Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 18:07

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 15:20

They are different things. One of the main differences is that NI contributions determine pension eligibility. You have to have a minimum of 35 years NI contributions to qualify for a state pension. 35 years income tax payments doesn’t entitle you to a pension at all.

Totally incorrect.

Tax and NI all go into the same pot.

NI payments being use for pension eligibilty is completely irrelevant.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 15:20

They are different things. One of the main differences is that NI contributions determine pension eligibility. You have to have a minimum of 35 years NI contributions to qualify for a state pension. 35 years income tax payments doesn’t entitle you to a pension at all.

Rainyrunway · 14/08/2023 15:17

They're really not different things though. NI is just another income tax. The only difference is that pensioners don't pay it!

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 15:15

SueVineer · 14/08/2023 14:43

It is of course not true that people pay the same tax on their earnings that they do on pensions. Pensions and unearned income is not subject to NI.

NI and income tax are different things. That’s why they have different names and are levied at different rates. 🤷‍♀️

fuchiaknickers · 14/08/2023 14:47

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:33

YANBU were are sinking and the very rich are just trying to plunder what they can from the wreckage.

This.

SueVineer · 14/08/2023 14:43

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 13:57

Maybe you could talk to me @TheThinkingGoblin? It’s extremely rude to insult someone by talking about them like that.

There has never been a generational contract that each generation strives to place the subsequent generation in a better position than they themselves started in. There were a couple of generations post war where that happened but more by chance than intent.

Clearly there is a temporary problem for society as the boomer generation moves into old age, in 20 or so years it will largely be over as they die. At that point there will be a flood of money into the economy as houses are liquidated and inheritances are spent. There will, of course, continue to be inequality with the heirs of more affluent boomers becoming those who are reviled. Additionally, pensioners continue to pay tax, those bloated pensions are subject to the same taxes as earnings.

If pensions and the NHS survive the swell of demand placed on them by the boomer generation, future generations need have little fear as there obviously be far less demand on them from a smaller population.

It is of course not true that people pay the same tax on their earnings that they do on pensions. Pensions and unearned income is not subject to NI.

1dayatatime · 14/08/2023 14:33

@Blossomtoes

There really isn't that much difference in home ownership between Germany and the UK:

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?
1dayatatime · 14/08/2023 14:30

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 12:37

The difference in Germany is that renting is socially acceptable and regulated. The Germans don’t fetishise home ownership in the way the UK does.

I don't understand your logic. If a property costs more money to buy then the landlord needs to charge more in rent otherwise they would not be able to afford the mortgage or would make such a low return that wouldn't make it worthwhile.

As for the rent controls in Germany they generally only relate to how much rent can be increased per year. Where actual rent caps were in place such as in Berlin then these have been ruled illegal.

amp.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/15/germany-highest-court-rules-berlin-rent-cap-illegal

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 12:37

The difference in Germany is that renting is socially acceptable and regulated. The Germans don’t fetishise home ownership in the way the UK does.

poetryandwine · 14/08/2023 12:29

1dayatatime · 14/08/2023 12:15

@Kendodd

"IMO housing is a huge factor, we need mass, affordable, good quality public housing, that would solve an awful lot of problems."

+++

I also completely agree. One thing I noticed about Germany is that because of the lower cost of housing people had more money to spend on things like say restaurants or cars or even health care insurance or private pensions. All of which put money back into the economy or reduce the burden on the state rather than being unproductively locked up in bricks and mortar.

However anyone who is fortunate enough to own their own home will often object to the building of new homes as it may spoil their view / place additional burden on existing infrastructure etc. Conveniently forgetting that their home when constructed did exactly the same thing.

This. And the cost of new houses in the UK is very high.

1dayatatime · 14/08/2023 12:15

@Kendodd

"IMO housing is a huge factor, we need mass, affordable, good quality public housing, that would solve an awful lot of problems."

+++

I also completely agree. One thing I noticed about Germany is that because of the lower cost of housing people had more money to spend on things like say restaurants or cars or even health care insurance or private pensions. All of which put money back into the economy or reduce the burden on the state rather than being unproductively locked up in bricks and mortar.

However anyone who is fortunate enough to own their own home will often object to the building of new homes as it may spoil their view / place additional burden on existing infrastructure etc. Conveniently forgetting that their home when constructed did exactly the same thing.

1dayatatime · 14/08/2023 12:08

@Soapnutty

"It’s wealth not income where the huge disparity lies."

+++

I completely agree which is why increases in wealth tax makes more sense than increases in income tax.

Kendodd · 14/08/2023 08:30

Soapnutty · 13/08/2023 22:44

Saw on Twitter:

”Great graphic by @jburnmurdoch. In other words, Britain is a poor country, with 1 moderately wealthy region”.

It would be really interesting to see how we ranked when we had a Labour government in charge. Although I don't think income per person is a particularly good measure and can cover up a lot of poverty, the real grinding poverty you get in the UK. IMO housing is a huge factor, we need mass, affordable, good quality public housing, that would solve an awful lot of problems.

Soapnutty · 13/08/2023 22:45

1dayatatime · 13/08/2023 21:32

The top 1% of income earners currently pay 28% of all income tax and the top 50% of income earners pay 90% of all income taxes.

fullfact.org/economy/do-top-1-earners-pay-28-tax-burden

It’s wealth not income where the huge disparity lies.

Soapnutty · 13/08/2023 22:44

Saw on Twitter:

”Great graphic by @jburnmurdoch. In other words, Britain is a poor country, with 1 moderately wealthy region”.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?
1dayatatime · 13/08/2023 21:50

@Blossomtoes

"Those figures are five years out of date."

+++

Feel free to provide more up to date figures.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 21:34

1dayatatime · 13/08/2023 21:32

The top 1% of income earners currently pay 28% of all income tax and the top 50% of income earners pay 90% of all income taxes.

fullfact.org/economy/do-top-1-earners-pay-28-tax-burden

Those figures are five years out of date.

1dayatatime · 13/08/2023 21:32

The top 1% of income earners currently pay 28% of all income tax and the top 50% of income earners pay 90% of all income taxes.

fullfact.org/economy/do-top-1-earners-pay-28-tax-burden

nonheme · 13/08/2023 20:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Blossomtoes · 13/08/2023 16:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

You can’t tax people on money they haven’t got. Maybe if we put some pressure on employers to pay decent wages more people would be taxpayers.

poetryandwine · 13/08/2023 16:34

PS The unit of measurement is GDP/population

poetryandwine · 13/08/2023 16:32

studentgrant · 13/08/2023 12:32

We are the 6th largest economy by GDP, but 30th in the list when you include buying power of citizens.

This is an excellent point, @studentgrant

Also, our wealth is London-centred to an alarming degree. Today in The Observer Will Hutton quoted some research recently reported in The Financial Times. If you strip out the wealth from the largest cities of Germany, the Netherlands, the USA and the UK, the rest of the UK is poorer than the others and is in fact poorer than Mississippi, the poorest American state.

Defiantjazz · 13/08/2023 16:27

Ooh a stealth Brexit thread. Haven’t seen one of those in a while.

Anxioys · 13/08/2023 16:23

I think the issue of wages stagnating is very real. A lot of people do pay income tax, but not at a high enough rate to maintain public services.

It's only the top 10 per cent of earners who are actually contributing net to the public purse. Paying tax is not the same as contributing, and that's why the UK has real problems stored up.

I don't think the Treasury wants to face the fact that income tax needs to go up (if you aren't interested in asset or windfall taxes) on basic rate taxpayers.

The UK's working population is older, sicker, and contributing much less than 30 or 20 years ago. And we have just removed ourselves from a younger, easily available source of immigration in the EU. We need younger and literally fitter people to come and work here.

Figmentofmyimagination · 13/08/2023 16:23

nonheme The problem is not that people are ‘choosing not to work’. It’s that wages are too low. The majority of people in receipt of state benefits are already in work. This is one of the many ‘through the looking glass’ things about the UK. Universal credit, topping up wages so that employers don’t have to, and incentivising a low wage, low skill economy.