Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband's brother not invited his step-child

409 replies

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:23

I got married 4 years ago and my husband became my child's stepfather. My child is 13, and doesn't see their father. My husband has nieces and nephews either side of this age.

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

His brother is getting married in a late afternoon early evening wedding in a world famous hotel. They are having 60 people there. Apparently this has been planned for the last two years but we only found out about this a month ago just days before the invitations went out. He told my husband after a night out (he had told their sister that afternoon).

The invitation stated just our names with no mention of my child.

I got it, it's a world class venue and a reasonably small wedding. I totally get child free weddings especially given the time of it. I found out yesterday that husband's sister's kids are invited. Mine clearly hasn't because they are a step-child. I feel quite heartbroken.

My husband asked yesterday if my child could be extended an invitation but was refused. A kicker came a minute later when brother was asked if there was a drop out could they come and brother said if there were drop outs relatively new work colleagues would be invited.

No idea if this is relevant but I want to put my cards on the table so any advice I get will be informed by the facts. My first wedding was massive and as my dad later told my cousin it cost a grand for every month it lasted. My wedding to my husband was in a registry office with just our parents so the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours.

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 28/04/2023 18:00

I get that argument but to me, family children are different to those of friends. If it was my wedding, and I knew my brother viewed his step child as his own and I was inviting my nieces, I'd invite my brother's step child. Particularly if my brother was close enough to me emotionally to be part of my official wedding party. I'd want my brother to feel comfortable.
Totally different if it's a child free wedding or even if a step child is non resident and not viewed as the child of the step parent. There's no hard and fast rule. I just can't imagine, having had a conversation with my brother and hearing how he feels about this child, saying 'nah, don't care, gonna invite a work colleague instead'.

aSofaNearYou · 28/04/2023 17:42

ImAvingOops · 28/04/2023 07:56

There's a difference between being right on a technicality (which bil is, since it's his wedding, he doesn't view the child as family) and being right morally (for want of a better word). A sensible person would consider that they love their brother and their brother loves the child (and considers the child to be his own). Therefore you invite the child in order to make your brother feel happy and welcome.
While to you (the groom) the child isn't your family, you accept that he is to your brother and for the sake of one place, you don't stomp all over your brother's feelings and commitment to that child.

Hmmm I don't think this is really an accurate summation unless you are inviting children generally. Everyone has a commitment to their own child, but if you're not inviting the children of all of your guests then surely with the ones you DO invite, it's because of your relationship with them, not their parents relationship with them?

Acornsoup · 28/04/2023 16:44

DangerNoodles · 27/04/2023 14:35

OP's child is not adopted, her husband is only the child's stepfather. If OP and her DH split there is every chance that the family would never see OP's child again. SIL is right to be upset, OP's child isn't really on equal terms with her children.

Children not being invited to a wedding is not the same as a manager discriminating against staff and it's offensive to compare the two. For a start there is the Equality Act that means the manager can't discriminate. There are no laws in place governing wedding invites.

Only a SD - like it's nothing Confused

billy1966 · 28/04/2023 09:32

ImAvingOops · 28/04/2023 07:56

There's a difference between being right on a technicality (which bil is, since it's his wedding, he doesn't view the child as family) and being right morally (for want of a better word). A sensible person would consider that they love their brother and their brother loves the child (and considers the child to be his own). Therefore you invite the child in order to make your brother feel happy and welcome.
While to you (the groom) the child isn't your family, you accept that he is to your brother and for the sake of one place, you don't stomp all over your brother's feelings and commitment to that child.

Absolutely this.

And if I was the MIL, I would be so upset about this.

All this angst and unpleasantness over one child going to a wedding.

The likely only fathering experience her son will have and yet his brother feels it necessary to be so exclusionary.

As for his sister, yes of course her children will be extra special to his mother, but did it really have to be rubbed in his face.

I think there is real unkindness and ugliness at the heart of this, and if it was happening among my children I would be devastated.

ImAvingOops · 28/04/2023 07:56

There's a difference between being right on a technicality (which bil is, since it's his wedding, he doesn't view the child as family) and being right morally (for want of a better word). A sensible person would consider that they love their brother and their brother loves the child (and considers the child to be his own). Therefore you invite the child in order to make your brother feel happy and welcome.
While to you (the groom) the child isn't your family, you accept that he is to your brother and for the sake of one place, you don't stomp all over your brother's feelings and commitment to that child.

Nanny0gg · 27/04/2023 19:43

As there is so much divorce/separation/remarriage/new partnerships these days we are going to have many, many children who won't be included in their step-parents wider families.

I find that very sad.

billy1966 · 27/04/2023 19:28

MelchiorsMistress · 27/04/2023 18:21

I feel sorry for the MiL in this story. She must feel very sad that she won’t see all of her children together at one of their weddings because of a partner and unrelated child.

I feel sorry for the MIL too, that one of her son's would feel it necessary to be so needlessly nasty towards the step child of his brother, whom he asked to be his best man.

