Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Blossomtoes · 15/08/2023 09:03

Say we got rid of the (Tory) triple lock tomorrow @Anxioys, how would you determine future pension rises? Bear in mind that all benefits, not just pensions, increased by 10.1% in April so aligning them would have had the same result.

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 09:00

I do agree with you about voting. We need compulsory voting brought in. We won't get it though because pensioners (who currently vote) wouldn't vote for it. So we're pretty much fucked really

Anxioys · 15/08/2023 08:57

It's in the press this morning because wages are going up and that can engage the triple lock.

Pensions are an issue because we are spending more on those than education, defence, and policing for the next two years.

The triple lock is not a sustainable policy. The question is whether the Tories or Labour will deal with this issue. I don't hear a lot!

beguilingeyes · 15/08/2023 08:47

God, this debate has got nasty. One of the main reasons that pensioners get more (eg the Triple Lock) is they they're hugely more likely to vote. 'Decisions are made by those who show up'.
If young people can't be bothered to vote then they're going to get ignored. They can't just whine that it's not fair and do nothing about it.
I think the FPTP system needs to change. It disproportionately favours the two main parties, who are invested in maintaining the status quo. But FPTP is what we're stuck with for the foreseeable.
The Torys have famously said that they don't care about poor people because 'they don't vote for us'. I imagine they feel the same way about the young.

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2023 08:38

Yes child poverty is absolutely shocking. Shame the highly effective Child Poverty Act was scrapped in 2015 and replaced with a two child cap on benefits. Let’s vote in a government that cares about it.

It’s not all rosy for pensioners though - one in five of them are living in poverty. And we already have means testing for all benefits above the basic state pension, the maximum is still a pittance though.

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/mar/17/number-of-pensioners-in-relative-poverty-in-uk-up-200000-in-a-year

Of course the other thing you’re failing to take into account is that all pension income, including the state pension, is taxable.

Number of pensioners in relative poverty in UK up 200,000 in a year

Report highlights inequalities in older age groups, and raises concerns for people nearing retirement age

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/mar/17/number-of-pensioners-in-relative-poverty-in-uk-up-200000-in-a-year

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 08:22

And of course you should home in on one group if that's where all the money is and is being diverted to!

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 08:21

Sure but there are a lot less of those people
And they generally have the ability to move their wealth out of the country and therefore pay even less in. Sorting out the amount paid out to pensioners WILL save the country significantly more than going after a few super wealthy like the PM (although I don't disagree we should be doing that too)
The simple fact is the "poorest pensioners" should absolutely get help. But that's what means testing is for.
As a group pensioners are the richest in the country. Even ahead of working adults without children. Yet the consistently get given the most help and handouts. That needs to stop.
Child poverty is at 27% in 2023. Yes I'll say that again. More than a quarter of our children live in poverty. That is outrageous.

Blossomtoes · 15/08/2023 08:03

It’s not gaslighting, it’s disagreement.

I’d support a wealth tax. I’d support higher inheritance tax and lowering the threshold because those would be targeted measures that would impact on the wealthiest - and not just pensioners. What I won’t support is a tax which would impact most on the poorest pensioners with the wealthiest barely noticing.

The way to achieve greater equality is to look at society overall, not home in on one group. The PM pays a smaller proportion of his income in tax than a nurse or a teacher - how about we start with people with wealth of that magnitude?

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 07:53

I also hate that whenever the inherent unfairness of the current situation is put forward, especially if you suggest ideas for things that might help to resolve some of the disparity (like the NI suggestion) you get responses like this one
"While people like you are busy conducting intergenerational warfare"
Its gaslighting!!

SerendipityJane · 15/08/2023 07:45

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 07:30

@TheThinkingGoblin your post is actually quite depressing because I can read the truth in it.
Obviously not all pensioners are like this but a very large proportion of them seem to be. Why?

Why is a honeycomb hexagonal ?

Kendodd · 15/08/2023 07:45

Absolutely agree that pensioners should pay NI. Also, I believe you stop having to pay NI once you are too rich and are deemed to have paid enough. Its so wrong. I also believe pensions should be a good level, not just to keep the poor from absolute poverty . We could do with a wealth tax on top (I'm older and would very likely be affected by this). Inheritance tax needs to be increased as well.
Problem though, pensioners are very politically powerful and most would never vote for wealth or inheritance tax. They cling onto their money, despite the poverty they see around them and is inflicted on the young, ever after they are dead, they try to cling onto their money. The old, 'I've worked all my life' (not even true half the time) so what, everyone works all their life.

Rainyrunway · 15/08/2023 07:30

@TheThinkingGoblin your post is actually quite depressing because I can read the truth in it.
Obviously not all pensioners are like this but a very large proportion of them seem to be. Why?

Anxioys · 14/08/2023 23:56

@TheThinkingGoblin - great post. I worry that not enough is being spent on education and concerned at this. Also the population is sicker after COVID. We don't seem to be investing in our future in the U.K.

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 23:49

echt · 14/08/2023 23:31

"Views"? Views is more accurate. They are real attitudes.

This is more in the realm of psychology/sociology + behavioral economics which is a bit beyond my normal remit.

Some thoughts:

I have talked to a lot of retired folks over the years in the UK and the dividing line is pretty much always class when it comes to attitudes (I call it "views" because they tend to be based on internal biases).

The wealthier pensioners:

£10k is basically a rounding error for them when they have DB pensions, no mortgages, and 2M in investments. £10k is basically another cruise for them.

Below them however you will find:

The professional class (normally Drs and Accountants) who have DB pensions, and no mortgage. Less in investments. £10k for them simply makes them even more comfortable.

The top two groups are about 20% of folks.

Below that is when you get attitudes based largely on ideology going back decades. The "I paid in all my life" brigade comes from this group. The wealthier ones don't really care to that extent.

I don't begrudge POOR pensioners their state pensions (thats fine and you will not find many younger folks that are against this), but the dividing line must be those pensioners that actually need help given that the country is actively getting poorer due to demographics and pension liabilities that keep getting uprated far faster than real GDP growth.

And that precisely is the problem that I have seem in many countries over my professional career.

When pension uprating is not linked to real GDP growth, pensioners become disconnected from the success or failure of the UK economy. This is extremely dangerous socially and economically as it creates increasing inter-generational inequality, which further destabilises intra-generation inequality amongst the working folks.

You see this now when we have 0% real GDP growth and pensioners are still getting a 10% uplift (April 2023), and another est 7% uplift next year in April 2024.

Those payments are actively crippling the UK economy further after the shocks of Brexit, Pandemic, and Ukraine War.

This then makes the country stagnate (investment drops) and then poorer and poorer (as pensions crowd out other spending like education and healthcare).

And then, when the situation has gotten bad enough the State turns on those folks (pensioners) as the country is basically broke and needs revenues to invest.

echt · 14/08/2023 23:31

"Views"? Views is more accurate. They are real attitudes.

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 23:28

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 23:21

How kind. I don’t need to Google Duning-Kruger. You epitomise it.

You are literally talking to a global professional in the actuarial world with 20+ years of pensions and life insurance experience over the UK, US, and Canada.

Keep going, this is gold.

Note to viewers:

This is precisely one of the problem in the UK. Older people think their "views" are better informed than those of the experts. Its become a problem in the UK because the Conservatives know this and succesfully manipulate this feeling for their own political benefit.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 23:21

How kind. I don’t need to Google Duning-Kruger. You epitomise it.

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 23:19

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 23:16

It’s downright amusing how you have literally no debating weapon in your arsenal except sneering and insult. You have absolutely no interest in any kind of meaningful discussion. You’re a waste of pixels.

I give you my very expensive time on here to educate you.

And you have consistently shown zero ability to learn.

That takes some doing given this is all basic finance.

So no, now you get nothing. I don't have the time or inclination to teach basic stuff to you.

Google "Duning-Kruger"

Thats you right now.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 23:16

It’s downright amusing how you have literally no debating weapon in your arsenal except sneering and insult. You have absolutely no interest in any kind of meaningful discussion. You’re a waste of pixels.

TheThinkingGoblin · 14/08/2023 23:07

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 22:50

I don’t think pensioners should come first and I’ve never said that. In fact everything I’ve said about government priorities is the opposite of that.

I don’t think they should pay NI unless the link between NI contributions and pension eligibility is broken. If it’s rolled up into income tax a new way of determining pension eligibility would have to be found. But bear in mind that if that happened the basic rate of income tax would rise to at least 32% and the optics of that would be political and electoral suicide.

Its downright amusing how uneducated you are about public finances and the mental gymnastics you do about reaching the conclusion that "pensioners cannot pay more tax".

Going to be highly satisfying to watch the entire country turn on you folks.

I realise you folks don't have a clue about the real world, but your behavior has become so obviously dysfunctional to society over the last 10 years that even folks that used to support you are completely disgusted by your behavior.

Remember, Greek pensioners were under the same illusions you folks are.

When a country is broke, those pensions will be cut. Its that simple really irrespective of your pie in the sky politics.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 22:56

Rainyrunway · 14/08/2023 22:53

That IS the basic rate of income tax though already for everyone except pensioners. So they'd just need to think of a way to word it. I'm sure they could come up with a 3 word slogan.
And pension eligibility, could be universal basic income. Nothing more than the minimum unless means tested and shown to need it.
The no need to show anything.

But we don’t have universal basic income. No political party would propose it either. How ever much you continue to insist otherwise basic rate income tax is 20% - I know because I pay it.

Rainyrunway · 14/08/2023 22:53

That IS the basic rate of income tax though already for everyone except pensioners. So they'd just need to think of a way to word it. I'm sure they could come up with a 3 word slogan.
And pension eligibility, could be universal basic income. Nothing more than the minimum unless means tested and shown to need it.
The no need to show anything.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 22:53

Kendodd · 14/08/2023 22:45

Can I point out, pensioners overwhelmingly vote Tory and voted for Brexit.

You can point that out by all means. Equally I can point out that many of today’s pensioners were below pension age in 2016 and in 2019. Perhaps the voting pattern of that demographic will be different in 2025, it will be interesting to see.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 22:50

Rainyrunway · 14/08/2023 22:28

@Blossomtoes it's selfish because you believe that pensioners should come first.and you've argued repeatedly that they shouldn't have to pay NIC. Even though they are the wealthiest group. The ones who are in poverty should ABSOLUTELY get help. Same as younger people who are in poverty. And as I've said many times I agree that everyone over retirement age should get a basic income from the state. But it really should be basic, unless they're actually in need. The money is needed elsewhere.

I don’t think pensioners should come first and I’ve never said that. In fact everything I’ve said about government priorities is the opposite of that.

I don’t think they should pay NI unless the link between NI contributions and pension eligibility is broken. If it’s rolled up into income tax a new way of determining pension eligibility would have to be found. But bear in mind that if that happened the basic rate of income tax would rise to at least 32% and the optics of that would be political and electoral suicide.

Kendodd · 14/08/2023 22:45

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:27

Do you seriously think that giving retired people £200 a week is wrong and unfair? Really? How much do you think it should be? In a country that’s paying £10 billion a week interest on its national debt because of its government’s incompetence? Focus on the cause of the problem - it’s not pensioners.

Can I point out, pensioners overwhelmingly vote Tory and voted for Brexit.