Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To be annoyed at kid’s new school hounding me when they’re ill

771 replies

MytosisIs · 20/04/2023 17:34

We recently moved and so DC are attending a new school. First day was supposed to be Monday.

On Sunday they tested positive for COVID. I had it earlier in the week and really suffered.
I tested them as they were coughing, had a high fever and even D&V.

I rang on Monday morning to say they’d be missing the first day. They said they don’t recommended children are tested but said “You’ve done it now though”. I said well I still very much test for COVID because whilst none of us are vulnerable, other people may be and it’s them I’m protecting.

anyway it’s now Thursday and as requested I rang every day and updated them. But really it’s just ‘they’re still I’ll and have COVID’.

They’ve run me back every single day to discuss ’an update on the kids’. I just repeat myself from what I leave on the voicemail.

Yesterday I was on a train (I’m now negative and have been for some time) and they heard the announcement and asked where I was. When I said was on a train they asked if I’d left my kids on their own!! I said “no they’re 6 and 9!” And they asked who was watching them - their dad!!!

Today I emailed to say I have back to back meetings so can’t call but the kids remain to be ill (DH was on a plane at this point). Again they called me, which I missed. So I found a window to call them back and they again were strange and said “They have been ill for so so long now” (5 days!) asking when it started etc.

Im starting to get pissed off. I’m thinking of pulling them out and enrolling them in another school which we were also offered and according to the receptionist still have places.

AIBU to be annoyed at their persistence? Would they rather I sent sick COVID-infected kids into school? In their old school they were great and just said “We will see them when they’re better, keep us updated”.

OP posts:
MonsterMunchengladbach · 21/04/2023 15:15

In the OP's situation - where there was any hint of being suspected of failing to safeguard my own children - I would be making every possible effort to co-operate with the school and I'd have invited the staff member into my Plague house to speak with my children. The OP is playing at awkward buggers because she's pissed off with the school, and that's a loser's game.

Spottycarousel · 21/04/2023 14:56

People can feel absolutely awful and still manage to wave through a window. It's not either/or. The same is the case for children.

I think some of these posts have become overwhelmingly critical and nit picking.

I don't blame the op at all for feeling annoyed at the constant phoning, even knowing now about safeguarding rules. She's being a great mum keeping her kids off when they are sick. I've had two friends both who had covid for two weeks and were very unwell with it.

MonsterMunchengladbach · 21/04/2023 14:46

If they're not bed-ridden, that should say!

MonsterMunchengladbach · 21/04/2023 14:45

I would think it very weird that children were just waving through the window. If they're ill, they wouldn't be able to get up. If they're bed-ridden, then they could come to the door. The whole thing is odd. My children did not go to school with high temperatures or with D&V (or for 48 hours after the last episode - I was very strict about this one). Otherwise, they went to school because there was no reason for them not to.

CouldBeOuting · 21/04/2023 14:14

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 13:09

5 metres then. I was making the point that the op did in fact not let them into her home, and that the school have seen the children only 'waving through a window'.

It's confirmed that they're there and alive and not on holiday, but it's not exactly a thorough safeguarding check.

At this stage it’s “thorough” enough. They have seen the children looking content, they have seen the parent looking capable of caring for her children and if they return to school next week that will be the end if it.

I’ve been on a home visit where the parent opened the door so drunk she thought we were delivering her more booze. Fortunately the child was not physically harmed but was living in neglect. Social services subsequently worked with the family

CecilyP · 21/04/2023 14:05

They can't be that ill if they are able to wave from the window. They still want your children in school regardless according to them it's over. It only affects adults now haven't you heard?

OP can't win, can she? You think they're not ill enough to be home if they can wave from their bedroom window? Obviously, in your world, there is no middle ground between being bedridden and fit enough for school. Whilst other posters think OP should have got them up to show them off to the visitor from a 5 meter distance, so the visitor could see that they were indeed sick but not abused. And COVID does affect children and OP has detailed their symptoms in one of her early posts.

2bazookas · 21/04/2023 13:25

Is this normal in UK schools?

The legal obligation to safeguard their pupils, is standard in UK schools. No surprise every school is now ultra-careful to follow the law to the exact letter.

This morning's BBC news was about a Head Tracher who committed suicide because her school had undergone Ofsted inspection, which failed it on ONE issue, "safeguarding".

Humanbiology · 21/04/2023 13:16

Spottycarousel · 21/04/2023 12:50

They have covid

"For children and young people aged 18 and under who test positive for COVID-19, the advice is to try to stay at home and avoid contact with other people for three days."

This is day 4 they have a right to do a house check. I realise I have contradicted myself with my last post.

Humanbiology · 21/04/2023 13:13

MytosisIs · 21/04/2023 11:22

Update: They showed up at 8.30 (I’d already rang in) kids waved from the window I had a chat with them. I said I understood from their point of view they have safeguarding obligations but from my point of view they are ill and there’s not much I can do.

They can't be that ill if they are able to wave from the window. They still want your children in school regardless according to them it's over. It only affects adults now haven't you heard?

Schools are very strict with attendance and they will not think twice about taking you to court. As they see it you are holding back your children over a sniffle or a cough.

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 13:09

Hellocatshome · 21/04/2023 13:07

If I was stood 10 metres away from my doorstep I would be stood in the back yard.

5 metres then. I was making the point that the op did in fact not let them into her home, and that the school have seen the children only 'waving through a window'.

It's confirmed that they're there and alive and not on holiday, but it's not exactly a thorough safeguarding check.

RedEyeBaby · 21/04/2023 13:09

I'm also glad you've kept them off school with covid. You're a good mother.

Hellocatshome · 21/04/2023 13:07

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 13:01

I didn't ask why they didn't come into close contact. You can't catch covid standing on a doorstep outside from someone standing indoors 10 metres away.

If I was stood 10 metres away from my doorstep I would be stood in the back yard.

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 13:01

Spottycarousel · 21/04/2023 12:50

They have covid

I didn't ask why they didn't come into close contact. You can't catch covid standing on a doorstep outside from someone standing indoors 10 metres away.

Spottycarousel · 21/04/2023 12:50

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 12:39

Did the school visitor ask to come in?

Why didn't the children come to the door to see them?

They have covid

SVRT19674 · 21/04/2023 12:46

I totally agree with you, it is daft, and wrapped up as some safeguarding thing. They wouldnt get to my home either. But then, I live outside Britain, and think this is really odd. But from the amount of threads I have read about this, it seems quite common in the UK.

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 12:39

MytosisIs · 21/04/2023 11:22

Update: They showed up at 8.30 (I’d already rang in) kids waved from the window I had a chat with them. I said I understood from their point of view they have safeguarding obligations but from my point of view they are ill and there’s not much I can do.

Did the school visitor ask to come in?

Why didn't the children come to the door to see them?

Northernladdette · 21/04/2023 12:38

It’s not a safeguarding thing, they’re worried about their attendance figures, on which the school is judged…,

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 12:37

AlltheFs · 21/04/2023 12:33

I live in a very quaint, very exclusive rural farming village. School population of 58 (5-11 year olds). This would 100% be the protocol here for safeguarding, including a visit if anyone registered their children at the school and then neither child arrived for a week due to illness. It has absolutely nothing to do with type of area or background.

The most hideous abuse of children happens in all communities. I sat through another 8hrs of harrowing information about it yesterday (I’m safeguarding lead for adults but the training is delivered for adults & children). My close friend is a police officer in child protection, if you knew what she did you wouldn’t sleep at night. And yet children are still harmed and still die because people are in complete denial about what can and does happen.

Thank you for that. I also thought it was ridiculous when that poster kept suggesting there was no child abuse in her lovely safe area. People are just so wilfully ignorant of what goes on behind closed doors.

AlltheFs · 21/04/2023 12:33

wednesdaynamesep · 21/04/2023 09:11

I am sheltered from it. I think I stated as much.

My thoughts on OP saying she'd refuse a home visit are that, prior to understanding exactly what's going on and why, I'd have done the same. If you don't know why then it's seems spectacularly invasive.

Incidentally, the bundle of info from our school didn't include anything on this. I wonder ... is this location specific? Are there areas where child abuse is more rife?

Because the understanding and acceptance that schools HAVE to do this is quite revealing as well, if you think about it. It's like abuse has become normalised.

I live in a very quaint, very exclusive rural farming village. School population of 58 (5-11 year olds). This would 100% be the protocol here for safeguarding, including a visit if anyone registered their children at the school and then neither child arrived for a week due to illness. It has absolutely nothing to do with type of area or background.

The most hideous abuse of children happens in all communities. I sat through another 8hrs of harrowing information about it yesterday (I’m safeguarding lead for adults but the training is delivered for adults & children). My close friend is a police officer in child protection, if you knew what she did you wouldn’t sleep at night. And yet children are still harmed and still die because people are in complete denial about what can and does happen.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 21/04/2023 12:04

MytosisIs · 21/04/2023 11:22

Update: They showed up at 8.30 (I’d already rang in) kids waved from the window I had a chat with them. I said I understood from their point of view they have safeguarding obligations but from my point of view they are ill and there’s not much I can do.

That’s a good school. They actually keep on top of situations that could be problematic even when it’s uncomfortable.

Do you feel better about their position now?

Putyourdamnshoeson · 21/04/2023 11:33

So they saw the kids, they fulfilled their safeguarding obligation for now. If they continue not to see them, they'll come to your home again and may insist on more than a wave.
Please remember that these school staff are people too. They will have been dreading having to visit, what an awkward thing to have to do, right? But they know full well the potential consequences of they don't.
You have to not take this personally, it isn't about you.

Blondeshavemorefun · 21/04/2023 11:32

MytosisIs · 21/04/2023 11:22

Update: They showed up at 8.30 (I’d already rang in) kids waved from the window I had a chat with them. I said I understood from their point of view they have safeguarding obligations but from my point of view they are ill and there’s not much I can do.

How poorly are they now ?

If not temp then they can go back

All kids cough and sniff /runny nose etc

Will they both go back Monday ?

SleepingStandingUp · 21/04/2023 11:28

MytosisIs · 20/04/2023 22:01

I’m not understanding what I should have done differently this week that would have made me not a red flag? Short of sending very sick children into school

Well this is the thing.

Nothing.

Because their absence indicates either a shot parent neglecting her kids or a good parent protecting her kids, but there's nothing you can do to prove one way or the other, hence why it's hard for you AND school and the only tool they have is monitoring and persistence.

You just have to accept this isn't about YOU or your kids but A ANOTHER family and that it's worth checking on all families in the hope of picking up the one that needs help.

It isn't you so just accept it and carry on.

MytosisIs · 21/04/2023 11:22

Update: They showed up at 8.30 (I’d already rang in) kids waved from the window I had a chat with them. I said I understood from their point of view they have safeguarding obligations but from my point of view they are ill and there’s not much I can do.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 21/04/2023 09:54

@backstreetsbackallright

There is a balance between safeguarding children and harassing a parent unnecessarily. In my experience, I would say this school are doing the latter.

I totally agree with this. I understand the need for the school to bottom this out and check out anything which has the potential to be a red flag.

But I think a kind of hysteria has developed around safeguarding which lacks any subtlety and nuance. In practice the way this often manifests itself is that any family which fails to adhere to absolutely textbook parenting can end up being put through really unreasonable hoops.

Sometimes there is a genuine safeguarding concern. A lot of the time this is families who are busy and stressed trying to spin a lot of plates at the same time.

I had a recent situation with my DD's school where because I was unable to fill in a medicine consent form within hours of it being sent to me, I was told there was a potential safeguarding concern. I had sent my DD in with medicine but had not had access to a printer the day I sent it in so I sent a covering email and phoned in to explain the situation alongside medicine in a labelled bottle with prescribing instructions. About two hours after sending the form, the school nurse started calling me multiple times (when I was unable to answer the phone) and left a message telling me there would be a safeguarding concern if I couldn't get the form done immediately.

I was extremely polite and I reiterated again and again that I understood the need to check but privately I found this really overbearing and unnecessary (and extremely stressful). I had been in constant dialogue with the school, there was a clear prescription and just no need for this.

And honestly a PP is right: families which are slightly "non traditional" in any way (such as single parent families, poorer families or families where both parents work) are more likely to fall outside these safeguarding guardrails because they just aren't able to provide this constant level of back and forth dialogue with schools and adhere this strictly to the checkbox demands due to being busy.

I don't really know what the solution is because I do understand why schools do this. But I do think sometimes there's a very unbending and unrealistic approach to this and a lack of ability to apply basic intelligence and pragmatism to these situations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread