Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we try and encourage babies to be independent too soon?

313 replies

graciousgrace · 21/04/2023 14:52

I just don't understand the obsession with wanting babies to be so independent so early on? I go to quite a few baby groups, and am constantly hearing comments like...

"I don't spoon feed my baby, I've encouraged self feeding from day one."

"My baby sleeps through the night because I didn't respond to their cries when they woke up."

"I don't rock my baby to sleep because they need to learn to put themselves to sleep and self soothe."

"I don't co-sleep because my baby needs to be in their own room in their own cot."

And the most shocking one of all... a mum at a baby group I went to said that her 7 month old baby "will only do a poo on the toilet"! Literally couldn't make it up!

As a mum who happily spoon feeds, co-sleeps and rocks my baby to sleep, it is so annoying hearing these comments because it's like these mums think they're superior. What's wrong with me wanting to treat my baby like a, you know, baby? I mean, great for you if those things work for you, but us mums who do things differently shouldn't be made to feel inadequate or like we're doing things wrong. Babies are only babies for such a short amount of time, so why can't we embrace the time when they actually need us to do things for them? I doubt I'll have a 15 year who still wants to be spoon fed, rocked to sleep and sleep in my bed 😂 does anyone agree or am I just being too sensitive?

OP posts:
Fandabedodgy · 23/04/2023 10:20

You are being just as judgmental of others as you perceive them to be of you.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 10:18

@CatCake

For the millionth time, it's not about SIDs and it's not based on 1 piece of evidence. I've read loads in years of these debates, including the stats on so called safe bed sharing.

If you as a parent feel you have mitigated the risk of SIDs and suffocation and feel you can bed share safely, after proper research, then great. That is your risk assessment to make.

I dont agree you can because the research shows equavically that the safest place is in a cot.

But you can ignore me. I have no relevance to your decision.

I won't however change my opinion or shut up because you don't like it.

You sound like a child having a temper tantrum because you're not getting your own way

CatCake · 23/04/2023 10:11

@botw1 it's based on one finding, which is that the safest place for babies to sleep is in their bare cot. Nobody disagrees with you.

That doesn't make planned co-sleeping unsafe. There's research for that, too.

Stop saying it's unsafe. It isn't. Stop calling those who are defending their position to co-sleep deniers of risk. They're not. The risks of co-sleeping are out there for everyone to see and for everyone to mitigate.

You're ignoring the "actual evidence" posters are providing, which tell you the statistical likelihood of SIDs during SAFE co-sleeping.

Our choices are also based on "actual evidence."

Wanderingowl · 23/04/2023 10:08

00100001 · 22/04/2023 15:16

There's not a chance a 18mo th old was independently using the toilet all day on their own without being prompted/taken by adults and having no accidents.

Yes there is. It is the absolute norm in my family. My DS literally poo'd twice in a nappy after 6.5 months. They were both just before 9mo when we were visiting MIL who had just been given 4 months to live and clearly his response to the emotional state of the people around him. He came out of nappies completely by 15 months. As did I and my DBs. Babies will choose not to soil themselves if they know they don't have to.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 10:08

@CatCake

I havent judged anyone. I haven't said co sleeping is wrong.

I've said it's not safe. I've said that the safest place for a baby to sleep is its own bare cot. On it's back, feet to foot.

The only 'hysteria' I can see is from defensive co sleepers who absolutely do deny the increased risk.

As you rightly say, everis entitled to their own risk assessments and choice. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

At least mine is based on the actual evidence

Blossomtoes · 23/04/2023 10:06

Ottersmith · 23/04/2023 01:14

How do you know they were sleeping through? High chance they were waking up but staying quiet.

In which case they were fine. Distressed babies cry.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 10:02

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 08:11

@botw incorrect, they have changed how that is recorded now, they do have lower SIDS deaths.
And when you actually think sensibly about it, it would make sense right? We know that room sharing is a protective factor against SIDS, absolutely no-one is arguing that. So it's logical that the baby would need to be pretty close in the room to achieve that benefit because it's based on breath and heartbeat, so what they are really recommending is that your baby sleeps CLOSE to you.

So maybe a side crib or cot next to the bed supports that, fine, but actually that isn't often enough security for the baby, which is why many cry and scream every time they are put back, so this leads to women keep putting them back and picking them up and occasionally falling asleep with them unsafely in the bed. I believe 60% admit to co sleeping, even if unintentionally.
If a mattress is firm, with no loose bedding and you don't drink/smoke then you eliminate the other risks and you achieve the gain of being close.

My agenda is that many many women are being told that bed sharing increases SIDS and they are suffering as a result. In fact many babies are dying because mothers are so exhausted and they are trying to feed in chairs and sofas to wake themselves up and given misinformation by health workers. 40% of women admit to falling asleep accidentally at least once in a chair or sofa! They are also being encouraged to use techniques like CIO in order to get sleep because their baby doesn't want to be left in their cot, madness.

The fact is, cot sleeping is safe. If the baby is happy and settled and it's what the mother wants, fine! I totally support that, but so is bed sharing when done correctly and all the actual evidence points to that.

Your point about infant mortality is completely irrelevant. A baby has evolved to want to be close to its mother for survival, it has developed a system where feeling her breath INCREASES survival, how amazing when we actually think about it. What on earth has infant mortality being 'normal' got to do with it.

All 100% accurate from someone who has taken the time to read ALL the research and make their own, informed choice, not just the one bit of research that validates her decision.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 10:01

And @Botw1 - something that carries risk is unsafe? There's a risk your baby will choke when they eat - should they stop? There's a risk your child will get bitten by a dog at the park - should you not go? There are risks involved in almost everything we do. All any of us can do is make well-informed choices that work the best on balance for our families.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 09:59

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 21:21

@Porridgeislife

I'd say that something that carries risk is unsafe, yes.

@Peppadog

Planned co sleeping is less risky than unplanned for sure.

It's not safer than cot sleeping though

Absolutely people should make their own risk assessment based on the actual evidence

You cant do that if you won't acknowledge the risk or evidence at all

Oh for goodness' sake, PLANNED co-sleeping IS acknowledging the risks, because in planning for co-sleeping, rather than just bringing them in ad hoc, you are mitigating the risks.

This hysteria around co-sleeping is silly. Nobody's judging you for putting your baby in a cot and persisting with that even if it gets hard - that's your informed choice. Stop judging other people or telling them they're ill-informed / ignoring the research if they make a different, informed choice from your own.

Your choice isn't better than anyone else's. Research is there to help people make informed choices, not to force everyone down a path that doesn't work for them. Many, many cultures co-sleep - it's a perfectly valid choice. You don't agree, and that's your prerogative, but it isn't your prerogative to tell everyone who doesn't agree with you that they're wrong. You're not wrong - neither are co-sleepers.

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 08:11

@botw incorrect, they have changed how that is recorded now, they do have lower SIDS deaths.
And when you actually think sensibly about it, it would make sense right? We know that room sharing is a protective factor against SIDS, absolutely no-one is arguing that. So it's logical that the baby would need to be pretty close in the room to achieve that benefit because it's based on breath and heartbeat, so what they are really recommending is that your baby sleeps CLOSE to you.

So maybe a side crib or cot next to the bed supports that, fine, but actually that isn't often enough security for the baby, which is why many cry and scream every time they are put back, so this leads to women keep putting them back and picking them up and occasionally falling asleep with them unsafely in the bed. I believe 60% admit to co sleeping, even if unintentionally.
If a mattress is firm, with no loose bedding and you don't drink/smoke then you eliminate the other risks and you achieve the gain of being close.

My agenda is that many many women are being told that bed sharing increases SIDS and they are suffering as a result. In fact many babies are dying because mothers are so exhausted and they are trying to feed in chairs and sofas to wake themselves up and given misinformation by health workers. 40% of women admit to falling asleep accidentally at least once in a chair or sofa! They are also being encouraged to use techniques like CIO in order to get sleep because their baby doesn't want to be left in their cot, madness.

The fact is, cot sleeping is safe. If the baby is happy and settled and it's what the mother wants, fine! I totally support that, but so is bed sharing when done correctly and all the actual evidence points to that.

Your point about infant mortality is completely irrelevant. A baby has evolved to want to be close to its mother for survival, it has developed a system where feeling her breath INCREASES survival, how amazing when we actually think about it. What on earth has infant mortality being 'normal' got to do with it.

Ottersmith · 23/04/2023 01:14

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 00:20

Some babies sleep through by that age, especially if they are formula fed.

Mine started sleeping through at 8 weeks.

How do you know they were sleeping through? High chance they were waking up but staying quiet.

Chocolatesandroses · 23/04/2023 00:54

Every does things differently and all babies are different . We do what is best for us and our kids at the time . When I had my children I was told not to co sleep because of cot death etc was safer for baby to sleep on their own . I was also advised to sleep train my dd as she was a terrible sleeper etc this is what worked for us but may not work for others . I always use to have comments about my kids going to bed at 9 as this classed as too late but it’s what worked for my children . I used to feel like inferior when my dd was born but now I just think my children are safe and Happy I don’t worry about others and what they do

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 00:50

Ugh.

technically you're right.

So annoying

No. I'm just right

@Peppadog

whats your agenda? The risk of bedsharing isn't just sids. It's also suffocation

The Japan thing is also misinformation

They record sids and suffocation infant deaths differently.

They actually don't have lower suds deaths than anywhere else

Of course infant mortality is a biological and evolutionary norm.
It happens to every living thing. Disease and infection are also biological norms

DontMakeMeShushYou · 23/04/2023 00:43

I think @Botw1 is being pedantic. When she says co-sleeping isn't safe, technically she's right in the sense that we cannot entirely remove the risk from everything, or indeed anything, that we do. But the co-sleeping advice is designed to make co-sleeping as safe as it can be, just as the feet to foot and no cot bumpers advice is given to make sleeping in a cot as safe as it can be. That isn't risk-free either.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 00:42

MumApril1990 · 23/04/2023 00:35

I hate the thought of a little helpless baby sleeping alone in a room.

I don’t. We all get a wonderful nights sleep.

MumApril1990 · 23/04/2023 00:35

I hate the thought of a little helpless baby sleeping alone in a room.

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 00:28

@Botw1 what is your agenda? If anyone mentions evidence that states that co sleeping under certain conditions is safe you just ignore it and pedal the same stuff.

Here's a fact that will blow everyone's mind. Which county has one of the lowest instances of SIDS in the world? Japan! How do they sleep? They favour co sleeping!

We have evolved with a desire to co sleep, evolution hasn't built systems in to harm us. Why does SIDS go up when babies are put in a separate room?
It makes no sense that room sharing is safER but bed sharing is less safe, EXCEPT for the conditions in the bed. Just because one thing is linked to another, doesn't mean one causes another. Co sleeping does not CAUSE an increase in SIDS.

The comparison to infant mortality is totally irrelevant . It's not a biological norm or evolutionary development to die young, we died from infection and disease and malnutrition. Pointless argument.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 00:20

MumApril1990 · 23/04/2023 00:16

@Nottamug can I ask what was your motivation for having them in their own room at 12 weeks? We’re you not having to go in all the time?

Some babies sleep through by that age, especially if they are formula fed.

Mine started sleeping through at 8 weeks.

MumApril1990 · 23/04/2023 00:16

@Nottamug can I ask what was your motivation for having them in their own room at 12 weeks? We’re you not having to go in all the time?

Nottamug · 23/04/2023 00:07

My formula fed babies that were in their own rooms at 12 weeks are all perfectly balanced adults.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 00:01

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 23:58

Also, my babies weren't traumatised by not being close to me.

I know they weren't because they weren't distressed

Exactly.

I have a very content, happy baby.

Even though he goes to nursery full time too! 😱😂

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 23:59

@MumApril1990

Yet formula fed babies aren't traumatised either

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/04/2023 23:58

MumApril1990 · 22/04/2023 23:54

@SouthLondonMum22 I never said babies who don’t cosleep are traumatised?

I said babies are traumatised when they aren’t close to their mother. Which is known. Closeness doesn’t necessarily mean cosleeping

You asked me how I knew my baby isn’t traumatised though.

Botw1 · 22/04/2023 23:58

Also, my babies weren't traumatised by not being close to me.

I know they weren't because they weren't distressed

MumApril1990 · 22/04/2023 23:57

@Botw1 breastfeeding reduces heart rate and regulates breathing too I think?