Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people saying everything should be means tested

118 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

OP posts:
SueVineer · 20/04/2023 15:28

Scottishskifun · 20/04/2023 15:24

Child benefit isn't means tested.

A separate tax return is required if you earn over the threshold and you pay back based on percentage but the benefit itself isn't as if over it you can still claim it which is wise to do for SAHP anyway as it pays NI contributions as well.

It effectively is as you have to pay it back in tax if you earn over a certain amount

SueVineer · 20/04/2023 15:27

MintJulia · 20/04/2023 15:03

The key one is pensions.

The old age pension is NOT a benefit. Workers have paid in their NI over many years, on the basis of a social contract.
Yes the terms of the contract can be varied over time but winning the lottery a week before you retire does not mean you are any less entitled to your old age pension. You have paid your dues and are owed it.

Other stuff - bus passes, prescriptions, winter fuel payments, child benefit are extras and I have no issue with those being means tested. They weren't agreed in a contract 50 years ago.

The other two I think should be universal are basic disability payments and free school meals. I'd happily pay an extra 1p in the £ to cover the cost of EVERY school child having access to a hot meal 365 days a year. For the simple reason, they cannot provide it for themselves.

That isn’t true at all. State pensions are contribution based benefits. There is no pot of money nor are they funded by people’s contributions. The contribution’s today pensioners have paid are nothing like enough to fund state pensions.

it is a serious issue as pensioners are the richest demographic and we are paying over 11% if all public revenue in state pensions. It really adds to ingenerational unfairness when the state is giving large sums of money to some of the richest people in society. Of course not all pensioners are wealthy but that isn’t an argument for a universal state pension.

Scottishskifun · 20/04/2023 15:24

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 13:28

I think given that child benefit is means tested then they can means test other things too

Child benefit isn't means tested.

A separate tax return is required if you earn over the threshold and you pay back based on percentage but the benefit itself isn't as if over it you can still claim it which is wise to do for SAHP anyway as it pays NI contributions as well.

SueVineer · 20/04/2023 15:22

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

Pretty much all benefits are means tested except for state pensions. This is why state pensions on their own cost about 11% of all government expenditure. It is extremely expensive to have universal benefits. The nonsense that it costs more to means test is crap.

NotTerfNorCis · 20/04/2023 15:14

The problem isn't that means testing is a bad idea, but that the cost of it would outweigh the benefits, especially considering it would slow everything down.

Also there's an argument, if someone has paid a lot into a system, shouldn't they benefit from it?

Coffeeandbourbons · 20/04/2023 15:14

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 13:35

Yeah I agree completely.

The issue with means testing everything is that ultimately it removes the levels of society that we’ve had for generations and whilst yes the concept of ‘everyone should have everything’ is wonderful in theory, in practice it removed the motivation to work harder and improve your own situation.

For example, and I’m just putting this out there, I have a relatively high earning DH in a professional and respected job who me and both children are financially reliant on. People perceive us to have a ‘comfortable life’ not rich just ok. Because of him we receive no benefits not even child benefit…fine no issues.

Recently I questioned whether this marriage was right for me, I checked out what financial support I would receive on my own with the kids 😂😂😂 there was pretty much no damn difference. If I left my DH I would receive so much ‘means tested’ support and UC that my life would change very little. I couldn’t actually believe it.
I find myself feeling incredibly sorry for the ‘Squeezed middle’ who in theory are working professional and difficult roles (nurses, teachers…etc) but live the same lifestyle as those working on a checkout and claiming UC.

where’s the motivation there?

I agree. It’s madness! I see so many posts on here about how those working should consider themselves lucky as ‘they’ll have a better pension’ and in another thread the same poster will be calling for generous pensions for those who have never or rarely worked as ‘nobody should live in poverty in 2023’

Where is the incentive for anything?

Dontbelieveaword · 20/04/2023 15:10

@Thehonestbadger don't put words in my mouth regarding unhappy or abusive relationships and someone's need or right to leave. Don't dare to even think you know my stance on such a matter.

If you can't see the hypocrisy and irony of your own post, slagging off 'checkout' workers not having any incentive or motivation to work when you're quite happy to consider moving from being supported by your husband directly onto being supported by the state, with no motivation to looking into your own earning power instead, then, as I said, I don't want to be part of this conversation.
So please don't put words in my mouth, don't quote me, don't bring me back into the conversation, I'm really not interested

Nordicrain · 20/04/2023 15:07

I think more should be offered to everyone!

MintJulia · 20/04/2023 15:03

The key one is pensions.

The old age pension is NOT a benefit. Workers have paid in their NI over many years, on the basis of a social contract.
Yes the terms of the contract can be varied over time but winning the lottery a week before you retire does not mean you are any less entitled to your old age pension. You have paid your dues and are owed it.

Other stuff - bus passes, prescriptions, winter fuel payments, child benefit are extras and I have no issue with those being means tested. They weren't agreed in a contract 50 years ago.

The other two I think should be universal are basic disability payments and free school meals. I'd happily pay an extra 1p in the £ to cover the cost of EVERY school child having access to a hot meal 365 days a year. For the simple reason, they cannot provide it for themselves.

Sirius3030 · 20/04/2023 15:00

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ShamElNasseem · 20/04/2023 14:44

@Nat6999 and I see what you are doing because you purposefully excluded the sentence where I said people in genuine need of benefits should be given more. Benefits are not there for you to save up for a rainy day if you have savings you have too much to claim benefits full stop as benefits are not a saving up or budgeting scheme.

ShamElNasseem · 20/04/2023 14:42

Nat6999 · 20/04/2023 14:24

It's easy if you have back payments in benefits to have more than these amounts. Are you saying that claimants shouldn't be allowed to have enough money to cover themselves for things like appliances breaking down, car repairs, home maintenance & in this day & age in case of being sactioned? The £6k limit hasn't been increased in line with inflation for years, it would be more like £10k now, someone who gets in work benefits could easily have £2k in their bank at times when they have just been paid.

6k is way more a boiler breakdown. people in genuine need of benefits don't even have 1k. yes I am saying all that.
Why would you be back paid benefits unless you were unaware of entitlement or given bad advice or appealing in which case it's different and you know that damn well. it's unreasonable to have rainy day savings but expect tax payers to pay for your when you have your rainy day. It's unreasonable to save for imaginary washing machine breakdown but then raid the food bank.

Pericombobulations · 20/04/2023 14:36

@Deathbyfluffy But at the moment the government don't help other than pay basic PIP. From that we pay for services but already have more expenses because of my disability and will have more in the future. At the moment I can still work as can my husband but if/when I get worse I will have to stop working and my husband too to care for me.

Means testing is a very blunt tool and with medical issues it does not cover all the information that it needs to and people will suffer. And the people who suffer already will suffer more because of it.

Inthedarkagain · 20/04/2023 14:32

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 13:35

Yeah I agree completely.

The issue with means testing everything is that ultimately it removes the levels of society that we’ve had for generations and whilst yes the concept of ‘everyone should have everything’ is wonderful in theory, in practice it removed the motivation to work harder and improve your own situation.

For example, and I’m just putting this out there, I have a relatively high earning DH in a professional and respected job who me and both children are financially reliant on. People perceive us to have a ‘comfortable life’ not rich just ok. Because of him we receive no benefits not even child benefit…fine no issues.

Recently I questioned whether this marriage was right for me, I checked out what financial support I would receive on my own with the kids 😂😂😂 there was pretty much no damn difference. If I left my DH I would receive so much ‘means tested’ support and UC that my life would change very little. I couldn’t actually believe it.
I find myself feeling incredibly sorry for the ‘Squeezed middle’ who in theory are working professional and difficult roles (nurses, teachers…etc) but live the same lifestyle as those working on a checkout and claiming UC.

where’s the motivation there?

