Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to put mum in care home

115 replies

Cantaffordthecost · 20/04/2023 15:53

So my 85-year-old mum, who is widowed, has become doubly incontinent and confused. We are in the process of getting a dementia diagnosis. We’ve recently had to start carers (sourced by social services) as she can no longer manage her personal hygiene and can’t make herself meals or clean herself properly when she is left in a mess from her incontinence. We’ve just had the finance assessment from the council and we have been told we need to pay £142 a week and we just don’t have it. She has a monthly income of £1,143 in pension but our costs for heating alone last year - which they don’t take into account - were £350 and that’s without the rise. We pay for a stairlift and spend best part of £100 a month on incontinence pants - not counting the numerous washing machine loads etc we are doing daily. That is in addition to travel costs to hospital appointments on a weekly basis plus general living costs. We expected to pay some but we just haven’t got the money to pay this much. But she can go and live in a nursing /residential home and have £34.75 a week pocket money with the rest of the costs met. It will leave us financially better off but obviously cost the council far more. Where is the logic in that? Am I being unreasonable to think we have no choice but to find her a residential home or does anyone have any suggestions? The one thing we can’t do is find that much money.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 20/04/2023 18:11

Don't feel guilty in the slightest. No parent surely, before any mental impairment, would expect or allow their busy adult DC in the prime of their life with jobs and families of their own to commit indefinitely to caring for them with all the time and stress that entails, as you are doing.

Mirabai · 20/04/2023 18:10

My aunt had dementia, double incontinence and mobility issues. She had lovely carers at her home but she still spent quite a bit of time alone. She perked up when she went into a home and I think not being responsible for her house was a massive weight off her mind. I wish we had done it sooner.

Featherhands · 20/04/2023 17:59

Having just been through this whole thing, can I just say that it's time. You are in the fortunate situation where you can go and see them and find out what's right for her - push for that with the local authority. you can't just get placed, you have to have some input.

she needs more help and more and more care. Best you do it considered than in a rush because she's had a horrible fall etc.

I speak from experience.

Huge sympathy and kindness to all concerned. It's a horrible decision to have to make.

FairAcre · 20/04/2023 17:58

When my mum had dementia we tried everything to keep her out of a care home. There were three of us and one of us went every day and we had carers twice a day. It just wasn’t enough. She was frightened and confused whenever she was alone. The occupational therapist who was sent to assess her made us see that in a care home there would always be someone to reassure her, make her a cup of tea at any time, help with her hygiene etc 24/7. It was a hard decision to make because you never feel your parent is bad enough to go in a care home. It was the best decision though. We still visited her ever day and would take her out, she made friends there and the staff were lovely and patient. You and your brother cannot be with her 24/7 and believe me it will only get worse.

JonahAndTheSnail · 20/04/2023 17:54

I don't think you should feel guilty about looking at care homes as an option as you and your brother obviously care greatly for your mum's wellbeing. If you are no longer having to spend time cleaning carpets and laundering clothes, you could spend that time enriching your mum's life by spending more quality time with her, perhaps taking her places etc.

ittakes2 · 20/04/2023 17:50

I would write to the council with the figures you have given us and ask them which option they would prefer. I did this for my m'n'law when my f'n'law had dementia and outlined their costs of him moving into a home compared to them helping him stay at home...and they had a rethink and helped him stay at home.

Hankunamatata · 20/04/2023 17:46

If she gets carers in then you could use the attendance allowance for the carers as wouldn't they do some cleaning and washing?
Check out the attendance allowance if she needs supervision day and night she may get the higher rate of £100 per week.

ferneytorro · 20/04/2023 17:44

Cantaffordthecost · 20/04/2023 17:09

Thank you for all your suggestions.
My mum has her own home but doesn’t own it thanks to an equity release mortgage from years ago. Unfortunately this bans anyone from living with her although my brother stays there most nights so she isn’t on her own as she can’t manage overnight.
She gets attendance allowance but this is used for someone to come in and see once a week and clean/ do the washing etc. My brother and I do the bulk of this though as it’s needed daily along with daily carpet washing as a result of numerous accidents!
She has to wear absorbent pants rather than pads as she can’t manage the pads. She doesn’t really understand wearing pads and just never put them in no matter how often we asked her and checked up on it. We had to resort to hiding her normal pants and only giving her the absorbent ones. Unfortunately we’ve been told only pads can be supplied and we can’t face the mess that goes with that or risk mam sitting in wet or soiled underwear which was what was happening before we switched.
We got the council finance assessment today and we had thought we might have to find about £60-80 a week or so but never thought it would be almost twice that.
She hasn’t got a dementia diagnosis yet but to be honest the more I think about it and reading these suggestions I think a home might be best. She’s lonely and hates being on her own and really struggles with the constant incontinence issues so being looked after somewhere there is company might work.
I looked at a care home I thought would be nice earlier this week with a view to respite but it was soul destroying - and that was one with good reviews and reports from families I know who used it.
Time to look at some others and see if they are better I suppose.

Why are you having to fund it - that's not right , they can't take relatives income into account. It's her income and house and savings.

Timesawastin · 20/04/2023 17:36

Cantaffordthecost · 20/04/2023 15:53

So my 85-year-old mum, who is widowed, has become doubly incontinent and confused. We are in the process of getting a dementia diagnosis. We’ve recently had to start carers (sourced by social services) as she can no longer manage her personal hygiene and can’t make herself meals or clean herself properly when she is left in a mess from her incontinence. We’ve just had the finance assessment from the council and we have been told we need to pay £142 a week and we just don’t have it. She has a monthly income of £1,143 in pension but our costs for heating alone last year - which they don’t take into account - were £350 and that’s without the rise. We pay for a stairlift and spend best part of £100 a month on incontinence pants - not counting the numerous washing machine loads etc we are doing daily. That is in addition to travel costs to hospital appointments on a weekly basis plus general living costs. We expected to pay some but we just haven’t got the money to pay this much. But she can go and live in a nursing /residential home and have £34.75 a week pocket money with the rest of the costs met. It will leave us financially better off but obviously cost the council far more. Where is the logic in that? Am I being unreasonable to think we have no choice but to find her a residential home or does anyone have any suggestions? The one thing we can’t do is find that much money.

Hang on though, it's the older person who pays, not the family. Her income must be enough to pay this contribution. I think you need a clearer picture of care home costs, as she would be expected to contribute to those too, up to a limit.

SpringLobelia · 20/04/2023 17:35

Hbh17 · 20/04/2023 17:16

Of course YANBU. In view of her care needs, a care home is clearly the most appropriate place for her. You and your brother are already doing far too much and she needs to be somewhere with proper professional support.

I agree. She will be safer and more comfortable in a care home. You have done everything you can and more it sounds like. But to me it definitely sounds like the best decision.

Thanks
Timesawastin · 20/04/2023 17:33

Lastnamedidntstick · 20/04/2023 16:03

Following as I can see us being in a similar situation soon.

the elderly parent in our case has just sold her house for £700000 so I assume she will be expected to pay for a care home?

Yes, as she should. As I said to my late mum, this is the rainy day you've been saving for...

Clarabell77 · 20/04/2023 17:30

I don’t trust care homes. Genuinely caring care homes are few and far between. Sorry for your mum and you and the family. It would be much better if something could be sorted to keep her at home, unless you can confidently find somewhere that would actually care for her.

Nordicrain · 20/04/2023 17:29

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/04/2023 17:28

Well, it’s not quite self evident, is it? We don’t expect a cancer patient to contribute to treatment fees if they have £700,000 in the bank. Why have we decided that no-one, however rich, needs to contribute to diseases which have a medical treatment, but the whole cost should fall on those unlucky enough to succumb to a disease which doesn’t have a medical treatment?

But a care home isn't medical treatment?

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/04/2023 17:28

Nordicrain · 20/04/2023 16:23

Do you not think she should have to with 700k in the bank?

