Although I’m annoyed there’s no way I’m going to lower myself to ask him to transfer the paltry sum!

popsypretty · 25/04/2023 09:25

@Flowersun6 the 20% was off his wages at the time we split, I used his payslip to work it out. He rounded it up a little to £250 and it's stayed at that for the last 5 years.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 25/04/2023 09:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

yoga4meinthemorning · 25/04/2023 09:02

I never had a penny in all the years. Even though ex is wealthy businessman.

I got tax credits to pay for nursery.

IAmCinderella · 25/04/2023 09:01

Flowersun6 · 24/04/2023 19:31

I was talking about @IAmCinderella to be bloody Frank. What utter cheek.

Really? When you're telling people they should have chosen a better father and making out that it's women's fault for not predicting that men would become abusive? Ok then.