I agree with you to an extent, but I like to think most people should have a reasonable standard of living despite their circumstances. I think the issue is wage stagnation and that people who work have had their living standards reduced due to this, so this is why there is no benefit perceived from working. It should be that people are supported adequately by welfare and working in a professional job means you have financial benefit (not just enough to get by).

The reason this issue is divisive is because wages have not kept up with the cost of living and the housing issues in this country have been hugely, massively neglected for decades. Working feels like a mugs game if you aren't earning above 60k.

Crikeyalmighty · 20/04/2023 14:30

One thing I do think is that child maintanance should be factored in when calculating UC etc. a lady I know with 2 kids of primary age and renting a pretty nice HA flat gets £1670 plus she is in the lucky position of getting around £780 maintenance. So around £2400 a month. Her rent isn't high. I'm not saying she has the life of Riley on that but she gets by nicely without working at all- I can see this isn't exactly fair when balanced against some young couples not in HA paying for nursery and both working and just on the limits not to get any help at all. She probably has more spare cash than they do.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 14:30

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 20/04/2023 14:25

I'm all in favour of certain benefits being universal, but I also happy to pay for these via higher taxation.

Trouble is that the "higher" earners usually have scope to change behaviour/circumstances to reduce the tax they pay, such as paying into a pension to get their earnings under the £50k or £100k thresholds, not taking on extra shifts/promotions which push their pay over such thresholds, and ultimately, retiring early (such as GPs and dentists to avoid the penal tax charge on pensions), or emigrating.

That's why most tax increases over the past 20 years have been paid mostly by the "squeezed middle" who are less socially mobile and have fewer opportunities to change behaviour to pay less tax as they need to earn to pay their mortgages and other ever-increasing living costs.

The lower earners pay little tax anyway, the higher earners have opportunities to change circumstances to avoid tax hikes, but the squeezed middle are trapped.

EsmeSusanOgg · 20/04/2023 14:27

A lot of things are offered universally because the cost of means-testing and the administrative burden that goes with it far exceeds the cost of just offering to everyone.

For example, in Wales prescriptions are free. Partly, because this was a popular policy, but also because when you took out all the people who were exempt from paying due to age/ means-testing etc. it actually cost fat more to run the administration than was brought in by those who did pay.

Bus passes are offered universally to pensioners because many people over a certain age qualify for a free bus pass either because of low income or because of health conditions that mean they cannot drive/ cannot drive without substantial restrictions. When youmeans test it for this age group, and take out those people who have enough money to pay but also have no health conditions that would entitle then to a free pass anyway, you're looking at an administrative burden that far exceeds any costs savings by making those who could pay, pay.

A lot of these decisions on universal entitlements are made for good old fashioned cost reasons, not just idealolgy/ vote winning.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 20/04/2023 14:25

I'm all in favour of certain benefits being universal, but I also happy to pay for these via higher taxation.

Nat6999 · 20/04/2023 14:24

ShamElNasseem · 20/04/2023 14:13

Of course they should be means tested. I think 6k in savings is too generous it should be 2k and up to 5k. You use your savings to get out of a tight spot, not tax payers money. The people who genuinely deserve benefits should be awarded more but there are too many cash in hand my husband doesn't live with me i'm saving for my kids or dogs piss takers.

It's easy if you have back payments in benefits to have more than these amounts. Are you saying that claimants shouldn't be allowed to have enough money to cover themselves for things like appliances breaking down, car repairs, home maintenance & in this day & age in case of being sactioned? The £6k limit hasn't been increased in line with inflation for years, it would be more like £10k now, someone who gets in work benefits could easily have £2k in their bank at times when they have just been paid.

SerendipityJane · 20/04/2023 14:24

Just popped in to see if anyone had an answer yet ? 😀

taxguru · 20/04/2023 14:23

The Govt can "means test" when they want to, i.e. child benefit reductions when income over £50k or removal of free childcare on incomes over £100k.

Likewise all the exclusions they found time and admin money to put in place for the covid support which ended up excluding 3 million people on ridiculous, unfair and spurious grounds, which caused suicides, bankruptcies, etc., yet couldn't think of a way to stop fraudsters taking bounce back loans!

Deathbyfluffy · 20/04/2023 14:23

Pericombobulations · 20/04/2023 14:18

The problem I have with means testing is that whilst we would probably have too much coming in, because I am disabled we also have more going out as we have to cover more things. I have to have things like a gardener as I can no longer do it and dh is too busy running the house and we really need a cleaner too.

For us these aren't luxuries but necessities. I have other expenses and we really need to convert the bathroom due to me rather than want to.

I currently have 4 items on my monthly prescription that I have to have and have a monthly pre-prescription payment set up but it's another expense. Means testing only looks at income not outcomes and therefore I and many others wouldn't get any benefit.

My mum has just been means tested by the local council as has daily carers etc but is deemed to have too much income as dad set his pensions up to benefit her on his death. So yes she isn't on the breadline but is having to pay for it all out of dad's pension.

It's a whole mess when they look at means testing and don't have the time or man power to review each case as it deserves.

But that's entirely the point - you're disabled, but that doesn't automatically mean the Government should pick up the tab for things you can no longer do.
It's not the Government's fault you're disabled, so unless you pass the benchmark for help you shouldn't automatically get help with gardening / cleaning IMO.

Those who genuinely can't afford it will get additional benefits they can use for it, but those who can fund it don't need the Government to mow their lawn.

dreamingbohemian · 20/04/2023 14:22

PollyPeptide · 20/04/2023 14:09

I think international studies show that the uk health system is actually rated higher than both France and Germany's. (There was a thread on it with statistics.)

Perhaps in the past but there is absolutely no way you can say the current NHS is better than the French and German systems, not when people are suffering and dying in such large numbers because they simply cannot access care.

It was just in the news that one in eight people are now using private healthcare in the UK, we are sleep walking into a de facto means testing where anyone who can afford to pay goes private, and everyone else has to put up with an NHS that's falling apart.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 14:20

AutumnCrow · 20/04/2023 14:13

Well that's just a bit fucking stupid tbh. Couldn't one grown adult involved have had the necessary conversation(s) to cancel them?

You'd think so, but when I do the repeat request and only tick the items I actually want, I still often get the entire list! I used to hand the list into the local pharmacy, so I never knew whether they ticked everything to make more profit out of dispensing more drugs, or whether it was the GP surgery lazily pressing the "tick all" box rather than ticking just what I asked for. Now I do it online directly with the GP surgery and still occasionally get the whole list, so it looks like the GP surgery who are the ones doing it (but then again, the GP partners now own the adjacent pharmacy so maybe they've told the admins to "tick all" so they make more profit from the prescriptions they generate!).

Same with OH with his cancer drug carrier bag - apparently no way to delete the drugs he never takes as it's a "package" on their system and there's no will within the oncology dept to change it!

Pericombobulations · 20/04/2023 14:18

The problem I have with means testing is that whilst we would probably have too much coming in, because I am disabled we also have more going out as we have to cover more things. I have to have things like a gardener as I can no longer do it and dh is too busy running the house and we really need a cleaner too.

For us these aren't luxuries but necessities. I have other expenses and we really need to convert the bathroom due to me rather than want to.

I currently have 4 items on my monthly prescription that I have to have and have a monthly pre-prescription payment set up but it's another expense. Means testing only looks at income not outcomes and therefore I and many others wouldn't get any benefit.

My mum has just been means tested by the local council as has daily carers etc but is deemed to have too much income as dad set his pensions up to benefit her on his death. So yes she isn't on the breadline but is having to pay for it all out of dad's pension.

It's a whole mess when they look at means testing and don't have the time or man power to review each case as it deserves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread