Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 12/08/2023 12:47

My husband is a post war boomer. He grew up in poverty which would be unimaginable today.

Having said that he is probably the last generation who received the state pension at 65. My generation will be eligible at 68.

beguilingeyes · 12/08/2023 10:47

Oh, it's Blame The Boomer time. Regular as clockwork. I was born at the tale end of the boomer era (61). I had no choice or influence as to when or where I was born. I'm also nowhere near being a millionaire.
Divide and rule, works every time. Try blaming your ruling class who have been syphoning money from the bottom and middle to the wealthy for the last 50 years, and managing to convince the population that they're doing a good job.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 12/08/2023 07:52

Kendodd · 11/08/2023 19:08

I heard on radio 4 ages ago, on More or Less, that the average baby boomer, so exactly the people you're talking about, have been subsidised by about £200,000 each over their lifetime, by the rest of us. So that's adding up the cost of their education, healthcare, public services etc, each one has taken out about £200,000 more than they've put in. I don't think any generation, before or after, will get such a good deal. I'm right at the tail end of that btw, so one of the big winners myself.

Also aren’t 1 in 4 of them millionaires?

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 12/08/2023 07:51

Yep. It’s fact. Brexit, Covid, Ukraine, ageing population.

You can’t vote to leave a massive bloc of trading partners and remain as rich as you were before.

You can’t pay half the population to do nothing for two years and remain as rich as you were before.

OoooohBobMonkhouse · 12/08/2023 07:29

When I come back from the US, I notice how poor the UK is now.

Really? I suppose if you are well off you don't notice the poverty in the USA. It has poverty you would never see in the UK and let's not get into the gun crime or being a poor person, who drops down in the street ill. God bless the NHS.

Copperoliverbear · 11/08/2023 22:34

Definitely

1967buglet · 11/08/2023 22:33

When I come back from the US, I notice how poor the UK is now.

I’m staying here for the sake of my British DH and his elderly mum. I know our standard of living in retirement would be so much higher if we went to the US.

The wage stagnation in the UK is unreal. I am making now what I made in the US about 20 years ago. Husband as an electronic engineer with a Cambridge degree could make 4 to 5 times what he does now, but he prefers working in a small firm and a slower way of life, and his happiness is important.

That said, I can’t help but think though how things would have been economically much easier on us in the States. We are pretty well off here with the house paid off and investments, etc, but we could have retired at 50, not 60, if we were in the US.

I also think the class system in the UK is much more entrenched than it is in America, and much to the UK’s detriment.

KnittedCardi · 11/08/2023 21:57

It's an interesting stat, but I'm not sure that subsequent generations don't get more, especially in healthcare. Millions can now be spent on individuals who would have died in previous generations, and only 15% went to university in the 1970's.

I think each generation has it's winners and losers, although the baby boomers do seem a particularly blessed generation. I am just a bit too young, but my three brothers are boomers.

Kendodd · 11/08/2023 19:08

KnittedCardi · 11/08/2023 17:27

Those that hold the most wealth in the country, the top 10%, are overwhelmingly pensioners, 60-64, because it includes pension pots, the house they live in and own, and savings.

Do you really want that demographic to be rinsed by wealth tax, when by the time they are 85, they have very little left? They pay tax on income, they pay cgt, they pay for their care, the estate pays iht. How much more would you like this demographic to pay?

I heard on radio 4 ages ago, on More or Less, that the average baby boomer, so exactly the people you're talking about, have been subsidised by about £200,000 each over their lifetime, by the rest of us. So that's adding up the cost of their education, healthcare, public services etc, each one has taken out about £200,000 more than they've put in. I don't think any generation, before or after, will get such a good deal. I'm right at the tail end of that btw, so one of the big winners myself.

KnittedCardi · 11/08/2023 17:27

Those that hold the most wealth in the country, the top 10%, are overwhelmingly pensioners, 60-64, because it includes pension pots, the house they live in and own, and savings.

Do you really want that demographic to be rinsed by wealth tax, when by the time they are 85, they have very little left? They pay tax on income, they pay cgt, they pay for their care, the estate pays iht. How much more would you like this demographic to pay?

Cyclebabble · 11/08/2023 16:51

WinterDeWinter · 20/04/2023 13:39

One of the reasons we have become a poorer country is because the rich have not been paying their fair share.

That would include the wealth creators who pay the majority of current tax and who take risks in their own businesses and work long hours? How about we focus on growth and generating revenue we can tax first?

Kendodd · 11/08/2023 16:46

I'm on holiday in Europe at the moment. Yes we have become really noticeably much poorer.

Howmuchfurther · 11/08/2023 00:39

Yes. We are getting poorer.

Cutting Govt would fix it. But they won’t. So those who can will leave. Go East young man.

EssexMan55 · 24/04/2023 12:10

most people in this country want those services, but seem to think there is a magical pool of rich people who are just going to pay for it all when asked ("tax the rich"). Average people in those countries pay far more tax than we do.

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 11:58

I suspect the failure of government to make absent fathers pay child support has a lot to do with it.

Where I live, deadbeats can be hauled into court, and paycheques can be garnished, based on the quaint notion that the taxpayer should not be required to pay for food or other necessities for other people's children.

Oh I completely agree that absent fathers should pay for their children. 50% of the costs of actually raising and housing a child and it be enforced like tax evasion.

However, that is a separate issue from the tax system penalising single parents. None of my posts are about any "notion that the taxpayer should be required to pay for food and necessities for other people's children". If that's what you thought you have misunderstood entirely. I am simply talking about the unfairness that single parents are taxed more on the same household income than a two parent working household. My suggestion is that the playing field is levelled, that we stop penalising single parents. Not for any "handouts". In fact the current system means that many single parent households are subsidising two parent households with the same earnings because the single parent is paying more in tax on the same household income. Why should single parents "be required to pay for food or other necessities for other people's children", as you put it?

IAmCinderella · 24/04/2023 11:53

L1ttledrummergirl · 23/04/2023 20:44

I Included the links in my post to the tax calculator I used.

Re the benefits, you missed the deductions due to salary, which brings the amount to £0.

Which calculators did you use?

Nope. I put the salaries in, 2 x £25k earners. All other info identical for the couple other than there being two people earning £25k each instead of one earning £60k.

I used the "turn to us" calculator and the "entitled to" one. I gave all of the figures. You can deny it all you want but it's factual.

SerendipityJane · 24/04/2023 07:41

Seems the top knobs agree with the OP and (as government have told them to) are voting with their feet. I seem to recall the Tory doctrine is we need these megapaid execs because of their skills.

On the plus side, I presume their departures leaves a vacancy for someone top move upwards.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/04/24/brexit-blamed-chief-execs-leaving-british-companies/

Brexit blamed for surge in chief execs leaving British companies

Executives departures from UK companies help push global tally to five-year high

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/04/24/brexit-blamed-chief-execs-leaving-british-companies

TomPinch · 23/04/2023 21:47

I'm sure that can happen under UK law too: the issue is that (leastways the impression that I pick up here) is that the CSA is so chronically underfunded that you have to pay them to get them to carry out their statutory duties.

Also, and I could be wrong, but I understand UK family courts prefer to award custody to one parent: meaning one disgruntled parent with a big liability. That will increase non-compliance.

mathanxiety · 23/04/2023 20:57

IAmCinderella · 22/04/2023 02:43

Walked past the bus stop yesterday and noticed a new poster, stating that 49% of children in single parent families are living in poverty. That’s horrific.

That's largely because the UK tax system deliberately penalised single parents (over 90% women) by charging them more tax on the same household income as a couple, despite them obviously having higher costs on average due to needing more childcare. The UK is an outlier on this - unsurprisingly most choose not to compound disadvantage by penalising people even more and making it virtually impossible for them to work their way out of poverty - and any Government that wanted to address child poverty could make huge inroads into this overnight by simply changing the tax code so single parents are taxed the same on the same household income as a couple. But they won't.

I suspect the failure of government to make absent fathers pay child support has a lot to do with it.

Where I live, deadbeats can be hauled into court, and paycheques can be garnished, based on the quaint notion that the taxpayer should not be required to pay for food or other necessities for other people's children.

L1ttledrummergirl · 23/04/2023 20:44

I Included the links in my post to the tax calculator I used.

Re the benefits, you missed the deductions due to salary, which brings the amount to £0.

Which calculators did you use?

IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 20:41

The figures are not incorrect. They are calculated with UK tax allowances/ thresholds and with benefit calculators online, verified with two different ones.

L1ttledrummergirl · 23/04/2023 20:26

IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 04:39

I don't think you've really understood my post at all given the random stuff you posted, but if you can explain what you mean that would be helpful.

I was pointing out that the figures you quoted were incorrect. A couple earning £50,000 wouldn't be entitled to universal credit as you claimed. The single person earning £60000 would still take home more than 1 person earning £50000, any child benefit they lost would be similar to the single person rebate on council tax. The single parent should also be receiving financial support from the absent parent in most cases- obviously there are some outwith the norm-or the absent partner is a twat.

Childcare can vary depending on the provider, some single parents work with the other parent to put the dc interests first, regardless of their feelings about each other, some use family or friends. Some two parent families pay for full time childcare. Some families choose for one or both parents to restrict their income level so they can work around their dc needs.This is down to the choices each family make should not be considered when deciding tax brackets.

VincentVaguer · 23/04/2023 04:57

FourTeaFallOut · 20/04/2023 13:41

Is Poland predicted to overtake us? Or are you repeating Starmer's statement back in February, which was that if the UK continues at .5% economic growth over the next ten years and that Poland maintains the 4% ish growth it achieved last year, for the next ten years then they would eventually overtake us?

Which is some statistical trickery. Not least because the oecd has Poland's economic growth at .7% for 2023.

This

Although I agree this is a depressing country to live in ATM.

IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 04:51

Student moan. Ahahaaa that made me laugh. At least some sunshine in the very depressing world of talking to people who do not get economics.

IAmCinderella · 23/04/2023 04:50

And no, there was no student moan in the calculations I made. I think you've clearlynot understood what I posted.

And obviously a couple can decide that one person works less or not at all so then their net income falls. 😆🙄 But if they do that it should be obvious that then their outgoings are a lot less also than those of the single parent because the couple will have very little/ no childcare expense! So eithet the single parent is hammered by way more tax on the same income as a household with two incomes with only half the time to earn the money, or they are taxed in a similar way to a couple who choose to have a parent earning nothing and having no childcare expense while the single parent has to pay it.

Either way it's an insane thing for a country to do because it increases poverty, health issues, lower educational scores, increases long-term welfare depenency and basically has shit ougcomes AND has been proved to cost taxpayers more. It's dumb. But I suppose it's not suprising that the UK has dumb policies when you look at the voting records for the last 5 years at least.