Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU feeding my kid instant noodles several times a week

293 replies

cooknwithbaby · 20/04/2023 21:48

I had dinner with my DS and my mum saw we were eating instant noodles with chicken soup and extra vegetable I added. She shamed me about feeding my DS instant noodles, saying it was unhealthy.

It's easy for me to make and everybody likes eating it. DS has loved noodles since he was 6 months old. I cook it several times a week. But I usually make it a bit healthier with broccoli. Sometimes I add a fried egg.

AIBU by feeding my kid some instant noodles for dinner?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
WinterDeWinter · 22/04/2023 09:05

GeriKellmansUpdo · 22/04/2023 08:39

There are so many cultures that never eat processed food, or even ultra processed food, but of course Chris Van Tulleken acts as if this is news. My mum has literally never eaten any processed food, except perhaps biscuits and crisps from time to time. 99% of her diet is unprocessed. My diet is about the same.

You seem to be implying that van tulleken has some kind of nefarious motivation in bringing the damage that ultra processed foods cause to light which is … weird. His whole point is that barely any of us eat like your mother does and barely any of us understand the impacts of that fact.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 22/04/2023 08:39

There are so many cultures that never eat processed food, or even ultra processed food, but of course Chris Van Tulleken acts as if this is news. My mum has literally never eaten any processed food, except perhaps biscuits and crisps from time to time. 99% of her diet is unprocessed. My diet is about the same.

Phoebo · 22/04/2023 08:38

ThirtysomethingL · 22/04/2023 08:10

It's really not as monstrous as some people on here are suggesting... yes there are obviously healthier things you could be offering but there are also far worse things you could be giving them.

Actually there aren't many worse things than instant packet noodles with the sachets.

itsabigtree · 22/04/2023 08:12

Obviously dried noodles are fine. But instant noodles like indomite, soba, Nissan etc, whilst very tasty, are not for kids. They are actually banned in some countries. It's not real food.

Just fry your protein and veg. Boil your noodles and add some sauce. Sweet chili mixed with soy sauce and peanut butter ia quite nice. Or a soy bean paste from an Asian shop. Super quick and simple and 1000000 times healthier.

Anyone saying it's precious to demonize instant noodles for little kids, has lost sight of normality.

ThirtysomethingL · 22/04/2023 08:10

It's really not as monstrous as some people on here are suggesting... yes there are obviously healthier things you could be offering but there are also far worse things you could be giving them.

Buffypaws · 22/04/2023 08:08

Not just UPF but I’m now seeing that plastic is making us fat and infertile especially when heated - my steamer and rice cooker are both plastic 😫

brokenarmabroad · 22/04/2023 07:36

WinterDeWinter · 21/04/2023 16:57

Regardless of salt and fat - anything with preservatives, emulsifiers, sweeteners, and most stabilisers are toxic to your gut bacteria.

Pretty much every day new research is published which connects the state of our gut bacteria/microbiome with illnesses which, on the surface, have nothing to do with your gut.

For example, it's increasingly clear that what we eat has a direct impact on our mental health - particularly anxiety and depression. It's also looking likely that eating highly processed food like instant noodles causes changes in our brain which make us crave more highly processed food, with an inevitable impact on the likelihood that we will be obese, and all the health outcomes associated with that.

As someone said upthread - almost everything we've been taught about 'bad' food is wrong. Eat anything you like that is not processed - for eg. potatoes are great. The most important thing, the thing we should all burn into our brains and have tattooed on our hands is not to eat food that's been fucked with.

It's a nightmare massive shock to the system at first - even those of us that think we cook from scratch aren't really avoiding processed food, because most stock cubes, sauces and flavourings, even 'posh' ones, have got shit in them. Likewise other stuff - 'artisan' wraps for eg still have the same shit in as the cheapest own brand ones. It's all marketing, and it's cynical as fuck.

At first it made cooking insanely time consuming - but once I'd worked out which products I could use and sort of started a system in terms of what I could bulk cook and prep ahead, it's not so bad. I still feel a bit Amish, but it's not as bad as feeling like your fucking with your children's mental and physical health every time you give them something to eat.

Agree with all off this. It's easy to come across as a miserable joyless fucker on this stuff but ultra processed foods have been a disaster for our physical and mental health. After decades of ill researched and constantly changing guidance from vested interests and even health agencies like the NHS, I think people are slowly realising that UPF is the real problem.

As many people have pointed out there is a massive difference between regular egg noodles (processed) and instant noodles like pot noodles or suoernoodles (UPF).

I'm far, far from being a model parent, in fact I am probably too lax about a lot of stuff. But I am doing my best to remove UPF from their diets. It's bloody difficult though.

My2pence2day · 22/04/2023 07:33

WinterDeWinter · 21/04/2023 16:57

Regardless of salt and fat - anything with preservatives, emulsifiers, sweeteners, and most stabilisers are toxic to your gut bacteria.

Pretty much every day new research is published which connects the state of our gut bacteria/microbiome with illnesses which, on the surface, have nothing to do with your gut.

For example, it's increasingly clear that what we eat has a direct impact on our mental health - particularly anxiety and depression. It's also looking likely that eating highly processed food like instant noodles causes changes in our brain which make us crave more highly processed food, with an inevitable impact on the likelihood that we will be obese, and all the health outcomes associated with that.

As someone said upthread - almost everything we've been taught about 'bad' food is wrong. Eat anything you like that is not processed - for eg. potatoes are great. The most important thing, the thing we should all burn into our brains and have tattooed on our hands is not to eat food that's been fucked with.

It's a nightmare massive shock to the system at first - even those of us that think we cook from scratch aren't really avoiding processed food, because most stock cubes, sauces and flavourings, even 'posh' ones, have got shit in them. Likewise other stuff - 'artisan' wraps for eg still have the same shit in as the cheapest own brand ones. It's all marketing, and it's cynical as fuck.

At first it made cooking insanely time consuming - but once I'd worked out which products I could use and sort of started a system in terms of what I could bulk cook and prep ahead, it's not so bad. I still feel a bit Amish, but it's not as bad as feeling like your fucking with your children's mental and physical health every time you give them something to eat.

I agree with you. I wonder how many of the more recent issues, both mental and physical from the last 40ish years are due to diet. When I was growing up people didn't have allergies, now it's more a question if who doesn't

Bewilderedandhurt · 22/04/2023 06:59

Normal noodlesconlybtake 3mins to boil anyway. We use these and add in chicken and veg.
Instant noodle are ok for an occasional snack but i would imagine normal egg noodles would be a cheaper more nutritious option.

MeinKraft · 21/04/2023 20:48

@Comedycook the noodles labelled instant noodles seem to be the ones that come with flavouring. Maybe they don't consider plain noodles to be instant because you have to add flavouring or other stuff?

Atethehalloweenchocs · 21/04/2023 20:44

I once had to live on instant noodles for about 4 months (no home, only access to cooking at the hostel I was in was a hot water dispenser). I gained so much weight and was so ill - I did not realize quite how bad for you they are before then. Just use the regular egg noodles - probably cheaper too!

VincentVaguer · 21/04/2023 20:17

WinterDeWinter · 21/04/2023 16:57

Regardless of salt and fat - anything with preservatives, emulsifiers, sweeteners, and most stabilisers are toxic to your gut bacteria.

Pretty much every day new research is published which connects the state of our gut bacteria/microbiome with illnesses which, on the surface, have nothing to do with your gut.

For example, it's increasingly clear that what we eat has a direct impact on our mental health - particularly anxiety and depression. It's also looking likely that eating highly processed food like instant noodles causes changes in our brain which make us crave more highly processed food, with an inevitable impact on the likelihood that we will be obese, and all the health outcomes associated with that.

As someone said upthread - almost everything we've been taught about 'bad' food is wrong. Eat anything you like that is not processed - for eg. potatoes are great. The most important thing, the thing we should all burn into our brains and have tattooed on our hands is not to eat food that's been fucked with.

It's a nightmare massive shock to the system at first - even those of us that think we cook from scratch aren't really avoiding processed food, because most stock cubes, sauces and flavourings, even 'posh' ones, have got shit in them. Likewise other stuff - 'artisan' wraps for eg still have the same shit in as the cheapest own brand ones. It's all marketing, and it's cynical as fuck.

At first it made cooking insanely time consuming - but once I'd worked out which products I could use and sort of started a system in terms of what I could bulk cook and prep ahead, it's not so bad. I still feel a bit Amish, but it's not as bad as feeling like your fucking with your children's mental and physical health every time you give them something to eat.

Nests of dried noodles have not been fucked with.

Comedycook · 21/04/2023 17:09

MeinKraft · 21/04/2023 16:14

Supernoodles, Koka, Soba, that kind of thing. There's shelves and shelves of them in the supermarket because they're a perfectly normal food and especially beloved by children.

I know what noodles are but are those plain nests of egg/rice noodles considered to be "instant noodles". All I have to do with them is soak them in boiling water and then stir fry with meat/veg/prawns etc. I mean that's pretty instant.

WinterDeWinter · 21/04/2023 16:57

Regardless of salt and fat - anything with preservatives, emulsifiers, sweeteners, and most stabilisers are toxic to your gut bacteria.

Pretty much every day new research is published which connects the state of our gut bacteria/microbiome with illnesses which, on the surface, have nothing to do with your gut.

For example, it's increasingly clear that what we eat has a direct impact on our mental health - particularly anxiety and depression. It's also looking likely that eating highly processed food like instant noodles causes changes in our brain which make us crave more highly processed food, with an inevitable impact on the likelihood that we will be obese, and all the health outcomes associated with that.

As someone said upthread - almost everything we've been taught about 'bad' food is wrong. Eat anything you like that is not processed - for eg. potatoes are great. The most important thing, the thing we should all burn into our brains and have tattooed on our hands is not to eat food that's been fucked with.

It's a nightmare massive shock to the system at first - even those of us that think we cook from scratch aren't really avoiding processed food, because most stock cubes, sauces and flavourings, even 'posh' ones, have got shit in them. Likewise other stuff - 'artisan' wraps for eg still have the same shit in as the cheapest own brand ones. It's all marketing, and it's cynical as fuck.

At first it made cooking insanely time consuming - but once I'd worked out which products I could use and sort of started a system in terms of what I could bulk cook and prep ahead, it's not so bad. I still feel a bit Amish, but it's not as bad as feeling like your fucking with your children's mental and physical health every time you give them something to eat.

thenightsky · 21/04/2023 16:40

justasmalltownmum · 20/04/2023 22:26

I saw a video just the other day about how they did a study to show that pot noodles do not digest.

Wait... so if I use them as a replacement meal, it means it doesn't count as calories as it passes straight through me? Shock

MeinKraft · 21/04/2023 16:14

Comedycook · 21/04/2023 12:36

I don't know what the op means by instant noodles.

Supernoodles, Koka, Soba, that kind of thing. There's shelves and shelves of them in the supermarket because they're a perfectly normal food and especially beloved by children.

Pamandherpampams · 21/04/2023 16:01

weirdoboelady · 21/04/2023 14:36

The last sentence of this is the most helpful. Perhaps it would be more useful to the OP if instead of shouting about how awful instant ramen are, we provided some 'just as easy and just as cheap' meal solutions?

Mine would be

Yes, potatoes - blitzed in their jackets in a microwave with some baked beans on top and cheese if you can afford it.
An omlette
Bread soaked in egg and fried (French toast)
Cheese on toast
Very easy pea and ham soup made by adding fried bacon or ham to a tin of mushy peas, diluting with water and heated, served with bread
Almost anything from https://cookingonabootstrap.com/category/recipes-food/ some recipes more labour intensive than others but all pretty simple I think

Microwave and bacon in the same post? Why don’t you just throw your kids in a car of boiling oil and be done with them altogether!

weirdoboelady · 21/04/2023 14:36

Bucketheadbucketbum · 21/04/2023 13:59

So unbeliveably depressing people would feed this to their kids, even worse then try and defend it 😕 no wonder uk is one of the unhealthiest nations in the world

What's wrong with potatoes

The last sentence of this is the most helpful. Perhaps it would be more useful to the OP if instead of shouting about how awful instant ramen are, we provided some 'just as easy and just as cheap' meal solutions?

Mine would be

Yes, potatoes - blitzed in their jackets in a microwave with some baked beans on top and cheese if you can afford it.
An omlette
Bread soaked in egg and fried (French toast)
Cheese on toast
Very easy pea and ham soup made by adding fried bacon or ham to a tin of mushy peas, diluting with water and heated, served with bread
Almost anything from https://cookingonabootstrap.com/category/recipes-food/ some recipes more labour intensive than others but all pretty simple I think

Recipes & Food – COOKING ON A BOOTSTRAP

Posts about Recipes & Food written by Jack Monroe

https://cookingonabootstrap.com/category/recipes-food

BurbageBrook · 21/04/2023 14:31

The NHS is way behind on nutrition. White carbs eaten regularly are not great at any age. OP, no, it's not an acceptable regular dinner for a child.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 21/04/2023 14:01

Boughtitdownthemarket · 21/04/2023 13:14

I was brought up on frozen Pizzas, waffles and fish fingers. I think all the outrage about noodles is a bit ridiculous.

Disgusting. But a generation ago peopke were more ignorant of the harm these foods do.

We know better now.

Don't eat crap. It's not rocket science that eating shit = shit health

Bucketheadbucketbum · 21/04/2023 13:59

So unbeliveably depressing people would feed this to their kids, even worse then try and defend it 😕 no wonder uk is one of the unhealthiest nations in the world

What's wrong with potatoes

ModestMoon · 21/04/2023 13:57

If you mean the pre-made packet ones for microwave, I love them, but they're over processed and bad for you. Use either fresh noodles or dry noodles. Costs the same and is much better for you, only takes 4 mins to boil.