Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you could choose your baby’s sex for free, would you?

192 replies

Lelophants · 20/04/2023 20:45

Interesting discussion with a friend earlier. She knows two people who flew to USA to do ivf and select their preferred sex of baby (both boys - they had girls already). Clearly they were also v wealthy.

If it was completely free for anyone to do ivf and choose your baby’s sex, would you do it?

YABU - I would never do it
YANBU - ooh I would do this

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 21/04/2023 20:16

Phoebo · 21/04/2023 01:54

But aren't you "playing God" anyway if you're doing IVF? What difference does it make if you pick which embryo to use? I know it seems weird, but the whole thing is weird when you really think about it because you are choosing anyway

Because you are turning IVF from a treatment for infertility into a way to create designer families.

And in some countries it would have the same effect as sex selective abortion, which I hope most people would agree is abhorrent. I suppose it's arguable that allowing people to choose the sex of their baby might reduce sex selective abortion, which would be a good thing, although only in families rich enough to pay for private IVF, so probably not that much overall.

But if it did become accessible to the population at large, you would have the same kind of population issues that exist in cultures where sex selective abortion is prevalent, and on a larger scale, because many people who would not abort a healthy foetus at a fairly late stage just for being the "wrong" sex would have no ethical concerns about selecting an embryo of the "correct" sex.

GooglyEyeballs · 21/04/2023 20:10

I would pick one of each if I could

CocoPlum · 21/04/2023 20:05

lifeturnsonadime · 21/04/2023 14:51

I don't think either reason is a good enough reason for commercial sex selection.

What a shame that you didn't think you could be a good parent to a boy, I'm glad your DS has proved that wrong.

I don't think they are good enough reasons, I was speculating on the reason why girls may be seen as "preferred". the OP was asking if you could, would you, and I think we're answering honestly, but most of the replies I read before replying were similar "i would have, but I'm so glad I couldn't because DC is actually the best". And I am so glad to have a boy now 😁

Lelophants · 21/04/2023 18:08

Zanatdy · 21/04/2023 07:53

I would have yes. I had 2 boys first and desperately wanted a daughter, my 3rd was to be my final child regardless of gender. I went into a rabbit hole world of gender swaying, joined a forum and spent hours and hours researching and perfecting my sway. The stress was unreal, especially after I got pregnant. I must add that I wanted a 3rd child regardless and I’ve have loved that baby regardless of gender. Anyway it was a girl and I was delighted. If someone had offered me to have the IVF gender selection instead of go through all of that, hell yes I’d have done it.

There’s a lot of stigma around parents wanting a preference for a child and I haven’t read the comments on this thread yet but can guarantee what they will say. But gender disappointment is a real thing and made worse by societies response to it, be grateful you can have a child etc. But its a real thing and can cause genuine depression.

Agreed. And so many people on mumsnet cough feminist forum cough go on about how much difference there is biologically that there is a reason people have these feelings and it’s not just to do with clothing.

OP posts:
AllOfThemWitches · 21/04/2023 17:51

Yousee · 21/04/2023 15:58

3 boys here. I'd make DS1 not diabetic, DS2 not dead and I could live with DS3 being a better sleeper but apart from that I'd not change a hair on their heads. Baffled that any mother would.

❤️

summerpoolandsun · 21/04/2023 17:22

Wednesdaysotherchild · 21/04/2023 15:53

We’re doing IVF but obv can’t chose in UK. A part of me would prefer girls tbh, so I’d consider it - but we barely get any genetically normal embryos so are unlikely to have the option or choice!

I’d be hugely overjoyed and grateful with just one healthy baby of either sex (unlikely for us sadly!)

IVF sways to boys slightly as the male embryos grow faster so are more likely to have made blastocyst by day 5, apparently. Interesting!

Best of luck @Wednesdaysotherchild We only got one genetically normal embryo from two rounds of IVF and it luckily worked. I was just going through the motions to say to myself in ten years time ‘I did everything I could’…I really hope it works for you and you get your miracle x

Beezknees · 21/04/2023 16:40

Nope. I struggle to understand gender disappointment as well to be honest, it's not a shop where you can pick and choose.

Yousee · 21/04/2023 15:58

3 boys here. I'd make DS1 not diabetic, DS2 not dead and I could live with DS3 being a better sleeper but apart from that I'd not change a hair on their heads. Baffled that any mother would.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 21/04/2023 15:57

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/04/2023 15:11

Yes I agree. Whilst I’m completely pro choice, I don’t agree with creating embryos deliberately to destroy them.

Most of the embryos die early on anyhow - of 40-something embryos we have created, only 7 survived 5 days (3 of which will never make it as they are abnormal). And in transferring an embryo you only have a low % of it surviving to pregnancy. It’s 100 cells at blastocyst stage.

They use the leftover embryos for medical research or practice for embryologists if consent is given so nothing is wasted.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 21/04/2023 15:53

We’re doing IVF but obv can’t chose in UK. A part of me would prefer girls tbh, so I’d consider it - but we barely get any genetically normal embryos so are unlikely to have the option or choice!

I’d be hugely overjoyed and grateful with just one healthy baby of either sex (unlikely for us sadly!)

