Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if literally anyone feels they are paid adequate child maintenance? I'm feeling desperate

282 replies

hadenlugff · 21/04/2023 15:39

Just that really. I’m paid 570 but it won’t even cover half of the nursery fees let alone wrap around care and everything else.

Not only that but it’s not even guaranteed so I can’t rely on it… and that’s fucking awful as I should be able to have some
assurance that I won’t be left entirely to raise a child that is half someone else’s.

I know people have it worse, it’s not a race to then bottom. I’m just dreading dc starting nursery in autumn and dont know how I will manage. Is anyone happy with what they get for maintenance? Ever? It feels so shit.

OP posts:
IAmCinderella · 28/04/2023 00:37

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 20:31

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough

@IAmCinderella and how is a father, in a room in a HMO, supposed to have any sort of overnight stays from his children? You’d then be complaining he wasn’t doing his fair share of parenting.

Did you actually read the posts? I soecifically stated - and then reiterated when another poster had done the same as you and not read it properly - that this comment was regarding fathers who have little or no contact with their children at all, and yet expect the mother to do most/ all parenting AND the father not even pay his 50% of the costs. And also specifically said that clearly if the father is actually housing the child 50% of the time, doing 50% of the parenting, and therefore by definition covering 50% of the costs of raising them then that is entirely different and clearly in those circumstances no maintenance should need to be paid at all, and indeed is not legally required to be.

IAmCinderella · 28/04/2023 00:33

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 19:26

When DH was with his first wife, he worked long hours, earned good money,and was classed as a good provider and a good father, and enabled his wife to be a SAHM.

Once they were divorced, he obviously had to re-house himself, he had an access rota that meant he could work fewer hours, therefore earning less, and yet his ex expected top dollar maintenance payments plus a good chunk of her housing costs paid too - and there simply wasn’t enough money to go round. His reduced earnings now had to pay for 1.5 households plus maintenance and it was mathematically impossible. He therefore lost his ‘good father’ badge. I still don’t know what he could have done differently

Diddums.

How does he think that lone single mothers somehow manage to maintain high earning careers then, if apparently this was beyond him if he had to look after his own children just part of the time?

TUCKINGFYP0 · 28/04/2023 00:22

@BibbleandSqwauk

it's not misandry to point out the fact that there is millions in unpaid child support owed almost entirely by men. And you actually said you'd like to hear my exes side of the story, but now I've given you it and there's not much wriggle room for him coming out if it well, you're not interested

Indeed. I believe it’s about About half a billion pounds ( £480 Million) owed through the CSA in direct pay and collect and pay. And no doubt even more owed to mothers who have never gone through the CMS as they used a family based arrangement.

And that’s not counting the fathers who have falsely declared their income as they work cash in hand or while on benefits, or who funnel their income through their new partner or family members. Or who move abroad to avoid caring for their children.

That’s millions that that fathers have stolen from the mouths of their own children . It’s disgusting.

IAmCinderella · 27/04/2023 01:50

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 20:31

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough

@IAmCinderella and how is a father, in a room in a HMO, supposed to have any sort of overnight stays from his children? You’d then be complaining he wasn’t doing his fair share of parenting.

I did state that my respones about that were about fathers who do little or zero parentingso should - as a minimum - pay half of the child(ren)'s living costs, and that if for example a child lives 50/50 with both parents they would both be covering half of their living costs anyway so no transfers of money to cover the costs between parents would be required because those two situations are totally different. The person I was suggesting should live in an HMO is a parent who is doing little parenting at all, AND thinks it's ol for the other parent to do most/ all parenting and pay all costs because they wouldn't be able to live the lifestyle they'd like if they even paid their half of costs (with the other parent still paying their own half AND doing most parenting, too). Obviously that would be unacceptable to anybody with decent moral standards. But if someone's paying the proportionate 50% share of living costs for the time that the parent with main residency has the children, it's fine. Not a complicated equation: living costs x % of time the kids live with you = what you should be paying to/ receiving from the main resident parent.

IAmCinderella · 27/04/2023 01:41

Seas164 · 26/04/2023 19:36

I care about exposing the soap opera of most single women

@taxpayer1 What an odd little mission

Indeed.

I have to say that one gets the impression that "@taxpayer1 " probably doesn't pay very much tax given that most people who do, do not tend to have such thought patterns and are generally a little more intelligent and nuanced in their responses.

AnonymousA1 · 26/04/2023 22:15

I’m paid 120 a month. My son literally eats that in a week 😂

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/04/2023 22:13

@katiejames2015 well we'll never know will we, seeing as so many dads have no intention of stepping up. As I've stated repeatedly, I'd love to do 50/50 but ex isn't interested. And if for some reason my kids went to live with him and I was free to work much longer hours or seek promotion I would. @taxpayer1 it's not misandry to point out the fact that there is millions in unpaid child support owed almost entirely by men. And you actually said you'd like to hear my exes side of the story, but now I've given you it and there's not much wriggle room for him coming out if it well, you're not interested. You really can't seem to bear the idea that many many single mothers are a) bearing the burden b) decent earners c) not fitting your stereotype. It's not "martyrish" to lay out the facts of an extremely unequal situation.

Seas164 · 26/04/2023 22:12

katiejames2015 · 26/04/2023 19:55

I wonder how many of these mums would like it if it was the other way round , and the dad actually was the primary caregiver. Would the mothers then be told to retrain or get a better job to pay half the cost for housing plus other expenses for their child plus paying for their own house.

I think the point is that if the care is shared, 50/50, there need not be any exchange of money as the situation is equal and allows each parent to earn and care for the children equally.

When this is not the case, then maintenence should be paid to compensate the primary caregiver who is doing the lions share of the parenting and help them care for the children.

It's such a weird notion that single mums are moneygrabbers and gold diggers, there's a really easy way out of handing over a penny with a clear conscience and it's just pitching in equally with the care of your children.

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 20:31

If paying what they should means they can only afford to rent a room in an HMO then tough

@IAmCinderella and how is a father, in a room in a HMO, supposed to have any sort of overnight stays from his children? You’d then be complaining he wasn’t doing his fair share of parenting.

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 19:58

katiejames2015 · 26/04/2023 19:55

I wonder how many of these mums would like it if it was the other way round , and the dad actually was the primary caregiver. Would the mothers then be told to retrain or get a better job to pay half the cost for housing plus other expenses for their child plus paying for their own house.

Very good point!

katiejames2015 · 26/04/2023 19:55

I wonder how many of these mums would like it if it was the other way round , and the dad actually was the primary caregiver. Would the mothers then be told to retrain or get a better job to pay half the cost for housing plus other expenses for their child plus paying for their own house.

Seas164 · 26/04/2023 19:36

I care about exposing the soap opera of most single women

@taxpayer1 What an odd little mission

MeetMyCat · 26/04/2023 19:26

When DH was with his first wife, he worked long hours, earned good money,and was classed as a good provider and a good father, and enabled his wife to be a SAHM.

Once they were divorced, he obviously had to re-house himself, he had an access rota that meant he could work fewer hours, therefore earning less, and yet his ex expected top dollar maintenance payments plus a good chunk of her housing costs paid too - and there simply wasn’t enough money to go round. His reduced earnings now had to pay for 1.5 households plus maintenance and it was mathematically impossible. He therefore lost his ‘good father’ badge. I still don’t know what he could have done differently

IAmCinderella · 26/04/2023 18:12

Everyone I know (all 1% top earners) has a horror story with a career single mom and I am entitled to share my experience without being called an idiot by the misandrist crowd.

Give it a rest. It would be a very strange and boring life if "everyone you know" is the top 1% of earners. You have no friends or family members who aren't? Not sure why you find single mothers being in the top 1% of earners a "horror story" but I know lots who are just like I am so I can't imagine that you know many people in this salary bracket if you know none. It's not misandrist to suggest men should pay half of the cost of raising their children. It appears to be rather more likely that you have misogynist views and likely know few high achieving professional people (including women) at all, and think that you can look down on single mothers, make ridiculous generalisations about them, and also judge anybody who does happen to earn less than you as not worthy of respect. None of that reflects very well on you.

taxpayer1 · 26/04/2023 17:58

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/04/2023 17:38

@taxpayer1 well sadly I'm not going to ask him to comment but I gave you a summary of the objective facts upthread. We married, planned children together, earned equally until mat leave and then I went part time (he later also did and we shared care). We shared our lives, made decisions together until, with my encouragement he started a hobby, met someone and whoooosh....out the door. If you asked him he'd say he'd been miserable for ages, had never wanted any of it, was manipulated and pushed into it. Funny, I don't remember having a gun to his head when he proposed, or signed house contracts or had unprotected sex. If you've heard of "the cheaters script" , his "side" is basically that. After he split he moved a distance and established Eow only contact which has since dwindled further. How many more ways are you going to desperately try and find fault with me? Why does it matter so much to you that I must not be in the right here?

I couldn't care less about your particular situation. I care about exposing the soap opera of most single women (aka martyrs, heroines, blah, blah working) on this site. Everyone I know (all 1% top earners) has a horror story with a career single mom and I am entitled to share my experience without being called an idiot by the misandrist crowd.

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/04/2023 17:38

@taxpayer1 well sadly I'm not going to ask him to comment but I gave you a summary of the objective facts upthread. We married, planned children together, earned equally until mat leave and then I went part time (he later also did and we shared care). We shared our lives, made decisions together until, with my encouragement he started a hobby, met someone and whoooosh....out the door. If you asked him he'd say he'd been miserable for ages, had never wanted any of it, was manipulated and pushed into it. Funny, I don't remember having a gun to his head when he proposed, or signed house contracts or had unprotected sex. If you've heard of "the cheaters script" , his "side" is basically that. After he split he moved a distance and established Eow only contact which has since dwindled further. How many more ways are you going to desperately try and find fault with me? Why does it matter so much to you that I must not be in the right here?

familyissues12345 · 26/04/2023 17:34

I got £25 a week and not a penny more - no contribution towards clothing, school trips etc. Never took DS shopping for clothes himself. It took until DS was about 9/10 to start paying properly and even then would often miss weeks without so much as a sorry.
He ended paying last summer as DS finished A Levels. Said he'd continue the £25 a week to help with Uni accommodation and I've had one payment. I wouldn't mind so much, but I asked if he intended on helping at all, as we were working out budgeting for accommodation (I know he doesn't have to legally pay) and he said absolutely. So we've been left footing the full cost - we would have chosen a cheaper room if he'd said no.

