Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we are becoming a much poorer country?

366 replies

Felixss · 20/04/2023 13:25

I keep seeing on threads increase taxes on the rich , increase salaries, increase nhs spending and increase benefits. People are acting like we are still hugely wealthy and everyone wants to come over. Poland is predicted to overtake us economically. I can earn twice my salary abroad and I'm thinking of leaving. Where is the money going to come from with a shrinking work force and low investment in new technology? AIBU to think the UK is hugely declining ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
L1ttledrummergirl · 21/04/2023 08:58

Before we had social housing, it was people like the Cadburys and Rowntrees who were improving the housing of their workers as they recognised the worth of their employees. Now employers have used tax credits and universal credit to depress the salaries of employees to the point some are having to use food banks.

When my dm was moved into a newly built council house as a dc, they were impressed as they had water in the house. Their previously rented home was pulled down as a slum dwelling. It reminds me of the victorians improving the housing in London- better drainage, less overcrowding, green spaces.

I can't see any political will for even small changes (get employers to pay decent salaries), they won't do it for public sector workers they employ.

My great grandparents budget (we found the ledger), shows that the rent was 20% of the take home pay, food was more expensive though. A massive difference to housing costs today.

socialmedia23 · 21/04/2023 07:47

TomPinch · 21/04/2023 02:25

@socialmedia23
I agree with you up to a point. It's true that 30 years ago (and even more 40 or 50 years ago) the private renting sector was very small. I also agree that in the past plenty of jobs that don't provide enough of an income now to buy a house did so in the past. I think that's mostly the value of houses increasing way above inflation and wages not keeping pace.

Incidentally before WW1 hardly anyone could afford to buy a house: provision of social housing depressed house prices, and perhaps we're now reverting to normality.

But we need to beware of things being that rosy in the past. I read a book called A Working Life by Polly Toynbee - published in the 60s - each chapter is devoted to a working class job she did, mostly in factories. They were all pretty poorly paid - awful, boring, dehumanising jobs - and the people she worked along side certainly weren't buying houses. They also weren't generally living in nicely-built new council estates either. They were living in slum housing built in Victorian times. Lots of British people were emigrating in those days to Australia and New Zealand for better prospects. Those countries - particularly the latter - were comparatively very wealthy but, to be honest, the 1960s NZ house I've lived in for the last decade is pretty basic, not very big, cold in winter, and certainly not big enough to fit in a lot of things. But it was a better alternative to living in a damp, cold draughty Victorian house and working in a factory in Britain.

Regarding single parent families: I think the change there is mostly to do with changing moral values, and I actually don't think that's economic at all. I think it's more that before the 80s, when everything started to change, the expectation on everyone was that you would marry and have a family in due course, and putting it off was frowned upon. So was divorce. This expectation was on both men and women. The attitude now is about free choice. Of course no one sensible wants to have children in difficult economic circumstances, but having a plan generally makes things easier, and this includes when society tells you what the plan is. Also - and I'm not making any comment on the morals of each alternative here - it's easier for governments to structure social provision around the former - it's cheaper, and splitting families spreads people across more houses which I suspect reduces the average number of people in houses. Furthermore, back in the day, if you were single, you lodged with a family or a bunch of other lodgers, and your tenure was pretty insecure. You generally did not have a place of your own.

The point of all this is that in the past a) average people often really weren't that flash b) the family was the mainstay and people outside one struggled and c) government support existed but there is now an expectation that the government provide support that b) provided in the past.

I do agree that for most of British history it has not been normal for ordinary people to own a house with garden. This particular expectation is a fairly recent one and the boomers were a lucky generation. It's also not a normal expectation in other countries, countries like Singapore and Portugal may have high home ownership rates but the majority own apartments. Also in UK, 92% of the land is rural/agricultural. I am a Green so I do want to protect our countryside. But we can't have it both ways- insist on not building on greenbelt and also insist that everyone needs to own their little house with garden.

For me, I am happy just owning an apartment as I see it as a natural consequence of living in London, a global capital in its own right. A lot of people don't agree. And London has also grown to include (unofficially) commuter towns within a 50 miles radius as we have people commuting from there with the effect that house prices there are also very expensive. A 2 bed flat in St Alban's cost the same as my zone 3 flat now.

What I do think is that everyone deserves a home and that we should encourage co-op's (where tenants can get loans to buy out their landlords and form a co op) as well as community led affordable housing (Google citizen house in Lewisham which is pegged to local incomes in perpetuity). In Singapore, affordable housing (which 85% of the population live in) is government owned but we have had the same party in power for 60 years. In the UK, successive governments tend to reverse the policy of previous governments so it's probably better if it's spearheaded by the community.

MrsMikeDrop · 21/04/2023 07:41

WinterDeWinter · 20/04/2023 13:39

One of the reasons we have become a poorer country is because the rich have not been paying their fair share.

Yes and also isn't it around 50% who take more than they put in? Recipe for disaster really! Hmm

Wedoronron · 21/04/2023 07:39

iloveyoghurt · 20/04/2023 15:41

I doubt it, i am polish living in the UK and know many who went back there a couple of years ago and came back to the UK again

My family is Polish and live in England and UK. I think it depends where you go. Warsaw, Gdansk, Krakow all feel on the up. Also less affected by the terrible rhetoric of the government.

TomPinch · 21/04/2023 07:33

I'm not sure whether that was in response to my point.

Just in case, I'm not suggesting that it's easier to live off benefits now. Clearly it isn't. I would say that in the past benefits were more generous but not accessed as often.

For example, tax credits for the low waged with families weren't really a thing until after 2000 as far as I know.

socialmedia23 · 21/04/2023 07:32

TomPinch · 21/04/2023 02:25

@socialmedia23
I agree with you up to a point. It's true that 30 years ago (and even more 40 or 50 years ago) the private renting sector was very small. I also agree that in the past plenty of jobs that don't provide enough of an income now to buy a house did so in the past. I think that's mostly the value of houses increasing way above inflation and wages not keeping pace.

Incidentally before WW1 hardly anyone could afford to buy a house: provision of social housing depressed house prices, and perhaps we're now reverting to normality.

But we need to beware of things being that rosy in the past. I read a book called A Working Life by Polly Toynbee - published in the 60s - each chapter is devoted to a working class job she did, mostly in factories. They were all pretty poorly paid - awful, boring, dehumanising jobs - and the people she worked along side certainly weren't buying houses. They also weren't generally living in nicely-built new council estates either. They were living in slum housing built in Victorian times. Lots of British people were emigrating in those days to Australia and New Zealand for better prospects. Those countries - particularly the latter - were comparatively very wealthy but, to be honest, the 1960s NZ house I've lived in for the last decade is pretty basic, not very big, cold in winter, and certainly not big enough to fit in a lot of things. But it was a better alternative to living in a damp, cold draughty Victorian house and working in a factory in Britain.

Regarding single parent families: I think the change there is mostly to do with changing moral values, and I actually don't think that's economic at all. I think it's more that before the 80s, when everything started to change, the expectation on everyone was that you would marry and have a family in due course, and putting it off was frowned upon. So was divorce. This expectation was on both men and women. The attitude now is about free choice. Of course no one sensible wants to have children in difficult economic circumstances, but having a plan generally makes things easier, and this includes when society tells you what the plan is. Also - and I'm not making any comment on the morals of each alternative here - it's easier for governments to structure social provision around the former - it's cheaper, and splitting families spreads people across more houses which I suspect reduces the average number of people in houses. Furthermore, back in the day, if you were single, you lodged with a family or a bunch of other lodgers, and your tenure was pretty insecure. You generally did not have a place of your own.

The point of all this is that in the past a) average people often really weren't that flash b) the family was the mainstay and people outside one struggled and c) government support existed but there is now an expectation that the government provide support that b) provided in the past.

I don't think it's just changing moral values. Yes it's a lot more acceptable to divorce or be a single parent or have a child out of wedlock. But if you look at middle class people, the vast majority end up marrying and the compelling reason for this is inheritance tax.you can only qualify for the higher tax threshold of up to a million pounds if you are married. However poor people have no assets. There are good articles on the web on the decline in marriage and economics is a big factor.

And yes a lot of middle class and rich people do divorce but the fact that there is a family home means that at least if the mum manages to hold onto the family home, they are far less likely to qualify for any form of housing benefit as housing benefits only pay rent.

beguilingeyes · 21/04/2023 07:27

It's not true that living off benefits is easier than 30/40 years ago. The safety net has been chipped away so that it's barely possible to live on it. Disabled people have to jump through hoops to prove that they're not fit to work and a lot of people are assessed as fit by people who aren't qualified to judge.
In the early 80 I knew quite a lot of people who lived 'on the dole'. With housing benefit it was possible to be reasonably comfortable even in London, although a lot of people lived in squats, which doesn't seem to be a thing any more.
A lot of musicians/actors/artists famously lived on benefits while building careers. That's almost impossible now...hence so many privately educated musicians and actors. Nobody else can afford it.

Beezknees · 21/04/2023 06:55

Bucketheadbucketbum · 20/04/2023 20:38

People need to work. Benefits shouldn't pay.

They don't. UC is literally designed so that you're better off working.

I work full time and still get benefits because wages are so shit.

TomPinch · 21/04/2023 02:25

@socialmedia23
I agree with you up to a point. It's true that 30 years ago (and even more 40 or 50 years ago) the private renting sector was very small. I also agree that in the past plenty of jobs that don't provide enough of an income now to buy a house did so in the past. I think that's mostly the value of houses increasing way above inflation and wages not keeping pace.

Incidentally before WW1 hardly anyone could afford to buy a house: provision of social housing depressed house prices, and perhaps we're now reverting to normality.

But we need to beware of things being that rosy in the past. I read a book called A Working Life by Polly Toynbee - published in the 60s - each chapter is devoted to a working class job she did, mostly in factories. They were all pretty poorly paid - awful, boring, dehumanising jobs - and the people she worked along side certainly weren't buying houses. They also weren't generally living in nicely-built new council estates either. They were living in slum housing built in Victorian times. Lots of British people were emigrating in those days to Australia and New Zealand for better prospects. Those countries - particularly the latter - were comparatively very wealthy but, to be honest, the 1960s NZ house I've lived in for the last decade is pretty basic, not very big, cold in winter, and certainly not big enough to fit in a lot of things. But it was a better alternative to living in a damp, cold draughty Victorian house and working in a factory in Britain.

Regarding single parent families: I think the change there is mostly to do with changing moral values, and I actually don't think that's economic at all. I think it's more that before the 80s, when everything started to change, the expectation on everyone was that you would marry and have a family in due course, and putting it off was frowned upon. So was divorce. This expectation was on both men and women. The attitude now is about free choice. Of course no one sensible wants to have children in difficult economic circumstances, but having a plan generally makes things easier, and this includes when society tells you what the plan is. Also - and I'm not making any comment on the morals of each alternative here - it's easier for governments to structure social provision around the former - it's cheaper, and splitting families spreads people across more houses which I suspect reduces the average number of people in houses. Furthermore, back in the day, if you were single, you lodged with a family or a bunch of other lodgers, and your tenure was pretty insecure. You generally did not have a place of your own.

The point of all this is that in the past a) average people often really weren't that flash b) the family was the mainstay and people outside one struggled and c) government support existed but there is now an expectation that the government provide support that b) provided in the past.

socialmedia23 · 20/04/2023 23:50

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 23:21

I can't remember where I saw it but I found some stats showing the breakdown of UK government spending from about 1950 onwards.

Massive declines in defence expenditure (in the early 50s it was more than 10% of government spending, now it's about 3%.)

Enormous % increased in spending on social security and health, and those increases have continued over time. The reason for some of of this will be an aging population that needs more health care and pensions.

But there are other things that don't. How much is the government forking out to private landlords on behalf of families that can't afford the rent? Go back 30 years and I bet it was way less.

Also there are probably way more single parent families now. They are more likely to need government support because they're poor.

Even if a country remains wealthy there is only so much money to go round.

30 years ago, the government owned the social housing so no need to subsidize the profits of private landlords. There are probably more single parent families now. Divorce rates actually have been declining but that doesn't mean less single parent families- poorer people don't tend to marry, they have children without marrying. But the high number of single parent families is in itself a product of economic decline- young working class men don't feel that they are in a favourable position to marry and start a family due to their low wages. Sex is however a human need and living with your partner is quite a good way of saving money....living together often brings out nesting instincts and boom, two becomes three (or more). Many of these couples do end up marrying and staying together but those who don't end up as single parents..it is quite well documented that cohabitating couples are more likely to break up though this may also be indicative of their more liberal positions towards love and marriage. Anyway, money (or the lack thereof) is a big cause of marriage breakup.

If you look at the countries with the smallest households, they are mostly rich countries e.g..scandinavian countries like Sweden where a large percentage of people actually live alone. So yes we have smaller households and that is in itself expensive to support (whether it's the government or yourself). However it is not a problem if it's a wealthy country... it is a sign it's a wealthy country when enough money goes around to support all these tiny households.

Indeed in the post war boom years working class men in UK/USA could buy a house and support a wife as well as children. This shaped the current expectations we have regarding family structures. I know because my husband's grandpa was a black cab cabbie who managed to buy a house in London and even gift a deposit to his son and fund cruises. If you skip to his grandchildren's generation, my DH is the only homeowner. So I see the current decline in living standards as a sign that the country is no longer wealthy and nuclear ,households (single/couple/small two parent family/single parent family- basically with anything less than 5 people) may very well become a luxurious family set up. Most people may end up having to live with extended family or in extreme examples live in 1 room..300k people in the UK live in 1 room with children in tow.

ejbaxa · 20/04/2023 23:25

We are fucked.

Can't get an appointment with a doctor
Can't book a driving test (no slots ever in my city)
Can't convict criminals or if we do, we don't jail them
Can't educate to a high standard in most schools

That's aside from the fact that millions are struggling to heat their homes and eat.

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 23:21

I can't remember where I saw it but I found some stats showing the breakdown of UK government spending from about 1950 onwards.

Massive declines in defence expenditure (in the early 50s it was more than 10% of government spending, now it's about 3%.)

Enormous % increased in spending on social security and health, and those increases have continued over time. The reason for some of of this will be an aging population that needs more health care and pensions.

But there are other things that don't. How much is the government forking out to private landlords on behalf of families that can't afford the rent? Go back 30 years and I bet it was way less.

Also there are probably way more single parent families now. They are more likely to need government support because they're poor.

Even if a country remains wealthy there is only so much money to go round.

beguilingeyes · 20/04/2023 23:06

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 20:12

User!

We are very wealthy by starting our own business!

What have you done?

If you're not a billionaire, we're not talking about you...or I'm not. It's more the billionaires who hide their money offshore or spend their money on space ships while their employees have to live in their cars. While we're not quite as bad as the US.. we're heading that way.
Sunak's wife has only given up her non- dom status because she was caught out.

beguilingeyes · 20/04/2023 22:55

Our dear leader doesn't pay anywhere near 45% tax. It's nearer 22%

bamboonights · 20/04/2023 22:04

WinterDeWinter · 20/04/2023 13:39

One of the reasons we have become a poorer country is because the rich have not been paying their fair share.

Yep.

socialmedia23 · 20/04/2023 22:00

ChickenDhansak82 · 20/04/2023 18:22

A huge issue is our tax system vs benefits.

54% of people now live in households that take more out from the system than they pay in. This includes the cost of schooling for each child, benefits, pensions, NHS etc... This was only around 42% in before 2000.

There has also been a huge increase in the number of people claiming disability benefits and not being able to work since COVID.

We have become "poorer" because more people are wanting to take but are not willing to contribute.

Go back 40 years where benefits were a helping hand until you got back on your feet, not a lifestyle.

It has become too easy to make benefits a lifestyle choice and too difficult to get back into work when you can "earn" the same not working.

I got laughed at by a SAHM for going back to work when I had twins. I earned £20 a week after childcare and petrol. I would have received more in benefits to stay at home, but I liked my job and didn't want to lose it.

There is also a change in mentality over the difference between WANT and NEED. Being able to take out credit and loans to buy things that people really can't afford, when they could get a second hand version for free.

I know someone who NEEDED a new sofa and took out a £2500 loan with DFS which they could barely afford to pay back, when in reality I they could have got a decent sofa for £200 on Facebook which I offered to pick up for them.

It is many changes that have led to the country becoming "poor".

Surely this has to do with many jobs having very low salaries so that they can even qualify for benefits while working. my DH was a higher rate taxpayer when he was doing his first permanent job! I don't think he is working any harder than a nurse (who is a single mum of 4 kids and whose dad just dumped them); in fact he is working far less hours and has a much easier life. However, that nurse would certainly be receiving in work benefits as well as help with childcare. the difference is that he lives in London and works in financial services (which is a big employer here), while the nurse chose to make helping people her profession and also it is too easy for men not to take any responsibility for the children they helped produce.

Kendodd · 20/04/2023 21:53

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 21:35

I have a Brexit theory that one of the reasons that certain voters and politicians supported Brexit was that they were fed up with the UK being a relatively well off country having to contribute more to the EU than it got back in grants compared to say Bulgaria that got back more than it contributed.

Now by deliberately making the UK poorer through Brexit when the UK does eventually rejoin the EU in say 10 or 20 years it will join as a relatively poorer country and therefore get back more than it contributes.

Genius really....

I have an elderly relative who, amongst other reason, said they voted leave because 'young people have it too easy these days'. So maybe you're right.

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 21:35

I have a Brexit theory that one of the reasons that certain voters and politicians supported Brexit was that they were fed up with the UK being a relatively well off country having to contribute more to the EU than it got back in grants compared to say Bulgaria that got back more than it contributed.

Now by deliberately making the UK poorer through Brexit when the UK does eventually rejoin the EU in say 10 or 20 years it will join as a relatively poorer country and therefore get back more than it contributes.

Genius really....

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 21:28

WishingMyLifeAway · 20/04/2023 21:11

That didn't post properly....

The issue is Brexit (which we can't do much about now) and the Super Rich. The really wealthy. The billionaires.

Don't let the government or anyone else fool you. This is not about the pensioners, or the people earning £85 or £100k.

It's the people who keep getting richer during the pandemic while others were losing their jobs and their businesses, and while the poor keep getting poorer.

GFC.

The UK struggled economically for a decade before Brexit.

The GFC was a punch in the UK's solar plexus and it's never discussed.

socialmedia23 · 20/04/2023 21:28

RollingInTheCreek · 20/04/2023 21:10

I agree the UK is getting poorer and we would be arrogant not to acknowledge this. However any poster who decides moving to the US is the solution needs their head examined. The volume of random shootings just this week puts me off ever visiting the US again let alone living there.

I agree with you but then Americans may think that we have a stabbing crisis in london too based on the media reports we read. I live in london and i do not fear stabbings (it is very specific to a certain demographic in certain areas). I remember i had a friend from huddersfield ask me about the 'high crime 'in London and my response was that i wasn't sure about that, i feel quite safe in my area!

Many people may think that if they live in a posh suburb, in a gated community and send their kids to private school on the new fat american salaries, they would be somehow insulated.

Kendodd · 20/04/2023 21:25

thebaneofmylifeisacat · 20/04/2023 20:12

User!

We are very wealthy by starting our own business!

What have you done?

I know this isn't aimed at me but let's say I had worked as a care worker all my life, would that mean I deserved to live in poverty?

WishingMyLifeAway · 20/04/2023 21:11

That didn't post properly....

The issue is Brexit (which we can't do much about now) and the Super Rich. The really wealthy. The billionaires.

Don't let the government or anyone else fool you. This is not about the pensioners, or the people earning £85 or £100k.

It's the people who keep getting richer during the pandemic while others were losing their jobs and their businesses, and while the poor keep getting poorer.

WishingMyLifeAway · 20/04/2023 21:10

The issue is Brexit (which we can't do much about now) and the Super Rich. The really wealthy. The billionaires.

Don't let the government or anyone else fool you. This is not about the pensioners, or the people earning £85 or £100k.

It's the people who keep getting richer during the pandemic while others were losing their jobs and their businesses, and while the poor keep getting poorer.

RollingInTheCreek · 20/04/2023 21:10

I agree the UK is getting poorer and we would be arrogant not to acknowledge this. However any poster who decides moving to the US is the solution needs their head examined. The volume of random shootings just this week puts me off ever visiting the US again let alone living there.

TomPinch · 20/04/2023 21:04

@socialmedia23 Thanks - that was in interesting post, and immigrants' reasons are complex. Your point about Indian professionals is interesting. I'm in NZ and hadn't noticed anything similar but I think we probably get a different kind of immigrant.

I note your comments about US / Australia too. In simple money / opportunity terms I think the UK probably is slipping behind them, and most other English speaking countries (other than NZ!)

But it seems to me that the point I'm addressing (ie, people will continue to want to immigrate to the UK at least for the foreseeable future definitely stands. If they're moving to the UK the country is - for whatever reasons - desirable to them.

Mass immigration to just about all developed countries other than Japan will, I think, be with us for a good while yet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread