Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 04:43

You appear to have got very confused regarding individual salaries and household income, which was the entire point of the comparison I made. 🙄

IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 04:39

I don't think you've really understood my post at all given the random stuff you posted, but if you can explain what you mean that would be helpful.

L1ttledrummergirl · 22/04/2023 17:36

For example, a couple with a £50k earnings and two children may receive £17.5k+ in universal credit plus child benefit for two children of another £2k plus Council tax support of nearly £2k. Their net pay after tax is £3504 per month. £173 child benefit. £1454 UC and £154 council tax support based on average costs in my area as an example. With no disabilities or health needs and normal nursery expenses (I just ran it through some calculators).

Lol.

Where I am a couple each working minimum wage for 40 hours a week with 2 dc would only get child benefit. So £40 a week. £1512 each giving them £3024 net plus your £173 child benefit.

A couple each earning £50000 a year would still get the child benefit but would also earn £3023 each a month, or £6026 net +£173.

A single person earning £60000, would have a take home pay of £3508 a month. They would also have a single person discount on their council tax.

https://www.stafftax.co.uk/gross-to-net-salary-calculator

I based it on standard tax allowance and no student loan.

It's also worth bearing in mind that because the cost of childcare is more than minimum wage, many low income families don't have 2 full time workers, 1 is quite often part time.

For universal credit they would be entitled to £1120 a month, less 55p for every £ they earn. Assuming they are working 60 hours between them the deduction is £1488 meaning they would be entitled to £0 universal credit. That gives them a monthly net of £2756.

https://www.gov.uk/universal-credit/what-youll-get

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 15:44

beguilingeyes · 22/04/2023 12:34

As was said previously, it doesn't mean the people who have incomes in six figures or so who 'made good choices' (although that's very disparaging to the rest of us). It means the people who've done bugger all but one of their ancestors made a king happy and now they get to go to Eton and think that inherited wealth makes them capable of running the country, for example.
What has Zac Goldsmith done to qualify him to be a minister except have a billionaire as a father?
£100,000 earnings isn't enough to be called rich these days. As Phil Collins said 'I remember when a million pounds was a lot of money '.

Exactly. In fact using my example just posted, a single parent would only just get to the net income that a couple receive for earning £25k each if the single parent earned £100k!

Think about that. They have to earn twice as much as two people put together to get the same net income. That is shocking. And anybody who thinks that is "rich" is taking the absolute piss.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 15:38

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 07:44

Fix the tax code to level the playing field and far fewer single parents will need any benefits because they'll be able to keep enough of their own earnings to support themselves.

What "earnings" might those be. Ah yes they're the most likely societal group to be minimum wage earners, so they'll get to keep the crumbs of that job in care work, retail, dinner lady at the school where their children are so the sum total of bugger-all then.

Not sure what planet you're on but no, that's not the case at all. Got any evidence to back up this bigoted ignorance?

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 15:37

TomPinch · 22/04/2023 05:41

What's the average difference though? I'm sceptical that it's all down to the tax system.

It's much more normal for families to have to get by with two incomes. Hard when there's only one person earning the income.

The difference can be huge.

For example, a couple with a £50k earnings and two children may receive £17.5k+ in universal credit plus child benefit for two children of another £2k plus Council tax support of nearly £2k. Their net pay after tax is £3504 per month. £173 child benefit. £1454 UC and £154 council tax support based on average costs in my area as an example. With no disabilities or health needs and normal nursery expenses (I just ran it through some calculators).

A single parent earning £60k - so actually earning more of their money - will have net pay of £3654 per month. No UC. No child benefit. No Council tax support, nothing.

So the couple have an earned household income of £50k and their net income per month is £5285. A single parent with an earned income of £60k still receives far, far less net income, only £3654. The couple receive 69% more net income, for earning less. That is HUGE. And they obviously have 48 hours per day to share childcare and earning between them, so the single parent will likely have even higher expenses in terms of childcare etc while also trying to do everything alone. No sensible country compounds the inbuilt disadvantage by also taxing single parents more on the same household income. It's insane.

The system is set up deliberately to penalise single parents, hence the extremely high rates of child poverty in single parent households in the UK. This is why other countries levy taxes on a household basis: not only does it improve childhood outcomes and health and reduce poverty and therefore increase future productivity, it also is cheaper for the taxpayer because our system creates long-term welfare dependency because it is almost impossible for single parents to provide adequately for their children when the tax system penalises them so heavily.

beguilingeyes · 22/04/2023 12:34

As was said previously, it doesn't mean the people who have incomes in six figures or so who 'made good choices' (although that's very disparaging to the rest of us). It means the people who've done bugger all but one of their ancestors made a king happy and now they get to go to Eton and think that inherited wealth makes them capable of running the country, for example.
What has Zac Goldsmith done to qualify him to be a minister except have a billionaire as a father?
£100,000 earnings isn't enough to be called rich these days. As Phil Collins said 'I remember when a million pounds was a lot of money '.

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 10:20

eighteenthirtyeight · 20/04/2023 15:49

'The rich' always gets trotted out. Who? People earning £100,000 who pay absolutely loads of tax? Or who?

I agree!

We shouldn't stunt the ambition to be successful by branding people so divisiveky. Surely it should be in the gift of each family to work towards a commensurate income if they choose to, so they build security for their family which then flows through society. £100k family income isn't the definition of being "stinkin' rich" It would have been in the 1950s and 60s when you could buy a family home for £4,000.

We need to stop putting people down for getting success through education and making good choices. It shouldn't be a race to the bottom.

KonTikki · 22/04/2023 07:58

You only need to look at our current PM, the best of a very poor bunch.
A firm Brexiteer with a tax avoidance wife.
Until there is integrity at the top of Government, the slide into impoverishment will continue.

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 07:46

The above is based on threads on this very site, where we see the reality of those families' incomes and having to make choices at the supermarket because they're down to their last £20 that week.

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 07:44

Fix the tax code to level the playing field and far fewer single parents will need any benefits because they'll be able to keep enough of their own earnings to support themselves.

What "earnings" might those be. Ah yes they're the most likely societal group to be minimum wage earners, so they'll get to keep the crumbs of that job in care work, retail, dinner lady at the school where their children are so the sum total of bugger-all then.

beguilingeyes · 22/04/2023 07:15

humblemeep · 21/04/2023 21:46

"I think one problem is that there is a 'human default setting' which means that (unless we think hard about what's really going on) we instinctively look up to and trust those who have power and wealth.
I suppose we need to look at the reasons why most of us do not think really hard about what's going on, why we don't see under the surface etc? I think much of it is because we are too stressed and angry and so we default to our kneejerk responses."

@Thesharkradar I don't know, I definitely don't trust or look up to any of them, I thought most of us were more intelligent than that 🤷‍♀️

I completely agree. What else explains the rise of people like Johnson, Cameron and Hunt?
A penis and a posh voice will get you anywhere in this country.
As for the tax thing...one of the reasons that JK Rowling is a Queen is that she insists on living here and paying all her taxes, when a lot of people with vast wealth think she's a mug.

TomPinch · 22/04/2023 05:41

What's the average difference though? I'm sceptical that it's all down to the tax system.

It's much more normal for families to have to get by with two incomes. Hard when there's only one person earning the income.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 03:09

Also there are probably way more single parent families now. They are more likely to need government support because they're poor.

They have higher rates of poverty largely because of the UK tax system which penalises them by charging them more tax that a two parent household with the same income. Fix the tax code to level the playing field and far fewer single parents will need any benefits because they'll be able to keep enough of their own earnings to support themselves.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 03:05

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 21:35

I have a Brexit theory that one of the reasons that certain voters and politicians supported Brexit was that they were fed up with the UK being a relatively well off country having to contribute more to the EU than it got back in grants compared to say Bulgaria that got back more than it contributed.

Now by deliberately making the UK poorer through Brexit when the UK does eventually rejoin the EU in say 10 or 20 years it will join as a relatively poorer country and therefore get back more than it contributes.

Genius really....

Lol. Yeah, genius. Except the small matter of the 4% of GDP it has cost us every year, compounding. 😂😂 The quadrupling of the balance of payments deficit which has trashed the value of the pound, and put a rocket under inflation. The fact that we had economic benefits exceeding our EU contributions by an order of magnitude during every year of EU membership. Not to mention the fact that 10 or so of the poorest regions in the EU that received the highest EU grants were... drumroll.... in the UK.

Those pesky facts again.

Incognitopah · 22/04/2023 02:53

We’re a country fueling gross inequality, and the government keeping the low earners quiet by handing out just enough to prevent rebellion. Covid fuelled a support mentality.
its the middle income families which suffer the most with no support and no motivation

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:44

focuslocus · 20/04/2023 19:21

You can either have a welfare state/adequate housing/functioning NHS or open borders. Not both unfortunately.

The UK has never had "open borders".

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:43

Walked past the bus stop yesterday and noticed a new poster, stating that 49% of children in single parent families are living in poverty. That’s horrific.

That's largely because the UK tax system deliberately penalised single parents (over 90% women) by charging them more tax on the same household income as a couple, despite them obviously having higher costs on average due to needing more childcare. The UK is an outlier on this - unsurprisingly most choose not to compound disadvantage by penalising people even more and making it virtually impossible for them to work their way out of poverty - and any Government that wanted to address child poverty could make huge inroads into this overnight by simply changing the tax code so single parents are taxed the same on the same household income as a couple. But they won't.

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 02:37

The reality is that the UK needs to tax the lower and average workers far more if it wants a model with public services like the countries we used to be comparable with.

no let's get this right, it's your reality, that doesn't make it "reality"

what sort of daft logic is it that says by taxing "the lower and average workers far more" that it will sort out the economy in UK when those are the very people who are already on their knees financially having to go to food banks, use prepayment meters for their energy, have benefit top ups even when working 2 jobs just to afford their weekly grocery shop.

i can only presume you're not a Turkey voting for Christmas, that you aren't a lower paid worker and you're alright Jacques.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:33

Exactly why would immigrants come here when lots of western countries will be fighting over them? And we will see more of our young leave eg HCPs going to Oz

Well that's not very bright of them given that fresh water will be one of the most scarce resources on Earth in 10-15 years time.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:29

Maybe people already pay 45%+ once you take into account NI and other deductions it's close to 50%.

Where's the incentive to work if you just keep increasing tax; highly suspect that public services will not catch up as quickly if at all!

It's worse than that. At £50k earnings now if someone has two children and a student loan their tax rate can reach 85% with withdrawal of child benefit.

At £100k, if you have two children, the tax rate is over 100% because of the withdrawal of the personal allowance and childcare funding.

Nobody is going to work for free or at a loss!

And yet politicians wave their hands in the air claiming they don't understand why UK productivity is so low. 🤦‍♀️

daisychain01 · 22/04/2023 02:29

Creepyrosemary · 20/04/2023 14:12

I disagree. Profit and wealth are a bookkeepers opinion. Have everyone pay more income tax, that way the rich can't bookkeep themselves "poor".

Tax property speculators til the pips squeak

Dennis Healey, 1974, Labour Chancellor

Plus ca change.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:23

Prior to Brexit the UK's economy was 90% of the size of Germany's. It's now 70%. That is HUGE decline in just a few years, and cannot be blamed on the war in Ukraine or Covid as all countries suffered these. Similar stats comparing to other countries that used to be our comparators. Nobody else in the G7 still has double digit inflation. So why do we?

Politicians must think we are so fucking thick if they don't think we can work it out. Although perhaps the problem is that enough people ARE that thick and still haven't woken up from their delusions.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:19

And yes people do need to understand also that the better systems in our Northern European neighbours' countries are funded by those on lower and a averages paying more tax. The rates paid by higher earning PAYE earners here are broadly comparable. It is the narrowing of our tax base that has led to the lack of funding by increasing the personal allowance to a level where many pay no or very little tax. Social taxes are MUCH higher for the majority of these workers.

The clamouring is always for "the rich" to pay but it's unclear what people mean by this usually except "not me". The reality is that the UK needs to tax the lower and average workers far more if it wants a model with public services like the countries we used to be comparable with. The higher earning PAYE employees are paying at the levels you see in those countries already but not getting the services in return because they are carrying everyone else. And the actual rich with lots of assets are not paying their way either. That part people usually recognise but they ignore the narrowing of the tax base which is just as important to fix as otherwise you'll never raise sufficient revenue with only a small minority being net contributors, and also create social instability. So we are extremely reliant on those in the middle of the spectrum, which is precarious and unstable and unsustainable.

Decades of mismanagement and a largely deluded population who have repeatedly voted to make it worse.

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:10

I think you have to start moving out of PAYE and looking at 'wealth' to hit 'the rich' and to me I think we are talking about multimillionaires in wealth terms.

I mean 100k is nice, and far beyond anything like my earnings, but as you say its just an income that someone has earned by putting effort in, in the right field. Its already taxed more than fairly as we dont have flat tax.

Its very different from having lots and lots of shares or inheriting lots and lots of properties.

Absolutely. It's the higher earning PAYE employees who have been royally screwed ever since the financial crisis with ever increasing tax rates and carrying everyone else, while self employed people and business owners and people who are actually rich, and have wealth, contribute very little. You can't squeeze higher PAYE earners more, they have nothing left.

I dont know how we tax wealth not income without everyone just putting their wealth somwhere else though.

A good start would be a US-type approach: all UK citizens are made liable for UK taxes on their global income regardless of where it is earned, and all UK residents likewise, plus change the tax code to crack down on transfer pricing out profits earned here lower tax jurisdictions. And a big increase in capital gains tax.

Meanwhile though of course there also needs to be a proper industrial strategy, reversal of Brexit or as a minimum rejoin the SM and CU immediately, at least doubling of the funding for state education and adult education, energy, food and water security strategies, huge infrastructure investment, total overhaul of the dysfunctional health service model and state pensions and public sector pension funding. It would require capable politicians with foresight and vision and some conviction to do what is needed. So it won't happen.