Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand the "entertainment value" of true crime

205 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 20/04/2023 19:35

I understand the enjoyment of murder mysteries, excitement, interesting characters, mystery aspect etc.

I dont understand the "enjoyment" of "true crime" where real people have suffered and died and been bereaved. The thread about Jonbenet for example, why are people enjoying "documentaries" and feeling they can speak authoritvly about the death a poor little girl, thousands of miles away about which they in reality know nothing, but feel like they can slag of members of her family anyway?

Ive just gone onto itv player to find something to while away a few hours, and find myself being offer a whole plethera of "true crime" stuff. No thanks, what on earth is fun or relaxing being a spectator to other people's grief, pain and misery?

I just dont understand what sort of person enjoys that. I hope you will enjoy it just as much if you are ever the subject of one of these dramas.

OP posts:
lemonchiffonpie · 22/04/2023 02:59

I was deeply invested in the NXIVM case. Some situations are just so puzzling, one wants to understand the human nature involved. I don't think it is "entertainment", but an obsessive interest perhaps, in those discussing cases - particularly those without resolution.

EustaceTheMonk · 22/04/2023 02:38

For some odd reason, while I agree as far as modern day crimes are concerned, I find accounts of historic crimes fascinating.

MissMissive · 22/04/2023 02:11

The Fall was also way too gratuitous on that side.

MissMissive · 22/04/2023 02:11

DuesToTheDirt · 21/04/2023 21:07

@Nounoufgs I now turn off any serial milker type mystery especially if they linger on unclothes female corpses. Not for me.

I started watching Spiral recently - late to the party, but everyone said how good it was. The first episode had long lingering shots of a naked female body, with one of the detectives saying she had obviously been murdered because she was so beautiful. WTF. There is a lot of misogyny in crime dramas, with a definite preference for young, attractive female victimes, but that took the biscuit and I didn't watch any more of it.

I struggled with this one, and couldn’t look away as needed to read the subtitles!

HighInfidelity · 22/04/2023 01:06

CampsieGlamper · 20/04/2023 20:16

I wonder if some of it is "shows you crime does not pay, the baddie gets caught" and conversely "that's why it's dangerous to go out, to be a "naughty/cheap/immoral" girl" or "well proves all men are bastards". The poor victims are almost always female, the perpetrator is always male, mostly white, mostly always romantically (often only in his mind) involved past tense with the victim.

I don’t think this is always true. There’s a big market for shows like Women Who Kill and people are very interested in the likes of Aileen Wuornos and Beverley Allitt. In cases of couples who kill there is often more interest in the woman - I would imagine more people know the name Karla Homolka than know the name Paul Bernardo despite them killing together. Perpetrators are certainly not always male and most serial killers don’t see themselves as romantically linked to their victims.

I have an interest in crime in general from a psychological perspective. I have a degree in psychology so that probably isn’t particularly unusual. I also have more interest in women’s crimes as they’re less common and crime tends to be researched from a male perspective. Women’s motives tend to be different and I’ve worked in female forensic services so this is more of an interest to me.

Nat6999 · 22/04/2023 00:27

I like true crime from the social history point of view, the same with disasters like Hillsborough, seeing how the politicians react & how history has been changed by things like the Hillsborough Independent Panel report.

DuesToTheDirt · 21/04/2023 21:07

@Nounoufgs I now turn off any serial milker type mystery especially if they linger on unclothes female corpses. Not for me.

I started watching Spiral recently - late to the party, but everyone said how good it was. The first episode had long lingering shots of a naked female body, with one of the detectives saying she had obviously been murdered because she was so beautiful. WTF. There is a lot of misogyny in crime dramas, with a definite preference for young, attractive female victimes, but that took the biscuit and I didn't watch any more of it.

MissMissive · 21/04/2023 20:34

I also think a number of podcasts are doing a great job of shining light on coercive control and violence against women and girls. It’s not glorifying it to talk about it.

somedogsdo · 21/04/2023 19:26

I don't know about the particular one you mentioned. But I find things like the Netflix series I Am A Killer fascinating. I don't find it macarbe more morally and socially interesting to see inside the minds of people who have committed murder and hear their stories and weigh up the whole nature vs nurture when it comes to sociopathic behaviour. Some of the stories are awful and feel like society has really failed these people. Others just don't seem to grasp the moral code. But then you ask if that's a problem with their brain development is it really their fault? Fascinating stuff and cause of much debate in our house. But then my job involves behaviour change and my son is studying psychology so possibly we're an odd household in that regard.
I also like to see the inner workings of police investigations as they gather evidence.

OrlandointheWilderness · 21/04/2023 17:00

Psychologically even... 😂 long day!

OrlandointheWilderness · 21/04/2023 16:58

Psychology it fascinates us because we are trying to comprehend a threat to our survival. It's a normal part of the human psyche.

Choconut · 21/04/2023 15:20

I'm always interested in why the perpetrator did it, what led up to the crime itself. Looking at their backstory and the impact it had, abuse, neglect, drug addiction. I've been watching the 'I am a killer' series on netflix and their childhoods are often horrific. One girl was raped several times by different men as a black 13 year old and although the rapes were reported nothing was done. Most had awful parents - alcoholics, drug addicts, in and out of prison - and many had been sexually abused as a child.

Funkyslippers · 21/04/2023 15:07

I'm currently addicted to Faking It:Tears of a Crime. It's about famous crimes and experts commenting on their body language etc. It's really interesting to see how the criminals basically gave themselves away in interviews etc. I don't like hearing the details of the crimes but it's satisfying to know that the criminals were not too clever for the police even though they thought they were

MissMissive · 21/04/2023 15:04

I don’t like hearing grisly details of the crime but like others, I do find the police / detective work interesting.

It’s the tenacity behind it sometimes and the justice for victims. For instance, the story behind Unbelievable. It made me cry when finally two female officers believed a rape victim who had had her life ruined by firstly the rape, but secondly the police officers who didn’t believe her. The female officers believed her and the other victims and doggedly tracked down the perpetrator.

There are other podcasts where victims and family have been let down by the police and the podcast itself is the catalyst for resolution.

I agree that the flippant ‘don’t get murdered’ stuff is distasteful.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 21/04/2023 14:57

For me - and I'm not a true devotee, I just find myself watching them - it's the neatness of the ending. I only watch solved crime (and also inexplicably strange crimes/happenings, but those are different). The bad person gets caught and prosecuted and there's an ending. I don't like shows which feature open-ended cases; I like the feeling that justice is done.

I also think that, in a small way, it keeps the names of the victims alive.

haze2003purple · 21/04/2023 14:49

It’s the psychological aspect for me. Wondering why someone ends up doing atrocious things and how we can stop it happening and how we as a society can spot signs in a person before they do something.

Tessisme · 21/04/2023 14:20

I love anything crime related. Dramas. Docudramas. Documentaries. I am especially fascinated by how real life crimes are solved - the forensics, the police procedures, the way some crimes are solved almost by accident. I have no interest in ongoing unsolved cases or theories/conspiracy theories, nasty gossip and conjecture.

LuvSmallDogs · 21/04/2023 12:58

I mainly find the methods of catching/gathering evidence on killers interesting - I also find documentaries/podcasts about taking down con artists and such just as good, but they're thinner on the ground.

Occasionally the thing about a case that stands out will be how it could've been prevented (stalking victim who has begged police for help beforehand) or a motive that's just bizarre (giving your neighbour heavy metal poisoning over noise/BBQ quibbles), but I'm here for the detective work!

I don't like the serial killer fanboys and fan girls, there is some truly distasteful Etsy merch out there for the likes of Manson, Ramirez etc.

Then there's the people who post the most outlandish theories thinking everyone is getting trafficked, or that there's no way someone could just get lost in a load of woodland and freeze when they're drunk and it's winter, there's no way people who have gone missing near deep flowing water could've drowned...I stay away from online discussions for the most part, bad for my blood pressure!

Catshaveiteasy · 21/04/2023 12:11

I absolutely love it. Not the fact people have been killed or abused, I have great sympathy for them and their families. But am fascinated by how people react to and deal with crime. How the police investigate it. How forensic science has developed over time and what can be discovered using it. Real investigations are so much more more interesting than fictional versions which rely on hunches and coincidences - though love a good crime drama too.

MisanthropistToTheCore · 21/04/2023 12:06

Xrays · 21/04/2023 12:03

I hadn’t heard of that one. I’ll have a search for it.

It’s called ‘The Stranger Beside Me.’

LowFlyingDucks · 21/04/2023 12:05

MisanthropistToTheCore · 21/04/2023 12:03

I know you’re talking about film making. I addressed that and talked about the ramifications.

‘I think…’

Your opinion. Which you’re entitled to.

I will no longer be engaging. Have a great day.

Whether you engage further or not, you didn’t understand what I said and you made something completely different up, which you then disagreed with.

This is bad form to not retract or apologise for it.

qazxc · 21/04/2023 12:05

I like the investigation part, seeing how the police find a perpetrator and prove their case. Not all programs are gory and violent (I enjoyed a 24hour in Police custody episode where a man was trying to claim he had been burgled but was in fact committing fraud)
Some cases can be used to highlight and encourage discussions on broader social issues.
Some documentaries are about miscarriages of justice or proving innocence (like "Long Shot" on Netflix).
I don't enjoy or watch gory, biased or speculative "documentaries".

phoenixrosehere · 21/04/2023 12:04

BMW6 · 21/04/2023 11:48

Having pondered mire on this I don't even watch these to be "entertained".

For me it's the same with programmes like Life on Earth or any wildlife programme. Invariably some poor creature will be eaten by another, or will starve for lack of prey.

Not "entertaining" at all, but Real, often interesting and always educational.

Agree with this. For me, it’s more on how people got away with it, the length of time they were able to commit these crimes, the good and bad of the police handling the case and other circumstances behind many of them that helped and/or hinder getting justice for the victims.

Xrays · 21/04/2023 12:03

MisanthropistToTheCore · 21/04/2023 11:28

Absolutely. The Bundy thing is very interesting. The book by Ann Rule (who was his friend and worked at the hotline with him) is fascinating.

I hadn’t heard of that one. I’ll have a search for it.

LowFlyingDucks · 21/04/2023 12:03

MisanthropistToTheCore · 21/04/2023 11:48

And that’s your opinion. Great.

So this is what you enjoy, a bit of torture porn, based on real life crimes? 🫤