Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you could choose your baby’s sex for free, would you?

192 replies

Lelophants · 20/04/2023 20:45

Interesting discussion with a friend earlier. She knows two people who flew to USA to do ivf and select their preferred sex of baby (both boys - they had girls already). Clearly they were also v wealthy.

If it was completely free for anyone to do ivf and choose your baby’s sex, would you do it?

YABU - I would never do it
YANBU - ooh I would do this

OP posts:
Lelophants · 25/04/2023 18:22

@SallyWD you’re thinking of white middle class women. That is not a lot of the population.

OP posts:
Lelophants · 25/04/2023 18:21

SallyWD · 25/04/2023 09:46

More or less every single female friend I have, had a preference for having a girl. I only know one woman who wanted a boy for her third. This was after almost having a nervous breakdown when she found out her second was a boy. Once she had him she adored him and wanted another boy! I know so many mums of girls and these are genuine quotes from some women I know: "When the sonographer told me it was a girl I cried with relief.", "I'm so relieved I have 3 girls and not three boys. Thank God!", "I'm going to keep having babies until I get my girl." "Little girls are so much better than boys". One colleague of mine had to take 2 months off work as she was so distressed about having a boy!! Of course it's fine to have a preference but these comments annoy me and I find it rather rude that they say these things to me - as I'm a mother of a wonderful son!

I do think most women in this country would prefer a girl. Obviously once they have their boys they love them. I'm not speaking for me personally by the way.

It depends on your social group.

OP posts:
Peppadog · 25/04/2023 18:01

MargotBamborough · 25/04/2023 17:53

Is the reason "because people are idiots"?

🤣

Peppadog · 25/04/2023 18:00

yoga4meinthemorning · 25/04/2023 17:50

A sons a son until he gets a wife, a daughter's a daughter for life.

There's a reason this ^ is a phrase.

I think this phrase is total sexist nonsense, but it is more likely to come true if you believe it.
I do see lots of mums of boys taking no interest in their sons interests and in those cases I can imagine it might work out that way.
My auntie has two sons who she sees most weeks who literally dote on her. My DH has two brothers and a sister. The sister lives over the other side of the world and sees her parents once a year, one son lives down the road and the other son visits every holiday. My brother sees my mum every week.
This is a phrase I've heard many a time but not something Ive witnessed hardly at all in real life. if anything the most complicated and often toxic relationships have often been mother daughter

HistoryFanatic · 25/04/2023 17:55

AlmostAJillSandwich · 25/04/2023 17:10

If i have a child, i 100% favour having a boy, but would love either sex equally.
I don't agree with IVF, so no i wouldn't have it at all, not even as a way to ensure i had a boy.

Thankfully IVF exists and I have the girl and boy I wouldn't have had because I would still be dealing with the infertility.

MargotBamborough · 25/04/2023 17:53

yoga4meinthemorning · 25/04/2023 17:50

A sons a son until he gets a wife, a daughter's a daughter for life.

There's a reason this ^ is a phrase.

Is the reason "because people are idiots"?

yoga4meinthemorning · 25/04/2023 17:50

A sons a son until he gets a wife, a daughter's a daughter for life.

There's a reason this ^ is a phrase.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 25/04/2023 17:10

If i have a child, i 100% favour having a boy, but would love either sex equally.
I don't agree with IVF, so no i wouldn't have it at all, not even as a way to ensure i had a boy.

Coffeeandbourbons · 25/04/2023 17:08

Peppadog · 25/04/2023 17:08

That's so sad

I just thought that as well

Peppadog · 25/04/2023 17:08

FirstTimeBuyersHelp · 25/04/2023 17:03

Yes. I'd have had another if I could have guaranteed a girl.

But stopped as I couldn't.

That's so sad

FirstTimeBuyersHelp · 25/04/2023 17:03

Yes. I'd have had another if I could have guaranteed a girl.

But stopped as I couldn't.

Peppadog · 25/04/2023 17:02

SallyWD · 25/04/2023 09:46

More or less every single female friend I have, had a preference for having a girl. I only know one woman who wanted a boy for her third. This was after almost having a nervous breakdown when she found out her second was a boy. Once she had him she adored him and wanted another boy! I know so many mums of girls and these are genuine quotes from some women I know: "When the sonographer told me it was a girl I cried with relief.", "I'm so relieved I have 3 girls and not three boys. Thank God!", "I'm going to keep having babies until I get my girl." "Little girls are so much better than boys". One colleague of mine had to take 2 months off work as she was so distressed about having a boy!! Of course it's fine to have a preference but these comments annoy me and I find it rather rude that they say these things to me - as I'm a mother of a wonderful son!

I do think most women in this country would prefer a girl. Obviously once they have their boys they love them. I'm not speaking for me personally by the way.

Don't forget for every woman that wants a girl there is usually a man that wants a boy. It seems to be quite natural to want a child that is more likely to share your interests.
Of course in reality it rarely plays out that way and actually the best relationships are when an adult sees their child as a human being rather than a gender and gets to know them and their interests. It's usually personality driven who gets on best with who.
My closest friend is a woman and is desperate for boys, so it's not always the case that women want girls, maybe the ones that are girlie and are only friends with other women.
My closest friendship groups have always been through sport or uni and are mixed sex, so the women tend to value male friendships and therefore are just as keen to have boys as girls.

Deadringer · 25/04/2023 10:19

I did hope for at least one girl, but I didn't really mind what I had and liked the randomness of it so it would be a no for me.

justpushingthrough · 25/04/2023 10:15

I have 3 girls, all a surprise at birth so never found out the gender.

If i was to have a 4th and if i could choose then id choose another girl.

BUT i would never find out the gender and would be absolutely delighted for a healthy baby boy.

I completely understand gender preference, its a genuine thing and doesn't mean people are ungrateful, telling people they should be ashamed or are being ridiculous is the same as telling someone with mental health to get it together.

I know a few people that had severe gender disappointment but when baby was born that all disapeared.

If i had my way....i would not allow anyone to find out the gender until birth.

CeriB82 · 25/04/2023 10:07

Absolutely not.

be thankful for what you’re getting.

SallyWD · 25/04/2023 09:46

Lelophants · 25/04/2023 08:39

I wouldn’t say that’s nationwide. Mumsnet attracts women and feminists especially.

In real life most people I know still wanted boys.

More or less every single female friend I have, had a preference for having a girl. I only know one woman who wanted a boy for her third. This was after almost having a nervous breakdown when she found out her second was a boy. Once she had him she adored him and wanted another boy! I know so many mums of girls and these are genuine quotes from some women I know: "When the sonographer told me it was a girl I cried with relief.", "I'm so relieved I have 3 girls and not three boys. Thank God!", "I'm going to keep having babies until I get my girl." "Little girls are so much better than boys". One colleague of mine had to take 2 months off work as she was so distressed about having a boy!! Of course it's fine to have a preference but these comments annoy me and I find it rather rude that they say these things to me - as I'm a mother of a wonderful son!

I do think most women in this country would prefer a girl. Obviously once they have their boys they love them. I'm not speaking for me personally by the way.

Lelophants · 25/04/2023 08:39

HistoryFanatic · 25/04/2023 07:13

Most threads that have someone disappointed about the sex tends to be that they are having a boy.

I wouldn’t say that’s nationwide. Mumsnet attracts women and feminists especially.

In real life most people I know still wanted boys.

OP posts:
LT2 · 25/04/2023 08:07

HistoryFanatic · 25/04/2023 07:13

Most threads that have someone disappointed about the sex tends to be that they are having a boy.

Hmm. Probably because there are more women here on MN than men. Doubt it's a National thing. I'm sure there's plenty of fathers who hope for a boy over a girl too.

HistoryFanatic · 25/04/2023 07:13

LT2 · 25/04/2023 06:59

@Coffeeandbourbons why do you think most would choose girls?🤔

Most threads that have someone disappointed about the sex tends to be that they are having a boy.

LT2 · 25/04/2023 06:59

@Coffeeandbourbons why do you think most would choose girls?🤔

Coffeeandbourbons · 22/04/2023 18:18

No it couldn’t work practically. In the U.K. I think most people would choose girls - then what? It would actually end up a much better life for the few boys around, with their novelty factor and their pick of girlfriends/jobs. The girls would have much worse lives with huge competition for a boyfriend or husband, many would end up single for life.

Ok it’s a hypothetical question but interesting to think of the consequences!

Hawkins003 · 22/04/2023 18:01

Yes. And if the technology was available, also a range of genetic enhancements

Isitsixoclockalready · 21/04/2023 20:54

Makes it seem rather mechanical. People can get obsessed with whether it's a boy or girl and considering that we're presumably against gender stereotyping, I don't see what difference it makes.

MargotBamborough · 21/04/2023 20:47

Lelophants · 21/04/2023 20:42

I agree that it could cause problems and also once you pick the sex, you start choosing all other sorts of qualities. Then some will become more desirable than others and there will be this awful thing of designer babies.

But I also hate sex selected abortions so if would be nice to stop that!

Well I don't think it would stop that.

Sex selective abortions most frequently happen in highly patriarchal cultures with largely poor populations and repressive laws, neither of which are conducive to free IVF with preimplantation genetic screening being offered to anyone who wants it.

Lelophants · 21/04/2023 20:42

MargotBamborough · 21/04/2023 20:16

Because you are turning IVF from a treatment for infertility into a way to create designer families.

And in some countries it would have the same effect as sex selective abortion, which I hope most people would agree is abhorrent. I suppose it's arguable that allowing people to choose the sex of their baby might reduce sex selective abortion, which would be a good thing, although only in families rich enough to pay for private IVF, so probably not that much overall.

But if it did become accessible to the population at large, you would have the same kind of population issues that exist in cultures where sex selective abortion is prevalent, and on a larger scale, because many people who would not abort a healthy foetus at a fairly late stage just for being the "wrong" sex would have no ethical concerns about selecting an embryo of the "correct" sex.

I agree that it could cause problems and also once you pick the sex, you start choosing all other sorts of qualities. Then some will become more desirable than others and there will be this awful thing of designer babies.

But I also hate sex selected abortions so if would be nice to stop that!

OP posts: