Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m going to give it a miss

84 replies

reebokbok · 20/04/2023 17:47

I feel abit affronted with that response to me asking a group of friends if they wanted to meet up for dinner next week.

Am I being too sensitive.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mainsfed · 22/04/2023 17:02

redskylight · 22/04/2023 16:15

Oh cos we’re silly, shallow women, for caring about how we communicate with people in order to ensure they feel respected and valued?

I actually find that people who reply to these sort of messages with "oh what am amazing idea, I would so love to make it and catchup with you but unfortunately I have something else on, but we must catch up soon, really miss seeing you xxxxx" tend not to be the ones to drop everything and come and support you when you actually have an emergency.

Of course communication is important. But this is a group of friends and they shouldn't need to try hard in brief messages to show how much they care.

In fact either this is normal for this friend, in which case OP is surely used to it OR it's not normal, in which case it's slightly ironic that OP's first response is to go to MN and ask whether her friend is being rude rather than wondering why her friend is acting out of character and getting in touch to see if anything is wrong.

I'd rather a friend that showed they cared in actions than flowery emails.

It doesn’t have to be flowery though. A simple ‘I won’t be able to make it, thanks’ would have done.

mainsfed · 22/04/2023 16:59

YANBU, they lack tact.

Next time they invite you and you don’t fancy it, say the exact same thing to them.

redskylight · 22/04/2023 16:15

Oh cos we’re silly, shallow women, for caring about how we communicate with people in order to ensure they feel respected and valued?

I actually find that people who reply to these sort of messages with "oh what am amazing idea, I would so love to make it and catchup with you but unfortunately I have something else on, but we must catch up soon, really miss seeing you xxxxx" tend not to be the ones to drop everything and come and support you when you actually have an emergency.

Of course communication is important. But this is a group of friends and they shouldn't need to try hard in brief messages to show how much they care.

In fact either this is normal for this friend, in which case OP is surely used to it OR it's not normal, in which case it's slightly ironic that OP's first response is to go to MN and ask whether her friend is being rude rather than wondering why her friend is acting out of character and getting in touch to see if anything is wrong.

I'd rather a friend that showed they cared in actions than flowery emails.

Tandora · 22/04/2023 13:46

redskylight · 22/04/2023 09:58

So if they'd said "I'll give it a miss; busy at the moment" you'd consider this fine? I think some people on this thread need to consider why they have certain expectations of social niceties.

I work and socialise predominantly in male environments and with quite a few neurodiverse people. Saying "I'll give it a miss" to a vague suggestion of meeting up (if it was something like a formal wedding invitation, it's different) is the way the majority would communicate in this situation. Putting in a vague reason (even if there is no reason beyond I don't fancy it at the moment) is something that tends to be a more female behaviour. Why? If the point of the message is to ascertain who is free for a meeting next week, and it's people you are friends with and presumably like, why is saying "no" or "I'll give it a miss" worse than "Can't make it next week - work is frantic" or "I'll give it a miss; busy with the children"?

fine? I think some people on this thread need to consider why they have certain expectations of social niceties

Why?

I work and socialise predominantly in male environments

Oh cos we’re silly, shallow women, for caring about how we communicate with people in order to ensure they feel respected and valued?

crossstitchingnana · 22/04/2023 11:35

I usually say "thanks for the invite but it's not for me this time" or words to that effect.

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/04/2023 10:12

It does depend to a large extent on how well you know the person and how often you see them. If a really good friend who I saw regularly said this to me I wouldn’t be overly troubled by it because I know the underlying commitment to the friendship is there and is unchanged by someone not being able to or not wanting to attend this particular meeting.

If it were a newer, less defined friendship or one with an old friend who you rarely see it would feel much more affronted.

For example I have an old friend who lives in rural Scotland (I live in London), who I see at most once a year. If she was coming down to London and we planned to meet and she said “I think I will give this a miss,” I would be pretty fucked off. With friends who you see less regularly there’s definitely more commitment needed to keep the friendship alive and the suggestion of lack of care would upset me.

redskylight · 22/04/2023 09:58

Restforabit · 22/04/2023 08:27

I think some explanation is generally required, even if it is vague. I think it is a bit impolite too.

So if they'd said "I'll give it a miss; busy at the moment" you'd consider this fine? I think some people on this thread need to consider why they have certain expectations of social niceties.

I work and socialise predominantly in male environments and with quite a few neurodiverse people. Saying "I'll give it a miss" to a vague suggestion of meeting up (if it was something like a formal wedding invitation, it's different) is the way the majority would communicate in this situation. Putting in a vague reason (even if there is no reason beyond I don't fancy it at the moment) is something that tends to be a more female behaviour. Why? If the point of the message is to ascertain who is free for a meeting next week, and it's people you are friends with and presumably like, why is saying "no" or "I'll give it a miss" worse than "Can't make it next week - work is frantic" or "I'll give it a miss; busy with the children"?

Jux · 22/04/2023 09:22

Do you all neet up regularly? How often?

I'll admit that if I were meeting with a group of friends every week I might give this response if for some reason I couldn't go, or didn't want to. If it were for a reason which I'd rather keep private for now, I'd say it. Missing one weekly meeting is no big deal.

So it depends how often you see each other, and whether she sees some of the people quite often and is less interested in the few she doesn't see who will be there.

5128gap · 22/04/2023 08:29

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:23

But do you need to be reassured each time someone rejects a meet-up proposition that that person otherwise would be interested in seeing you and values time with you? Every time?

Its not about needing proactive reassurance is it? There are certain social conventions towards friends in polite society. One of which is when declining an invitation you thank the issuer and give some sort of reason. Its what people expect from others because its typical behaviour.
When a person chooses to dispense with shared understanding of courtesy, it makes us question why that might be. Are they being deliberately rude to give us a message for example?
Human communication is complicated and multi layered. Most people read not only the text but the subtext. Most people mitigate against sending negative subtexts to their friends.

Restforabit · 22/04/2023 08:27

I think some explanation is generally required, even if it is vague. I think it is a bit impolite too.

5128gap · 22/04/2023 08:21

Is an unusual and blunt way to refuse an invitation alright. On the plus side at least you know you cam trust that person to be honest, rather than playing the polite game of fobbing you off with excuses, or attending and moaning behind your back. Which is worth something.

Tandora · 22/04/2023 08:16

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:23

But do you need to be reassured each time someone rejects a meet-up proposition that that person otherwise would be interested in seeing you and values time with you? Every time?

fair enough; I suppose it depends on the context. I suppose I’m thinking in the context I my current life/ friendships, where I have two small kids and don’t see my friends too often. If I went the trouble of organising something and asking people and they replied with “I’m going to give it a miss” and nothing further, I’d definitely find that dismissive and indicative of the fact that they weren’t interested in making an effort to see/ spend time with me. I suppose it’s different if is a group of friends who do things together all the time.

ChocChipHandbag · 21/04/2023 09:25

ShowUs · 20/04/2023 21:40

It’s fine.
Its just a nice way of saying no.

MNers are always saying ‘no’ is a full sentence yet everyone seems to get offended if they don’t get an apology and full explanation.

Most people would say something like this.
Its not a negative thing.

No, it's a LESS nice way of saying no! It's snide and flippant.

redskylight · 21/04/2023 09:03

Bhyr358 · 20/04/2023 22:59

When a friend suggests meeting for a meal you honestly think that "I'll give it a miss. " is an appropriate response? Why would anyone bother asking again if they get brushed off like that? No wonder so many people on here struggle with friendships. Common manners cost nothing.

If it was an individual invitation, that would apply.

But this isn't. OP has (presumably) sent a message to a group chat. Her friend can't come/doesn't want to come on this occasion, but presumably others in the group might be interested.

I have a similar group chat with friends. If someone suggests a meet up, some people will say "yes", some people will say "no" and some people don't reply at all. Not a single person says "thanks for inviting me" which seems to be what what the OP is wanting, because it's a given that we're a group of friends and we invite each other to stuff.

And if people don't reply, or say "no" and don't offer up any particular reason, they are not excluded for ever more. We just assume that they are busy or don't fancy it but will probably come along next time because, you know, we're actually friends and like each other.

Bhyr358 · 20/04/2023 22:59

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:23

But do you need to be reassured each time someone rejects a meet-up proposition that that person otherwise would be interested in seeing you and values time with you? Every time?

When a friend suggests meeting for a meal you honestly think that "I'll give it a miss. " is an appropriate response? Why would anyone bother asking again if they get brushed off like that? No wonder so many people on here struggle with friendships. Common manners cost nothing.

Wereongunoil · 20/04/2023 22:48

When's payday?
Suggest a date after that, they may be more likely to say yes 🤷

rainyskylight · 20/04/2023 22:46

I agree with you OP, it was rude. Don’t know what all the other PPs are on about.

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:35

clpsmum · 20/04/2023 22:29

It's not about the op being reassured it's about her friends having manners!!!

You don't think this comment (not by OP) A nice way of saying no would offer some meagre indication that you would have course like to see/ catch up with your friend/ that you do value the friendship , albeit you won’t be making this particular meet up. is about wanting reassurance?

clpsmum · 20/04/2023 22:29

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:23

But do you need to be reassured each time someone rejects a meet-up proposition that that person otherwise would be interested in seeing you and values time with you? Every time?

It's not about the op being reassured it's about her friends having manners!!!

Precipice · 20/04/2023 22:23

But do you need to be reassured each time someone rejects a meet-up proposition that that person otherwise would be interested in seeing you and values time with you? Every time?

Howdoesitworkagain · 20/04/2023 22:17

I think it is a softer way of saying “no”, and I use the phrase myself but wouldn’t use it on its own. At the very least I’d add “but thanks anyway :)” or similar

Tandora · 20/04/2023 22:04

ShowUs · 20/04/2023 21:40

It’s fine.
Its just a nice way of saying no.

MNers are always saying ‘no’ is a full sentence yet everyone seems to get offended if they don’t get an apology and full explanation.

Most people would say something like this.
Its not a negative thing.

It’s not a nice way of saying no though? A nice way of saying no would offer some meagre indication that you would have course like to see/ catch up with your friend/ that you do value the friendship , albeit you won’t be making this particular meet up.

ShowUs · 20/04/2023 21:40

It’s fine.
Its just a nice way of saying no.

MNers are always saying ‘no’ is a full sentence yet everyone seems to get offended if they don’t get an apology and full explanation.

Most people would say something like this.
Its not a negative thing.

girlfriend44 · 20/04/2023 21:23

Abrupt and tactless. Some people have no idea.

Tandora · 20/04/2023 21:17

Honestly these responses 🙄. I’d find it super rude , OP.
Aside from the pp who explained she says this because she unwell and doesn’t want to have to explain - that’s understandable. Otherwise ruddddee.