He doesn't even visit DS, or offer to pick him up. So DS has to pay for fuel from his student finance to see him. He stopped doing any travel as soon as DS learnt (he lives 2 hours away!) suffice to say he doesn't see much of him.

I think he has always really begrudged paying anything towards DS. We live a comfortable life and I think he's always looked at us and thought we didn't need his money so why should he pay. Any money I did get went into a separate account and was saved towards whatever DS needed, never went anywhere near our bills etc

cool4cats2020 · 26/04/2023 17:24

My ex pays zero (always has), and I end up 'lending' them money reguarly so our 3 kids get fed during their contact (every other weekend). So I guess that's effectively negative maintainence! Ex choses not to work or only works cash in hand jobs (probably in order to avoid maintenance), so officially ex has zero income, just universal credits.

On that basis, I'd say £570 a month for what sounds like one child is a decent amount, unless your ex is a very high earner?

IAmCinderella · 26/04/2023 17:24

I don't hate anyone. You paying tax 🙄

Excuse me? I earn six figures. I pay plenty of tax. As do many other single parents. Quite clearly you are clueless.

Whochangedmynamec · 26/04/2023 17:23

Only ever got half what I should have got, he agreed to take the kids eow but never did so I should have got more really. Trying to get more causes ww3 and hurts the kids. I often wonder if anyone thinks these men are stealing off us because we have to pay or go into debt while they do OK. But what can you do?

taxpayer1 · 26/04/2023 17:11

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/04/2023 14:54

Still waiting for @taxpayer1 to come and explain why exactly we SHOULDN'T be damn proud of what we do and seek to have it both acknowledged and respected. My ex hasn't taken the kids to school for 8 years. Our youngest has never, in her life, had the experience of both parents there at the gate, or a play or her dad taking her in, and never will. His phone contact is increasingly sporadic and he knows nothing of their daily lives in terms of what they do on a given day, what they are into. He always asks me for ideas for xmas and birthdays - as do his family. He doesn't know his own kids well enough to have ideas himself and he still talks to them as though they are the ages they are when he left. When they do come back from visits there are numerous complaints about how he doesn't listen to them, doesn't respect their choices or tastes with regard to food or outings, just expects them to do what he says. He is totally out of touch with them. But yeah, he's really hard done by losing that 20% of income every month 🙄

I would like to hear the other side of the story. Your opinion about your heroic behavior may be skewed.

taxpayer1 · 26/04/2023 17:10

IAmCinderella · 26/04/2023 13:07

It is heroic to provide for, look after and raise children singlehandedly. That in no way equates to "perfect". It also in no way is a reason to criticise someone, that they're managing alone to do the work that is usually done by two people. Quite the opposite. Hence people being confused about your desire to attack such people and make nasty and baseless insinutations about them and random unfounded conjectures about their lives. Why exactly do you hate single mothers so much @taxpayer1 ? You appear on all such threads and spout such bile, you clearly seek them out. Ironically many of us probably pay significantly more tax than you do.

I don't hate anyone. You paying tax 🙄

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/04/2023 14:54

Still waiting for @taxpayer1 to come and explain why exactly we SHOULDN'T be damn proud of what we do and seek to have it both acknowledged and respected. My ex hasn't taken the kids to school for 8 years. Our youngest has never, in her life, had the experience of both parents there at the gate, or a play or her dad taking her in, and never will. His phone contact is increasingly sporadic and he knows nothing of their daily lives in terms of what they do on a given day, what they are into. He always asks me for ideas for xmas and birthdays - as do his family. He doesn't know his own kids well enough to have ideas himself and he still talks to them as though they are the ages they are when he left. When they do come back from visits there are numerous complaints about how he doesn't listen to them, doesn't respect their choices or tastes with regard to food or outings, just expects them to do what he says. He is totally out of touch with them. But yeah, he's really hard done by losing that 20% of income every month 🙄

IAmCinderella · 26/04/2023 13:07

It is heroic to provide for, look after and raise children singlehandedly. That in no way equates to "perfect". It also in no way is a reason to criticise someone, that they're managing alone to do the work that is usually done by two people. Quite the opposite. Hence people being confused about your desire to attack such people and make nasty and baseless insinutations about them and random unfounded conjectures about their lives. Why exactly do you hate single mothers so much @taxpayer1 ? You appear on all such threads and spout such bile, you clearly seek them out. Ironically many of us probably pay significantly more tax than you do.

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/04/2023 22:29

She said we are superheroes and heroines, not perfect. And she's not me so you haven't answered my question. Please do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread