Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband's brother not invited his step-child

409 replies

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:23

I got married 4 years ago and my husband became my child's stepfather. My child is 13, and doesn't see their father. My husband has nieces and nephews either side of this age.

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

His brother is getting married in a late afternoon early evening wedding in a world famous hotel. They are having 60 people there. Apparently this has been planned for the last two years but we only found out about this a month ago just days before the invitations went out. He told my husband after a night out (he had told their sister that afternoon).

The invitation stated just our names with no mention of my child.

I got it, it's a world class venue and a reasonably small wedding. I totally get child free weddings especially given the time of it. I found out yesterday that husband's sister's kids are invited. Mine clearly hasn't because they are a step-child. I feel quite heartbroken.

My husband asked yesterday if my child could be extended an invitation but was refused. A kicker came a minute later when brother was asked if there was a drop out could they come and brother said if there were drop outs relatively new work colleagues would be invited.

No idea if this is relevant but I want to put my cards on the table so any advice I get will be informed by the facts. My first wedding was massive and as my dad later told my cousin it cost a grand for every month it lasted. My wedding to my husband was in a registry office with just our parents so the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours.

OP posts:
Elfandwellbeing · 05/06/2023 18:58

Sounds like BIL is making his feelings known and frankly they are unkind. He could have extended one seat to keep family unity strong and chose not to. Has your dh explained that whilst his brother has no relationship to your child, that he in fact does and that step parenting is as close as parenting will get for him? What if he adopted him, would he still feel the same ! Sad fact is it is BIL loss.

Greenqueen40 · 05/06/2023 18:56

MyTruthIsOut · 05/06/2023 18:01

A very god friend of my husband (they’d been good friends for well over 10 years) was getting married and it was a child-free wedding.

Our first baby (breast fed)was 2 months old when we got the invite and he would be 4 months old on the day of the wedding. I was told that I could only come if I left my baby at home which obviously just wasn’t feasible.

My husband spoke to his friend about it, who was fine about me still coming as our son was obviously just going to be in my arms, but his fiancée got the final say and I wasn’t allowed to attend.

My husband then declined the invite and said he wouldn’t be going either.

It massively soured their friendship. It’s never recovered and that was over 9 years ago.

This behaviour is awful OP and your DH should stand united with you.

I genuinely don't understand why couples cannot do things solo. If his fiancé did not want children there - respect it!! Its her bloody wedding. Let your husband go alone and stay at home with the baby, no need for drama and offence at every turn.

Gothambutnotahamster · 05/06/2023 18:48

I'm in the minority on this thread Op, but I think your BIL was right to do what he did, given how he felt, so I wouldn't doubt that people who attended were supportive of him.

ITryHarder · 05/06/2023 18:36

Throwncrumbs · 05/06/2023 17:30

But you didn’t invite him to yours, what do you expect, you can’t have it both ways or all your way. I understand it is disappointing but maybe he was disappointed to not be invited to his brothers!

I am amazed that the subject of OP and dh's wedding has come up yet again. It's been clarified a couple of times that BIL and SIL have no ill feelings about that. And if that were some dark, hidden, unspoken grudge harbored by BIL, then tit-for-tat would have been to not invite his own brother and SIL, not take it out on a child.

Americano75 · 05/06/2023 18:09

Your DH sounds like mine, the only decent one out of a bad lot.

MyTruthIsOut · 05/06/2023 18:01

A very god friend of my husband (they’d been good friends for well over 10 years) was getting married and it was a child-free wedding.

Our first baby (breast fed)was 2 months old when we got the invite and he would be 4 months old on the day of the wedding. I was told that I could only come if I left my baby at home which obviously just wasn’t feasible.

My husband spoke to his friend about it, who was fine about me still coming as our son was obviously just going to be in my arms, but his fiancée got the final say and I wasn’t allowed to attend.

My husband then declined the invite and said he wouldn’t be going either.

It massively soured their friendship. It’s never recovered and that was over 9 years ago.

This behaviour is awful OP and your DH should stand united with you.

Throwncrumbs · 05/06/2023 17:30

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:43

My husband is absolutely devastated by it, he is the best man (along with a friend). I 100% don't want to go but I 100% want him to go as it would wreck his relationship with his brother.

My child would 100% want to go to this wedding. They would want to go to any wedding especially this one as it is family and the venue is out of this world.

We very simply accepted the invitation without question, it never occurred to us to question the invitation, we thought given the venue and time that it was over 18s only.

