Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people saying everything should be means tested

118 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 20/04/2023 17:00

I don't think it's about the mathematical reality, it's a gut reaction. There's a tendency in this country to find the idea of somebody receiving more than their share - of anything - so abhorrent and outrageous that we'd prefer nobody received anything and the poorest starve in the street just to avoid it.

It's the same pinched, mean-spirited, jealous resource-guarding instinct that leads people to vote Tory in the first place. It will keep people voting Tory even while public services are being suffocated out of existence, elderly and disabled people are dying of neglect and we have an actual oligarch as Prime Minister. It's a psychological sickness, and it runs through this country like Brighton through a stick of rock.

Quveas · 20/04/2023 17:00

I am fully in favour of taxpayers money not being paid to those who don't need it. Let's start with not paying multi- millionaire Sunak £168,000 to fuck up the country.

MathiasBroucek · 20/04/2023 16:55

YANBU. The savings from means testing can be significantly eroded by adminstration. For example, imagine if anyone with a retirement income of over £100k became ineligble for the State Pension. The number of people affected would be a tiny percentage of pensioners but the admin would be horrendous (and of course they'd be paying 40% or 45% back in tax in any case).

Means testing also increases the chance that some people who should be eligible miss out due to the complexities (often the most vulnerable, sadly).

Some people even suggested the energy price support should have been means tested. Last time I checked, the power companies didn't have access to income and savings data for their customers!!!!

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 20/04/2023 16:54

To me, it just wouldn't pass the financial analysis to make it viable - I believe that the cost of means-testing child benefit for example is at least equal to the money that was saved from not giving it to everyone.

Think about it - to means test you have to produce the application forms, process them, then implement a system that only gives people money who meet the criteria, then you have to do that what, once a year? Once every 5 years? To check that people are still liable, you need to have a department to investigate edge cases and to reclaim overpayments etc.

How much do you think that service costs to run? More or less than just giving every one that benefit?

Also, morally, I feel that in the case of child benefit, means testing the parents, when it's specifically a benefit aimed at children, is wrong.

x2boys · 20/04/2023 16:52

Crikeyalmighty · 20/04/2023 14:30

One thing I do think is that child maintanance should be factored in when calculating UC etc. a lady I know with 2 kids of primary age and renting a pretty nice HA flat gets £1670 plus she is in the lucky position of getting around £780 maintenance. So around £2400 a month. Her rent isn't high. I'm not saying she has the life of Riley on that but she gets by nicely without working at all- I can see this isn't exactly fair when balanced against some young couples not in HA paying for nursery and both working and just on the limits not to get any help at all. She probably has more spare cash than they do.

If her kids are primary school.age ( assuming no.disabilities) she will.be required to.look for work.

JudgeRudy · 20/04/2023 16:49

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 13:35

Yeah I agree completely.

The issue with means testing everything is that ultimately it removes the levels of society that we’ve had for generations and whilst yes the concept of ‘everyone should have everything’ is wonderful in theory, in practice it removed the motivation to work harder and improve your own situation.

For example, and I’m just putting this out there, I have a relatively high earning DH in a professional and respected job who me and both children are financially reliant on. People perceive us to have a ‘comfortable life’ not rich just ok. Because of him we receive no benefits not even child benefit…fine no issues.

Recently I questioned whether this marriage was right for me, I checked out what financial support I would receive on my own with the kids 😂😂😂 there was pretty much no damn difference. If I left my DH I would receive so much ‘means tested’ support and UC that my life would change very little. I couldn’t actually believe it.
I find myself feeling incredibly sorry for the ‘Squeezed middle’ who in theory are working professional and difficult roles (nurses, teachers…etc) but live the same lifestyle as those working on a checkout and claiming UC.

where’s the motivation there?

I think your housing situation makes a massive difference. Eg a young couple with 2 children who have just purchased a home (with a mortgage) most definitely would not be in the same position if they separated. Let's say mum and children stayed in the home. Any benefits she recieved would not consider the mortgage payments. Let's say they were £600pcm. If she was in rented accommodation she might recieve and extra £800 to cover the rent. Now the challenge is finding a home for £800pcm that you want to live in

Flamingogirl08 · 20/04/2023 16:48

Well maybe they will start means testing bus passes, prescriptions for over 60s, PIP just in time for you to be in your 60s or maybe be seriously ill and then you can complain how it's a disgrace because you've paid in all your life.

Tealsofa · 20/04/2023 16:43

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 13:28

I think given that child benefit is means tested then they can means test other things too

Yeah

And how they can link a couple for benefits, but not for CB confunds me?
Your income changes
You will not have to pay the tax charge if your or your partner’s individual ‘adjusted net income’ for the whole of a tax year is less than £50,000.
Household ‘adjusted net income’ for £99,999 - thats fine,
Single parent ‘adjusted net income’ for £50,001 - nah, you cant have that

Believeitornot · 20/04/2023 16:43

taxguru · 20/04/2023 14:30

Trouble is that the "higher" earners usually have scope to change behaviour/circumstances to reduce the tax they pay, such as paying into a pension to get their earnings under the £50k or £100k thresholds, not taking on extra shifts/promotions which push their pay over such thresholds, and ultimately, retiring early (such as GPs and dentists to avoid the penal tax charge on pensions), or emigrating.

That's why most tax increases over the past 20 years have been paid mostly by the "squeezed middle" who are less socially mobile and have fewer opportunities to change behaviour to pay less tax as they need to earn to pay their mortgages and other ever-increasing living costs.

The lower earners pay little tax anyway, the higher earners have opportunities to change circumstances to avoid tax hikes, but the squeezed middle are trapped.

Are you factoring all taxes into that statement or just income tax?

SlipperyLizard · 20/04/2023 16:41

People often say “it costs more to means test than making it universal”, but somehow the government means tests everything that working age people get and hardly anything that older people get.

It is either more expensive to means test, or it isn’t.

I’d prefer things to be universal (child benefit, free prescriptions, the tax free allowance, childcare help) and recoup the cost from taxation. The tax rates for those edging over 50k (lose child benefit) and £100k (lose childcare help & personal allowance), as well as withdrawal of benefits when people earn more, drive behaviours that result in less tax being paid.

Believeitornot · 20/04/2023 16:41

Think of all the staff and systems needed to means test benefits. It’s an industry in itself.

I think means testing is madness for many benefits and the level of means testing goes to far.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/04/2023 16:39

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

Just because people don't type out a long screed about how they would make things means-tested, doesn't mean they don't understand or appreciate costs and complexities. It probably means they know they don't have the expertise (or time) to advise on an anonymous chat forum, but still have an opinion. Or, maybe they do, but recognise announcing a plan on Mumsnet will have no impact.

But sure, probably all those people are just 'ignorant' Hmm

Crikeyalmighty · 20/04/2023 16:19

@caringcarer totally agree.

caringcarer · 20/04/2023 16:13

Crikeyalmighty · 20/04/2023 14:30

One thing I do think is that child maintanance should be factored in when calculating UC etc. a lady I know with 2 kids of primary age and renting a pretty nice HA flat gets £1670 plus she is in the lucky position of getting around £780 maintenance. So around £2400 a month. Her rent isn't high. I'm not saying she has the life of Riley on that but she gets by nicely without working at all- I can see this isn't exactly fair when balanced against some young couples not in HA paying for nursery and both working and just on the limits not to get any help at all. She probably has more spare cash than they do.

I agree all incomes from all sources including child maintenance should be included to determine the amount of benefit received. It always seems strange to me that child maintenance is not included. There should also be a failsafe system where child maintenance is not paid for any reason then UC covers it, but absent parents are chased for payment.

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 16:12

Dontbelieveaword · 20/04/2023 15:10

@Thehonestbadger don't put words in my mouth regarding unhappy or abusive relationships and someone's need or right to leave. Don't dare to even think you know my stance on such a matter.

If you can't see the hypocrisy and irony of your own post, slagging off 'checkout' workers not having any incentive or motivation to work when you're quite happy to consider moving from being supported by your husband directly onto being supported by the state, with no motivation to looking into your own earning power instead, then, as I said, I don't want to be part of this conversation.
So please don't put words in my mouth, don't quote me, don't bring me back into the conversation, I'm really not interested

You post was blatantly mocking and bashing me for having the audacity to ‘research’ my options to leave my marriage with my small children. You were villainising me for my personal observations during that process.

Whether that was your intention or not that’s what you did so your accusation of hypocrisy is in entirely two edged sword 😏

I do enjoy your ‘don’t you dare call me out on this’ rant though, even though you took it on yourself to ‘call me out’ on my original post. I would recommend not giving judgment unless you’re willing to receive a rebuttal.

As for your comment about my unwillingness to work. Again your hypocrisy is a two edged sword as whilst you rant and rave about my not knowing your circumstances or stances on matters you’ve likely completely ignored the part in my earlier comment where I reference my disabled child. I’m actually unable to work due to being their carer 👍🏻 so I wouldn’t be able to work to support us for at least the next few years.

I do receive carer benefit, I do have a generally liberal outlook. I do fully support a welfare system and think everyone deserves a decent standard of life.
I do not, however, think that everyone earning under <£70k deserves a largely similar quality of life. You can call me every name you like tbh and I’ll still never think that.

Checkout workers was just the first minimum wage example job I thought of. I worked checkouts for years. It’s unskilled, low responsibility, it’s usually minimum wage, nothing wrong with it at all but it’s not a job that should ever rival teachers/nurses in terms of income or lifestyle.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 16:11

@caringcarer

I think if the government changed the way state pension was paid so only those without a private pension could claim it, then many people would simply spend more of their money on themselves and stop paying into private pensions. People would opt to take more holidays etc instead.

