Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people saying everything should be means tested

118 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/04/2023 14:18

I think the issue is, which things are means tested and which things aren’t.

Eg, it seems odd that child benefit is means tested (all at, and also that the thresholds haven’t changed since means testing came in), but benefits that apply to older people never are.

lemmein · 20/04/2023 14:17

Therein lies the rub - it either gets spent on those people, or it gets spent trying to decide which people to give it to. That's why some benefits are just given to everyone - it's less costly to just hand it out than it is to try to work out who should and shouldn't get it.

The admin has already been done for pension credit which could be used as a qualifier for other benefits 🤷🏻‍♀️

LlynTegid · 20/04/2023 14:16

Means testing costs money to do, even in this internet age. I think there are some things that should be, but not everything.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 14:16

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:45

Also I like the means tested argument because it's all based on the delusion that most UK tax payers are putting in to system.

Truthfully it's higher rate taxpayers who make a net contribution- short of that, everyone below is getting more than they pay in tax.

Sshhh! Don't go saying the truth of the matter!

My MIL is a classic case. She looked at a single mother with several children and glibly said "I'm paying my taxes for that!". She didn't like it when I pointed out that she barely pays any tax at all. She gets state pension and a widow's pension from her husband's pension scheme, no income tax as it's all just below personal allowance. She has around £100k in savings, all in ISAs, so no income tax on the interest/dividends. She doesn't have a car, so no road tax, fuel duty, VAT on fuel/repairs etc - just uses her free bus pass and cadges lifts from us. She barely buys anything, so no VAT on most of the food she buys, no VAT on her Daily Mail, a bit of VAT on her telephone bill and 5% on her electric & gas (mostly covered by the winter fuel allowance she doesn't need), OK, VAT on clothes/shoes etc buy she hardly ever buys anything. It's not as if she "paid in" - she hadn't worked since having my OH in her 20's - just a SAHM relying on her hubbies wage and accumulating credits for state benefits using the "home responsibilities" protection for 16 years! She can still save a few hundred per month after costs which goes into her tax-free ISA. Yet, she's first to whinge when there's any suggestion of OAPs paying for prescriptions, means testing bus passes, etc., even though she can easily afford them, and that's someone on a very low income! She also burst a blood vessel when they took away her free TV licence (which she can afford to pay for!). Despite paying virtually nothing in tax, she still thinks she's personally paying for half the benefit claimants in our town!

ShamElNasseem · 20/04/2023 14:13

Of course they should be means tested. I think 6k in savings is too generous it should be 2k and up to 5k. You use your savings to get out of a tight spot, not tax payers money. The people who genuinely deserve benefits should be awarded more but there are too many cash in hand my husband doesn't live with me i'm saving for my kids or dogs piss takers.

lemmein · 20/04/2023 14:13

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:26

Pretty much any universal benefit has been mentioned on here - often (but not always) the ones given to older folks.

People only seem to have a problem with means-testing when it comes to older people 🙄

AutumnCrow · 20/04/2023 14:13

Grapefruitsquash · 20/04/2023 14:11

Conversely when my MIL died her medicine cabinet was full of packets and packets of prescription medication. When we asked her carers why, we were told that she stopped taking most of them but the chemist had them on a repeat prescription and they were free so she kept collecting them.

Well that's just a bit fucking stupid tbh. Couldn't one grown adult involved have had the necessary conversation(s) to cancel them?

AutumnCrow · 20/04/2023 14:11

Is this a TAAT about over-60s and free prescriptions by any chance?

Grapefruitsquash · 20/04/2023 14:11

ShandyQuaffer · 20/04/2023 13:41

Yes, I agree. For some things the costs of means testing outweigh the savings. For others, there's no sensible reason for means testing- we all have NHS treatment free at the point of use so why means test prescriptions? (I'd have free prescriptions for all throughout the UK.) Keeping some things universal helps to ensure that people buy into the system and realise that they benefit from it as well as paying out. It also ensures that people take up what is due to them- the number of people who don't take prescribed medicines to save the prescription cost is shocking and probably costs the NHS more in the long term as illnesses don't get treated.

Conversely when my MIL died her medicine cabinet was full of packets and packets of prescription medication. When we asked her carers why, we were told that she stopped taking most of them but the chemist had them on a repeat prescription and they were free so she kept collecting them.

Miajk · 20/04/2023 14:11

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:26

Pretty much any universal benefit has been mentioned on here - often (but not always) the ones given to older folks.

To be honest when the younger generation is facing not even having a state pension potentially, not being able to get on the housing ladder, unprecedentedly high rent and cost of living, giving lots of stuff for free constantly to one of the wealthiest generations is stupid.

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 20/04/2023 14:10

Dontbelieveaword · 20/04/2023 13:39

Ah, I see, so it is a benefits bashing thread. quelle surprise. I'm off

And a "why won't the elderly just die" thread.
As ever.

PollyPeptide · 20/04/2023 14:09

dreamingbohemian · 20/04/2023 13:59

I would agree except that I've lived in other countries where means testing works rather well.

In France healthcare fees are means tested so if you are unemployed or on benefits you don't pay anything, if you are low income you pay a token amount, if you are high income you pay more.

In Germany childcare is means tested so it's basically free for low or no income and then gradually more expensive as your income rises. We paid 40 euros a month for full-time childcare!

