Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any other school that do auditions for choir and have a DC that hasn't been chosen?

34 replies

ChoirAuditions · 20/04/2023 13:30

My DC hasn’t been offered a place despite trying out several time, this is Key Stage 2 so 7 to 11 year olds and primary aged. Only the best singers are allowed.

I think this isn’t on. I absolutely get limiting places to say 30/40 but surely at this age it should be first come first served? Or another fair system like if you’ve never been before and don’t go to any other school clubs?

I get my DC isn’t the best singer, but I feel they should be given the chance to join in, even if they never get a solo or even get chosen for events etc. I think the same about all choirs, they should be available for everyone to join in not just the best singers. How can they improve if not given the chance?

I get the teacher or TA is giving up their time to run the club but I can’t help feeling gutted for my little DC who tried so hard to get into the choir for the 3rd time and didn’t get chosen again (just had the email from school to say they’re not accepted)

Are other schools like this? DC has SN so can’t do other clubs in school time and I feel that choir would really help their SN, but we’re not even given a chance to see if it will help.

I've looked into local childrens choirs but they seem to run a similar system of only selecting the best singers, there doesn't seem to be a community choir where anyone can join in.

So anything else I can try for them?

OP posts:
Tigofigo · 20/04/2023 13:45

It's the same with sports. I have a sporty child who works hard at their favourite sport but they're just not quite good enough to make the team. We're doing community sports outside of school instead. Near me there are definitely non auditioned children's choirs.

ChoirAuditions · 20/04/2023 13:45

listsandbudgets · 20/04/2023 13:43

DS's school has 2 choirs. One can be joined by anyone. The other is by invitation by the music teachers and drawn from the main choir. Both have the opportunity to perform including solos and visiting other schools but the second choir does more complicated things and competitions. DS was invited but chose not to join as he just wants to sing for fun and the second is more serious work.

They have the same system with the orchestra - the unauditioned one makes a very interesting collection of noises Grin

@listsandbudgets Thats a good system, I'm not bothered if DC never gets chosen for solos or to do competitions, they just want to have a bit of fun an sing with their friends, which is the way it should be.

OP posts:
listsandbudgets · 20/04/2023 13:43

DS's school has 2 choirs. One can be joined by anyone. The other is by invitation by the music teachers and drawn from the main choir. Both have the opportunity to perform including solos and visiting other schools but the second choir does more complicated things and competitions. DS was invited but chose not to join as he just wants to sing for fun and the second is more serious work.

They have the same system with the orchestra - the unauditioned one makes a very interesting collection of noises Grin

TeenDivided · 20/04/2023 13:42

If you have the money, then try Stagecoach for musical theatre.

I think it is a shame when things are selective at primary level, for all things like sports teams and choir etc. How do children get a chance to improve if they are told at 8 they are not good enough?

And yes, I know that it is up to teachers, they don't have to run clubs etc, but being inclusive at primary should be the standard.

northerngoldilocks · 20/04/2023 13:41

That feels quite harsh at junior age. My DDs junior school has a massive choir that anyone can attend and the secondary has both a fun choir for all and a more serious auditioned one.

It sounds as though they're aiming it at competitions though. Are there any other local options she could do instead? My DD does a non auditioned choir at her Sat music school and our local church has a childrens choir without audition.

ChoirAuditions · 20/04/2023 13:37

Skybluepinky · 20/04/2023 13:36

If they r attending competitions they need the best singers only.
Find a MT club and join that.

@Skybluepinky But surely they can just take the best singers to competitions? I'm not worried about that, it just feels really unfair.

Will look at Musical Theatre which is what I'm assuming you mean?

OP posts:
Skybluepinky · 20/04/2023 13:36

If they r attending competitions they need the best singers only.
Find a MT club and join that.

ChoirAuditions · 20/04/2023 13:34

hopeishere · 20/04/2023 13:31

Have you spoken to the school?

Are there local drama groups? Singing lessons??

@hopeishere School say it's up to the Teacher or TA running the club to decide selection process, if that's auditions or try outs or similar then it's fair to everyone.

Will look at local drama groups to see if they do singing. I can't see any just choirs and I don't think DC would want to sing alone.

OP posts:
hopeishere · 20/04/2023 13:31

Have you spoken to the school?

Are there local drama groups? Singing lessons??