Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU feeding my kid instant noodles several times a week

293 replies

cooknwithbaby · 20/04/2023 21:48

I had dinner with my DS and my mum saw we were eating instant noodles with chicken soup and extra vegetable I added. She shamed me about feeding my DS instant noodles, saying it was unhealthy.

It's easy for me to make and everybody likes eating it. DS has loved noodles since he was 6 months old. I cook it several times a week. But I usually make it a bit healthier with broccoli. Sometimes I add a fried egg.

AIBU by feeding my kid some instant noodles for dinner?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
BebbanburgIsMine · 15/08/2023 15:57

@Davestwattymissus

Good one 🤣

PousseyNotMoira · 14/08/2023 07:08

kennycat · 13/08/2023 22:14

i think if you just do the noodle part without the sachet that’s almost the same as serving pasta isn’t it?! People have pasta several times a week. (Not sure why when potatoes are so flipping excellent!)

or am I wrong about the noodles on their own being not too bad?

Most instant noodles have been deep fried which is what makes them cook ‘instantly’, and the types of oil they use are often high in saturated fat. Even without the flavour packet (sodium bomb), they are pretty unhealthy.

Pasta is just flour and water (dried) or flour, water and eggs. Regular (non ‘instant’) noodles and pasta are pretty much the same, though.

kennycat · 13/08/2023 22:14

i think if you just do the noodle part without the sachet that’s almost the same as serving pasta isn’t it?! People have pasta several times a week. (Not sure why when potatoes are so flipping excellent!)

or am I wrong about the noodles on their own being not too bad?

Buffypaws · 25/04/2023 10:49

VeronicaTimeTurner · 23/04/2023 14:04

For anyone interested, this is a good app. You scan the food (& cosmetics) packet’s barcode and it tells you what harmful shit is in it. Quite an eye opener.
Don’t know if this link works but it’s on the App Store - YUKA

https://yuka.io/en/

Thank you I have downloaded this app - been after something like this for ages!

WinterDeWinter · 24/04/2023 14:56

VeronicaTimeTurner · 23/04/2023 14:04

For anyone interested, this is a good app. You scan the food (& cosmetics) packet’s barcode and it tells you what harmful shit is in it. Quite an eye opener.
Don’t know if this link works but it’s on the App Store - YUKA

https://yuka.io/en/

Thanks @VeronicaTimeTurner that looks really helpful.

On the subject of the cost of eating without additives, I've found that we spend about the same as we did when we were broadly 'cooking from scratch' using sauces, stock cubes, condiments etc which contained additives, plus having pizza once a week and probably another 'quality' ready meal. As I said, it's a massive PITA at the beginning while you're working it out but it gets a lot easier as you go on.

Critically, though, we were already spending more than average. What I absolutely couldn't do while also cutting out additives is to provide a very varied diet on a very low budget.

Ultimately, ultra processed food is much cheaper. And because it is sold in such huge numbers, with so little spoilage, it's incredibly profitable.

The upshot is that the NHS/the state is subsidising food industry corporations and their shareholders, who will not have to pick up the bill for the damage they are (knowingly) causing us all, and particularly poorer families.

PousseyNotMoira · 23/04/2023 18:20

JJWT · 23/04/2023 16:48

I wasn't going comment but omg what is going on with this post?? Some ppl are responding as if she's feeding pot noodle to a baby from a crack spoon. "Noodles" are DEFINITELY NOT equivalent to crisps. Good grief. Note to self: Do not post about food where the alpha mothers hang out. Even my cheap rectangular aldi ones only say 6% fat. 6% is not "full of fat". They also say 0.43g of salt but a lot of that will be in the little sachet. Maybe we need more info but i don't think hydrating dried noodles (how is that different nutritionally to cooking shop bought dried pasta, Persephone?!), and serving with chicken soup and veggies or sometimes adding an egg is that bad! I'm picturing a ramen bowl kinda vibe. Some people are picturing Maccies and Monster Munch several times a week, I feel.

If the op is still looking (I wouldn't be) I'd suggest maybe widening the repertoire with a bit of salmon. A chunk cut from an adult portion will microwave in seconds.

I agree "it's just noodles". Who is Michael?? 🤣

To use your example, a packet of Aldi own brand instant noodles (just the noodles, not the flavour packet) contains:

Noodles (94%) [𝐖𝐡𝐞𝐚𝐭 𝐅𝐥𝐨𝐮𝐫, Palm Oil, Sugar, Iodised Salt (Salt, Potassium Iodate)], Maltodextrin, Flavour Enhancers: Monosodium Glutamate, Disodium 5'-ribonucleotides; Sugar, Iodised Salt (Salt, Potassium Iodate)

A packet of Aldi own brand pasta contains:

Durum 𝐖𝐡𝐞𝐚𝐭 Semolina, Water.

That’s the difference. Noodles, in general, are fine and not really much different from most standard carb sources. Instant noodles are not the same thing, and have generally been fried and part of the production process. Even without the flavour packet, they are not food that should be consumed regularly - certainly not from six months onwards.

JJWT · 23/04/2023 16:48

I wasn't going comment but omg what is going on with this post?? Some ppl are responding as if she's feeding pot noodle to a baby from a crack spoon. "Noodles" are DEFINITELY NOT equivalent to crisps. Good grief. Note to self: Do not post about food where the alpha mothers hang out. Even my cheap rectangular aldi ones only say 6% fat. 6% is not "full of fat". They also say 0.43g of salt but a lot of that will be in the little sachet. Maybe we need more info but i don't think hydrating dried noodles (how is that different nutritionally to cooking shop bought dried pasta, Persephone?!), and serving with chicken soup and veggies or sometimes adding an egg is that bad! I'm picturing a ramen bowl kinda vibe. Some people are picturing Maccies and Monster Munch several times a week, I feel.

If the op is still looking (I wouldn't be) I'd suggest maybe widening the repertoire with a bit of salmon. A chunk cut from an adult portion will microwave in seconds.

I agree "it's just noodles". Who is Michael?? 🤣

VeronicaTimeTurner · 23/04/2023 14:04

For anyone interested, this is a good app. You scan the food (& cosmetics) packet’s barcode and it tells you what harmful shit is in it. Quite an eye opener.
Don’t know if this link works but it’s on the App Store - YUKA

https://yuka.io/en/

Yuka - The mobile app that scans your diet and cosmetics

Yuka is a mobile application that scan food products to get clear information on the health impact of the products you consume.

https://yuka.io/en/

DJT86 · 23/04/2023 11:45

Hello, noodles may be good for an occasion item but do not feel suitable for a regular dinner on there own . Are these the ones you cook on the hob or pour water over. Some are high in salt. A source or protein and vegetables could make them a meal but otherwise feel almost more of a quick snack. What about batch cooking and freezing?

leilani83 · 23/04/2023 11:10

firef1y · 23/04/2023 08:56

OFGS will some of you listen to yourselves.

Yeah it would be lovely if everybody could feed their children lovely homecooked field to plate meals. But you know what that isn't going to happen for various reasons.

  1. The child themselves may not eat it. My autistic child wouldn't touch a vegetable with a barge pole or most of my homecooked versions of processed foods either for that matter.

2 I'm lucky home ec was still a thing when I was at school, we were taught to cook healthy foods. I also had family that had time to involve me in cooking (I could and did cook a full roast dinner by the time I was in senior school). Home Ec is no longer a thing in schools and so many children/teens now have parents that both work meaning there was less time to teach them the cooking. (Plus less time to put a cooked from scratch meal on the table every night)

  1. For lots of people money is tight at the moment, there are people literally choosing between food and heat. Thankfully I'm in a good situation now, but I've been in that position. I've been in the position where I had to choose whether to have the lights on or cook a meal, the choice of whether I eat or my child eats was always a forgone conclusion. But I had to make a stupidly small amount of money stretch for food. Luckily I had parents/grandparents who had lived through rationing and had been taught ways to make a little go a long way. Lots of people in this situation now don't have that background.

Those of you harping on about how people who are doing their best to put food in their children's bellies (even if it's ultra processed food) are damaging them, reign yourselves in. You're making people who are already feeling shitty about the choices they are having to make feel even worse.

As for the op, depending on the type of instant noodle and whether you are using the "flavouring" sachet, there is nothing wrong with feeing them to your child several times a week as part of a balanced diet. My NT child loved noodles during the baby led weaning days, I used the nests that you just add to a pan of boiling water for a few minutes along with his veggies.

Feeding instant noodles to children several times a week is not a balanced diet. They are simply not a healthy choice. And dry noodles and instant noodles are different things. I really think the mostly time-pressured/cash-strapped parent can manage better than regular instant noodles.

WinterDeWinter · 23/04/2023 10:41

Sorry miss. There is potassium carbonate in the noodles. The study suggests a deleterious impact on the microbiome by potassium and sodium. Thanks miss.

FurAndFeathers · 23/04/2023 09:11

WinterDeWinter · 21/04/2023 20:24

Well you'd think. But:

  • IngredientsWheat Flour, Pasteurised Egg (2%), Salt, Acidity Regulator (Potassium Carbonate)

and: Associations of sodium and potassium consumption with the gut microbiota and host metabolites in a population-based study in Chinese adults

@WinterDeWinter could you please explain how the study you’ve linked relates to the ingredient list in the noodles and what the relationship is between the two.

simply posting two random unrelated pieces of information shows nothing.

Frenchtoastie · 23/04/2023 09:01

Read the ingredients on the back of the packet. If you don’t know what they all are you should not be eating this regularly, let alone giving it to your children

firef1y · 23/04/2023 08:56

OFGS will some of you listen to yourselves.

Yeah it would be lovely if everybody could feed their children lovely homecooked field to plate meals. But you know what that isn't going to happen for various reasons.

  1. The child themselves may not eat it. My autistic child wouldn't touch a vegetable with a barge pole or most of my homecooked versions of processed foods either for that matter.

2 I'm lucky home ec was still a thing when I was at school, we were taught to cook healthy foods. I also had family that had time to involve me in cooking (I could and did cook a full roast dinner by the time I was in senior school). Home Ec is no longer a thing in schools and so many children/teens now have parents that both work meaning there was less time to teach them the cooking. (Plus less time to put a cooked from scratch meal on the table every night)

  1. For lots of people money is tight at the moment, there are people literally choosing between food and heat. Thankfully I'm in a good situation now, but I've been in that position. I've been in the position where I had to choose whether to have the lights on or cook a meal, the choice of whether I eat or my child eats was always a forgone conclusion. But I had to make a stupidly small amount of money stretch for food. Luckily I had parents/grandparents who had lived through rationing and had been taught ways to make a little go a long way. Lots of people in this situation now don't have that background.

Those of you harping on about how people who are doing their best to put food in their children's bellies (even if it's ultra processed food) are damaging them, reign yourselves in. You're making people who are already feeling shitty about the choices they are having to make feel even worse.

As for the op, depending on the type of instant noodle and whether you are using the "flavouring" sachet, there is nothing wrong with feeing them to your child several times a week as part of a balanced diet. My NT child loved noodles during the baby led weaning days, I used the nests that you just add to a pan of boiling water for a few minutes along with his veggies.

Nimbostratus100 · 23/04/2023 07:53

Phoebo · 22/04/2023 08:38

Actually there aren't many worse things than instant packet noodles with the sachets.

agreed

carriedout · 22/04/2023 23:09

WinterDeWinter · 22/04/2023 23:00

its true that if you use most supermarket ham - even ‘naice ham’ - and most bread, you’d be doing a lot more damage than most of us would generally realise. For eg mono- and diglyverides of fatty acids in hovis white. Nitrates and nitrites in waitrose own brand Wiltshire Ham.

