Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we try and encourage babies to be independent too soon?

313 replies

graciousgrace · 21/04/2023 14:52

I just don't understand the obsession with wanting babies to be so independent so early on? I go to quite a few baby groups, and am constantly hearing comments like...

"I don't spoon feed my baby, I've encouraged self feeding from day one."

"My baby sleeps through the night because I didn't respond to their cries when they woke up."

"I don't rock my baby to sleep because they need to learn to put themselves to sleep and self soothe."

"I don't co-sleep because my baby needs to be in their own room in their own cot."

And the most shocking one of all... a mum at a baby group I went to said that her 7 month old baby "will only do a poo on the toilet"! Literally couldn't make it up!

As a mum who happily spoon feeds, co-sleeps and rocks my baby to sleep, it is so annoying hearing these comments because it's like these mums think they're superior. What's wrong with me wanting to treat my baby like a, you know, baby? I mean, great for you if those things work for you, but us mums who do things differently shouldn't be made to feel inadequate or like we're doing things wrong. Babies are only babies for such a short amount of time, so why can't we embrace the time when they actually need us to do things for them? I doubt I'll have a 15 year who still wants to be spoon fed, rocked to sleep and sleep in my bed 😂 does anyone agree or am I just being too sensitive?

OP posts:
00100001 · 30/04/2023 11:10

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 09:49

I have just said my DCs were not trained by 14m did you read what I said ?

Not you... The people who are claiming such nonsense

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 09:49

00100001 · 30/04/2023 08:54

Yes, fine, be proud of yourself.

But don't pretend your child is toilet trained at 14m and make others feel like they're doing something wrong because their child was in nappies until 2.5y.

I have just said my DCs were not trained by 14m did you read what I said ?

loislovesstewie · 30/04/2023 09:01

I don't know. My sister is 16 years younger than me. I can recall her standing in wet training pants going 'ugh' and screwing her face up in disgust. She must have been about 2 because I went off to university when she was that age. She was out of nappies when I went home at Christmas.

00100001 · 30/04/2023 08:55

loislovesstewie · 30/04/2023 08:40

I would be interested to know if toddlers were trained earlier as wearing terry towelling nappies was just uncomfortable. I mean feeling wet is horrible and putting 2 and 2 together and realizing that weeing in the loo/potty prevents it seems logical. Do people use terry training pants anymore?

I think they were out of nappies earlier. But we're they actually trained earlier than 2.5ish?

00100001 · 30/04/2023 08:54

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:21

So is it not an achievement to have carefully observed for infant so that you can catch most wees, rather than "getting on with things" ? Do these parents not have a right to be proud of it ?

Full disclosure mine were trained at 2years 4m and 2years 7m, very average ages in the 00's. But it is interesting socially the shift.

Yes, fine, be proud of yourself.

But don't pretend your child is toilet trained at 14m and make others feel like they're doing something wrong because their child was in nappies until 2.5y.

loislovesstewie · 30/04/2023 08:40

I would be interested to know if toddlers were trained earlier as wearing terry towelling nappies was just uncomfortable. I mean feeling wet is horrible and putting 2 and 2 together and realizing that weeing in the loo/potty prevents it seems logical. Do people use terry training pants anymore?

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:27

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:21

So is it not an achievement to have carefully observed for infant so that you can catch most wees, rather than "getting on with things" ? Do these parents not have a right to be proud of it ?

Full disclosure mine were trained at 2years 4m and 2years 7m, very average ages in the 00's. But it is interesting socially the shift.

The reason for the difference was the seasons, both trained in early summer, as was the fashion at the time.

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:21

Sorry your infant not for infant.

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:21

So is it not an achievement to have carefully observed for infant so that you can catch most wees, rather than "getting on with things" ? Do these parents not have a right to be proud of it ?

Full disclosure mine were trained at 2years 4m and 2years 7m, very average ages in the 00's. But it is interesting socially the shift.

00100001 · 30/04/2023 08:11

I just think there's this air of superiority about the idea that you've "trained" your child at 11 months... implying that the 2.5yo is somehow being failed or behind or whatever.but the reality is, that kids are actually generally independent in toileting around the same age.

Yes there's the issue of modern conveniences meaning some kids are still in nappies at 5 etc. But it's hardly a new phenomenon that some kids struggle with toileting at that kind of age.

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:01

00100001 · 30/04/2023 07:03

That's not trained though... That's the child being taken to the toilet.

Yes interesting points, I wonder which approach is more child centred and which is encouraging independence? My impression is that the responsive to infants signals, careful observation of cues is more child centred, the " "everybody doing their own thing, stick em in enviromentally catastrophic disposable nappies till 3" is more adult centred , indivualistic and fostering independence.

Incidentally although most children can adapt to the delayed training, there is an increasing number of DCs who resist or can't be trained at this age are therefore entering school in nappies. We need to look at this as a society.

It happens at the other end of life too, with continent older adults being put in to incontinence products for convenience, equally environmentally disastrous

00100001 · 30/04/2023 07:03

Dyslexicwonder · 29/04/2023 21:54

In less Western cultures babies are constantly carried the care giver learns to interpret the baby's signs. Yes by the time they can walk these children are to all intents and purposes toilet train. It's no so odd I am 47 and I was dry by 18m (Terry nappies), my sister by 15m and at night by 2.

That's not trained though... That's the child being taken to the toilet.

jannier · 29/04/2023 23:47

Dyslexicwonder · 29/04/2023 21:54

In less Western cultures babies are constantly carried the care giver learns to interpret the baby's signs. Yes by the time they can walk these children are to all intents and purposes toilet train. It's no so odd I am 47 and I was dry by 18m (Terry nappies), my sister by 15m and at night by 2.

If a baby is reliant on the adult recognising signals taking to a potty and putting on the potty it's the adult that is trained not the child. If you sit on a toilet you can empty your bladder even if you only went 15 minutes ago but that doesn't mean you're trained just that you're voiding your bladder at cold air and pressure much like a dog salivating at Pavlov's bell.
Parents say their child is trained because the parent is good at catching wee but the baby would still soil if the parent didn't watch. Training is being able to hold a wee, communicate a need and in normally developing children take themselves. Be fully dressed not naked ....naked children revert to wetting when dressed. If a child is truly ready training takes a few days not months everyone can live their lives, play, work, relax not sit staring at a child or sitting them every 20 minutes.

Dyslexicwonder · 29/04/2023 21:54

jannier · 29/04/2023 20:48

Why would you spend months watching your child and training them to wee on command interrupting their natural play? Do you not have anything else to do?

In less Western cultures babies are constantly carried the care giver learns to interpret the baby's signs. Yes by the time they can walk these children are to all intents and purposes toilet train. It's no so odd I am 47 and I was dry by 18m (Terry nappies), my sister by 15m and at night by 2.

jannier · 29/04/2023 20:48

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 15:47

Well opinions will differ (and culturally no less), but much rather do that for a few months instead of changing nappies...
Especially when I see people talking about changing nappies of 3 year olds!!!

Why would you spend months watching your child and training them to wee on command interrupting their natural play? Do you not have anything else to do?

SophieBu · 29/04/2023 15:48

This was 9 months ago!!! I still cuddle my baby to sleep 💗

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/04/2023 21:44

@MumApril1990 It isn't as healthy. I've never claimed that it is.

MumApril1990 · 24/04/2023 21:36

@SouthLondonMum22 bur formula isn’t as healthy as breast milk is it,
you can’t pretend it is?

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/04/2023 16:36

00100001 · 24/04/2023 15:51

Well...a few months for. 6.kntjsnokd to actually being independent would probably actually be over a year.

Most people's lifestyle doesn't work like that, like if kids are in nursery from 6 months old, I can't imagine it would work in that setting?

They're probably all independent at the same kid of age, just some are being taken to the toilet by adults whilst others are in nappies.

It wouldn't work.

My baby started nursery at 3 months and I wouldn't want to pay £100+ a day for them to stare at him so they can catch his wees/poos.

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 16:10

I'm not sure exactly how it would work since I emigrated a long time ago - but for example my mother was a Dr, and her mat leave was 3 months long.
This was the practice then there then too in my country.

Aria999 · 24/04/2023 16:04

Hugasauras · 21/04/2023 16:53

I never spoon-fed either of mine really, especially not second, because we all eat the same meals together and if I or DH have to spoon feed, neither of us can eat our dinner very well! So not especially about independence, but both of mine have taken to eating with their hands very quickly. DD2 is 10 months old now and can feed herself whole meals without any help from me. Both had teeth bang on 6 months which helps maybe, but I do find it a bit weird when babies who are totally capable of eating proper food are still being spoon-fed unappetising mush.

I co slept with DD1 until she was 3 but after doing it a bit at the start with DD2 I didn't really fancy continuing it with DD2, and turns out she sleeps better in her own cot anyway so I'm happy with that! A lot of the stuff we 'choose' to do is just because of our baby's preferences anyway.

Yes, this. You read around to figure what's safe then you do what works best for you and your baby (often in a fug of sleep deprived confusion. It can also be different for different babies).

As long as the outcome is what works best for everyone then you are probably doing the right thing and can crack on and ignore others doing it differently.

Just don't e.g. co-sleep but spend all your time complaining about how tired you are and how difficult co-sleeping makes things for you.

00100001 · 24/04/2023 15:51

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 15:47

Well opinions will differ (and culturally no less), but much rather do that for a few months instead of changing nappies...
Especially when I see people talking about changing nappies of 3 year olds!!!

Well...a few months for. 6.kntjsnokd to actually being independent would probably actually be over a year.

Most people's lifestyle doesn't work like that, like if kids are in nursery from 6 months old, I can't imagine it would work in that setting?

They're probably all independent at the same kid of age, just some are being taken to the toilet by adults whilst others are in nappies.

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 15:47

Well opinions will differ (and culturally no less), but much rather do that for a few months instead of changing nappies...
Especially when I see people talking about changing nappies of 3 year olds!!!

00100001 · 24/04/2023 15:35

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 15:18

@00100001
"
Asia:
In many parts of Asia, such as China, Japan, and Korea, children may start potty training between 1 and 2 years of age.

Middle East and Africa
In some Middle Eastern and African countries, potty training may begin at an earlier age, sometimes as young as 6 months old.
"

Ask any non westerner, like me - the western way is not the only way.

And those 6 month olds are taking themselves to the toilet are they? Those 14m olds are having no accidents?

Or is it that they're being taken to the toilet by the adults?

In my mind, a toilet trained child is one that can take themselves to the toilet unprompted, and do the whole process independently with accidents only happening incredibly rarely such as illness etc. Not a baby that is being out on a potty every few hours/at some tiny signal by the adults around them .

SeulementUneFois · 24/04/2023 15:18

@00100001
"
Asia:
In many parts of Asia, such as China, Japan, and Korea, children may start potty training between 1 and 2 years of age.

Middle East and Africa
In some Middle Eastern and African countries, potty training may begin at an earlier age, sometimes as young as 6 months old.
"

Ask any non westerner, like me - the western way is not the only way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread