Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school have my kid mixed up with someone else?

67 replies

WhereAreYouuu · 20/04/2023 22:45

A while ago I got a message from school saying my daughter had a detention for rude behaviour.

My daughter is on SEN pathways at school, extremely timid, extremely quiet, so I was surprised.
I asked DD about it and she said she had no idea what it was about. I rang school and receptionist said that her maths teacher told DD off for being on her phone and as she was being told to put it away she continued texting.

DD denied any of this ever happened and was upset.

Yesterday I get a text saying DD had an after school detention because she didn't attend a lunch time detention she got for being late.

DD was late but only by a minute (they usually let that slide) but said she wasn't told she had a detention. Wasn't given a late slip or a detention slip.

So she had no idea she was supposed to attend a lunchtime detention.

So I phoned school to ask could she still just do a lunchtime detention as she had no idea she was supposed to.

Receptionist asks for DDs name, and says she also missed 6th period today. Why wasn't she in lesson?

I said I don't know. What lesson was it?

Spanish. DD doesn't do Spanish. I said you mean French?

Receptionist carries on convoy about DD not attending her lesson and I say she may have been with SEN teacher (she misses class occasionally)

I talk to DD today and ask why she wasn't in 6th period.

She says she was.
I ask if it was French (thinking the receptionist just got the language mixed up)

Nope, she had MATHS 6th period and ATTENDED her lesson.

Should I ring back again tomorrow and bring this up?!

I feel like this is twice they've given her a detention she didn't know about and seem to have her mixed up with someone else?

OP posts:
ShowUs · 21/04/2023 08:36

My apologies, I don’t know why there is a GIF above my post.

ShowUs · 21/04/2023 08:35

You need to speak to her actual teachers.

So find out from your DD the name of her maths teacher and ask to speak to them about it to find out the facts.
If they have no knowledge of it then obviously something is going on.

It’s highly unlikely that every staff member giving the detentions is getting your child’s name wrong.
So either your DD is getting in trouble at school but doesn’t want to admit it to you or there is a fault on the school system somehow.

Definitely give them a ring today and ask for the teachers who have given the detentions to give you a call back asap.

Hari Raya Love GIF
duvetcovereddissident · 21/04/2023 08:26

WhereAreYouuu · 20/04/2023 23:03

She has a really unusual name though.

Along the lines of Ophelia Hayles for comparison.

Don't think there's any other in the school with either name!

Thar doesn't really make any difference - to conform with GDPR many schools just use initials in communication and emails now

Spendonsend · 21/04/2023 08:22

Mistakes happen all the time. It could bd someone looks similar, some one has the same inititals, an admin error on the record.

I'd probably email and say what you think has happened, rather than phone though.

Putyourdamnshoeson · 21/04/2023 08:16

Definitely follow up. I work in an education role, visiting several schools, honestly, some are terrible. Not excused by funding, just a poor culture and leadership. Good luck.

gamerchick · 21/04/2023 08:16

I'd be making an appointment with the head and senco tbh and I'd be telling them no further punishments in the meantime until it's sorted out.

Hankunamatata · 21/04/2023 08:14

Just phone back and be polite and explain about dc being in maths and you think there's been a mistake

iolaus · 21/04/2023 08:11

With regard to the 'unusual' name you may be surprised

I remember several years back as a community midwife going to see a new baby called Persephone, there was another Persephone born the same week in the same town

Never come across one before or since, but you can get the odd unusual thing where you get unusual names in the same area (and tbh they will be the ones getting muddled often as other people may not realise there were two of them - so teacher says to the receptionist Ophelia didn't come to Spanish class today - the only Ophelia the receptionist knows if your Ophelia - whereas if it was Ellie she'd probably have asked which one)

Rosula · 21/04/2023 07:32

Don't just call, follow it up in writing. You may well need a record of all this.

g1c2d3 · 21/04/2023 07:12

My DS’s award for rugby player of the year group went to someone else because the PE teacher didn’t bother to remember my DS’s name despite being his form tutor the year before and his rugby couch at present. He announced the award goes to ‘this amazing young man, a captain of the rugby B team’, my DS started to get up (he was the captain of the rugby team) and got pats on the back from his friends sitting around him, only for the wrong name to be announced. The other boy got up, received the award, as confused as my DS. The other boy’s name is nothing like my son’s and he doesn’t look anything like my DS. I wanted to question it with the school but DS didn’t want me to. Five years later, I am still bitter about it on his behalf and I wish I had said something.

OP, definitely talk to the school!

artimesiasfootsteps · 21/04/2023 03:18

I had a similar thing happen to me at school, I did about three detentions for a girl of a completely different name. Somehow a teacher had mixed our names up as we look very similar.🙄

When my mother found out she raised hell with the school ( I was a straight A quiet student). The school offered me detention credits, which was ridiculous as I was never going to be given a detention in a million years to be able to use a ‘credit’.

In the end I was given a free place on an extra curricular trip to an outing that was for the year above that I really wanted to go on. ( art gallery trip to the city).

ReliantRobyn · 21/04/2023 02:53

WhereAreYouuu · 20/04/2023 23:03

She has a really unusual name though.

Along the lines of Ophelia Hayles for comparison.

Don't think there's any other in the school with either name!

"Along the lines of Ophelia Hayles" is comedy gold.

Dibbydoos · 21/04/2023 02:23

Def call, they have got her mixed up with someone else, how ridiculous!

Your poor DD must be feeling anxious about it all....

unkownone · 21/04/2023 01:45

Newestname002 · 21/04/2023 01:08

@unkownone

I had a call from a teacher yelling at me at DD’s behaviour.

So not only was that teacher wrong, she was unprofessional as well. I hope you/your DD got an apology? 🌹

Nope lol just told she has to deal with so many kids. Though hind sight is wonderful - that was the start of a very bad few years at the school which lead to some very dark times, til she moved schools. Should've picked up on it then it probably wasn't the school for her and save thousands on therapy and mental health issues. She's much better now thankfully :)

Dodgeitornot · 21/04/2023 01:10

I forgot this part, we even got a phone call from a maths teacher. She said she was concerned about my DD not fulfilling her potential due to behaviour. She's a bright girl that's predicted 7s and 8s according to her flight path. I was like erm...I don't think we're talking about my child here. Then an email from science saying the same thing. This was all happening within about a 2/3 week time period which makes me thing they did some system update and names migrated wrong. It was all fixed but the fact there's another (insert very rare first and last name, and same birth year) girl in the school still weirds me out. Feel a bit sorry for the other girls parents too, she sounds like a pain.

Mummyoflittledragon · 21/04/2023 01:09

It could be that your dd looks like the other girl. Apparently ofsted have recently introduced a rule that surnames aren’t logged as a matter of course much in schools due to safeguarding concerns. I’m not sure how it works but this was discussed on another thread so there is a possibility, however unusual, that there is another girl with the same first name, who’s doing x,y,z.

Newestname002 · 21/04/2023 01:08

@unkownone

I had a call from a teacher yelling at me at DD’s behaviour.

So not only was that teacher wrong, she was unprofessional as well. I hope you/your DD got an apology? 🌹

Dodgeitornot · 21/04/2023 01:05

Same thing happened to us. Started with us weirdly getting FSM, told the school we definitely weren't eligible, nothing was done. DD, also SEN with an EHCP kept getting demerits for rudeness, lack of homework etc. Attendance officer called me asking why she's not in and I got so scared. She was definitely in school. She went looking for her and low and behold she was in her lesson. Turns out there was another girls in the school with the same name, surname and year of birth but in the year below. My DDs name it NOT common. It's a foreign spelling of a common name and an uncommon foreign surname. It actually freaked me out more than anything else.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 21/04/2023 00:36

WhereAreYouuu · 20/04/2023 23:03

She has a really unusual name though.

Along the lines of Ophelia Hayles for comparison.

Don't think there's any other in the school with either name!

I literally posted a similar story on a fb page. When my niece was at secondary, no behaviour issues loved school, my DSis got a call from her form tutor explaining she had heard her name mentioned by another teacher. in relation to quite a serious incident. My niece has a very unusal first name normally given to boys and 20 yrs ago it was rare for girls to have 'boys' names. Teacher suggested DSis talked to my niece.. she denied it ofcoursr, had a full scale argument, a) because of the incident, and b) because she assumed Dd was lying. Sis called the school the next day and the teacher had mixed up 2 girls who didn't look like each other or have anything like similar names.

OP write down all the points, and ask for a face to face meeting with at least the HoY (send email so you have a paper trail) school is hard enough without having this pushed onyour DD. I am now 'that parent' who calls out school when they are being incompetent (x teacher married to one )

Pieceofpurplesky · 21/04/2023 00:35

We had two boys with exactly the same name in my last school - right down to middle names. Really confusing as one was an Angel and the other really naughty!

It will be a mix up, either timetable, name or teacher. I would ring up and ask to see the head of year

lemonchiffonpie · 21/04/2023 00:16

Spanish. DD doesn't do Spanish.

Should I ring back again tomorrow and bring this up?!

Well, yes! Somehow she has been confused, or your phone number in their records has been confused, with another student. I would go in personally, as talking on the phone is not getting you far. But one way or the other it does need to be cleared up.

DFWM · 21/04/2023 00:13

This happened with my son, too. Turned out they were mixing him up with another child with a similar name. They sorted it pretty quickly though after I turned up the following morning.

dimorphism · 21/04/2023 00:09

Your poor DD.

I'd probably go for a message in writing setting out that you think there's been a mix up more than once copying in the headteacher or head of year. There's little point having another discussion with the receptionist who didn't listen to you the first time you said your daughter didn't do Spanish.

And if a child is skipping school, that's potentially a safeguarding issue and it's a real problem if they're informing the wrong parent.

ComputerWifeKaren · 20/04/2023 23:58

I used to find accident slips with another child's full name in DD's bag during primary school years. It was DD's nickname but another child's first name, surname and class written down, no wonder I wasn’t called when she'd hurt herself. Challenge the mix up, it's ridiculous.

VivaciousRadish · 20/04/2023 23:51

I had so many letters about outstanding school library fines. I replied every time.

Eventually they phoned me, I don’t think they’d read any of my letters and I was quite annoyed by this time. I told her I wasn’t paying, and she asked why. I told her I’d pay any fines accrued by Milly Radish (year 11) and Molly Radish (year 9) but I was buggered if I was paying for Mandy Radish (year 10). She was so cross and said I’d signed something when they’d joined the school to say I was responsible, and I said ‘yes but only for my kids. You’ve got the wrong family’

You’d think they’d check. We don’t have an uncommon surname, and unlike my example the girls all have quite different first names.

I think they get it wrong a lot but they’re never sorry