Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be annoyed at kid’s new school hounding me when they’re ill

771 replies

MytosisIs · 20/04/2023 17:34

We recently moved and so DC are attending a new school. First day was supposed to be Monday.

On Sunday they tested positive for COVID. I had it earlier in the week and really suffered.
I tested them as they were coughing, had a high fever and even D&V.

I rang on Monday morning to say they’d be missing the first day. They said they don’t recommended children are tested but said “You’ve done it now though”. I said well I still very much test for COVID because whilst none of us are vulnerable, other people may be and it’s them I’m protecting.

anyway it’s now Thursday and as requested I rang every day and updated them. But really it’s just ‘they’re still I’ll and have COVID’.

They’ve run me back every single day to discuss ’an update on the kids’. I just repeat myself from what I leave on the voicemail.

Yesterday I was on a train (I’m now negative and have been for some time) and they heard the announcement and asked where I was. When I said was on a train they asked if I’d left my kids on their own!! I said “no they’re 6 and 9!” And they asked who was watching them - their dad!!!

Today I emailed to say I have back to back meetings so can’t call but the kids remain to be ill (DH was on a plane at this point). Again they called me, which I missed. So I found a window to call them back and they again were strange and said “They have been ill for so so long now” (5 days!) asking when it started etc.

Im starting to get pissed off. I’m thinking of pulling them out and enrolling them in another school which we were also offered and according to the receptionist still have places.

AIBU to be annoyed at their persistence? Would they rather I sent sick COVID-infected kids into school? In their old school they were great and just said “We will see them when they’re better, keep us updated”.

OP posts:
Lolaandbehold · 20/04/2023 21:17

Like schools haven’t enough to be doing than dealing with people like you. All they’re trying to do is their duty by some children they don’t know that should have started school almost a week ago but haven’t, and minimal family history/info means they’re erring on the side of caution. If I were in your situation, I’d be inwardly a bit frustrated but ultimately grateful for their diligence.

EarringsandLipstick · 20/04/2023 21:16

SamPoodle123 · 20/04/2023 21:13

I would be thankful you have a school that actually cares. If my school asks why my dc is not in school or what they have. I do not get angry or defensive about it. It is their job to ask these questions. Sometimes I forget to email the school to let them know when one dc is being kept home and then I get a call or email. I then explain the reasons. One time I decided to keep my 3 year old home and said she was not well so I am keeping her home. They asked what is wrong with her. My response, she vomited during the night and I am keeping her home to make sure she is okay. No questions asked after that.

But this isn't OP's situation!
She did inform the school and has stayed in contact. She has now been excessively harassed & questioned by the school.

That's what's not appropriate, unlike in your situation where you didn't contact them so they rang to ask you for details.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 20/04/2023 21:14

One thing that doesn't seem to have been mentioned - or I missed it if it was - is that apart from abuse, it's common for parents to take children out of school for holidays as they're cheaper in term time. Two siblings being off for a week is a very suspicious from that point of view. That's why they asked where the OP was - they were suspicious that the children weren't sick at all, but rather were out and about travelling somewhere. While that's not an abuse situation, it's still a safeguarding issue as the children are missing school when they shouldn't be.

I have to say the question 'Why would I lie about my children being ill?' is a spectacularly naive question, I really can't believe an adult would ask that - how can you get to 25+ and not realise that some people lie about things like that? Can an adult really have such little knowledge about the world?

SamPoodle123 · 20/04/2023 21:13

I would be thankful you have a school that actually cares. If my school asks why my dc is not in school or what they have. I do not get angry or defensive about it. It is their job to ask these questions. Sometimes I forget to email the school to let them know when one dc is being kept home and then I get a call or email. I then explain the reasons. One time I decided to keep my 3 year old home and said she was not well so I am keeping her home. They asked what is wrong with her. My response, she vomited during the night and I am keeping her home to make sure she is okay. No questions asked after that.

OhwhyOY · 20/04/2023 21:09

I would also be really irritated by this. As a child basically every year I would catch flu and have a week off school for it, or severe tonsillitis, or a bunch of other things. Once I was older my immune system picked up and my attendance was basically 100%. But to say it's highly unusual for kids to be ill for a week is nonsense.

Also I totally understand the safeguarding aspect but that doesn't mean they need to assume you are leaving the kids home alone, there are ways of asking politely e.g. 'Would you mind letting me know who is caring for the children currently please as the school has a duty to make sure they are ok' etc. I would rather they checked up every day just in case, to protect vulnerable children, but I'd also expect them to be cognisant of the fact that it feels pretty intrusive, so at least be polite to you.

Whilst I understand the example of avoiding a kid starving to death as their lone parent has suddenly died, I'm also not sure how expecting you to call in every day would e.g. protect kids from FGM as a pp mentioned, surely as an abusive parent you could just phone in and lie that they had a bug? Unless the school actually visits and sees they aren't there how would they know they hadn't been shipped off for forced marriage or FGM or whatever?

Greentree1 · 20/04/2023 21:09

You should just have said they are sick. Covid is often very mild now and not worth staying off school for. But if they are actually ill for whatever reason fair enough.

Itstarts · 20/04/2023 21:05

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:58

You haven’t explained the bit I’ve asked about. You’ve alluded to other things. But I was specifically asking about how the process of calling the OP each day and getting her to repeat herself guarded against disguised compliance if her story isn’t then being verified in any other way.

The school will have a protocol. It may be on day 5 (so tomorrow) triggers a home visit. Day 1-4 may be just a phone call. You're not going to 'catch them' using disguised compliance from one phone call. Its all about building up a record, which may include daily phone calls.

And FYI the same story word for word can be as much a sign of cover up as changes in a story. Naturally we use different words/phrases when retelling. The same words would suggest a rehearsed response which would be a red flag too.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 20/04/2023 21:05

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:58

You haven’t explained the bit I’ve asked about. You’ve alluded to other things. But I was specifically asking about how the process of calling the OP each day and getting her to repeat herself guarded against disguised compliance if her story isn’t then being verified in any other way.

Someone did explain this. An unannounced phone call gives you the opportunity to potentially hear the children in the background, judge the tone of voice of the mum - stressed?, scared?, drunk? - that you don’t get from a voicemail she placed under her own controlled circumstances.

Branleuse · 20/04/2023 21:04

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 20/04/2023 20:31

Because that will really stop the school informing the appropriate authority.

I wouldnt care. Theyll be back at school next week and it will all blow over. If 'relevent authorities' want kids in school while infected with covid, thats a bit odd.
I dont tend to answer the phone to school when im at work. Ill check the voicemail and call back if its important

StarDolphins · 20/04/2023 21:04

I think it’s because DFE/LA are so incredibly strict on attendance that schools now pester the life out of people. We’re constantly getting messages on parent hub about this.

Plus, I got an Amazon voucher & a book voucher ‘awarded’ to me by the headteacher in a strange assembly thing for apparently sending my kid in everyday. You wouldn’t give out a voucher unless you had to report these figures babk to someone surely.

I would ring them, say they won’t be in today then ignore your phone (you’re looking after your poorly kids). No need to keep speaking after you’ve reported them obsent.

Malloryhitops · 20/04/2023 21:03

I dont think you’re being unreasonable at all. I would be rightly pissed off also. And all those bleating on about red flags is bullshit. Your kids are sick, keep them home and keep the school updated every couple of days. I would be rightly pissed if they questioned me about having left my kids home alone. Like do they ring parents everyday of the school holidays too to check in on the kids to see if they ok and make sure they are not being left home alone?

WandaWonder · 20/04/2023 21:01

The school is trying to care for your kids, thry don't employ someone just to annoy you

Change your thinking to make it about your children not about you

Medinburgh · 20/04/2023 21:01

Sounds like a stressful week, and I’m sure you will be able to build a good relationship with the school moving forward.

I think it sounds great that they are so involved and interested in the wellbeing of their pupils. They are doing everything right to make sure their pupils are safe, just as you are doing the right thing keeping your children safe and healthy. Just unlucky timing in a new setting.

Lostinalibrary · 20/04/2023 21:01

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:58

You haven’t explained the bit I’ve asked about. You’ve alluded to other things. But I was specifically asking about how the process of calling the OP each day and getting her to repeat herself guarded against disguised compliance if her story isn’t then being verified in any other way.

I have explained clearly; yet you said I’d changed my posts. Noticed you’ve back tracked on that as I haven’t. I’ve been consistent all along. Absolutely fascinating someone who I’d spend the time writing 6 or so paragraphs arguing why op is right to be outraged. Especially when you’ve been told multiple times but multiple people the reasons. Truly bizarre and over invested behaviour. At least those in the job of safeguarding are quite clear on what is as risk and what isn’t. You’ve been told by other posters too, so you crack on.

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:58

Lostinalibrary · 20/04/2023 20:54

I have explained to you the reasons - you’ve chosen not to read them. Obviously deciding you know more about safeguarding than the people who do it for a job and the school who will have their records. As I said - quite the feat.

You haven’t explained the bit I’ve asked about. You’ve alluded to other things. But I was specifically asking about how the process of calling the OP each day and getting her to repeat herself guarded against disguised compliance if her story isn’t then being verified in any other way.

Strictly1 · 20/04/2023 20:57

Mamapiggywig · 20/04/2023 18:07

This isn’t safeguarding this is harassment . I would be calling a meeting to discuss this ridiculous constant calling approach. The kids have Covid?! Ffs.

It is safeguarding. If you read a serious case review it’s often because professionals have accepted adults reasons or something has not been chased up.

LesleyA · 20/04/2023 20:56

I’m sure this thread has moved on hugely as I only read the first couple of pages but seriously ‘kids haven’t turned up’ that expression is used when someone is expected and hasn’t arrived WITHOUT any message or notice. The OP told the school, update the school. Wasn’t ‘out and about’ was commuting for work perfectly normal. Whatever their concern they should have voiced it like we are concerned that the kids may have started school elsewhere or are being intentionally kept away rather than questioning the OP with passive implication and doubt. FFS what more could the OP have done once having decided that due to COVID they as parents have decided to take the more cautious but also reasonable approach. OP I like to be supportive and not suspicious but without a doubt record what you have proactively done and write what and when they have called because any more of this it might get a little itchy scratchy and should you need to present your reason for the frustration you have a clear unemotional record. Except of course u may have moved them by now as I didn’t follow thread

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 20/04/2023 20:55

SpringCherryPie · 20/04/2023 20:44

Out of curiosity, could you explain why this is red flags? I’m genuinely very shocked that this would be ‘red flags all over it’ and you are a safeguarding lead. Is this really part of your training? I don’t think the OP should be thinking of changing schools. But I don’t think she is displaying a single red flag.

The OP is taking care of her kids health and keeping them appropriately out of school. And updating every day. The fact that it’s the beginning of term doesn’t mean a thing. The school would have the previous schools attendance record and anyone can fall ill, even the beginning of term!

There are no other indications of neglect or abuse at all.

Where are the red flags?

It’s worrying as I don’t often feel that schools do enough about safeguarding. It’s’ tricky I know, but it’s picking up patterns with children surely isn’t it? Of neglect or abuse. If it’s all on ‘how dare you keep your kids home with covid’ then that is ignoring the very real red flags elsewhere?

“The fact that it’s the beginning of term doesn’t mean a thing”.

Suggest you read back. People have already explained more than once that abuse is more common in the holidays, children are kept off until bruises fade, and abusive parents try to avoid scrutiny by moving schools.

Nobody’s seen these children since they left their last school. As another previous poster explained, calling to follow up on a voice mail gives you the opportunity to potentially hear the children in the background, see if mum sounds sick, stressed, or potentially off on a jolly to Ibiza having left her kids at home with a teenage babysitter. Or, yes, on a term time holiday. Which, whatever your thoughts on the matter, schools have a responsibility to record so that they can keep as many children in education as much of the time as possible.

And you have no idea if the children’s attendance at the previous school was good or not. Perhaps it wasn’t.

Strictly1 · 20/04/2023 20:55

MytosisIs · 20/04/2023 18:00

Why would I lie about them being ill?

As if parents who do abuse their children tell the truth when asked!

Branleuse · 20/04/2023 20:55

Twizbe · 20/04/2023 18:49

You're being very aggressive in your responses to posters who aren't agreeing with you or asking for clarification.

Because theyre being weird about it?

How the fuck have we got to the point where we are treated like abusers and liars for keeping our kids home when they are literally ill with covid.

Lostinalibrary · 20/04/2023 20:54

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:49

If you think a wave of the hand is really an explanation for anything at all, let alone a question about the mechanics of safeguarding, then it’s no wonder inquiries into safeguarding failures frequently find that professionals are more interested in filling reports and ticking boxes than determining what is actually going on in children’s lives?

I have explained to you the reasons - you’ve chosen not to read them. Obviously deciding you know more about safeguarding than the people who do it for a job and the school who will have their records. As I said - quite the feat.

VaccineSticker · 20/04/2023 20:53

Covid is still flooring lots of people I personally know including my own family. We had to be off for at least a week being very poorly with it.
having said that, the school has a duty of care that check on the children.

Itstarts · 20/04/2023 20:53

@SSpringCherryPie

  1. Absence after a school holiday
  2. Absence after a change of school
  3. Both children ill at the same time so neither have been seen for a week
  4. Longer absence than is usual with the illness mentioned
  5. Mum is the one to contact the school re:absence but isn't with the children when contacted
  6. No signs of children during phone calls so no way to check they are OK

Those are the obvious ones. Possibly more if we were privy to files/conversations.

ktitten · 20/04/2023 20:52

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 17:50

I think this is safeguarding tbh, I can see why your situation seems dodgy to them. Your DC were supposed to start school and haven’t turned up not just for one or two days but the whole week. They then call you and you’re out and about. They’ll be worried you’re hiding the kids away.

If someone was going to hide their kids away why would they even bother enrolling them in school? Genuine question. Surely you'd just pull them out of their old school, move house, and "home school" (or abuse!) them.

I couldn't be arsed with this either to be honest. There's a line between safeguarding and parental authority. If I tell you my child is ill and they won't be in this week because it's already Wednesday, they've been throwing up all night so would need to be off Thursday anyway, and there's no point sending them back for 3 hours on Friday then I'd expect that to be the end of it. I won't be calling again and don't expect to be called. My school are fine with this (probably- I don't really care if they're not).

NumberTheory · 20/04/2023 20:49

Lostinalibrary · 20/04/2023 20:34

It really is.

If you think a wave of the hand is really an explanation for anything at all, let alone a question about the mechanics of safeguarding, then it’s no wonder inquiries into safeguarding failures frequently find that professionals are more interested in filling reports and ticking boxes than determining what is actually going on in children’s lives?

Swipe left for the next trending thread