Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if literally anyone feels they are paid adequate child maintenance? I'm feeling desperate

282 replies

hadenlugff · 21/04/2023 15:39

Just that really. I’m paid 570 but it won’t even cover half of the nursery fees let alone wrap around care and everything else.

Not only that but it’s not even guaranteed so I can’t rely on it… and that’s fucking awful as I should be able to have some
assurance that I won’t be left entirely to raise a child that is half someone else’s.

I know people have it worse, it’s not a race to then bottom. I’m just dreading dc starting nursery in autumn and dont know how I will manage. Is anyone happy with what they get for maintenance? Ever? It feels so shit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TUCKINGFYP0 · 30/04/2023 08:41

Beezknees · 29/04/2023 12:20

Anyone who has a username of "taxpayer" is a twat. I'm a tax payer, I don't feel the need to remind people every 5 minutes.

Yeah it’s the same as posters announcing “ man here “. They obviously expect some special treatment or status, as if their opinions should be given more weight because they are Special.

Im pretty sure I pay a lot more tax that a certain poster on this thread. But that’s not relevant because child maintenance isn’t about how much the RP earns. It’s about how much taxable income the NRP has , how many children they have and how many nights they have them.

It’s about them ( nearly always men ) making a financial contribution to the costs of raising their own child. The child they chose to make .

Beezknees · 29/04/2023 12:20

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 09:59

I would be interested to know just how much tax @taxpayer1 actually pays, given their claims that single mothers are all claiming benefits that they are allegedly paying for. Hmm I have significant doubts that they are even a net contributer to the tax system based on the implausibility of some of their claims on this and other threads.

Anyone who has a username of "taxpayer" is a twat. I'm a tax payer, I don't feel the need to remind people every 5 minutes.

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 10:00

BibbleandSqwauk · 29/04/2023 07:23

@MeetMyCat I absolute loathe that phrase "you sound bitter". It's gaslighting someone into feeling that they are unjustified in feeling anger over an ongoing situation. This is something I tried to explain to my ex. I am not "bitter" that he upped and left years ago. I am angry (at a rational and not emotionally raging level) with the fact that every single day, every single thing is down to me. I've lost count of the plates I spin on a daily basis trying to keep kids, work, home, me all where they should be. That's not in the past. That's today, tomorrow, everyday for the next decade probably. It's a situation absolute not of my own making and not one I can realistically change since you cannot force an unwilling person parent.

Indeed.

It is an insult, like "bossy", usually levelled exclusively at women who dare to assert themselves, particularly if they are objecting to misogyny.

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 09:59

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/04/2023 21:45

Oh are you back @taxpayer1 ? Care to scroll back and respond to my last post from a couple of days ago? Or do the facts of my experience spoil your fantasy narrative?

I would be interested to know just how much tax @taxpayer1 actually pays, given their claims that single mothers are all claiming benefits that they are allegedly paying for. Hmm I have significant doubts that they are even a net contributer to the tax system based on the implausibility of some of their claims on this and other threads.

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 09:57

In extended use: sufferings and penalties involved in maintaining a particular (usually moral or ethical) position or point of view. In later use frequently: exaggerated self-sacrifice.

You mean like the poor little menz who are being persecuted by evil women, telling you their "horror stories" as you put it, about the mothers of their children expecting them to pay towards the costs of housing and feeding their children? Poor, misunderstood little things, hounded to pay a pittance towards raising their children.

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 09:53

Don't tell me. Did you sacrifice an outstanding career at minimum wage to take care of your children and want to be supported for life like you had any future?

Why do you keep repeating this nonsense? Many single mothers earn more than their ex-husbands, and probably a lot more than you do.

IAmCinderella · 29/04/2023 09:52

Bullying tactics of men haters.

Delusional. It's not "hatred" to state that men should be responsible for 50% of the cost of raising children they created.

You sound as unhinged as the man who reported Ms Creasy to social services for "persecuting men" because she objected to VAWG.

BibbleandSqwauk · 29/04/2023 07:23

@MeetMyCat I absolute loathe that phrase "you sound bitter". It's gaslighting someone into feeling that they are unjustified in feeling anger over an ongoing situation. This is something I tried to explain to my ex. I am not "bitter" that he upped and left years ago. I am angry (at a rational and not emotionally raging level) with the fact that every single day, every single thing is down to me. I've lost count of the plates I spin on a daily basis trying to keep kids, work, home, me all where they should be. That's not in the past. That's today, tomorrow, everyday for the next decade probably. It's a situation absolute not of my own making and not one I can realistically change since you cannot force an unwilling person parent.

OhamIreally · 29/04/2023 07:01

The sufferings and penalties borne by single mothers is not to maintain a moral or ethical point of view, but to maintain a child. A child they are only 50% responsible for creating.

It's not exaggerated self sacrifice, it's a genuine hard, relentless self sacrifice, and the women here are saying they wouldn't be required to make such a huge sacrifice if the children's fathers would step up and do 50%.

This is the absolute opposite of martyrdom - we are being forced into this position and we'd rather not be thank you very much.

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/04/2023 21:45

Oh are you back @taxpayer1 ? Care to scroll back and respond to my last post from a couple of days ago? Or do the facts of my experience spoil your fantasy narrative?

Barbecuebeans · 28/04/2023 21:27

OnlyFannys · 21/04/2023 15:56

I'm paid exactly £0 by self employed ex

Does that mean he fiddles his tax as well? Or do they not check between CMS and tax returns?

CarrotCake01 · 28/04/2023 21:25

I get less than £200 a month in maintenance and that's the highest its ever been from the father of my DD.
He has never had her overnight and pays no additional costs for extra curricular activities, school uniform, school photos, childcare etc

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 21:09

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 20:58

You confused me with your ignorant comment about martyrdom. I assumed you never used a dictionary before. I will help you this time. Please check the Oxford dictionary before correcting someone next time. It's free!

From the OED:

In extended use: sufferings and penalties involved in maintaining a particular (usually moral or ethical) position or point of view. In later use frequently: exaggerated self-sacrifice.

Like I said “sacrifice”

why don’t you go and find some like minded losers on fathers for justice you’re wasting your time with me. Compared to my ex trust me you are like Tom from the Good Life.

all the best 😊

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 20:58

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 20:17

no I didn’t. To give you an idea almost six years after I became a single parent I have no mortgage and the maintenance their father has ripped from his pay every month by the normally useless CMS (so he just have been really shocking) after his appalling conduct is spent on things they’d like but don’t need and put to one side for their futures because he will stop contributing the second he can the sad sack. He’d rather have cancer than see
that I have more money coming in that an him every month. I’ll leave you to work out I’m not on a minimum wage job 😂

you clearly feel like you’ve been shafted through which makes me smile and I suspect you deserve it

have a nice evening. I am.

You confused me with your ignorant comment about martyrdom. I assumed you never used a dictionary before. I will help you this time. Please check the Oxford dictionary before correcting someone next time. It's free!

From the OED:

In extended use: sufferings and penalties involved in maintaining a particular (usually moral or ethical) position or point of view. In later use frequently: exaggerated self-sacrifice.

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 20:17

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 20:06

Don't tell me. Did you sacrifice an outstanding career at minimum wage to take care of your children and want to be supported for life like you had any future?

no I didn’t. To give you an idea almost six years after I became a single parent I have no mortgage and the maintenance their father has ripped from his pay every month by the normally useless CMS (so he just have been really shocking) after his appalling conduct is spent on things they’d like but don’t need and put to one side for their futures because he will stop contributing the second he can the sad sack. He’d rather have cancer than see
that I have more money coming in that an him every month. I’ll leave you to work out I’m not on a minimum wage job 😂

you clearly feel like you’ve been shafted through which makes me smile and I suspect you deserve it

have a nice evening. I am.

curious79 · 28/04/2023 20:11

My ex used money as a weapon. He was meant to give me something like £800. I think I received it for 3-4 months then he stopped and played silly buggers. I was happy with that amount given I was working myself too.
I wish I had taken him to court sooner. I did eventually after 4 yrs. Originally I felt I couldn't afford to litigate but it literally costs £200 for the application and if you work out how to self-apply, and then act as a litigant in person the courts HATE HATE HATE exes who fail to pay maintenance. They will automatically bash them. You'll get it all back as long as the ex is working and hasn't had some kind of mental breakdown like my ex

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 20:06

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 18:52

You have more chips on your shoulder than a McCain factory whereas mine and others viewpoints of a similar nature are borne out by the CMS themselves in terms of outstanding monies written off

Furthermore you really ought to consult the dictionary since martyrdom involves death. Thanks fully for the millions of kids being single-handedly raised by single mothers we are still alive unlike these pathetic feckless failures of men who are fathers and parents in name only.

hope that helps with your ignorance misogyny but suspect that’s naively optimistic

Don't tell me. Did you sacrifice an outstanding career at minimum wage to take care of your children and want to be supported for life like you had any future?

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 20:04

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 18:52

You have more chips on your shoulder than a McCain factory whereas mine and others viewpoints of a similar nature are borne out by the CMS themselves in terms of outstanding monies written off

Furthermore you really ought to consult the dictionary since martyrdom involves death. Thanks fully for the millions of kids being single-handedly raised by single mothers we are still alive unlike these pathetic feckless failures of men who are fathers and parents in name only.

hope that helps with your ignorance misogyny but suspect that’s naively optimistic

Bullying tactics of men haters.

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 18:52

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 16:57

Here we go again, the martyrdom of single motherhood.

You have more chips on your shoulder than a McCain factory whereas mine and others viewpoints of a similar nature are borne out by the CMS themselves in terms of outstanding monies written off

Furthermore you really ought to consult the dictionary since martyrdom involves death. Thanks fully for the millions of kids being single-handedly raised by single mothers we are still alive unlike these pathetic feckless failures of men who are fathers and parents in name only.

hope that helps with your ignorance misogyny but suspect that’s naively optimistic

taxpayer1 · 28/04/2023 16:57

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 16:22

They are making a number of valid points but actually what is wrong with being bitter about all the legwork cost and general shit being left to you when you didn’t sign up for that

When you are doing everything, paying for everything and watching the other parent fail their child on every level it’s only natural to find some righteous indignation

hope it’s ok - in that spirit - to also find one or two of your posts jaundiced by a very subjective experience and not based on societal observation and actual facts regarding the monumental injustices faced by millions of single mothers at the hands of the CMS and these “fathers”

Here we go again, the martyrdom of single motherhood.

Whiskeypowers · 28/04/2023 16:22

MeetMyCat · 28/04/2023 15:50

@IAmCinderella you sound very bitter

They are making a number of valid points but actually what is wrong with being bitter about all the legwork cost and general shit being left to you when you didn’t sign up for that

When you are doing everything, paying for everything and watching the other parent fail their child on every level it’s only natural to find some righteous indignation

hope it’s ok - in that spirit - to also find one or two of your posts jaundiced by a very subjective experience and not based on societal observation and actual facts regarding the monumental injustices faced by millions of single mothers at the hands of the CMS and these “fathers”

MeetMyCat · 28/04/2023 15:50

@IAmCinderella you sound very bitter

Blueuggboots · 28/04/2023 01:42

My ex pays me £100 a month. I've asked for more in the past and he's refused. I'm not prepared to rock the boat. He doesn't see his son and hasn't had any contact for 9 years.

IAmCinderella · 28/04/2023 00:46

TUCKINGFYP0 · 28/04/2023 00:22

@BibbleandSqwauk

it's not misandry to point out the fact that there is millions in unpaid child support owed almost entirely by men. And you actually said you'd like to hear my exes side of the story, but now I've given you it and there's not much wriggle room for him coming out if it well, you're not interested

Indeed. I believe it’s about About half a billion pounds ( £480 Million) owed through the CSA in direct pay and collect and pay. And no doubt even more owed to mothers who have never gone through the CMS as they used a family based arrangement.

And that’s not counting the fathers who have falsely declared their income as they work cash in hand or while on benefits, or who funnel their income through their new partner or family members. Or who move abroad to avoid caring for their children.

That’s millions that that fathers have stolen from the mouths of their own children . It’s disgusting.

I believe that half a billion pounds is just what is "outstanding" currently: the CMS have "written off" billions of pounds more (without the consent of the parents to whom it is owed). There are no consequences for men behaving in this way. It should be treated like tax evasion. Criminal prosecution, imprisonment, social shaming, be fired from their jobs, passports confiscated, etc.

IAmCinderella · 28/04/2023 00:41

katiejames2015 · 26/04/2023 19:55

I wonder how many of these mums would like it if it was the other way round , and the dad actually was the primary caregiver. Would the mothers then be told to retrain or get a better job to pay half the cost for housing plus other expenses for their child plus paying for their own house.

Of course they should?! What a ridiculous question. The whole point is that each parent should pay 50% of the costs of raising their child.

However, how many mothers are you aware of that bugger off and do no parenting and pay a pathetic amount (or nothing) towards their children's upbringing? It doesn't appear to be common. The fact is that many single mothers do ALL of the parenting and pay ALL of the costs. And that there is no effective legal recourse to address these feckless fathers doing nothing for their children, and that society has no will to change that and - absurdly - seems to blame the mothers who are actually doing everything for the situation.