Not as shite as instant noodles though.

Processed meat is worse than instant noodles.

WinterDeWinter · 22/04/2023 23:00

its true that if you use most supermarket ham - even ‘naice ham’ - and most bread, you’d be doing a lot more damage than most of us would generally realise. For eg mono- and diglyverides of fatty acids in hovis white. Nitrates and nitrites in waitrose own brand Wiltshire Ham.

Not as shite as instant noodles though.

ThirtysomethingL · 22/04/2023 18:51

Phoebo · 22/04/2023 08:38

Actually there aren't many worse things than instant packet noodles with the sachets.

Just as an example a cheese and ham sandwich contains a similar amount of salt, and many parents make sandwiches daily for thier kids

Oli83 · 22/04/2023 12:04

I'm not sure many people know but instant noodles are deep fried before packaging so they are not really the equivalent of pasta. There is also some debate whether they have a high trans fat content - a particularly bad form of fat. Saying that I think as an easy meal they are great as long as you make sure there's an egg or some other protein in there, veggies and like others say avoid the sachet and put in a low sodium msg free stock cube for children

brokenarmabroad · 22/04/2023 11:41

JazbayGrapes · 22/04/2023 11:36

ok, everyone knows they are not exactly healthy foods. But what if your kid is a food refuser? And its one of very few things they would eat?

That's different issue, though. There is a big difference between knowing UPF is shit but trying to balance that against the need to feed a child with genuine food refusal, and mistakenly thinking that suoernoodles nutritionally equivalent to pasta or potatoes.

JazbayGrapes · 22/04/2023 11:36

ok, everyone knows they are not exactly healthy foods. But what if your kid is a food refuser? And its one of very few things they would eat?

PollyThePixie · 22/04/2023 10:48

WinterDeWinter · 22/04/2023 08:31

This is good, from the doctor that @PollyThePixie mentioned upthread. DR CHRIS VAN TULLEKEN: What happened when I ate ultra processed food? In the mail today

Yes. That’s the book I’ve pre-ordered. Not that I eat much processed food at all. I’m a cook from scratch cook. But I thought I’d read it out of curiosity on the back of this thread.

Doubletroublemummy2 · 22/04/2023 09:24

It's impossible to answer this without knowing the rest of your child's of your child's diet. If they get daily fruit and veg intake for the rest of their meals/ snacks? Are you preparing the noodles without the added flavouring? What is the soup you provide? Tinned/homemade? How much salt/sodium is in their daily intake? Do they get vitamins and minerals elsewhere? What is the portion size? If you ensure that their daily diet is balanced and varied and the way you prepare and serve the noodles fits with this then no, yanu. If everything else is also high carb, high fat, high salt and highly processed then maybe it warrants a rethink of their diet generally. Its tough having to come up with stuff that's going be good for them and then do all the prep etc and then hope they'll eat what you give them. Personally I think its the hardest part of parenting 😕.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 22/04/2023 09:09

No, I am not. I just get annoyed by this- I don't want to say appropriation- but sort of "Look what I discovered" stuff from Western gurus. So many influencers touting superfoods they borrowed from other cultures. Some miracle stew made its way onto my social media feed the other day, and then it turned out to be the staple food of billions: beans. Not baked beans.

Anyway, ignore me.

VincentVaguer · 22/04/2023 09:07

WinterDeWinter · 22/04/2023 09:05

You seem to be implying that van tulleken has some kind of nefarious motivation in bringing the damage that ultra processed foods cause to light which is … weird. His whole point is that barely any of us eat like your mother does and barely any of us understand the impacts of that fact.

He is a bit of a crashing bore though let's face it. I do get it, but he's like a one trick pony.