Really inexplicable.

i would be appalled at the Grooms ascertain that he exacerbate the upset by saying he would ask new colleagues than the child in question.

Why?

billy1966 · 27/04/2023 18:55

What I wonder is where BIL imagines the relationship with his brother will go after this.

The BIL feels so strongly about NOT having his brother's step child there, that he has stated he would ask new colleagues that he doesn't really know, rather than extend a last minute invite to.

Unbelievable.

I cannot fathom such a nasty spiteful response.

It does make one realise the different lives we all lead on MN and how needlessly awful some families are to each other.

Iwasafool · 27/04/2023 18:50

MelchiorsMistress · 27/04/2023 18:21

I feel sorry for the MiL in this story. She must feel very sad that she won’t see all of her children together at one of their weddings because of a partner and unrelated child.

No this is on her son not her DIL and her child.

Iwasafool · 27/04/2023 18:44

Peapodburgundybouquet · 27/04/2023 15:08

It’s just not the same, which might be the ugly truth of blending families. But it’s a situation that’s bound to arise. And an expensive wedding with limited numbers is an example of that when it might happen. And especially when, as the OP herself has said, they don’t have a relationship.

What's not the same? OP came into the family 4 years ago, her child came into the family 4 years ago. That sounds the same to me.

Gothambutnotahamster · 27/04/2023 18:40

melj1213 · 27/04/2023 12:48

At the weekend my husband withdrew from the wedding when BiL was given a chance to rectify things and he said he couldn't but also wasn't inclined to as he felt no relationship with my child as nice as they were, he acknowledged.

So this child is a virtual stranger as a lot of us surmised and therefore YABU to expect an invite for him to an expensive event involving people has has no actual relationship with.

The BIL is not unreasonable to not prioritise inviting a child he doesn't know to his wedding and he is NBU to want to invite his nieces/nephews he has known since birth and presumably has a close relationship with.

This!

I'm sorry Op but I think you're both out of order. Your DHs relationship with his brother (& potentially wider family) is now ruined (or at least tarnished) and whilst it would have been nice for your DC to be invited, your BIL wasn't in the wrong. Such a sad situation and one I think your DH will ultimately regret.

ScribblingPixie · 27/04/2023 18:28

I feel sorry for the MiL in this story. She must feel very sad that she won’t see all of her children together at one of their weddings because of a partner and unrelated child.

FFS, she won't see both her sons at the wedding because one of them has hurt the other's feelings very badly.

MelchiorsMistress · 27/04/2023 18:21

I feel sorry for the MiL in this story. She must feel very sad that she won’t see all of her children together at one of their weddings because of a partner and unrelated child.

ITryHarder · 27/04/2023 18:12

It's amazing how many people don't even seem to have read what OP said. She and her dc have been in the family for 4 years, live in the same city and have reached out with invitations. Her and husbands' wedding has no bearing on anything because they didn't have a traditional wedding with guests, and husband's siblings never minded. If that were the case, then OP and husband wouldn't have been invited. The child is the one specifically being targeted.

Many are correct that people have a right to invite anyone they want to an event. They have a right to dump on anyone, even a brother. They have a right to hurt the feelings of a child and the child's mother. But what does that say about them, and worse, that they don't seem to care.

The mistake OP made was calling this 'a world-class wedding'. There is no class at all in this wedding. Otherwise, the right thing would have been done - brother's sc would have been included since other family children are.

OP, is there something you haven't told us about dc? If not, the only thing world-class are the two cold-hearted asses getting married.

Vivalaive · 27/04/2023 18:02

It’s an invitation not a summons. You don’t have to go, don’t be afraid to put bils back up. He obviously hasn’t cared about doing that to you!

OhmygodDont · 27/04/2023 17:55

A step nephew or just nephew isn’t really immediate family. Not if you don’t actually have a relationship with them.

It’s like the strange cousin you don’t know but your mum forces you to invite. You don’t know them but “family”. You know a cousin being your “immediate” families child.

My immediate family certainly isn’t my nephews. It would be my husband and my children. At a push my parents.

A wedding is a union of the two people. Not the whole extended family.

BeepBoopBop · 27/04/2023 17:40

.. and he is not likely to ever have one at this rate, is he.

For all those saying, "he doesn't know his step-nephew, he has no relationship, blah blah blah" his step-nephew is now part of his immediate family and his rather short sighted and selfish actions will now cause a wedge between the family for years to come. If he would prioritise his newish work colleagues over his family, then that is down to him and his rather thoughtless wife-to-be.

I am so glad for you OP that your husband has your and your son's back. As it should be and you have his parents support here too. Save the wedding outfit and present money and book an amazing weekend away for the date involved so you have something lovely to look forward to. And if they then change their minds, look them in the eye and tell them your family break has priority over their fake wedding - the whole purpose of which is supposed to be the union of two people and their families.

Wheresthebeach · 27/04/2023 17:07

I'm sorry to read that instead of stupid and thoughtless it turns out they are just awful. The DC is resident, and therefore, presumably goes to all family events normally. Nobody ever invites some children, but not others, based on how close they feel to them. Can you imagine?? 'Well your DS is invited, but frankly I don't click with your DD so she's not'. Its not about how they feel, its about treating all the family the same so that you don't ruin relationships and can rub along okay over the coming years. Your poor DH must be gutted.

TonTonMacoute · 27/04/2023 17:04

I think it’s very odd, and quite petty, to invite OP and her DH and exclude the DC.

They are perfectly entitled to invite whoever the hell they want to, but this makes them look selfish and rather spiteful. OP and DH have behaved with dignity. Now they know where they stand with his family.

pinkorchidsoooh · 27/04/2023 16:25

I'm curious about the comparisons people are drawing between your wedding invites and BiL wedding invites. It's not the same.

A comparable situation would be if you'd invited just SiL to your wedding because you see her more and not invited BIL. You didn't invite anyone.

Or if BIL had not invited any children to his wedding including your child rather than just some nieces and nephews.

I'm also interested with SiLs children how old they are and how much time they spend with BiL? Are they really close? It would still feel unfair but if he's known them for a decade and spends comparably way more time with them then I can see some reasoning.

Fundamentally I think in a case like this where your DH considers your son to be his son in effect and he is the father figure-you can't invite some children in the family and not others and not expect fall out. Does it not matter to BiL that his brother and best man considers this child his son? It's a very rigid way of looking at things from your BiL pov.

burnoutbabe · 27/04/2023 16:09

its a bit different if this was a non resident child, who they never mix with.

But a resident child, one assumes goes to family events normally, as much as the OP's husband does? (ie easter and xmas). therefore is "part of the family" rather than a virtual stranger.

i mean i probably see my nephew once a year due to distance but still he is part of the family.

Wenfy · 27/04/2023 15:51

JaynesSmalls · 27/04/2023 12:34

Just wanted to give an update and clear up a few things.

My child is a perfectly well behaved young person.

We actually live in the same city, not 300 miles away as some people seem to think.

The wedding has been booked for two years but nobody, not just us knew. We found out when the rest of the family did.

I used the word 'involved' when talking about my husband's parents, I didn't mean my husband wanted them to advocate on my child's behalf but just to inform them what was happening, in the end my BiL told them.

Anyway we are not going.

At the weekend my husband withdrew from the wedding when BiL was given a chance to rectify things and he said he couldn't but also wasn't inclined to as he felt no relationship with my child as nice as they were, he acknowledged.

Both his parents and his sister said that BiL should have invited my child. On Monday evening his sister asked if my husband would meet her. When he arrived his mother was there as well. They both reiterated that my child should have been invited but sister was annoyed that they whole drama was prompted by my finding out that her children were invited. She said that we were completely out of order to suggest that my child, again as lovely as they are, they acknowledged, was somehow equal to her children in the family.

His father then begged him to come for unity's sake. He said that BiL should have invited my child but it was not their place to compensate them for their absent family.

So there we are!!!

This works both ways you know.

They don’t consider themselves your DS’ family so you and your DS don’t need to return the favour. So don’t do any ‘wife work’ to arrange anything nice for them - don’t give so much as a birthday card or a Christmas present. No need to see DH’s side of the family during holidays - they can focus around their ‘family’.

People like this make me so angry because they clearly can’t see that their other son, by drawing a line between a step gc and blood gcs, will probably begin to draw the line between his parents and his partner’s parents when gc come along. Idiots the lot of them.

frazzledasarock · 27/04/2023 15:46

No you don’t reject or treat a child of the family as less than the rest of the children.

I would not expect inheritance or child maintenance or anything. But inclusion in family events absolutely.

reading such awful posts and peoples blasé responses and agreement makes me realise how very lucky I am to have loving inlaws.

frazzledasarock · 27/04/2023 15:43

god these are nasty nasty people.

it’s the cost of one child’s meal. BIL could have easily agreed to give your child first refusal for any last minute cancellations.

the entire family could keep to themselves that they don’t count your child, your husbands step child as family.

I have children from a previous marriage and my husband and I have children together.

if my IL’s chose to blatantly discriminate against my older children, they’d have no kind of relationship with any of us. Because I’m the one who organises meet ups and invites them over. Left to DH there’s be no relationship whatsoever.

my older DC would absolutely maintain a relationship with my DH if we split up, they’d maintain a relationship with all my IL’s. Because they’re treated with love by all of them.

how horrific for a young child to be rejected by people she probably thinks of as her family.

I hope BIL trips and falls headfirst into the wedding cake.

whumpthereitis · 27/04/2023 15:38

ScribblingPixie · 27/04/2023 15:26

It’s just not the same, which might be the ugly truth of blending families.

Then it's an ugly truth people should have the sense and decency to conceal. Telling your brother - your best man! - that his stepchild comes below new work colleagues on your reserve list of potential invitees is inevitably going to damage that relationship.

It’s a common belief, and concealing it won’t change that fact.

When it comes to blended families it is indeed a reality that may occur, whether it’s liked or not. It’s arguably better to be pragmatic about it and consider the situation as it is, rather than what you would like it to be.