Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
socialmedia23 · 20/04/2023 20:47

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 20:24

Japan is in a bit of a mess of its own.

Why would immigrants come to the UK???? For the reasons they always have: wealth, the English language, much less corrupt than their place of origin, opportunity.

In the last hundred years the UK has gone from being a world superpower to something of a has-been, but I really doubt that the average immigrant is thinking "Oh! I'll not go to the UK. They're not famous any more!"

I came to London to study. I fell in love with my British DH and we decided to settle in London because he had family here (free place to stay while we saved up to buy) and as a international couple, we wanted a place where we could get spouse visas easily. UK visa rules are at least pretty easy to fulfil if you meet the requirements. my home country is singapore and the requirements for a lot of visas seem fairly opaque (40% of the country are foreigners so evidently a lot of people get in but there is no certainty). Also in order for us to buy government housing in Singapore (the only choice for a first time buyer in singapore without a million pound budget), DH had to be a permanent resident. On the other hand, we bought in London before I even got indefinite leave to remain and for far less than a private apartment in Singapore. So for me, I chose to live in the UK not because it is an amazing country to live in from a quality of life perspective (though I have grown fond of the city and the people); but because it met my requirements at that time and now I have become fairly comfortable here. I am not sure if this would change but for now my quality of life is too comfortable for me to contemplate the upheaval of leaving even though i know we probably would earn more elsewhere. Every developed country seems to have a housing crisis too, as well as problems with high rents and that always affects new immigrants more than established locals.

I work with many professionals from India. The main reason why they chose UK was because they wanted to go to an English speaking country and the visa requirements in the UK were relatively easier to meet than Australia or the USA (for them). The main plan seems to be earn a good income, send money back to family in India, educate children (if they have any) in local schools and retire in India (they own land and a self built house in India by that time). Therefore, they don't mind as much if their lives are less comfortable than locals because there is a long term benefit- for now £ converts well into rupees.

Therefore, it is not useful to judge the desirability of a country based on the decisions of immigrants. Immigrants don't choose a country based on how rich it is. there are also practical realities that limit this and they don't choose a country based on how comfortable their lives would be. Furthermore the main benefit they enjoy from being in the uk do not apply to any local Brits, most working class British people would not be able to relocate to a cheaper country and buy lots of land lol... In any case, many foreigners I know do regret choosing the UK but its all water under the bridge now

Bucketheadbucketbum · 20/04/2023 20:38

People need to work. Benefits shouldn't pay.

BMW6 · 20/04/2023 20:37

We're DOOMED I tell ye. DOOMED 😂😂

FFS such dramatics! Save yourselves and feck off to an El Dorado elsewhere for the love of God.

So tedious.

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 20:37

The Guardian is always moaning about something. Right now it's the UK's poor growth rate. But last year when it was good? Nothing.

A Conservative government bringing in a general anti-avoidance tax law? Nothing in the Guardian.

Recent changes to stop debt collection agencies behaving like sharks? Unreported.

The Guardian simply doesn't report what doesn't suit its agenda. Not that it's any worse than any other paper on that respect but it, and its readers think it's better.

Creepyrosemary · 20/04/2023 20:34

@ladykale

*Maybe people already pay 45%+ once you take into account NI and other deductions it's close to 50%.

Where's the incentive to work if you just keep increasing tax; highly suspect that public services will not catch up as quickly if at all*

I live in the Netherlands and we pay 52% income tax. The ambulance arrives within 10 minutes, I can see the GP the same day and I needed an eye appointment in the hospital and could see someone the same week.

We also have a housing problem, not enough are built and the average family home now costs 360k gbp. (Average house in England is 290k gbp according to www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-house-price-index-for-january-2023)

If you want better services, you need to pay for them.

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 20:31

The guardian hugely relevant?

Sorry just belly laughing

Sorryyoufeelthatway · 20/04/2023 20:26

Feels like the UK is becoming a 2nd world country or whatever the PC term
is. Sinking ship.

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 20:24

tubing · 20/04/2023 17:54

so is the east...china has a much bigger demographic problem than we do, ditto japan

Japan recognised this yrs ago & have implemented things to mitigate the impact.

if young people willing to have babies are in short supply then immigrants will be able to pick & chose, they wont be comming here where no one can afford to have children

Exactly why would immigrants come here when lots of western countries will be fighting over them? And we will see more of our young leave eg HCPs going to Oz

Japan is in a bit of a mess of its own.

Why would immigrants come to the UK???? For the reasons they always have: wealth, the English language, much less corrupt than their place of origin, opportunity.

In the last hundred years the UK has gone from being a world superpower to something of a has-been, but I really doubt that the average immigrant is thinking "Oh! I'll not go to the UK. They're not famous any more!"

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 20:24

I think it's the realisation that unless you have assets, you are poor in the U.K. That has always been true but rising inflation, stagnant wages and crumbling public services really expose this.

Assets, property or whatever, mean that people don't feel it. They don't even see it. If you are well off then you don't see it. If you are retired and not using public services, you don't see it. Instead you moan about pot holes. It's literally all that is visible.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 20/04/2023 20:22

The roich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer, helped out by a Tory government (looking out for themselves, their donors and their mates) and an "I'm alright, Jack" mentality among their voters.

Weedoormatnomore · 20/04/2023 20:18

Definitely if this had happened 7 years ago we would be planning to move abroad !

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 20:12

Here's another thing that would skew the stats in favour of Poland: I expect there are far, far, far, far, far fewer single-parent families in Poland. Single-parent families are more likely to be hard up and have to rely on state assistance (which in the UK has reduced.)

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 20:12

User!

We are very wealthy by starting our own business!

What have you done?

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 20:10

Wealth hoarding?

What the what now?

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 20:04

NB: others have said this boy it bears repeating: the average Polish family will be better off by the end of the decade if trends continue. Not that Poland will be better off, even in terms of GDP per capita.

Poland is not "overtaking" the UK.

The issue is that the UK has a larger than usual number of very rich people, meaning wealth is more evenly distributed in Poland.

The other issue is that Europe as a whole isn't doing that well. Someone said upthread that they could earn twice as much elsewhere. Maybe- but people who leave / left the UK to earn twice as much are, IME more likely to be going somewhere like North America / the Gulf / Australia etc. Not Europe.

Havanananana · 20/04/2023 19:59

Another week ,another Britain bashing post.

I know of at least one European country where:

  • Ambulances arrive within 10-15 minutes - often quicker;
  • It is possible to walk in and see a GP within 15-20 minutes;
  • There are generally no waiting lists for hospital appointments;
  • Minor operations are available within 2-4 weeks - majors max. 2-3 months;
  • Public transport runs on time and is clean and reliable;
  • An annual ticket for local public transport costs €365;
  • In some months, Fridays are "Free-days" - public transport is free for the day;
  • The standard of living and quality of life are far higher than the UK;
  • Housing is not subject to speculation and is generally affordable.

Compare and contrast with the UK, and then rather than complaining about "another Britain bashing post" ask yourself why you not demanding the same conditions in the UK that are common throughout much of Europe (and that used to be within grasp in the UK before the Conservatives set about destroying the post-war Welfare State).

User98866 · 20/04/2023 19:55

It’s funny how people find the concept of greed and hoarding most unattractive when it’s other things (loo roll) but people see no problem with wealth hoarding. Those people actively harm the economy and the wealth of everyone else. Wealth hoarding to the degree which we’ve allowed it means that those assets and money are not circulating and that’s what an economy is after all. No one become mega rich through just their own hard work, let’s stop calling them wealth creators and call them hoarders. Re frame the discussion.

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 19:50

I find posts about brexit as bloody boring as self 1D snd the trans nonsense. Cost of living crisis not here but obviously aware could be elsewhere just sharing my experience.

We live in an fairly affluent area so bars pubs clubs packed.

Christ the garden centres need booking for a lunch on a week day let alone weekend

Our city brum is packed bloody packed every weekend.

I

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 19:44

Brexit always gets mentioned on this thread. But if you look at the graphs the slide for the UK began in 2008 - the Global Financial Crisis.

Until then the UK had generally been outperforming other countries in economic growth, even Germany, as I recall, since the early 90s.

The UK was particularly exposed to the GFC because it has a giant (and still very profitable) financial sector. Its public and household finances are still dealing with the fallout of the GFC and will be for some time to come in a way that just about no other countries are. There really needs to be more of a discussion about this: Brexit was just the effect- this was the cause.

The UK had also been the EU's financial services provider, basically. Whether in hindsight that was a good thing is a matter for historians to discuss in good time.

MotherOfRatios · 20/04/2023 19:41

as a young person renting is becoming so unaffordable , and I can't afford to buy.
we have an aging population, but you don't want to address young peoples concerns. We focus on all the older people in society and that is a major issue in this country.

I earn £34k and I'm looking to move, and I just cannot afford to pay over £1000 a month for a room. Unfortunately my job means I need to be in London therefore I have to pay London rent. But even my friend in Manchester at the minute are struggling to find affordable rent because Londoners are moving out of London.

I probably won't have children, just because I can't afford to rent a good size home I can't afford childcare. this is a problem as well.

Endlesssummer2022 · 20/04/2023 19:40

It will get worse because many of the electorate have become radicalised and will vote for bollocks which harms them. All they need to hear is something about dinghy’s and they will run to the ballot box to vote for more austerity. They can’t be helped.

Even the opposition are obsessed with appealing to the ‘red wall’ voters who will vote us in to developing world status.

For many voters the answer appears to be tax the middle class more. They don’t understand the net contributors are dwindling with more taking out than those putting in. Instead of asking how we improve services/processes/investment, the answer seems to be ban others from having what I don’t have.

DH and I have voted against Cameron’s austerity, Johnson’s Brexit and Sunak’s managed decline. We’re working hard and are net contributors, however, there seems to be a lot of resentment that we have more than others and live in ‘that London’.

There’s a real crabs in a barrel mentality in this country. I resent paying pensions and benefits to those who made us all poorer. We’re waiting until DC1 completes secondary then leaving as I would resent it even more for DC to be paying taxes to support people who limited their choices. Fortunately, DH and therefore kids are dual nationals and we have in demand skills.

CurlewKate · 20/04/2023 19:32

@Honbee If you can afford good healthcare in the UK you get it too. Ask Sunak.

Kendodd · 20/04/2023 19:31

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 20/04/2023 18:41

Not really, it’s because we’ve allowed wages to stagnate for so long and real growth and productivity has been negatively impacted.

Taxing the rich isn’t the solution; it’s everyone earning more and contributing more to the tax pot not everyone looking at the rich to subsidize them.

I agree that taxing the rich isn't the solution, higher wages is the solution (and vastly more, quality, social housing). Unfortunately, mega rich people won't share the profits, that everyone in the company helped make, fairly with the workers. I don't know how we get them to do that. I remember reading once that the cost of Philip Green's third superyacht was approximately equivalent to the amount staff employed in his shops had claimed in tax credits in a year because they couldn't live on the wages he paid.

anon666 · 20/04/2023 19:29

YANBU

The decline started with the banking crash of 2008. This government have done everything they can to gear it so that their rich buddies and sponsors get to hang onto their wealth while everyone else gets screwed.

They've exceeded even their own hopes in that the rich haven't just retained wealth, they've increased it beyond all expectations.

The rest of us are shafted. We are living in a poorer country than we did twenty years ago.