IVF sways to boys slightly as the male embryos grow faster so are more likely to have made blastocyst by day 5, apparently. Interesting!

itsserendipity · 21/04/2023 15:45

No. I understand that many people have gender disappointment but I think this is highly unethical. Often there's an ingrained preference for sons in many societies, and this sort of practice would create problems. (Just look at what happened in China with the one child policy).

lozrox90 · 21/04/2023 15:18

As my first DC was a boy, I probably would have chosen for my second to have been a girl, just so I had one of each. I'm a girly girl and would have liked to have had a daughter. Two boys for me though and I wouldn't change them for the world, love them both with all I have!

SlashBeef · 21/04/2023 15:12

I don't know. If I was desperate for one or the other maybe I would. I have two of each and people have often said "ooh well done!" as if I had some control in it!
I don't want to diminish people's very really feelings with regards gender disappointment so although I feel like I wouldn't chose, I don’t know how I'd feel in a different situation.

Tigofigo · 21/04/2023 15:12

I would maybe have chosen a girl as already had a boy to experience one of each, ended up with two boys. In hindsight it's great I didn't as I don't think they'd be as close as one of each.

I also don't project my own shit onto them as much as I might with a daughter!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/04/2023 15:11

MushroomQueen · 21/04/2023 07:56

This!

Yes I agree. Whilst I’m completely pro choice, I don’t agree with creating embryos deliberately to destroy them.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 21/04/2023 15:10

I wouldn’t but then I don’t think I can judge as I got what I vaguely thought and even more vaguely sort of wanted each time (a girl and then a boy). But there is so much else about a child other than their sex, it sort of becomes irrelevant. It’s just that it’s the only thing we really know about them at that stage that makes it seem like a big deal.

AllOfThemWitches · 21/04/2023 15:09

Women want girls so they can live vicariously through them, no matter how much they try to dress it up as a very reasonable desire.

mumonthehill · 21/04/2023 14:59

I really wanted a dd when i was pregnant first time, but i am so very glad i did not have the choice as i have 2 ds and i would not change this for anything.

Yuja · 21/04/2023 14:57

No way. A step too far I would never have done this

Drlovestrong · 21/04/2023 14:57

VestaTilley · 20/04/2023 20:53

No. I think it’s obscene and highly unethical.

A thousand times, this.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/04/2023 14:54

@Coffeeandbourbons girls are just as likely to be autistic as boys. They are just massively under-diagnosed.

My DD is autistic.

My DS is also autistic but he's doesn't have behavioural problems 🙄

lifeturnsonadime · 21/04/2023 14:51

CocoPlum · 21/04/2023 14:48

Do you think though this preference is coming from women who want to recreate or repair thr relationship they had with their own mother, or who think they will understand a female child better? For me, I always felt awkward around boys growing up and still find women mostly easier to talk to, I couldn't imagine being a parent to a boy!

I don't think either reason is a good enough reason for commercial sex selection.

What a shame that you didn't think you could be a good parent to a boy, I'm glad your DS has proved that wrong.

summerpoolandsun · 21/04/2023 14:51

Coffeeandbourbons · 21/04/2023 08:56

Why is this? Lots of posters are saying what their preference would be but not why, and it’s usually girls.

I have 2 DC, first a girl second a boy. I had a very strong preference for a girl first time, and a mild preference for another girl the second time. Of course now I have baby DS I wouldn’t trade him for any number of girls!

For me it’s because girls seemed a much safer bet - much less likely to be violent or get into crime, or have autism or other behavioural problems. My relationship with my dad is basically non existent as he’s an alcoholic, I didn’t grow up with any good male role models.

I had to do a bit of talking to myself and remind myself that DS is half DH who I adore, and is a completely new person who will be raised away from the toxic males in my family. After that settled in I got excited to meet him and of course when he was born the worries just melted away, I couldn’t love him any more now.

But I do wonder if it’s this ‘men are violent/sexist/perverts’ and toxic masculinity narrative that makes women reluctant to raise boys, rather than specifically wanting girls. If that makes sense.

The points you make are really interesting. I wanted two boys but for the same reasons in reverse, that I didn’t want a girl to potentially go through abuse, violence etc. And thought any boys I had would be mini versions of DH who is decent and a gentlemen. It’s always scared me to have a girl in case they get hurt, I just feel like they are so much more vulnerable. I know that I got into some awful situations when younger and it scares me she’ll go through the same…

I have one DS and pregnant with a DD, I’m already thinking about self defence courses for her! Want her to grow up feeling like she can deal with anything.

CocoPlum · 21/04/2023 14:48

lifeturnsonadime · 21/04/2023 14:40

No, it's unethical which is why it is unlawful in so many countries.

Why should only wealthy people be able to pay for designer babies?

What happens if you pay for a girl, and she doesn't turn out to be girly enough, can you request a refund?

I think it's so interesting that in the UK most indicate that they have a preference for a girl where in large parts of the world female babies have been abandoned or murdered because of their sex.

Do you think though this preference is coming from women who want to recreate or repair thr relationship they had with their own mother, or who think they will understand a female child better? For me, I always felt awkward around boys growing up and still find women mostly easier to talk to, I couldn't imagine being a parent to a boy!

CocoPlum · 21/04/2023 14:44

Before I had children/before I had baby 2, I would probably have chosen girls (baby 1 was a girl). And that would have been a real shame because until DC2 i never would have thought I'd want to be a boy mum but I love it!