Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand the "entertainment value" of true crime

205 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 20/04/2023 19:35

I understand the enjoyment of murder mysteries, excitement, interesting characters, mystery aspect etc.

I dont understand the "enjoyment" of "true crime" where real people have suffered and died and been bereaved. The thread about Jonbenet for example, why are people enjoying "documentaries" and feeling they can speak authoritvly about the death a poor little girl, thousands of miles away about which they in reality know nothing, but feel like they can slag of members of her family anyway?

Ive just gone onto itv player to find something to while away a few hours, and find myself being offer a whole plethera of "true crime" stuff. No thanks, what on earth is fun or relaxing being a spectator to other people's grief, pain and misery?

I just dont understand what sort of person enjoys that. I hope you will enjoy it just as much if you are ever the subject of one of these dramas.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
qazxc · 24/04/2023 10:34

Are you thinking of the Alice Sebold case?

It's not a murder case but the person accused and convicted of it has been released after being exonerated.
I can't remember a documentary about it, but it's quite possible one has been made.

The case was a rape case. Alice Sebold was an 18 year old student at the time. She then went on to be an author and wrote a book called "The lovely bones" which is about a murder and a memoir about the attack and it's aftermath called "Lucky".

Goodread1 · 24/04/2023 09:09

Hi 👋 Op

There was a true life murder case in America, in which the wrong man was wrong convicted, essentially cause of his skin colour,

I seen a news article about this, He was in prison for 20 + years,

A Documentary about this case went on to Netfix or another media outlet,

And a Astute Journalist, who was very inquisitive, helped to re open the case as he could see how flawed the case was,

The Author of this true life murder case was called. Funny Bones , or those lovely bones something like that,

Very quirky Title of the name of the book..

There was a book on it,

Does Anybody know proper name of this book and Author out there on Mumsnet ?

lemonchiffonpie · 24/04/2023 01:12

Dithyramb · 23/04/2023 22:17

Perhaps the OP hopes that as ‘human nature’ has moved on from witchburnings and public executions, using it as excuse for normalising a grubby, prurient tabloid-y interest in suffering and death is pretty weak?

You mean like this thread posted by the OP?

daughters of Frya has blown my mind | Mumsnet

WandaWonder · 23/04/2023 23:02

I think there is a difference in watching and switching off and overinvesting like the people who write and marry serial killers and wear t-shirts 'save him' to campaign

Even in here people over invest in other people's dramas and lives

MissMissive · 23/04/2023 22:53

SargentSagittarius · 23/04/2023 22:46

In fact, the answer to the OP’s question, as posed in the thread title, isn’t necessarily that people find the topic entertaining per se, although I’m sure some people do.

They find it interesting.

Which is different. And not really explainable, in as much as I don’t find, I dunno, off the top of my head - Formula 1 - either entertaining or interesting. I just have to accept that other people do, and so I leave them to it.

Or, on a more ‘distasteful’ note - I don’t understand the mentality behind war, but plenty of men seem to see something appealing in it, and after the devastation it has wrought throughout human history, men still engage in, and even willing sign up, for it. Downright weird if you ask me, but 🤷🏻‍♀️

And again, it’s not the gory details that many people are interested in, it’s the process, the investigation, the piecing together of facts to form a picture, and then hopefully - someone brought to justice.

Again, God forbid, but if I disappear one day without a trace, or am brutally murdered, I hope people talk about it.

Yep, and in fact some podcasts are the only reason families have been able to get the attention that closes a case or draws interest where the police have failed and / or been negligent. Often where women are the victims and it’s just been swept umder the carpet.

There’s quite a few but Marion Barter (The Lady Vanishes). Lyn Dawson (The Teacher’s Pet) and Kristin Smart (Your Own Backyard.)

Some of these have had the result of improving the situation for other victims and their families or future victims.

SargentSagittarius · 23/04/2023 22:46

In fact, the answer to the OP’s question, as posed in the thread title, isn’t necessarily that people find the topic entertaining per se, although I’m sure some people do.

They find it interesting.

Which is different. And not really explainable, in as much as I don’t find, I dunno, off the top of my head - Formula 1 - either entertaining or interesting. I just have to accept that other people do, and so I leave them to it.