I know that I and my child who will remain an only child, and for 'political' reasons won't have a relationship with their father's nieces are disappointed that my husband's nieces and nephews haven't really embraced them in spite of trying on our side with invitations etc. These are the children of his sister. The couple getting married have no children.

I have never heard my child comment on DH's brother or express an opinion on him. All of them are polite when we see them.

Husband wants us to go round and express how disappointed we are. But who am I to talk when we didn't invite them to ours?

Husband wants also to involve his parents but I have said no. I can't focus on work and think I am going home.

But you didn’t invite him to yours, what do you expect, you can’t have it both ways or all your way. I understand it is disappointing but maybe he was disappointed to not be invited to his brothers!

aSofaNearYou · 05/06/2023 17:19

It’s entirely possible that popular consensus was/is that OP’s DH was unreasonable in declining to go. That that this isn’t what some posters would like to believe doesn’t change that.

Yes, I agree. There was no need to slag him off but I would have thought he was daft not to come.

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/06/2023 17:16

I think it's also possible to agree with both sides up to a point.

I don't think it was unreasonable for the BIL not to invite the DSS to begin with - they are not close, the DSS was 9 at the time of the marriage, not a very young child. I think it's unusual to consider a step child of 9+ your own, I see that as more of a when you have got together with the parent when the child was under 5 sort of thing.

But I think once the DH had made clear he was upset, the BIL should have invited the DSS with good grace for the sake of family harmony.

And then I think it is over the top for the DH to refuse to go to his brother's wedding over it, it doesn't seem such a horrible thing that it merits this drastic a response.

And this may be unfair but the OP's "heartbreak" and leaving work early because of being upset sort of automatically puts me a little on the in laws side.

So on balance, I sort of agree and disagree with everyone!

whumpthereitis · 05/06/2023 16:48

JenniferBarkley · 05/06/2023 16:45

I guarantee you plenty of people listening thought your husband was in the right, but weren't brave enough (or rude enough, in fairness) to say it.

You really can’t guarantee that.

It’s entirely possible that popular consensus was/is that OP’s DH was unreasonable in declining to go. That that this isn’t what some posters would like to believe doesn’t change that.

JenniferBarkley · 05/06/2023 16:45

I guarantee you plenty of people listening thought your husband was in the right, but weren't brave enough (or rude enough, in fairness) to say it.

billy1966 · 05/06/2023 16:22

Correction.

Do not allow your FIL make your husband feel guilty about the Grooms horrible behaviour.

Sounds like the Groom is more like his father.

pikkumyy77 · 05/06/2023 16:20

Really shameful behavior by DH’s whole family. BIL’s clever speech is a sign of how embarrassed he was that his own brother wasn’t at the wedding.

billy1966 · 05/06/2023 16:18

My goodness OP, what twats your BIL/SIL are.

All over inviting one little boy. Unbelievable.

As for everyone agreeing with them?

Really?

I find that very hard to believe.

I think most people would be absolutely shocked that a couple would be so insistent on the grooms brothers step child not be there.

Inexplicable that they should cause their parents such upset.

You were not unreasonable to expect your family to be treated with respect.

I think this couple are not good people and if my child was to behave in such a manner I would be appalled, and would let them know their actions were spoiling what should be a joyous occasion.

I would be MORTIFIED to have raised someone so petty and unkind.

How any parent would be happy or proud of your BIL and his behaviour is beyond me.

As for bringing it up in the speeches?

Vulgar, crass, tacky and utterly cringeworthy are what I imagine any guest with an iota of self awareness would think.

Don't allow your husband to make you feel guilty about HIS brothers choices.

You are some woman if you are prepared to carry on as normal with them.

GabriellaMontez · 05/06/2023 16:14

This
Talk about airing dirty laundry!!!

He gave the reason in the wedding speech?!

He made a dick of himself.

Of course no guest shouted that out. But many people will have thought, it's a pretty crazy hill to die on.

ITryHarder · 05/06/2023 16:06

The brother talked about it at the wedding!!! Talk about airing dirty laundry!!! Now I absolutely know who the ass is.

And all those people who agree with his not inviting the child - they are wrong!! The brother created a wedge of a lifetime and compounded it by bringing it up to the masses. All so he could invite one more co-worker he barely knows over a family member. Your husband may have sacrificed his brother's wedding in favor of a child and it's mother he cares for, but the brother sacrificed his brother all in the name of a silly wedding guest list.

Your FILs comment about you wanting them to make up for the deficits of the child's biological family is just sad. Some people would go above and beyond to do that for a child, even a strangers

OhmygodDont · 05/06/2023 15:57

So his speech mentioned it.

“my dear brother, my best man, it’s a shame he wouldn’t join us today because I didn’t have space to invite his wifes child” “let’s toast to those we love who are not here”

kinda thing. I mean I like his balls tbh 😂

AliceOlive · 05/06/2023 15:52

Papernotplastic · 05/06/2023 15:24

The OP’s DH was supposed to be the best man so I think it’s understandable that he was mentioned in the speeches.

Mentioning him is of course ok. The OP wrote that he went beyond that.

"My brother-in-law mentioned this in his speech and gave the reason my husband wasn’t there."

I'll be he didn't say "My Brother didn't come because I refused to invite a child that he considers his own."

Papernotplastic · 05/06/2023 15:24

The OP’s DH was supposed to be the best man so I think it’s understandable that he was mentioned in the speeches.

AliceOlive · 05/06/2023 15:07

It seems really crass to mention this a wedding toast. I doubt he had as much true support as you are being told. Respectable people don't criticize anyone at their own wedding.

In fact, I was at a wedding once of long-time family friends. The aunt of the groom started making critical remarks about the bride and groom's choices to my mother. I have never looked at her the same way since.

Iwasafool · 05/06/2023 14:07

I don't suppose people were likely to say they were wrong at their wedding, taken the place of someone they were close to when he was prepared to invite a random from work?

I'm sorry for what they did, you deserved better and so did your child but your husband very definitely did.

I bet his cousin thinks your BIL is a fool. I hope you did something nice instead of the wedding.

JaynesSmalls · 05/06/2023 13:29

Just to clarify again my husband and his siblings are actually close and I don’t believe there is any hidden drama and I also don’t believe that this will make any difference to their relationship going forward.

As for our wedding my husband has asked his sister about her thoughts on our wedding. She said something along the lines of each to their own and she wished we’d had a big wedding as she liked weddings but there is no resentment.

We were told about the wedding at exactly the same time as everybody else; they just didn’t want conversation about the wedding to dominate for two years.

An update for those who are interested.

Father-in-Law was begging DH to go and he remains very disappointed. He felt that he would not exclude my child from a family event but totally understood why BiL did. He does feel however, that I want them to make up for the deficits of my child’s biological family. I most definitely do not but want them to be respectful of our family unit.

What I hadn’t realised until last weekend was that my brother-in-law had not been present at Sister-in-Law’s wedding as he had been travelling. So with DH not being at this wedding my in-laws have never had all three siblings at their children’s weddings.

My brother-in-law mentioned this in his speech and gave the reason my husband wasn’t there. My husband’s health was toasted along with all “absent friends” (Father-in-Law’s brother-in-law died the week before at the wedding). Apparently he brought the house down with his wit, something I can well imagine.

The bride and groom had been honest and open about my husband’s absence which according to my sister-in-law gave rise to lots of conversations that supported Brother-in-Law’s choices, apparently the guests felt that my DH had been unreasonable not to go because his step-child would have taken the place of someone they were close to.

This seems to be supported by DH’s cousin who had been looking forward to seeing him at the wedding. He texted asking him to catch up and said he was sorry that he felt unable to go to the wedding.

So that is the update.

OP posts:
EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 05/05/2023 08:53

the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours.

Well, there you go.

Have you or your DH ever reflected on how his brother might have felt about this?

ITryHarder · 30/04/2023 00:19

melj1213 · 29/04/2023 22:49

But the only reason the child's feelings are hurt is because their parents have made a massive fuss over them not being invited!

The child has "no opinion" on the BIL, has a nonexistent relationship and isn't close in any way shape or form to his "Uncle" so why would they be bothered by a lack of invite?

There is clearly a lot going on that the OP hasn't said, but it seems her DH isn't actually that close to his siblings - he didn't even consider inviting them to his own wedding; I couldn't ever imagine getting married without all my siblings being invited as a minimum - and yet is surprised when his brother had decided to prioritise people he has a relationship with (his nieces/nephews he has known since birth and seemingly has a close relationship to; and people he works with) over someone he barely knows (OPs son, whom he has known for a few years and doesn't have anything close to an "uncle" relationship with) for an invite for an expensive event he is funding to celebrate his relationship.

I have aunts and uncles on my dad's side of the family that I have a perfectly cordial but distant relationship with - we can go out for meals and make polite discussion, spend time together at wider family events etc - but if they were getting married and didn't invite me then I wouldn't be all that bothered. My dad is the youngest of his siblings so when I was born all my aunt's and uncles were all mid-30s at the youngest and they all live away from our hometown so I didn't see them all that often, and kids were definitely to be seen and not heard - they'd ask about school and what we were doing as extra curricular activities then we'd be sent outside/to another room to play so the adults could talk.

On the other hand I am extremely close to some of my maternal aunts and uncles as when I was born two of my uncles were still teenagers so we have a more "cool older sibling" type relationship - there is the same age difference between my mum/uncles and me/uncles. I grew up going on family outings with them, them babysitting me (and then me babysitting their kids when I got to my teens) and taking me out for the day and just being the "fun" uncles that took us to the park, let us go down the slide our mum said was too dangerous; fed us chips, chocolate and fizzy drinks before taking us home before the sugar crash kicked in ... If one of those uncles had got married without inviting me as a child (and both uncles got married when I was 10-12 as I was bridesmaid for both) then I would be devastated because we had such a close relationship.

Oh Lord, here we go again! You don't even know if the child knows his parents have made a fuss, if that's what you call it. And the child may have no opinion on BIL because no one has ever reached out to it or accepted an invitation. And he never said anything negative about BIL either, as far as we know. We don't know how close dh and his brother are, but we do know they're close enough for the groom to ask his brother to be best man and OP to be invited. And why in the hell do people keep bringing up OP and dh's wedding when they wisely didn't have a traditional family event and from everything OP said, the siblings have no ill feelings. Makes me wonder how many of you would dump on a sibling because, boo hoo, you weren't at it's wedding.

Your circumstances may have made sense with your family dynamic, but it is very different from this situation. For 4 years, she has tried to form a relationship for her DC, but for some reason DC is rejected. Come on OP - tell us what you're leaving out! Is it religion, is it racism, is it fear of something? Is it a deformity or illness? Even the BIL said he's a nice kid, so what's wrong.

Whatever, my heart goes out to the child, and you may have married into a family of asses, and are being advised by many more. You and DH go have a good day with DC and put it behind you. The saddest thing about all of this is the wedge that's now in this family over something so easily remedied, and BIL and SIL defend their actions to the end at the expense of a child and a sibling relationship. What a world!

melj1213 · 29/04/2023 22:49

ITryHarder · 29/04/2023 21:07

Absolutely agree. Very mean spirited to choose to hurt the feelings of a child, under any circumstances.

But the only reason the child's feelings are hurt is because their parents have made a massive fuss over them not being invited!

The child has "no opinion" on the BIL, has a nonexistent relationship and isn't close in any way shape or form to his "Uncle" so why would they be bothered by a lack of invite?

There is clearly a lot going on that the OP hasn't said, but it seems her DH isn't actually that close to his siblings - he didn't even consider inviting them to his own wedding; I couldn't ever imagine getting married without all my siblings being invited as a minimum - and yet is surprised when his brother had decided to prioritise people he has a relationship with (his nieces/nephews he has known since birth and seemingly has a close relationship to; and people he works with) over someone he barely knows (OPs son, whom he has known for a few years and doesn't have anything close to an "uncle" relationship with) for an invite for an expensive event he is funding to celebrate his relationship.

I have aunts and uncles on my dad's side of the family that I have a perfectly cordial but distant relationship with - we can go out for meals and make polite discussion, spend time together at wider family events etc - but if they were getting married and didn't invite me then I wouldn't be all that bothered. My dad is the youngest of his siblings so when I was born all my aunt's and uncles were all mid-30s at the youngest and they all live away from our hometown so I didn't see them all that often, and kids were definitely to be seen and not heard - they'd ask about school and what we were doing as extra curricular activities then we'd be sent outside/to another room to play so the adults could talk.

On the other hand I am extremely close to some of my maternal aunts and uncles as when I was born two of my uncles were still teenagers so we have a more "cool older sibling" type relationship - there is the same age difference between my mum/uncles and me/uncles. I grew up going on family outings with them, them babysitting me (and then me babysitting their kids when I got to my teens) and taking me out for the day and just being the "fun" uncles that took us to the park, let us go down the slide our mum said was too dangerous; fed us chips, chocolate and fizzy drinks before taking us home before the sugar crash kicked in ... If one of those uncles had got married without inviting me as a child (and both uncles got married when I was 10-12 as I was bridesmaid for both) then I would be devastated because we had such a close relationship.