Well, it’s not quite self evident, is it? We don’t expect a cancer patient to contribute to treatment fees if they have £700,000 in the bank. Why have we decided that no-one, however rich, needs to contribute to diseases which have a medical treatment, but the whole cost should fall on those unlucky enough to succumb to a disease which doesn’t have a medical treatment?

VickyEadieofThigh · 20/04/2023 17:27

Lastnamedidntstick · 20/04/2023 16:22

Thank you.

no she’s moved in with one of her children. However that child is not a “carer”- good at sorting logistics, but I can’t see them wiping bums etc.

they seem to think £200k will be enough to pay for any care needed for the remainder of relatives life. I disagree. Especially if a care home is needed, or a 1:1 carer which is apparently their plan.

would they have to pay 100% of care home fees until the money is gone, or just “top up” over LA contributions?

If the elderly person has more than £23k they must pay for their care - all of it - until they are down to £23k. Then, however, they will still pay part of it until they are down to (not certain of exact amount) about £13k.

My Dad had £60k in savings, no property. He paid out £10k - the full cost of the short time he was in care before he died.

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/04/2023 17:22

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 20/04/2023 16:42

@Lastnamedidntstick yes if your mum (MIL?) has just sold her home for £700,000 then that sum will need to be used to pay for her ongoing care costs. Care home fees are likely to be around £6,000 per month - depending on where you live. You are still entitled to claim for attendance allowance as this isn't means dependent .

You can only get AA in a care home if you are a self funder, with no LA contribution

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/04/2023 17:20

@Cantaffordthecost Are you sure of the calculations? If on the basis of her income they’ve calculated she needs to contribute £142,then they’ll come to the same conclusion if she’s in a care home, or more if she owns her current home.

The “pocket money” you refer to isn’t so that she’s given, it’s the amount they’ll let her keep out of her pension if they’re contributing to the funding of the care home.

ChickenDhansak82 · 20/04/2023 17:17

Cantaffordthecost · 20/04/2023 17:09

Thank you for all your suggestions.
My mum has her own home but doesn’t own it thanks to an equity release mortgage from years ago. Unfortunately this bans anyone from living with her although my brother stays there most nights so she isn’t on her own as she can’t manage overnight.
She gets attendance allowance but this is used for someone to come in and see once a week and clean/ do the washing etc. My brother and I do the bulk of this though as it’s needed daily along with daily carpet washing as a result of numerous accidents!
She has to wear absorbent pants rather than pads as she can’t manage the pads. She doesn’t really understand wearing pads and just never put them in no matter how often we asked her and checked up on it. We had to resort to hiding her normal pants and only giving her the absorbent ones. Unfortunately we’ve been told only pads can be supplied and we can’t face the mess that goes with that or risk mam sitting in wet or soiled underwear which was what was happening before we switched.
We got the council finance assessment today and we had thought we might have to find about £60-80 a week or so but never thought it would be almost twice that.
She hasn’t got a dementia diagnosis yet but to be honest the more I think about it and reading these suggestions I think a home might be best. She’s lonely and hates being on her own and really struggles with the constant incontinence issues so being looked after somewhere there is company might work.
I looked at a care home I thought would be nice earlier this week with a view to respite but it was soul destroying - and that was one with good reviews and reports from families I know who used it.
Time to look at some others and see if they are better I suppose.

This can't be right. She doesn't live with you so why are you having to fund anything?!?!

Is this the case of the council trying to pass the care costs on to someone else and guilt trip them into paying when it is not your responsibility? It happens a lot...

FWIW, I remember my parents being told something similar (going back 15 years ago) with my gran who lived alone. She needed had to go into an assisted home and the council were trying to get my parents to pay the extra which wasn't right - my gran had no assets, only a state pension as she was widowed aged 32 and never remarried). In the end they didn't have to pay anything, and my gran finally ended up in a residential home with around £20 a week left over to spend on newspapers and a pedicure or something!

Hbh17 · 20/04/2023 17:16

Of course YANBU. In view of her care needs, a care home is clearly the most appropriate place for her. You and your brother are already doing far too much and she needs to be somewhere with proper professional support.

Cantaffordthecost · 20/04/2023 17:09

Thank you for all your suggestions.
My mum has her own home but doesn’t own it thanks to an equity release mortgage from years ago. Unfortunately this bans anyone from living with her although my brother stays there most nights so she isn’t on her own as she can’t manage overnight.
She gets attendance allowance but this is used for someone to come in and see once a week and clean/ do the washing etc. My brother and I do the bulk of this though as it’s needed daily along with daily carpet washing as a result of numerous accidents!
She has to wear absorbent pants rather than pads as she can’t manage the pads. She doesn’t really understand wearing pads and just never put them in no matter how often we asked her and checked up on it. We had to resort to hiding her normal pants and only giving her the absorbent ones. Unfortunately we’ve been told only pads can be supplied and we can’t face the mess that goes with that or risk mam sitting in wet or soiled underwear which was what was happening before we switched.
We got the council finance assessment today and we had thought we might have to find about £60-80 a week or so but never thought it would be almost twice that.
She hasn’t got a dementia diagnosis yet but to be honest the more I think about it and reading these suggestions I think a home might be best. She’s lonely and hates being on her own and really struggles with the constant incontinence issues so being looked after somewhere there is company might work.
I looked at a care home I thought would be nice earlier this week with a view to respite but it was soul destroying - and that was one with good reviews and reports from families I know who used it.
Time to look at some others and see if they are better I suppose.

OP posts:
CloudPop · 20/04/2023 16:59

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 20/04/2023 16:45

Sometimes going to live in a care home where a relative can get the care they need is the right decision to make. It sounds as though your mum might need that and while finances shouldn't drive things, sometimes they do and that's just life. I'm not sure if you and your mum are getting all the benefits eg attendance allowance, help with continence pads? Maybe citizens advice could help if you are thinking to keep your mum at home if possible.

Agree with this. We all need to move on from thinking "putting in a care home"
Is the least good solution, many times it is entirely the right and best thing to do for everyone concerned.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 20/04/2023 16:45

Sometimes going to live in a care home where a relative can get the care they need is the right decision to make. It sounds as though your mum might need that and while finances shouldn't drive things, sometimes they do and that's just life. I'm not sure if you and your mum are getting all the benefits eg attendance allowance, help with continence pads? Maybe citizens advice could help if you are thinking to keep your mum at home if possible.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 20/04/2023 16:42

@Lastnamedidntstick yes if your mum (MIL?) has just sold her home for £700,000 then that sum will need to be used to pay for her ongoing care costs. Care home fees are likely to be around £6,000 per month - depending on where you live. You are still entitled to claim for attendance allowance as this isn't means dependent .

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 20/04/2023 16:37

@Cantaffordthecost
You should be able to get someone from your local adult services to do a financial assessment as well as an assessment of needs for your mum. A couple of things - one, as others have mentioned your mum needs to claim for attendance allowance, if she isn't already. Secondly she should be able to get free incontinence pads though the district nurses and also some support in respect of making her home safer for her - through occupational health services - either the GP or memory (dementia) centre should be able to support with referral .

However - unless either you or your siblings are in a position to provide a lot more support to her yourselves (as in being there and helping rather than financial) then at some point it is likely your mum may need to move into a care home . It would probably be a good idea to start looking round now - seeing which local homes have availability and which ones will accept local authority funding referrals (i.e. where you won't be expected to pay top up). It sounds at the moment that your mum would be OK with residential care (as opposed to full nursing) and a decent home should be able to give support in respect of dementia including activities to help her mentally active ).

dowhat · 20/04/2023 16:28

YANBU

My mum, also widowed, was struggling with personal hygiene and taking care of herself with cooking, cleaning etc. We paid for someone to help with her shopping, cleaning and bits around her retirement flat, but other than that let her get on with it. Until she had a fall. In hospital the occupational therapist, physiotherapist, nutritionist, social worker and doctor all recommended she move to a care home, which is what we did (not that she thanked us for it!). We're lucky the decision was essentially taken out of our hands, but I'd say don't leave it.