Or, on a more ‘distasteful’ note - I don’t understand the mentality behind war, but plenty of men seem to see something appealing in it, and after the devastation it has wrought throughout human history, men still engage in, and even willing sign up, for it. Downright weird if you ask me, but 🤷🏻‍♀️

And again, it’s not the gory details that many people are interested in, it’s the process, the investigation, the piecing together of facts to form a picture, and then hopefully - someone brought to justice.

Again, God forbid, but if I disappear one day without a trace, or am brutally murdered, I hope people talk about it.

JarByTheDoor · 23/04/2023 22:35

Human nature hasn't changed. That's why it's called human nature.

SargentSagittarius · 23/04/2023 22:31

Dithyramb · 23/04/2023 22:17

Perhaps the OP hopes that as ‘human nature’ has moved on from witchburnings and public executions, using it as excuse for normalising a grubby, prurient tabloid-y interest in suffering and death is pretty weak?

Clearly she does - you won’t get disagreement from me on that.

Doesn’t negate the fact the people find the topic, and the individual cases, highly interesting, and yes, will form opinions and discuss them.

QueefQueen80s · 23/04/2023 22:27

I don't enjoy them in a fun way but I watch a lot of them. I'm a woman and there's something about watching true crime, mostly against women, from my safe place.. Like I'm getting tips to protect myself and be more self aware. I have so much empathy for them and their families and find myself crying for them. I like to see the police methods and how the courts work.
Lots of my friends are the same. It's not fun, it's interesting to watch. Makes you appreciate life while we have it.

Dithyramb · 23/04/2023 22:17

SargentSagittarius · 23/04/2023 20:44

You’re being very naive if you think people shouldn’t be interested in crimes of this nature, OP.

OK - you find it distasteful. That’s more than fine, you absolutely shouldn’t expose yourself to anything you find uninteresting and/or uncomfortable.

But other people do find it interesting and intriguing and want to know more. It’s human nature (not all humans - some) to be curious about all sorts of different things.

And as people know more, they will form opinions, which they will share. You can say that’s ‘unreasonable’, and it’s fine for you to think this. But it’s a free world, so unfortunately it’s not illegal for people to do this.

I guess you will just have to find a way to come to terms with this. Because, I mean, what’s the alternative? You can berate away and tell people you’re disappointed in them, but it’s not going to change anything.

Perhaps the OP hopes that as ‘human nature’ has moved on from witchburnings and public executions, using it as excuse for normalising a grubby, prurient tabloid-y interest in suffering and death is pretty weak?

SargentSagittarius · 23/04/2023 20:44

You’re being very naive if you think people shouldn’t be interested in crimes of this nature, OP.

OK - you find it distasteful. That’s more than fine, you absolutely shouldn’t expose yourself to anything you find uninteresting and/or uncomfortable.

But other people do find it interesting and intriguing and want to know more. It’s human nature (not all humans - some) to be curious about all sorts of different things.

And as people know more, they will form opinions, which they will share. You can say that’s ‘unreasonable’, and it’s fine for you to think this. But it’s a free world, so unfortunately it’s not illegal for people to do this.

I guess you will just have to find a way to come to terms with this. Because, I mean, what’s the alternative? You can berate away and tell people you’re disappointed in them, but it’s not going to change anything.

Nimbostratus100 · 23/04/2023 07:56

thewinterwitch · 22/04/2023 11:53

You are not in a position to state her parents faked a kidnap.

Well.... after over a year of examining the evidence and hearing expert testimony the Grand Jury convened to determine if there was anyone who could be charged did indict her parents, and that meant that one or both of them did stage a kidnapping. The Boulder police department believed that one or both of the parents staged a kidnapping. It is not an unreasonable statement, therefore.

it is a very unreasonable statement, from people who dont know anything about the poor child's death, except what they have learnt from watching "documentaries" for entertainment

OP posts:
Broken123BiscuitBag · 22/04/2023 20:01

Some people look normal on the outside

But they are "monsters" on the inside

Some people living double or multiple lives

It's how they get away with things for many years

ReadtheReviews · 22/04/2023 19:52

I think it's the why did they do it? Could it happen to me? What would stop it happening? Would would I do in that scenario? How do I spot someone capable of that? Etc etc.

peechie · 22/04/2023 19:36

Rarely do you hear 'she was a bit depressed, didn't have many friends and things weren't going well in life'. Maybe those people just don't make the documentaries, who knows

peechie · 22/04/2023 19:33

I also question the trite things people say about victims, e.g. 'She didn't deserve this; she was so beautiful!' Ugly women don't deserve to be murdered either.

Very true

'She was so beautiful, popular, the kindest person, bubbly, loved life, her smile lit up the room, she wanted to study law' and on and on

Sometimes I wish true crime commentary would just tone it town a bit. It makes it sound like those things give your life more meaning. It's ok to just be a normal person.

You can be sensitive and respectful without all this embellishment.

Broken123BiscuitBag · 22/04/2023 18:59

Before all the choices on the TV & Internet

There used to be crime genre books & magazines

Going back in history people were punished harshly for simple crimes like stealing food & were imprisoned or deported

Some people were innocent & still punished for crimes

Social history

anonymous98 · 22/04/2023 18:51

DuesToTheDirt · 21/04/2023 21:07

@Nounoufgs I now turn off any serial milker type mystery especially if they linger on unclothes female corpses. Not for me.

I started watching Spiral recently - late to the party, but everyone said how good it was. The first episode had long lingering shots of a naked female body, with one of the detectives saying she had obviously been murdered because she was so beautiful. WTF. There is a lot of misogyny in crime dramas, with a definite preference for young, attractive female victimes, but that took the biscuit and I didn't watch any more of it.

Ew.

I also question the trite things people say about victims, e.g. 'She didn't deserve this; she was so beautiful!' Ugly women don't deserve to be murdered either.

LlynTegid · 22/04/2023 12:00

It's not for me either, though I'm also not someone who watches much fictional crime drama.

As long as it is done with sensitivity for those bereaved or otherwise affected by a crime.

thewinterwitch · 22/04/2023 11:53

You are not in a position to state her parents faked a kidnap.

Well.... after over a year of examining the evidence and hearing expert testimony the Grand Jury convened to determine if there was anyone who could be charged did indict her parents, and that meant that one or both of them did stage a kidnapping. The Boulder police department believed that one or both of the parents staged a kidnapping. It is not an unreasonable statement, therefore.

Nimbostratus100 · 22/04/2023 08:59

mainsfed · 20/04/2023 21:40

The thread about Jonbenet for example, why are people enjoying "documentaries" and feeling they can speak authoritvly about the death a poor little girl, thousands of miles away about which they in reality know nothing, but feel like they can slag of members of her family anyway?

Because a little girl died and her killer was never brought to justice? It’s human nature to want justice for victims.

Plus her parents clearly faked her kidnapping, shame that you are more concerned about their feelings rather than the victim.

I think you have demonstrated exactly what I mean by "people who know nothing but feel they have the authority to slag of members of her family anyway.

You are not in a position to state her parents faked a kidnap. YOu know nothing. You have simply watched some entertainment based on this poor child losing her life, and have decided you are an expert now

How would you feel if this was your child dead, and people saying this about you on the internet, because they have watched a "documentary" and have appointed themselves an "expert"

OP posts:
Goodread1 · 22/04/2023 08:35

I am not intrigued so much by historic crimes or unsolved ones for strange reason

I prefer watching true crimes genre from 1960s era upwards ...

Goodread1 · 22/04/2023 08:33

I find American true crime far way to Graphic and sensalist in ther way of depicting tragic victims bodies of true crimes .
They linger on and reveal far too much of the victim broken /damaged bodies,
I wish they didn't do that style of camera, filming editing,

backstreetsbackallright · 22/04/2023 03:07

I wouldn't describe is as 'enjoyment' but I find it interesting from the aspect of solving a crime and looking at the psychological profile behind the murderer.

hippygirllucky · 22/04/2023 03:03

Being aware of danger keeps any being alive. In humans,we've turned this natural phenomenon into entertainment. It's not weird, it's not gross, it's survival. It's also overwhelmingly a female interest, as women are more likely to be victims of the sort of crimes sensationalised by true crime.