Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we try and encourage babies to be independent too soon?

313 replies

graciousgrace · 21/04/2023 14:52

I just don't understand the obsession with wanting babies to be so independent so early on? I go to quite a few baby groups, and am constantly hearing comments like...

"I don't spoon feed my baby, I've encouraged self feeding from day one."

"My baby sleeps through the night because I didn't respond to their cries when they woke up."

"I don't rock my baby to sleep because they need to learn to put themselves to sleep and self soothe."

"I don't co-sleep because my baby needs to be in their own room in their own cot."

And the most shocking one of all... a mum at a baby group I went to said that her 7 month old baby "will only do a poo on the toilet"! Literally couldn't make it up!

As a mum who happily spoon feeds, co-sleeps and rocks my baby to sleep, it is so annoying hearing these comments because it's like these mums think they're superior. What's wrong with me wanting to treat my baby like a, you know, baby? I mean, great for you if those things work for you, but us mums who do things differently shouldn't be made to feel inadequate or like we're doing things wrong. Babies are only babies for such a short amount of time, so why can't we embrace the time when they actually need us to do things for them? I doubt I'll have a 15 year who still wants to be spoon fed, rocked to sleep and sleep in my bed 😂 does anyone agree or am I just being too sensitive?

OP posts:
MeinKraft · 24/04/2023 10:26

MumApril1990 · 22/04/2023 23:30

I agree. They are only little for long and babies feel traumatised when not close to Mummy. Why wouldn’t you want your baby to feel loved and secure?

I get told I hold my baby too much, feed him too often, I’m spoiling him by breastfeeding and by co-sleeping. He should be in his own room left crying at 6 months apparently. And when awake left in his pram or on the play mat alone?

For gods sake. You're not going to traumatise your baby by putting them on the floor. They need floor time to develop properly, physically.

Botw1 · 24/04/2023 10:13

@Ottersmith

I've said a few times now people are free to ignore me and the evidence. If you dont think it matters what I think, that is absolutely fine.

I havent scrapped my car, despite the very clear risk, because I've made the risk assessment that the benefits outweigh the risk. I feel its a necessary risk to take.

Others feel the same about bed sharing. I dont. And I won't ever think it can be done safely (because you cant remove the risk of suffocation) but people who want to do it are completely free to disagree

@JudgeJ

I dont like football and I'm not English so you could tell me whatever you like about a random footballer I've never heard of

Lights22 · 24/04/2023 02:45

OP I've only read pages 1, 2 and 11, which all seem to be different topics in themselves, but your original post appears to be more about parenting styles rather than independence. For me, encouraging independence and losing out on babyhood would be weaning early or saying a baby can sit when really they're leaning, so to speak: a parent declaring they've met their goals ahead of time.

Either way here are some musings to accompany either school of thought: parent and baby groups can be just as toxic as they are supportive; quite often people who brag about how well it's going, are actually struggling; first time mum-itis; PND and "needing" the baby to grown up more quickly; if it works for you, it works; parenting is just making it up as you go along and hoping for the best. And so on.

For me, I had a very clingy and high needs first baby who I needed to stop being so dependent on me and I had PND. My second I'm not rushing anything because I'm enjoying him. My first I felt I needed to be on top of everything, my second I've given up and embraced the mess I've become 🤣 and am much, much happier.

If it works for you, it works. Just as if it it works for them, it works. Neither is right or wrong.

JudgeJ · 23/04/2023 23:06

Facts are facts

It's the interpretation of facts that matters, 'Give me you data, tell me what you want to prove and I'll prove it!'

This thread and it's reliance on 'facts', 'research' etc is hilarious, a perfect example of the Use and Abuse of Statistics!

BTW, Harry Kane is not England's best goal scorer of all time, I have the 'facts' to prove it!

Ottersmith · 23/04/2023 21:24

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 16:48

@CatCake

I havent used the word deluded. And it wasn't me who first used hysteria. I do think bedshareres cone across as very defensive. I'm not sure why they are.

I dont agree that there is research that proves bed sharing can be safe, no.

I agree it can be safer than unplanned bedsharing or sofa sleeping.

And I think I'm done circling this drain

@SouthLondonMum22

I'll take my unnatural health care any day of the week thanks!

It doesn't matter what you think. The evidence is out there. Bedsharers are defensive because everyone tells them it's going to kill their baby. There's a 1 in 16000 chance of baby dying by bedsharing. 1 in 32000 chance dying in a cot. The highest risk for sids is having a baby in another room and formula feeding. That's the evidence.

Risk of dying in a car crash in a year 1 in 20000, lifetime risk 1 in 240. So you better get your car scrapped and never drive again and forge a campaign against car drivers because they are putting their babies at a higher risk than cot death.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 17:09

@botw1 the very fact you think they come across as defensive belies your belief that their position requires defending. It doesn't. Bedsharers aren't defensive. You believe this because you believe that your position is correct and that any other position requires a defence, so any engaging in debate with you makes you automatically decide that said engagement is a "defence."

Whether or not you believe there is research / guidance showing that co-sleeping can be safe is entirely up to you. Such research-based guidance does exist but it's an absolutely fine choice to say that, even if it exists, it's not sufficient for you to make any other choice than to cot sleep your child. It's not fine to instead claim that this research/guidance doesn't exist, that it's "made up" by "defensive, risk-denying posters." Not one advocate of co-sleeping here as denied that there are risks involved in co-sleeping. They've simply pointed out - correctly, whether you like it or not - that there are ways to address those risks that make them statistically marginal. That is still too much risk for you and that's fine but to tell everyone else that it's categorically unsafe is just wrong.

As other posters have said, I hope a desperate mum looking for advice reads through and sees that there are choices where baby sleep is concerned and that a decision to co-sleep is not simply an unsafe option.

Bunnybeeee · 23/04/2023 16:53

If the way another parent chooses to parent thier offspring makes me feel inferior, I'd probably have a look into why. I'm confident in my parenting, so another mum doing things differently has no effect on me or my kids lives and definitely doesn't make me feel bad. We all parent differently. There's no one way of doing it correctly. As long as you get them to adulthood in semi reasonable condition and they still want something to do with you, congrats, you did good 👍 Treat yourself to the kindness you'd show your kids if they came to you as adults and said this.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 16:48

@CatCake

I havent used the word deluded. And it wasn't me who first used hysteria. I do think bedshareres cone across as very defensive. I'm not sure why they are.

I dont agree that there is research that proves bed sharing can be safe, no.

I agree it can be safer than unplanned bedsharing or sofa sleeping.

And I think I'm done circling this drain

@SouthLondonMum22

I'll take my unnatural health care any day of the week thanks!

CatCake · 23/04/2023 16:39

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 16:31

Well I'm hoping that there is some benefit to this pointless debate. By refusing to acknowledge any alternative evidence surrounding the issue you've meant that I and other posters have had to rehash it relentlessly.
Hopefully at least one struggling sleep deprived mum will read it and realise there is a wealth of evidence out there to show they can (if they want to) let their babies sleep beside them safely, and both get a decent nights sleep, just like nature intended.

Spot on again.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 16:38

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 16:28

@CatCake

And yet, you keep trying to reason.

All the while arguing that you're not defensive. Or that you don't think you're choice is superior. And that you do acknowledge the risk while denying them.

If I'm so unreasonable and ill informed then ..... ignore me.

You know best after all.

I completely agree with everything you've said.

Of course, ''it's natural'' and ''like nature'' is thrown in there to be superior.

Personally, I enjoy living in 2023 with formula, washing machines, dishwashers and many other things nature didn't make.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 16:37

I don't think my choice is superior.

I do absolutely know best for me and my family.

Engaging in debate on a forum isn't being defensive. It's just disappointing when those you're engaging with aren't capable of reason. That doesn't mean your choice to sleep your baby in a cot is wrong or that my choice to not do so is somehow better. It's no longer that that I try to reason with you about. It means that you doggedly refuse to acknowledge that other research exists on co-sleeping that isn't "made up by other posters." Instead, you continue to bleat that it is unsafe no matter what and to place the perfectly valid and reasonable, evidence-based assertions of those choosing to co-sleep into a "deluded, made up, hysterical, defensive" category.

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 16:31

Well I'm hoping that there is some benefit to this pointless debate. By refusing to acknowledge any alternative evidence surrounding the issue you've meant that I and other posters have had to rehash it relentlessly.
Hopefully at least one struggling sleep deprived mum will read it and realise there is a wealth of evidence out there to show they can (if they want to) let their babies sleep beside them safely, and both get a decent nights sleep, just like nature intended.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 16:28

@CatCake

And yet, you keep trying to reason.

All the while arguing that you're not defensive. Or that you don't think you're choice is superior. And that you do acknowledge the risk while denying them.

If I'm so unreasonable and ill informed then ..... ignore me.

You know best after all.

CatCake · 23/04/2023 16:26

@Peppadog

Very accurate depiction of what trying to reason with the unreasonable is like...

CatCake · 23/04/2023 16:24

@Botw1 Your sense of superiority is really misplaced. Here's how it actually goes:

Botw1: here's a statement drawn from research: the safest place for a baby to sleep is in its bare cot. Oh, also, co-sleeping is categorically unsafe. Anything with risks associated is categorically unsafe.

Other posters: You're spot on that the safest place is the bare cot. But, actually, there's research about co-sleeping, too. It doesn't have to be unsafe. Oh, and, it's prevalent in many cultures and has been for years. And did you - did you really just say that anything with risks associated is ... unsafe? What about crossing the road / travelling by car / giving a weaning baby solid foods / all the myriad other things that carry risk and people do every day?

Botw1 (ignores all reference to other precedent / research / statistics relating to co-sleeping and risk): Er, no. You're ignoring the research. My decision is the only one based on research. Your insistence on using all available research to make a balanced choice is simply hysterical and childish.

There aren't any "defensive co-sleepers." There are simply other posters, who looked at what's out there and at their own family situations and made a different choice from you, and who have simply tried to point out that research and to tell you that co-sleeping isn't unsafe by definition. It really isn't those posters you term "defensive co-sleepers" who aren't capable of rational debate and conversation. Nobody told you to take anything back. Your comment that co-sleeping parents "make up their own evidence" is just another example of your dogged inability to see things from any perspective but your own and your clear sense of (completely misguided) superiority.

KnittedCardi · 23/04/2023 16:14

Wanderingowl · 23/04/2023 10:08

Yes there is. It is the absolute norm in my family. My DS literally poo'd twice in a nappy after 6.5 months. They were both just before 9mo when we were visiting MIL who had just been given 4 months to live and clearly his response to the emotional state of the people around him. He came out of nappies completely by 15 months. As did I and my DBs. Babies will choose not to soil themselves if they know they don't have to.

Agreed. DD was potty trained in the summer of her first birthday. July baby. She was clean and dry during the day within a couple of weeks. Yes, I prompted her after breakfast, before going out, after eating and drinking. But it worked and saved a fortune in nappies. It's why we (as adults) always go for a pee before leaving the house, or before bed, even if we don't need to, it's learned behaviour. She wasn't dry at night, until much later though. I had to pick her up asleep, put her on the loo, she peed, and I took her back to bed, still asleep!

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 16:10

@Peppadog

Actually it's more like

Botw1 the evidence states x

Defensivecosleepers how dare you!!! You take that back right now and don't ever say it again!!! Stop saying it right now!! I dont want to hear it and will just make up my own evidence that ignores the actual evidence because I dont want to have to listen. So you stop it right now! I made my choice and I dont want anyone to be allowed to disagree!!

Botw1 alrighty then

🤣🤣

Hardbackwriter · 23/04/2023 15:36

Hugasauras · 23/04/2023 10:22

Weird how it's only cosleeping that generates this level of ire on here. We also know it's safest for babies to be breastfed and for children to travel rear-facing in the car for far longer than the minimum legislation, yet people fall over themselves to declare 'fed is best!' at the first hint of breastfeeding not being plain sailing and happily turn their tiny babies to face forward at 9mo and think people who ERF are some sort of crunchy weirdos. But cosleeping REALLY gets under people's skins for some reason. It's interesting.

I really disagree! The pendulum has swung a bit towards 'fed is best' but the ERF posts is always an absolute festival of people smugly declaring that they must just love their child more and that's why they don't want them decapitated (it also normally reveals how poor most people's grasp of risk is). I have a theory that the car seat thing invites some of the most extreme stuff because it's the only case where you can literally buy superiority.

Peppadog · 23/04/2023 15:26

Debating with @Botw1
Bowt1 - I've seen this evidence
Other poster - yes I realise that but if you interrogate the evidence then it actually says this
Bowt1 - yeah but my evidence says this
Other poster - yes yes I realise that but actually on closer inspection the evidence looks like this...
Bowt1 - I don't agree with you, stop having a tantrum

At least we can all agree to disagree!!

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/04/2023 13:30

Ottersmith · 23/04/2023 01:14

How do you know they were sleeping through? High chance they were waking up but staying quiet.

He can self settle so it’s possible that he wakes briefly before drifting off again.

If something is wrong, he cries.

aSofaNearYou · 23/04/2023 13:11

As a mum who happily spoon feeds, co-sleeps and rocks my baby to sleep, it is so annoying hearing these comments because it's like these mums think they're superior.

NRTFT, but on the flip side mothers such as yourself often view themselves as superior, too. It's about perspective. There are holier than thou people on both sides.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 12:33

@CatCake

🤣

CatCake · 23/04/2023 12:30

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 10:18

@CatCake

For the millionth time, it's not about SIDs and it's not based on 1 piece of evidence. I've read loads in years of these debates, including the stats on so called safe bed sharing.

If you as a parent feel you have mitigated the risk of SIDs and suffocation and feel you can bed share safely, after proper research, then great. That is your risk assessment to make.

I dont agree you can because the research shows equavically that the safest place is in a cot.

But you can ignore me. I have no relevance to your decision.

I won't however change my opinion or shut up because you don't like it.

You sound like a child having a temper tantrum because you're not getting your own way

Pot kettle black, much. 😂

You're extremely rude. I've made clear your choice is your choice, without accusing you of acting like a child.

Also, the word meant to use is "unequivocally." HTH.

Botw1 · 23/04/2023 10:26

@Hugasauras

Bm is better than fm. Erf is safer (5×?)than ff.

Facts are facts

Hugasauras · 23/04/2023 10:22

Weird how it's only cosleeping that generates this level of ire on here. We also know it's safest for babies to be breastfed and for children to travel rear-facing in the car for far longer than the minimum legislation, yet people fall over themselves to declare 'fed is best!' at the first hint of breastfeeding not being plain sailing and happily turn their tiny babies to face forward at 9mo and think people who ERF are some sort of crunchy weirdos. But cosleeping REALLY gets under people's skins for some reason. It's interesting.