Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people saying everything should be means tested

118 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 20/04/2023 13:22

It's ignorant, ill-informed and shows a lack of consideration given to the costs and complexities. Just saying "x should be means tested" as if it's a magical answer is stupid.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 20/04/2023 22:09

DdraigGoch · 20/04/2023 21:51

Isn't the state pension partially based on your contributions, to a degree?

Not to a degree, totally. It’s a minimum of 35 years NI for a full state pension. In practise most people pay a lot more - I had 46 years.

DdraigGoch · 20/04/2023 21:51

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:41

Of course welfare does include pensions which is by far the biggest spend. Yet strangely, nobody wants rid of that one!

Isn't the state pension partially based on your contributions, to a degree?

DdraigGoch · 20/04/2023 21:49

Krustykrabpizza · 20/04/2023 13:39

What benefits are universal? I don't get any that I can think of 🤔

The government's energy support over the last winter was universal.

Bus passes and winter fuel payments are universal for all over a certain age, whether they are rich or poor.

Free healthcare is universal.

Free education is universal.

The big issue with means-testing is that often it is more expensive to administer than it actually saves.

Dontevenstart · 20/04/2023 21:29

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 20/04/2023 13:33

When I look at the fact that 20% of the tax I pay is spent on welfare I think too right everything should be means tested. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary/how-public-spending-was-calculated-in-your-tax-summary

When I look at twenty percent of the tax I pay is spent on welfare I think it should be more, you odious twat.

LawksaMercyMissus · 20/04/2023 21:16

@taxguru everyone has to complete a tax return here. It's not popular but it's reasonably straightforward and there's a lot of help available.

Issania87 · 20/04/2023 20:58

I think we should means test more. Certainly we should all have to pay a means tested fee when accessing healthcare. Even a nomimal means tested fee for schooling. Anything that means we can sort out the funding of our public services and stop all this bloody striking. Although being public services they would probably give all the money to higher ups rather than getting it to front line staff.

Badbudgeter · 20/04/2023 20:28

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 13:35

Yeah I agree completely.

The issue with means testing everything is that ultimately it removes the levels of society that we’ve had for generations and whilst yes the concept of ‘everyone should have everything’ is wonderful in theory, in practice it removed the motivation to work harder and improve your own situation.

For example, and I’m just putting this out there, I have a relatively high earning DH in a professional and respected job who me and both children are financially reliant on. People perceive us to have a ‘comfortable life’ not rich just ok. Because of him we receive no benefits not even child benefit…fine no issues.

Recently I questioned whether this marriage was right for me, I checked out what financial support I would receive on my own with the kids 😂😂😂 there was pretty much no damn difference. If I left my DH I would receive so much ‘means tested’ support and UC that my life would change very little. I couldn’t actually believe it.
I find myself feeling incredibly sorry for the ‘Squeezed middle’ who in theory are working professional and difficult roles (nurses, teachers…etc) but live the same lifestyle as those working on a checkout and claiming UC.

where’s the motivation there?

I did that same calculation and got divorced tbh. I work as well so not just claiming benefits but I’m much better off now really as I have control of my own finances. I do pay more in tax and NI than I get in UC so I’m not feeling too bad about it.

MuddlingMackem · 20/04/2023 20:15

And speaking of abusive relationships, I have never agreed with Child Benefit having an income threshold.

As I understood it, it was originally called Family Allowance and was a redistribution of tax to go directly to the mother as too many were kept short by their earning husband. You can't guarantee all victims of financial abuse have spouses earning under the threshold, and presumably those abusers earning over it are not going to agree to completing a tax return so their spouse has independent access to money for the children.

MuddlingMackem · 20/04/2023 20:11

caringcarer · Today 16:13

I agree all incomes from all sources including child maintenance should be included to determine the amount of benefit received. It always seems strange to me that child maintenance is not included. There should also be a failsafe system where child maintenance is not paid for any reason then UC covers it, but absent parents are chased for payment.

That's a bit contradictory, isn't it?

Currently, there is no way of ensuring all absent parents pay for their children. Although I agree with a PP that any in employment should have it taken at source, I'm not sure how you can ensure that the dodgers (eg who go cash in hand) pay up as they should. To be honest, unless society starts shaming the (mainly) men who dodge their responsibilities it can't change.

Also, there are probably too many single parents who are single because they left an abusive relationship, and including maintenance as income in UC calculations can give an abusive ex way too much ongoing control over the resident parent.

Babyroobs · 20/04/2023 19:43

I agree. My dad has more than enough money to heat his house yet has been given over £1000 this winter in extra payments he didn't need.

Throwncrumbs · 20/04/2023 19:42

LexMitior · 20/04/2023 13:41

Of course welfare does include pensions which is by far the biggest spend. Yet strangely, nobody wants rid of that one!

Yawn!

KittyAlfred · 20/04/2023 19:42

I’d have thought that one of the problems of means testing healthcare would be that it might become like child care and working. People with health problems may find themselves in a situation where their healthcare was free if they didn’t work, but as soon as they took a job they’d have to pay for their care, so it wouldn’t be worth them working.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 19:39

LawksaMercyMissus · 20/04/2023 18:04

I live in France where everything is based on your tax return, so things like winter fuel payments go to low income households rather than pensioners.

Successive UK governments are schizophrenic about tax returns. Every so after they announce "simplifications" so fewer people have to complete them (such as the £1k interest allowance, the £2k dividend allowance, etc), and then a few years later, they reduce the allowances dragging people back into tax returns and then reduce capital gains tax allowance dragging even more people into having to complete tax returns for the first time. The politicians and mandarins need to make their bloody minds up.

The French idea sounds very sensible, having a form of consistent reporting for income and benefits. Trouble is in the UK, the tax/benefits are far too complicated (thank you politicians and mandarins), and HMRC are incapable of running a bath, let alone a complicated tax system, so it'll never happen without fundamental root and branch reform.

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 19:39

JudgeRudy · 20/04/2023 17:56

@Thehonestbadger yes you are correct you can get some help with mortgage payments (interest) but it only kicks in after months and its a loan based on equity.
https://www.gov.uk/support-for-mortgage-interest

As for single people receiving same tax 'perks' as families I think they should. I'm not sure families should be 'rewarded' for having children or being married. I've not really considered what the tax 'threshold' should be. Maybe average wage?

Ah I didn’t know that about the loan based on equity, learn something new every day. Thanks for sharing that.

As for people not being rewarded for having kids, I can understand your view point but I’d like to challenge it a little. Children are rather expensive to raise (the small financial dispensations offered to families certainly don’t cover this cost) and the having, and raising, of children as a contribution to society itself is being viewed in an increasingly negative light. At what point does the act of having children become so unattractive people simply stop?
To an extent this is already happening, more people are choosing not to have kids now than ever before and whilst the decision to not have children is entirely valid, it’s important to remember the bigger long term picture here and not fragment the situation to only view the impact upon us in the immediate future rather than the long term.

Society requires children.

We need a next generation and we need a large enough next generation to meet the needs of the generations above otherwise the entire system crumbles beneath us.

Have a look at what happened in Singapore, they made having children so unattractive people simply stopped and it resulted in the government having to fork out significant financial bribes to incentivise them to start again. I find that really interesting.

It’s also worth remembering that children are actively people in their own right. They are not the fault of, liability of, or pets owned by their parents. They have a right to be supported by the system just as everyone else is. I always find it completely mind boggling that people are happy to be paying pensions to people who have realistically had their whole lives to work, save and support themselves but are incensed at the idea of paying towards maintaining a child who is incapable of working or supporting themselves 🤷‍♀️ I find the differing views between children and old people a bit insane. The entire crux of the argument seems to be ‘well parents shouldn’t have them if they can’t afford them’ but that’s not the child’s fault is it? The child is a person Independent of the parent they are not responsible for their parents poor financial planning or bad choices. They are certainly not to blame for their own existence.

taxguru · 20/04/2023 19:35

Believeitornot · 20/04/2023 16:43

Are you factoring all taxes into that statement or just income tax?

Yes, especially for the ultra rich such as Lewis Hamilton who bought his private jet through via the Isle of Man through a trust to avoid paying VAT.

Or the pop stars, actors, sports personalities who "emigrate" so as to become non resident and avoid UK tax, who therefore buy their rolexes, designer handbags, sports cars, yachts, etc in their overseas tax havens so don't pay UK VAT on them. If they were incentivised to stay resident in the UK, they'd buy stuff in the UK and pay VAT on their luxuries!

Fudgewomble · 20/04/2023 18:56

But many many countries means test everything which means there is more money for people who need it, and people who don’t aren’t unjustly enriched. I was living in New Zealand when this concept was first introduced in the 1980s and fully implemented in the 1990s and the naysayers said it was too complicated. Yes it takes a while to implement but once it’s done it’s done. (For the record I think the current way of administering child benefit in the uk and clawing back overpayments in tax returns is bonkers. I’m not aware of any other jurisdiction that does it like this!).

LawksaMercyMissus · 20/04/2023 18:04

I live in France where everything is based on your tax return, so things like winter fuel payments go to low income households rather than pensioners.

JudgeRudy · 20/04/2023 17:56

@Thehonestbadger yes you are correct you can get some help with mortgage payments (interest) but it only kicks in after months and its a loan based on equity.
https://www.gov.uk/support-for-mortgage-interest

As for single people receiving same tax 'perks' as families I think they should. I'm not sure families should be 'rewarded' for having children or being married. I've not really considered what the tax 'threshold' should be. Maybe average wage?

Support for Mortgage Interest (SMI)

Support for Mortgage Interest (SMI) helps homeowners on certain benefits pay interest on loans or mortgages - what you'll get, eligibility and how to claim.

https://www.gov.uk/support-for-mortgage-interest

HistoryFanatic · 20/04/2023 17:56

I think £6k is quite a low limit on savings before it affects how much you receive. If you need a new (second hand) car many are a few grand in price.

Thehonestbadger · 20/04/2023 17:38

JudgeRudy · 20/04/2023 16:49

I think your housing situation makes a massive difference. Eg a young couple with 2 children who have just purchased a home (with a mortgage) most definitely would not be in the same position if they separated. Let's say mum and children stayed in the home. Any benefits she recieved would not consider the mortgage payments. Let's say they were £600pcm. If she was in rented accommodation she might recieve and extra £800 to cover the rent. Now the challenge is finding a home for £800pcm that you want to live in

Yes I will definitely concede that housing situation will make a difference.
It is however worth noting that mortgage payments aren’t discounted by UC (as far as my research went) it looked as though they would aid in the interest element but not the capital repayment.

For example; our mortgage is £780. Around £380 or which is actually just interest and UC took that into account as it does rent. Or at least that’s what my calculation suggested. I may be wrong.

I do think your comment around the ridiculousness of families earning lower wages paying tax then claiming back dispensation via UC and such, and the cost associated with running that entire pointless process is actually very on the nose. The only issue is that putting a blanket ‘no one earning under X will pay any tax’ in place wouldn’t take into account situations. So a family reliant on one £30k income with 3 kids and a single person earning £30k would both be living on the same income. Right now the single person would be paying tax whilst the family would be paying tax but receiving this back via the government.

Whilst allowing everyone to keep their earnings might seem the better idea to cut admin costs I suspect that everyone having more would actually systematically push up prices and cost of living anyway.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 20/04/2023 17:23

If it's economically viable to means test, then means testing should be done.

stayathomer · 20/04/2023 17:21

My MIL is a classic case. She looked at a single mother with several children and glibly said "I'm paying my taxes for that!". She didn't like it when I pointed out that she barely pays any tax at all. She gets state pension and a widow's pension from her husband's pension scheme, no income tax as it's all just below personal allowance. She has around £100k in savings, all in ISAs, so no income tax on the interest/dividends. She doesn't have a car, so no road tax, fuel duty, VAT on fuel/repairs etc - just uses her free bus pass and cadges lifts from us. She barely buys anything, so no VAT on most of the food she buys, no VAT on her Daily Mail, a bit of VAT on her telephone bill and 5% on her electric & gas (mostly covered by the winter fuel allowance she doesn't need), OK, VAT on clothes/shoes etc buy she hardly ever buys anything. It's not as if she "paid in" - she hadn't worked since having my OH in her 20's - just a SAHM relying on her hubbies wage and accumulating credits for state benefits using the "home responsibilities" protection for 16 years! She can still save a few hundred per month after costs which goes into her tax-free ISA. Yet, she's first to whinge when there's any suggestion of OAPs paying for prescriptions, means testing bus passes, etc., even though she can easily afford them, and that's someone on a very low income! She also burst a blood vessel when they took away her free TV licence (which she can afford to pay for!). Despite paying virtually nothing in tax, she still thinks she's personally paying for half the benefit claimants in our town!
Well lovely that you told her how little she contributes to society… sigh …

JudgeRudy · 20/04/2023 17:06

This might be a very simplistic way of looking at things and I'm sure someone who is more eco savvy will come along and challenge this but if the tax threshold was considerably higher but UB like child benefit were cancelled, in a way your wages would be your UB.
So let's say we didn't pay tax till over £20k then we wouldn't have this ridiculous affair where families on say £25/30k are needing to claim UC or Tax Credits to get by, but being taxed also. What is the 'admin' cost of collecting the tax then giving it back out?
Clearly there will always be those that cannot work. I don't begrudge them benefits, means tested or otherwise.
I think the government has an obligation to reduce this bill so if mum and 2 under 4s are on UC and dad is working I think the state should take child maintenance at source and it should come off the UC. Any addition support should be on top.

I think a lot of people in the 'squeezed middle' feel their quality of life is no better than someone else in a less stressful job, or with only one working parent, but they overlook the fact that they own their own home. Yes, there are some families in some very nice spacious Council Homes. More are in shitty flats or houses. Just over half the rented homes are private. So they really are in the minority. Owning your home is now becoming a luxury again but if you do you are generally fortunate. I don't mean you didn't work hard or go without, I mean you were fortunate to stick with a partner, be educated or well paid, or buy at the right time. I don't think benefits should be used to pay for home ownership no more than you should be offered extra money because you have a loan for a car or school fees.

Daisiesandprimroses · 20/04/2023 17:03

What is it you’re taking issue with op specifallh, what benefit is means tested but you feel shouldn’t be?

im a higher earner and I support means testing,I believe below certain thresholds the government should step in to support. Above folks need to pay for what they need and manage their finances accordingly

Blossomtoes · 20/04/2023 17:02

She can still save a few hundred per month after costs which goes into her tax-free ISA.

I don’t see how if her income is below the income tax threshold. How can you save “a few hundred” from an income of less than £1k a month?