Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't believe we've been to the moon and SpaceXs failure further convinces me.

610 replies

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 20/04/2023 17:30

I know I've posted this before and the majority of you think I'm batty, but I don't think we've landed on the moon.

3 billion USD, a giant leap in technological advances and yet it can't even launch.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
Anactor · 22/04/2023 11:44

SwedishEdith · 22/04/2023 10:59

Whilst I still don't believe (honeslty it is akin to God for me, completely and utterly unbelievable) thank you for posting an alternative view point

Not sure I follow the logic here. Not "believing" in the moon landings is the same as belief in God. There is evidence of the moon landings and no evidence of God. The counter views to both of these require "belief".

Actually, I’m recognising a lot of the same kind of ‘my mind is made up, please don’t confuse me with evidence’ that I get when I chat online to dedicated atheists. Same vibe of presenting people with evidence (lots of evidence) and them finding various reasons to reject it.

The poster’s ‘I don’t believe it, so the evidence must be fake’ sounds very familiar.

There is evidence for the Moon Landings and if accepted, the evidence proves the Moon Landings happened. There is evidence for God and if accepted - it’s not enough to prove God exists.

If you like, the Moon Landings are proven facts of history, God is a theory with supporting evidence. That’s where ‘faith’ comes in - faith is when we believe in things without sufficient evidence to prove them beyond a doubt.

SwedishEdith · 22/04/2023 10:59

Whilst I still don't believe (honeslty it is akin to God for me, completely and utterly unbelievable) thank you for posting an alternative view point

Not sure I follow the logic here. Not "believing" in the moon landings is the same as belief in God. There is evidence of the moon landings and no evidence of God. The counter views to both of these require "belief".

BMW6 · 22/04/2023 09:07

There were 6 successful lunar landings in total.

12 men have walked on the moon.

SerendipityJane · 22/04/2023 09:03

This thread is the reason we have words like idiot. numpty and worse in all languages. It's also not a great advert to encourage young people - especially girls - into STEM subjects which we so desperately need.

It will however ensure that internet scammers will continue to target the UK. Clearly rich pickings here.

MaryBeardsShoes · 22/04/2023 08:57

I think we need to leave the moon alone. We’ve already wrecked one planet. Poor The Moon. Doesn’t know what’s coming.

saffy2 · 22/04/2023 08:24

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 20/04/2023 21:10

Weird you ask this as my sister and I had this conversation today. I feel the same as how come if we got to the moon in 1969 they haven't done it since with all the money and new technology.

Cracking up at all the people commenting who haven’t even googled.
we have landed on the moon at least 5 times…

saffy2 · 22/04/2023 08:04

Lauz841 · 20/04/2023 18:26

I understand what you're saying and I've thought about this a few times. Im not saying that i dont believe it happened, but just that i have an open mind about it. The moon landing was in 69, and I just find it very difficult to think of a solid, valid reason why we (as a species) have never done it again. I can obviously think of many reasons, but with the huge advances in technology I really would have thought someone would have succeeded since the 60's.

Are you aware that since 1969 they did do it again 4 more times…

saffy2 · 22/04/2023 07:59

Tarantullah · 20/04/2023 17:48

It's strange the US hasn't landed on the moon since, thought they'd have built a Mc Donald's and some sort of space military base by now. It was an incredible feat especially given the general capabilites of technology then, I do also find it strange but wouldn't say I don't believe it happened, I'm just open minded about it.

I mean, the US have landed on the moon 5 times. Could be more by now…
why do people think they only went once? 🤔

notimagain · 22/04/2023 07:25

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/04/2023 00:27

Ok then. Why don’t you let NASA know just easy it is then?

Quote:

Proper Propulsion
The farther into space a vehicle ventures, the more capable its propulsion systems need to be to maintain its course on the journey with precision and ensure its crew can get home.
Orion has a highly capable service module that serves as the powerhouse for the spacecraft, providing propulsion capabilities that enable Orion to go around the Moon and back on its exploration missions. The service module has 33 engines of various sizes. The main engine will provide major in-space maneuvering capabilities throughout the mission, including inserting Orion into lunar orbit and also firing powerfully enough to get out of the Moon’s orbit to return to Earth. The other 32 engines are used to steer and control Orion on orbit.

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/top-five-technologies-needed-for-a-spacecraft-to-survive-deep-space

I didn't say it was easy,

OTOH some posters are saying/implying/mistaken in thinking that because the Moon is (roughly) a thousand times further away from the Earth than the ISS then it's a thousand times harder/difficult (on some arbitrary scale of their choice) to get to the Moon than it is to get to the ISS...

That's completely wrong and is perhaps an example of where even a basic knowledge of the Physics, especially knowledge of the laws of gravity and the concept of escape velocity are more use than simply "common sense" combined with "critical thinking".

FWIW the rough numbers I gave on velocities (orbital and escape) still stand, I'm sure NASA don't need my help on that.

The C&P you provided is interesting, but not really relevant to how Orion accelerates from orbital velocity to escape velocity. The energy for that is provided by the Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage, part of SLS, which does a similar job to that performed by the Saturn V S-IVB stage which sent Apollo to the Moon.

The Orion service module propulsion system comes into play after the IPS is dumped.

Hope that helps.

Mamanyt · 22/04/2023 02:52

It was not a NASA ship. It was an Elon Musk ship, which probably explains it.

Now, this is the plain truth of going to the moon...we did not, at that time, have the technology in video to fake the moon shots. It did not exist. I know it sounds odd that we could even attempt to send a man to the moon, but could not have faked the video of it, but, there you have it. And I now, looking back, realize how incredibly dangerous that trip was. We could easily have faked the still shots, but NOT the actual video.

GoldenAye · 22/04/2023 02:41

woketwatism · 21/04/2023 23:25

Of course it’s fake - look at the footage , it’s so obvious.
While you’re at it look at the videos of 9/11 - there were no planes, cgi. People took videos with recorders the explosions came from inside. Eye witnesses said no planes , explosions from inside.

climate change - we have less co2 than we had millions of years ago. If it gets lower plant life will die.

As for the gene therapy https://www.theflstandard.com/top-insurance-analyst-600-000-americans-per-year-are-dying-from-covid-shots/

switch off your TVs. I wear my tinfoil hat proudly

So much idiocy crammed in just a few sentences. I'm almost proud of you!

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 22/04/2023 01:10

BMW6 · 22/04/2023 00:13

It WAS really exciting. In July 1969.

Yes! I remember getting up early and then watching on and off all day on the live television feed.

In those days, schools didn’t have televisions - a local hi fi and television shop lent us one for the day.

The OP is an example of the stupidity of a half-education. They’ve grasped the concept of asking sceptical questions, but not the concept of actually having any knowledge about the topic.

Unless they can give me a reference to their peer-reviewed publications in reputable scientific research journals.

But I guess pigs might fly, as well.

Sturnip · 22/04/2023 01:10

Vynalbob · 21/04/2023 23:04

Two points....what was the purpose then and what is the purpose now.

In any other field technology gets cheaper and better.

I'm just agreeing with OP that it's odd....I do think it happened though.

The purpose then was that the capitalist USA and communist USSR were in a technological arms race, to bolster their hard and soft power. Putting a man on the moon had never been done before and was perceived to be a huge PR victory.

There was, of course, some interesting scientific research to be conducted but that was really secondary to the achievement itself.

The aim of Space-X (Musk’s endeavour) is to get to Mars and begin colonizing. This is also the same reason why NASA plans to return to the moon in the coming years, in preparation for a Mars trip, something which would have been unthinkable a decade or two ago.

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/04/2023 01:00

TruthsAndALie · 21/04/2023 19:04

Why is anyone trying to go there (again or for the first time)? Don’t get the point, what’s the benefit?

I don’t think SpaceX et al should be allowed; waste of natural resource and HUGE pollution issue that is undoing some of the regeneration of the ozone layer.

Ground it I say.

I get where you are coming from and I agree that we need to put our energy and resources into preserving our planet and reducing our carbon emissions.

The reason why they want to build a rocket to take people to the moon (these days) is not just about creating firsts eg. the first woman to the moon and the first person of colour to the moon (that is one of their objectives) but to eventually be able to travel to Mars.

Why do we want to go to Mars? To colonise it. What is so great about colonising Mars when Earth has such an abundance of life and resources? Because we may have fucked up the climate here on earth and it would be great to have a back up planet to go live on.

Let’s say we can create an ecosystem that enables us to live on Mars, how amazing would that be. If we can do that, then surely we can preserve the ecosystem here.

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/04/2023 00:27

notimagain · 21/04/2023 10:35

@ImustLearn2Cook

the International Space Station is 400 km from Earth but the moon is a whopping 384,000 km from Earth. So clearly it is much easier to get to the International Space Station.

Those numbers have been quoted a few times so is it perhaps worth pointing out that there is not a linear relationship between distance travelled and energy/velocity needed to do so.

To get into Low Earth orbit to go to ISS you need to reach roughly 18,000 MPH,

To set off for the Moon you need roughly 25,000 MPH.

Basically from an energy/velocity/propulsion POV once you've got into Low Earth Orbit at 18,000 MPH you're well over half way to the Moon, you just 🙄need to find another 7000 MPH.

Ok then. Why don’t you let NASA know just easy it is then?

Quote:

Proper Propulsion
The farther into space a vehicle ventures, the more capable its propulsion systems need to be to maintain its course on the journey with precision and ensure its crew can get home.
Orion has a highly capable service module that serves as the powerhouse for the spacecraft, providing propulsion capabilities that enable Orion to go around the Moon and back on its exploration missions. The service module has 33 engines of various sizes. The main engine will provide major in-space maneuvering capabilities throughout the mission, including inserting Orion into lunar orbit and also firing powerfully enough to get out of the Moon’s orbit to return to Earth. The other 32 engines are used to steer and control Orion on orbit.

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/top-five-technologies-needed-for-a-spacecraft-to-survive-deep-space

https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/orion_smonline.pdf

BMW6 · 22/04/2023 00:13

Candymay · 21/04/2023 22:37

It would be great if man really could go to the moon though. So exciting to think about it.

It WAS really exciting. In July 1969.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 21/04/2023 23:47

There are some spectacularly dumb takes on this thread. The Super Heavy launch is not a retrograde step, it’s a first test of a vehicle with a bunch of very new technologies on board.

  • Reusable 1st AND 2nd stages
  • Methane powered engines with full flow combustion
  • Fucking HUGE payload capacity
  • On-orbit refuelling capability

This monster is a game changer and with so much pioneering technology it will take a few goes to get right. In ten years time hundreds of these will have launched thousands of tonnes of kit to the lunar surface.

And there are well documented and clear reasons the US didn’t return humans to the moon after Apollo 17, and why we concentrated on LEO missions. The OP is so completely uninformed it’s mind boggling.

Oakbeam · 21/04/2023 23:42

@Inwiththenew

They also didn’t have the technology to take photos or film in space. Obviously you can’t use a normal camera.

It’s not obvious to me. Please explain why they couldn’t have used a normal camera and film.

Jourdain11 · 21/04/2023 23:37

Although on 9/11, I was a 12 year old in a Geography class and my teacher was trying to flip the classroom TV from TV channels to DVD and kept coming back to the same image (the plane hitting the second tower). She did definitely say, "why are they all showing a silly disaster film at this time of the day?"

Candymay · 21/04/2023 23:34

woketwatism · 21/04/2023 23:25

Of course it’s fake - look at the footage , it’s so obvious.
While you’re at it look at the videos of 9/11 - there were no planes, cgi. People took videos with recorders the explosions came from inside. Eye witnesses said no planes , explosions from inside.

climate change - we have less co2 than we had millions of years ago. If it gets lower plant life will die.

As for the gene therapy https://www.theflstandard.com/top-insurance-analyst-600-000-americans-per-year-are-dying-from-covid-shots/

switch off your TVs. I wear my tinfoil hat proudly

Looooooorrrrrrrddddd have mercy

Jourdain11 · 21/04/2023 23:27

woketwatism · 21/04/2023 23:25

Of course it’s fake - look at the footage , it’s so obvious.
While you’re at it look at the videos of 9/11 - there were no planes, cgi. People took videos with recorders the explosions came from inside. Eye witnesses said no planes , explosions from inside.

climate change - we have less co2 than we had millions of years ago. If it gets lower plant life will die.

As for the gene therapy https://www.theflstandard.com/top-insurance-analyst-600-000-americans-per-year-are-dying-from-covid-shots/

switch off your TVs. I wear my tinfoil hat proudly

Whaaaaaat? Of course there were bloody planes!

woketwatism · 21/04/2023 23:25

Of course it’s fake - look at the footage , it’s so obvious.
While you’re at it look at the videos of 9/11 - there were no planes, cgi. People took videos with recorders the explosions came from inside. Eye witnesses said no planes , explosions from inside.

climate change - we have less co2 than we had millions of years ago. If it gets lower plant life will die.

As for the gene therapy https://www.theflstandard.com/top-insurance-analyst-600-000-americans-per-year-are-dying-from-covid-shots/

switch off your TVs. I wear my tinfoil hat proudly

600,000 Americans Per Year Are Dying From COVID Shots Says Top Insurance Analyst

Former Bernstein senior analyst Josh Stirling draws a shocking conclusion from UK government health data.

https://www.theflstandard.com/top-insurance-analyst-600-000-americans-per-year-are-dying-from-covid-shots/

Vynalbob · 21/04/2023 23:04

Sturnip · 21/04/2023 21:14

The US spent $25 billion in the 1960s on the Apollo program. Adjusted for inflation, that’s about $250 billion today. Space-X has cost around 1% of that. It’s relative peanuts.

In the 1960s, against the backdrop of the Cold War, there was the political will for the US to beat Russia to the moon. It was a massive investment with a cost so prohibitive that public support (which was only ever lukewarm at best, given the money involved) evaporated after the first few landings.

Which countries do you think, over the past half century, have had both (a) the financial resources, and (b) public support to expend tens of billions of pounds, in order to also send a manned spacecraft to the moon (for no particularly obvious purpose)?

Two points....what was the purpose then and what is the purpose now.

In any other field technology gets cheaper and better.

I'm just agreeing with OP that it's odd....I do think it happened though.

Candymay · 21/04/2023 22:37

It would be great if man really could go to the moon though. So exciting to think about it.

KimberleyClark · 21/04/2023 21:34

Do those who think we never landed on the moon think all subsequent Apollo missions were also faked?

Swipe left for the next trending thread