Both French healthcare and German childcare are a million times better than what we have in the UK right now (a free NHS that is breaking apart, and horrifically expensive childcare). So maybe means testing isn't such a bad idea BUT I think it works in those countries because even the richest people are not paying insane amounts (e.g. it's about 30 euros for a GP visit in France).

I think international studies show that the uk health system is actually rated higher than both France and Germany's. (There was a thread on it with statistics.)

SerendipityJane · 20/04/2023 14:02

Feel free to answer the question before sounding off.

To be sick of people saying everything should be means tested
Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 14:01

@Dontbelieveaword

🤔 just to clarify, do you personally hold the criteria for who is and isn’t allowed to leave a relationship? Or just who is/isn’t allowed to claim benefits if they do?
Or is it simply that I had the audacity to check out what I would get in advance of actually leaving? Mental that I would consider the financial impact to my small children (one of whom is disabled) over and above my own wish to leave 🤷‍♀️

I’d remind you that the first piece of advice given to any woman wanting to leave a relationship is generally to ‘check out how much you’d be entitled to’ and that there should be no shame or stigma in any woman doing that.

I was very shocked, and remain very shocked, that there was such little difference between what is perceived as a ‘comfortable professional’ income brings in to support a family vs benefits I’d receive as a single mum. It’s not what I expected. I’m not entirely sure that the government should be supporting anyone to that level if I’m honest, no. Thats not ‘bashing’ I fully support help being offered but the moment you question anything about the system you’re just screamed at about how horribly terrible you are 😬

dreamingbohemian · 20/04/2023 13:59

I would agree except that I've lived in other countries where means testing works rather well.

In France healthcare fees are means tested so if you are unemployed or on benefits you don't pay anything, if you are low income you pay a token amount, if you are high income you pay more.

In Germany childcare is means tested so it's basically free for low or no income and then gradually more expensive as your income rises. We paid 40 euros a month for full-time childcare!

Both French healthcare and German childcare are a million times better than what we have in the UK right now (a free NHS that is breaking apart, and horrifically expensive childcare). So maybe means testing isn't such a bad idea BUT I think it works in those countries because even the richest people are not paying insane amounts (e.g. it's about 30 euros for a GP visit in France).

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:58

@Neededanewuserhandle - if you do include VAT then the figure drops out of the higher tax band. If you don't, then in the basis of income tax, you will not be a net contributor. The figures I could find were from 2017. I don't know the latest.

I'm not anti benefits but I do find it silly that people who declare themselves to be the squeezed middle and thus apparently supporting feckless scroungers are, in some cases, not contributing themselves.

xyxygy · 20/04/2023 13:49

OoooohMatron · 20/04/2023 13:44

This. I don't see why my taxes should fund people who don't actually need help.

Therein lies the rub - it either gets spent on those people, or it gets spent trying to decide which people to give it to. That's why some benefits are just given to everyone - it's less costly to just hand it out than it is to try to work out who should and shouldn't get it.

Fixing that problem would involve first fixing a much larger issue - the fact that our government (any of them, of any political persuasion) is incapable of completing almost any large IT project within budget and on schedule. If they were to make a change like that, it would take longer than a single term and would likely get shelved by the next lot.

bingoitsadingo · 20/04/2023 13:48

I agree OP.

Means testing splits people into "people who pay" and "people who receive". Rather than viewing it as a system that people pay into according to their means and receive according to their needs.
Means testing means higher earners look at things and go "I'm paying for them to get that, and I have to pay to get it myself".
Free prescriptions is a great example. Child benefit. Travel passes for college age children. Student maintenance loans. The tapering of the personal allowance for high earners.

To people who say "but high earners don't need the help" - it's easy enough to adjust tax thresholds so it works out even. Especially if you get rid of the cost of all the means testing.

Dontbelieveaword · 20/04/2023 13:48

@Neededanewuserhandle did I quote you? Please refrain from swearing at me.
I was quite willing to join your conversation until other PPs started the old, boring, bashing crap. You've even got one woman who's benefit bashing single mums who claim benefits but still considered leaving her unhappy marriage and researched...wait for it...how much benefits she could claim. Amazing.
I don't want to be a part it, is that OK with you OP?

Irritateandunreasonable · 20/04/2023 13:47

So everyone should get benefits? What do you suggest should not be means tested?

Only thing I can think of is free school meals for primary children.

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:46

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:45

Also I like the means tested argument because it's all based on the delusion that most UK tax payers are putting in to system.

Truthfully it's higher rate taxpayers who make a net contribution- short of that, everyone below is getting more than they pay in tax.

Are you including VAT etc?

OP posts:
LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:45

Also I like the means tested argument because it's all based on the delusion that most UK tax payers are putting in to system.

Truthfully it's higher rate taxpayers who make a net contribution- short of that, everyone below is getting more than they pay in tax.

OoooohMatron · 20/04/2023 13:44

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 20/04/2023 13:33

When I look at the fact that 20% of the tax I pay is spent on welfare I think too right everything should be means tested. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary

This. I don't see why my taxes should fund people who don't actually need help.

thimblewomgee247 · 20/04/2023 13:44

Wenfy · 20/04/2023 13:42

Means testing prescriptions would mean that the rich end up getting their drugs from outside the NHS which would eventually result in everyone paying for them.

Surely the drugs would cost more then the cost of a prescription

Wenfy · 20/04/2023 13:42

Means testing prescriptions would mean that the rich end up getting their drugs from outside the NHS which would eventually result in everyone paying for them.