Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To gift own art

56 replies

Bubblegumtea · 21/04/2023 00:06

Hi all, will try to keep this relatively concise to determine whether this is acceptable or not. I have afull time and very demanding job. In the last year I've been painting a lot in my spare time and my art has really started to pick up a fan base online and become a good sideline for me. I have just finished a painting which I know my fiancées relative will absolutely adore and it's her birthday in a fortnight. I'd usually sell an original painting of this size for about £75 and have done this already online with others. A print can go for about £12-£15. I was wondering what to get my fiancées relative and thought the painting would be perfect however I really don't know whether she will realise quite how much time and effort goes into it and I'd never tell her what I'd usually sell them for. I want her to have it because she's a wonderful person and I'm proud of it & know its to her taste but if I gift it alone and she doesn't quite get it does that look like I couldn't be bothered to get her a real gift? I know obviously what the materials and time cost me and the value of the painting in the sense of what I'd sell it for but I'm not sure she would... the alternative is to put something with it but then I feel it devalues the work and then I might aswell just gift something else. She has everything she could ever want but always goes above and beyond on my birthday and has gone out of her way to include me in fiancées family since I met him so I want to give her something special and thoughtful. I have spoken to his family about how much the painting sideline has taken off but I'm not sure they know the extent because I am still in a full-time job I'm a completely different field.

Yabu- regardless of the cost and time to make it and handmade gift for someone you've always otherwise got something lavish for will look cheap and odd, buy something.

Yanbu- if you know she will love it gift it to her.

Just to add, I'm sure the tone of my op doesn't sound this way as I've re read but just just confirm I'm not for a second suggesting gifts have to be high in material value to be acceptable acceptable give to someone, it's just we have always gifted her a decent amount as she is so close to my fiancée and I love giving her something special once a year.

OP posts:
Bubblegumtea · 21/04/2023 00:29

HeddaGarbled · 21/04/2023 00:26

He’ll be getting her something as well, won’t he?

He has tickets to take her to a show she wanted to see so a lovely gift but a non-physical item to unwrap, unless he wraps the tickets I suppose haha. We had agreed I'd do something for her to have on the day and he would do the tickets as a good birthday balance.

OP posts:
GulfCoastBeachGirl · 21/04/2023 00:28

@Bubblegumtea I knit blankets and throws and I do occasionally gift them to people I think will appreciate that type of thing. Between the cost of materials and the the huge time investment, it would be cheaper and easier to just buy something, tbh. But there's something so meaningful and personal about homemade gifts, isn't there?

HeddaGarbled · 21/04/2023 00:26

He’ll be getting her something as well, won’t he?

Bubblegumtea · 21/04/2023 00:20

Thank you both for replying that is a relief! I did ask my fiancée but wasn't sure he could be honest if he didn't agree with gifting it as he's seen me working hard on it. I'll wrap it up nicely and put it aside for her birthday.

OP posts:
GulfCoastBeachGirl · 21/04/2023 00:15

I love receiving handmade gifts! My SIL is a talented artist and occasionally gifts her work to family members. I've never had anyone tell me that they would have preferred something store bought. You are being generous with your time and talent. YANBU

KarmaStar · 21/04/2023 00:12

Do it!😀
Well done you for making time for doing a hobby that brings you happiness.
I would be delighted to receive such a thoughtful gift.
Please don't worry,instead be proud of what you have created.🌻