That's what happened with pension credits. Those with only state pension and a small private pension weren't eligible for pension credits, but those without a private pension got pension credits, and both groups ended up with the same income! A real disincentive to pay into a private pension scheme if you didn't earn much money! I wish policy makers would think through the consequences of their policies!

taxguru · 20/04/2023 16:08

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 15:57

If you are planning to rely on a state pension, which is welfare, then you are planning for poverty. Pensions are benefits. They rely on additional taxpayers making contributions.

People are all very good about kicking the working poor over benefits etc but if you look at pensions, the biggest part of welfare, then they say that is different because they contribute. As discussed earlier, most people are not net contributors for tax and a pension is another example of taking more than you put in over a working lifetime for most.

Any working person now should be planning another source of income than a state pension. The government made that clear over a decade ago.

Partly. During the 80s and 90s the governments had various schemes to "top up" state pension with enhanced state pension, i.e. S2P and SERPS which were earnings related additional pensions, the idea being you got normal state pension based on years of NIC credits AND a separate state pension based on your actual earnings/NIC contributions. Successive governments faffed around with those schemes and ultimately scrapped them and now we're back to basic state pension. So, a lot of today's pensioners and those approaching pension age would in fact be quite right in thinking they were entitled to pensions based on earnings, not just "credits", as that was what successive governments told them over 2/3 decades of their working lives.

Workers could also "contract out" of the earnings related element of the state pension, and pay a little less NIC, as an incentive for them to pay into private/occupational pension schemes instead. Again, now scrapped.

I do wish successive governments would stop all this short termism, change for change's sake, etc., and just be consistent rather than introducing schemes only to change them and ultimately scrap them.

caringcarer · 20/04/2023 16:08

I wish all children in primary schools got free school meals. Sometimes, means testing is very expensive to do and so simply allowing everyone to access the benefit is simpler. EG all children get free prescriptions. It would cost so much money to try to mean test so best to allow all children to benefit regardless of if their parents are well off or not.

I think if the government changed the way state pension was paid so only those without a private pension could claim it, then many people would simply spend more of their money on themselves and stop paying into private pensions. People would opt to take more holidays etc instead.

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/04/2023 16:07

Pretty much all benefits are means tested except for state pensions.

State pension isn’t welfare though, it’s something everyone contributes to on the basis that they will receive a return on that contribution upon retirement. It’s not something you can opt out of paying either, otherwise many people would divert their NI stamp to a private pension with possibly better returns.

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 15:57

If you are planning to rely on a state pension, which is welfare, then you are planning for poverty. Pensions are benefits. They rely on additional taxpayers making contributions.

People are all very good about kicking the working poor over benefits etc but if you look at pensions, the biggest part of welfare, then they say that is different because they contribute. As discussed earlier, most people are not net contributors for tax and a pension is another example of taking more than you put in over a working lifetime for most.

Any working person now should be planning another source of income than a state pension. The government made that clear over a decade ago.

PollyPeptide · 20/04/2023 15:54

dreamingbohemian · 20/04/2023 14:22

Perhaps in the past but there is absolutely no way you can say the current NHS is better than the French and German systems, not when people are suffering and dying in such large numbers because they simply cannot access care.

It was just in the news that one in eight people are now using private healthcare in the UK, we are sleep walking into a de facto means testing where anyone who can afford to pay goes private, and everyone else has to put up with an NHS that's falling apart.

Nope. The report was 2021. They do it every couple of years. We were 4th behind Norway, Australia and another country. I can't remember which. To be fair, they didn't do all countries, they chose 11 - I don't know the criteria. But the list included France and Germany. Back in 2016, we were 2nd, so we've definitely slipped.

MintJulia · 20/04/2023 15:51

@suevineer 'It really adds to ingenerational unfairness when the state is giving large sums of money to some of the richest people in society. Of course not all pensioners are wealthy but that isn’t an argument for a universal state pension.'

The current generation of pensioners left school at 14, 15 or 16, 90% didn't go to university. They didn't have redundancy pay, unemployment benefit until the 60s, no maternity leave/pay and were too often dismissed for becoming pregnant.

You and I have had many benefits that they could only dream of. The state pension is the one thing they knew they would get. Compulsory work pensions didn't come in until 2018, so older citizens bought into the state pension because that was the agreement, and there was nothing else.

If the universal state pension is to disappear then the agreement with the public needs to change, so people can plan for old age. That is why we now have compulsory workplace pensions. The transition has started and will take a generation to achieve.

But blaming the current pensioners for taking a pension that most have worked 50 years for, is unreasonable.

Crikeyalmighty · 20/04/2023 15:49

@TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed you are absolutely right- many will have a very large shock at how little help they get with benefits once they have no under 18s

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 20/04/2023 15:45

Mumsnet is so left wing and anti-Tory until it comes to benefits isn’t it?

Try being a neurodivergent person who can’t work, but isn’t considered ill enough for PIP. The safety net in the uk exists (just about) for those with children. Once they go to university all help is withdrawn and we’re expected to magically earn enough money.

makeacupppa · 20/04/2023 15:28

There is a general principle, I find, that many things should be the case according to a lot of people, with no grasp that the process and cost of doing so outweigh the actual benefit.