Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we try and encourage babies to be independent too soon?

313 replies

graciousgrace · 21/04/2023 14:52

I just don't understand the obsession with wanting babies to be so independent so early on? I go to quite a few baby groups, and am constantly hearing comments like...

"I don't spoon feed my baby, I've encouraged self feeding from day one."

"My baby sleeps through the night because I didn't respond to their cries when they woke up."

"I don't rock my baby to sleep because they need to learn to put themselves to sleep and self soothe."

"I don't co-sleep because my baby needs to be in their own room in their own cot."

And the most shocking one of all... a mum at a baby group I went to said that her 7 month old baby "will only do a poo on the toilet"! Literally couldn't make it up!

As a mum who happily spoon feeds, co-sleeps and rocks my baby to sleep, it is so annoying hearing these comments because it's like these mums think they're superior. What's wrong with me wanting to treat my baby like a, you know, baby? I mean, great for you if those things work for you, but us mums who do things differently shouldn't be made to feel inadequate or like we're doing things wrong. Babies are only babies for such a short amount of time, so why can't we embrace the time when they actually need us to do things for them? I doubt I'll have a 15 year who still wants to be spoon fed, rocked to sleep and sleep in my bed 😂 does anyone agree or am I just being too sensitive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VestaTilley · 31/05/2023 11:43

I went to A LOT of baby groups; I never heard anyone say any of these things. Don’t take a few overheard conversations as evidence of some wholesale change in parenting attitudes. Everyone has always taken slightly varied approaches.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/05/2023 11:39

Botw1 · 21/04/2023 15:36

Says co sleeping can be done safely.

Shows picture of completely unsafe co sleeping

Kind of understandable when the entire point of the image is the woman's purely coincidentally perfect breast, not the burglar that's crept in behind her or the angelic, not at all red-faced, sweaty, angry, biting, scratching and kicking, flaxen haired, toddler. Not even focusing on her - just her glowing, perfect breast.

Co sleeping can be safe. Personally, I preferred actual sleeping. Same way I preferred food getting into my child occasionally, rather than a spoon being grabbed and used as a trebuchet in the direction of the ever hopeful cat or as a trowel for applying concrete mix weetabix to the hair they shriek with rage about having warm water or soap applied to.

But hey, as was said in those incredibly bitchy groups, some of us are just more natural parents than others...

110APiccadilly · 31/05/2023 11:34

Yazo · 30/05/2023 21:39

No way, I have relatives who never put their baby down. He's 8 months old and can't sit up because they hold him constantly. Encouraging them to use their bodies is important for development.

My second one gets put down plenty and couldn't sit unaided until 9 months. She's under a pediatrician for something unrelated and the pediatrician wasn't concerned about that.

WhiskersPete · 31/05/2023 11:22

Also, you can't hold them 100% of the time. That's physically impossible.

WhiskersPete · 31/05/2023 11:21

How did she sit up when she was in your arms? How did she learn to undress herself and get onto the potty if you never put her down?

@jannier

Well she's only 6 months old now so give her chance!

jannier · 31/05/2023 10:15

WhiskersPete · 30/05/2023 22:42

I hold mine constantly and she could sit up unaided at 4 months.

How did she sit up when she was in your arms? How did she learn to undress herself and get onto the potty if you never put her down?

jannier · 31/05/2023 10:14

Wenfy · 04/05/2023 08:51

What are you talking about? Most children in the world are fully potty trained by 1-1.5 and not in the ‘watch and catch’ way but properly in that they will go to the loo themselves for wees and poos and even wash themselves. This concept of waiting for them to be ‘aware’ of potty urges is a white concept designed specifically to make nappy companies more money.

Your not on the same planet....a 12 to 18 month old is barely walking let alone going to a toilet climbing on, undressing, wiping then redressing and going to a sink to wash hands. The pre disposable era was potty training to reduce washing and it meant sitting your child for large parts of the day with many feeding on the potty. Many children were left nappy free crawling on wooden floors they didn't wee less .....how much academic research have you done on the subject? Many poor homes reeked with the smell of urine and pooh in wealthy homes that had nannies a nanny was paid to watch and catch....you can condition any animal to pee on command.....just like most of us can produce a sample or force a wee before a long trip.....you can also condition pooh times by feeding them enforced sitting for half an hour.....but as a minute per year is like an hour of adult time why would you mistreat a child like that....and probably scream about how wrong a 2 minute time out would be?
I'm sure the baby wearers in paddy fields etc have totally potty trained 12 month olds

CrotchetyCrocheting · 30/05/2023 23:01

WhiskersPete · 30/05/2023 22:42

I hold mine constantly and she could sit up unaided at 4 months.

Snap! Dd was a stage 5 clinger and I held her constantly until she was about 18months old. She could sit unaided at 4 months too. All babies are different, you don't damage them by keeping them close.

WhiskersPete · 30/05/2023 22:42

Yazo · 30/05/2023 21:39

No way, I have relatives who never put their baby down. He's 8 months old and can't sit up because they hold him constantly. Encouraging them to use their bodies is important for development.

I hold mine constantly and she could sit up unaided at 4 months.

Yazo · 30/05/2023 21:39

No way, I have relatives who never put their baby down. He's 8 months old and can't sit up because they hold him constantly. Encouraging them to use their bodies is important for development.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 30/05/2023 21:37

I know this is the best part of a month late, but @Wenfy is talking pure SHITE.

00100001 · 04/05/2023 11:08

Wenfy · 04/05/2023 08:51

What are you talking about? Most children in the world are fully potty trained by 1-1.5 and not in the ‘watch and catch’ way but properly in that they will go to the loo themselves for wees and poos and even wash themselves. This concept of waiting for them to be ‘aware’ of potty urges is a white concept designed specifically to make nappy companies more money.

No they aren't.... You're telling me a 12 month old baby has the capacity to control their bladder to the point they can take themselves to the toilet without any prompting, remove their clothes and do their business with no accidents? Show me examples where this is the norm, with actual independent toileting.

SouthLondonMum22 · 04/05/2023 09:09

@MumApril1990 I'm more than just a mother, my baby is an important part of my life but he isn’t my whole life and I think that’s a good thing for the both of us.

It doesn’t mean he’s an inconvenience just because I’ve made different decisions to you.

Mothers don’t need to be martyrs to be good mothers.

Wenfy · 04/05/2023 08:51

jannier · 30/04/2023 11:32

Most parents have to work to provide a home etc. They are having to get on with things the idea you can spend 18 months watching for a wee....or even one is not in most families priority list... especially as the only benefit is reduced washing or less disposables and no benefit to the child, possibly detriment I'm having play constantly interrupted. There is also an argument that these children in my experience are less independent in play and socially because they have been kept so close and not allowed to move away in play.

What are you talking about? Most children in the world are fully potty trained by 1-1.5 and not in the ‘watch and catch’ way but properly in that they will go to the loo themselves for wees and poos and even wash themselves. This concept of waiting for them to be ‘aware’ of potty urges is a white concept designed specifically to make nappy companies more money.

WorryMcGee · 04/05/2023 07:34

I didn’t breastfeed because I have breast cancer. I pumped for a bit but it was destroying my already wobbly MH and I wasn’t getting much anyway, (unsurprisingly as one side was busier trying to kill me but anyway) DH is a truly equal parent and often had to get up in the night because I literally couldn’t pick my baby up as I had a drain in my armpit. I didn’t co sleep because on the couple of times I tried, my baby was prodding/poking my sore bits and trying to pull the picc line out of my arm. My baby went into her own room at 6 months because her sleep was being disturbed by my insomnia - she was sleeping through, I wasn’t. My baby started nursery at 9 months old because I needed time to recover from chemo. She loves food and has always fed herself with her hands because she prefers it. She’ll take hold of a loaded spoon to feed herself sometimes - but if you try to spoon feed she turns her head and cries.

She’s just turned 1, I am her favourite person in the world, and she is mine. A mother that doesn’t breastfeed or co sleep or spoon feed or do absolutely everything herself because her child has another parent who is perfectly capable of caring for his child (and wants to!) still loves her child as much as a mother who does choose to do those things.

I don’t know why I click on these threads. I feel enough guilt over breastfeeding without reading the sweeping statements you always get on threads like these…

blahblahblah1654 · 04/05/2023 02:45

I spoon fed for longer as my son was premature so didn't have great hand eye coordination. He was also happy for me to feed him. I didn't think co sleeping was safe. There was no way I could have slept properly or relaxed with him in the bed, especially as he was so tiny to begin with. He sleeps amazingly on his own. We all do things differently, I couldn't care less what another parent is doing.

Fifi0 · 04/05/2023 02:45

Also I didnt co sleep because I have a sleep disorder much safer for my DD to be in her own cot.

Fifi0 · 04/05/2023 02:43

Farmersswife · 30/04/2023 22:24

I totally understand. I feel like people have babies and these days babies have to fit in with our lives and people want not to be inconvenienced by having a baby! It’s like breastfeeding now is almost frowned upon. Having recently a lot of friends having babies they are very much I won’t be glued to the baby, 2 parents , husband up in the night just as much ect ect babies should be babies & cuddled and co sleep. I think women don’t want to be seen to be the primary caregiver either . Makes me quite sad I’ve also heard similar things at baby groups. 8 week old babies sleeping through because you can buy magic over night milk powder that keeps them fuller for longer, 8 week old babies are supposed to wake through the night!.

Why is it sad? I don't want to be primary care giver i want to be equal. My DD slept through from 6 weeks it was fantastic no hungry baby milk needed bf in the day and stage 1 at 11pm dh did that bottle quite often for one feed slept through until 7am. Should I want to be sleep deprived for years? If I'm sleep deprived I'm more grumpy with sleep I'm a better parent. DDs 10 so a long time ago now.

MumApril1990 · 04/05/2023 02:09

@SouthLondonMum22 most mothers feel a mother is the most important thing they will do in their life, and they don’t see their baby as an inconvenience

rattlinbog · 30/04/2023 23:57

Farmersswife · 30/04/2023 22:24

I totally understand. I feel like people have babies and these days babies have to fit in with our lives and people want not to be inconvenienced by having a baby! It’s like breastfeeding now is almost frowned upon. Having recently a lot of friends having babies they are very much I won’t be glued to the baby, 2 parents , husband up in the night just as much ect ect babies should be babies & cuddled and co sleep. I think women don’t want to be seen to be the primary caregiver either . Makes me quite sad I’ve also heard similar things at baby groups. 8 week old babies sleeping through because you can buy magic over night milk powder that keeps them fuller for longer, 8 week old babies are supposed to wake through the night!.

Babies have always fitted in with adults' life. Since forever!

SouthLondonMum22 · 30/04/2023 22:47

Farmersswife · 30/04/2023 22:24

I totally understand. I feel like people have babies and these days babies have to fit in with our lives and people want not to be inconvenienced by having a baby! It’s like breastfeeding now is almost frowned upon. Having recently a lot of friends having babies they are very much I won’t be glued to the baby, 2 parents , husband up in the night just as much ect ect babies should be babies & cuddled and co sleep. I think women don’t want to be seen to be the primary caregiver either . Makes me quite sad I’ve also heard similar things at baby groups. 8 week old babies sleeping through because you can buy magic over night milk powder that keeps them fuller for longer, 8 week old babies are supposed to wake through the night!.

You think it's sad that some men actually get up in the night and parent their own child? I think it's sad that you think it's sad.

I absolutely do not want to be seen as the primary caregiver. My baby has a second parent who loves him just as much as I do, as well as grandparents and a keyworker who regularly care for him. A mother is only part of who I am.

8 weeks is when my baby started to sleep through. No hungry baby milk, just the usual stage 1 milk and the ability to self settle. Looks like he missed the memo that he's 'supposed' to wake up at night.

Farmersswife · 30/04/2023 22:24

I totally understand. I feel like people have babies and these days babies have to fit in with our lives and people want not to be inconvenienced by having a baby! It’s like breastfeeding now is almost frowned upon. Having recently a lot of friends having babies they are very much I won’t be glued to the baby, 2 parents , husband up in the night just as much ect ect babies should be babies & cuddled and co sleep. I think women don’t want to be seen to be the primary caregiver either . Makes me quite sad I’ve also heard similar things at baby groups. 8 week old babies sleeping through because you can buy magic over night milk powder that keeps them fuller for longer, 8 week old babies are supposed to wake through the night!.

AlltheFs · 30/04/2023 18:12

loislovesstewie · 30/04/2023 08:40

I would be interested to know if toddlers were trained earlier as wearing terry towelling nappies was just uncomfortable. I mean feeling wet is horrible and putting 2 and 2 together and realizing that weeing in the loo/potty prevents it seems logical. Do people use terry training pants anymore?

We used washable nappies from birth. They weren’t terry but children in reusable nappies do often toilet train earlier as they are more aware that they have had a wee. They aren’t uncomfortable though, they are highly absorbent but give more feel.
My DD was dry 3 weeks after her 2nd birthday- no effort required. She was off nursery with Covid (but wasn’t ill) back when it was a mandatory 10 days isolation. We used it to toilet train as we couldn’t go anywhere. Was a doddle.

jannier · 30/04/2023 11:32

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:21

So is it not an achievement to have carefully observed for infant so that you can catch most wees, rather than "getting on with things" ? Do these parents not have a right to be proud of it ?

Full disclosure mine were trained at 2years 4m and 2years 7m, very average ages in the 00's. But it is interesting socially the shift.

Most parents have to work to provide a home etc. They are having to get on with things the idea you can spend 18 months watching for a wee....or even one is not in most families priority list... especially as the only benefit is reduced washing or less disposables and no benefit to the child, possibly detriment I'm having play constantly interrupted. There is also an argument that these children in my experience are less independent in play and socially because they have been kept so close and not allowed to move away in play.

jannier · 30/04/2023 11:25

Dyslexicwonder · 30/04/2023 08:01

Yes interesting points, I wonder which approach is more child centred and which is encouraging independence? My impression is that the responsive to infants signals, careful observation of cues is more child centred, the " "everybody doing their own thing, stick em in enviromentally catastrophic disposable nappies till 3" is more adult centred , indivualistic and fostering independence.

Incidentally although most children can adapt to the delayed training, there is an increasing number of DCs who resist or can't be trained at this age are therefore entering school in nappies. We need to look at this as a society.

It happens at the other end of life too, with continent older adults being put in to incontinence products for convenience, equally environmentally disastrous

I was brought up in the generation of early trainers...for parents convenience to avoid washing....many reverted at times of stress like school aged 5. Many have constipation and continence issues.
The children I have experience of and working with various agencies and parents most delayed training except SEN is parents not being bothered and comments like that's schools job ...not children resisting. They have missed the point of readiness and started ignoring the need a child of 30 to 40 months is not delayed a child of 50 months is. A child of 11 months is having parent control their bladder not controlling it themselves.....and as they reach independence at around the same age ...30 months ish they are not trained any earlier. Parents are just wee catching.