Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband's brother not invited his step-child

409 replies

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:23

I got married 4 years ago and my husband became my child's stepfather. My child is 13, and doesn't see their father. My husband has nieces and nephews either side of this age.

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

His brother is getting married in a late afternoon early evening wedding in a world famous hotel. They are having 60 people there. Apparently this has been planned for the last two years but we only found out about this a month ago just days before the invitations went out. He told my husband after a night out (he had told their sister that afternoon).

The invitation stated just our names with no mention of my child.

I got it, it's a world class venue and a reasonably small wedding. I totally get child free weddings especially given the time of it. I found out yesterday that husband's sister's kids are invited. Mine clearly hasn't because they are a step-child. I feel quite heartbroken.

My husband asked yesterday if my child could be extended an invitation but was refused. A kicker came a minute later when brother was asked if there was a drop out could they come and brother said if there were drop outs relatively new work colleagues would be invited.

No idea if this is relevant but I want to put my cards on the table so any advice I get will be informed by the facts. My first wedding was massive and as my dad later told my cousin it cost a grand for every month it lasted. My wedding to my husband was in a registry office with just our parents so the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours.

OP posts:
Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 15:51

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:48

It isn't about "a" child, it is about a family and he is judging his brother's family to be less than his sister's family. Would you think it was OK if the OP and her husband had adopted a baby, would they be excluded as well? Families come in all shapes and sizes and this family has a mum, a (step) dad and a child. If they are going to an event where families are invited then this is their family and not for some judgemental idiot to decide if it qualifies as a family.

I just don’t see it that way. I am not part of a blended family, however. Maybe that has a bearing on some responses on here.

And adoption is not the same. Parents are on an even footing with adoption.

I fully support the OP’s decision not to go, that’s absolutely her choice. But I don’t think the situation is as black and white as some posts would suggest.

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:48

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 15:42

Again, he may not have a relationship with this child, whereas he does with the others.

I’m not actively defending excluding parts of a family, but it is notable that the brother didn’t invite his siblings to his wedding (why?), when he could have done easily, the guest list is very small, the venue is very expensive, and the closeness between the stepchild and the stepuncle is unknown.

I wouldn’t want to pay a vast sum to host a child I didn’t know, when that place could be taken by an appreciate adult friend who I could celebrate with.

It isn't about "a" child, it is about a family and he is judging his brother's family to be less than his sister's family. Would you think it was OK if the OP and her husband had adopted a baby, would they be excluded as well? Families come in all shapes and sizes and this family has a mum, a (step) dad and a child. If they are going to an event where families are invited then this is their family and not for some judgemental idiot to decide if it qualifies as a family.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 20/04/2023 15:47

I would be upset too op. If other children have been invited then it says that your bil hasn't accepted yours. I think your bil is punishing you both for not being invited to your wedding, and think that this will be the retort if your dh pushed. You don't have to go, let one of the new colleagues your bil cares so much about trying to impress go instead.

dimpleton · 20/04/2023 15:44

He sees your child as “brother’s new wife’s child”. And on that basis, I don’t think it’s entirely unreasonable when you’re talking about a very small wedding (although it would have been nice if he could have been more inclusive about it).

They've been married for 4 years though, and presumably were together a while before that? Hardly a new wife.

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 15:42

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:37

It is disrespectful to his brother. His sister's family get invited but his brother's family doesn't.

Again, he may not have a relationship with this child, whereas he does with the others.

I’m not actively defending excluding parts of a family, but it is notable that the brother didn’t invite his siblings to his wedding (why?), when he could have done easily, the guest list is very small, the venue is very expensive, and the closeness between the stepchild and the stepuncle is unknown.

I wouldn’t want to pay a vast sum to host a child I didn’t know, when that place could be taken by an appreciate adult friend who I could celebrate with.

GOW56 · 20/04/2023 15:40

the more I think about it the cheekier it is that your husband is so annoyed about it when he didn't even invite his own brother to his wedding?!
I don't see how that is relevant when it was a totally different type of wedding with no guests other than parents.
OP is upset because as far as she, het child and hwe DH are concerned DH is her child's father. He doesn't have any other father figure. The lack of invitation for him where his sister's children have been invited demonstrates that the brother hasn't accepted the child as DHs child. That is hurtful

SavBlancTonight · 20/04/2023 15:38

Also, as I see it, the issue is not that your DC isn't invited. its that your DC isn't invited while other DC are! That's totally different to him being upset that he wasn't invited to your wedding.

LucifersLight · 20/04/2023 15:38

If I was your husband there is no way in hell I would go.
I would go so far as to never speak to my brother again.
I wouldn’t change my mind if they suddenly changed theirs either.

SavBlancTonight · 20/04/2023 15:37

treespouse · 20/04/2023 12:45

Do you see the brother regularly? Has he met your child more than a handful of times? Tbh I couldn't get too worked up about it (certainly not heartbroken) especially if I hadn't even invited this brother to my own wedding

My siblings live in different countries to me. None of us have spent a lot of time with the others' children due to distance. I would be absolutely devastated if my brother in one country chose to invite my nieces and nephews but not my DC to such an event.

I think your DH has the right of it - there should be a conversation. But I don't think you should be involved. I think he should take his brother out for a drink or something and discuss it. Explain how hurt he (your DH) is that the child he considers his own is being excluded because he doesn't share blood and that it has massively hurt you and, once this child finds out, will devastate him too.

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:37

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 15:34

The relationship between the stepchild and the BIL has not been spoken about. It’s relevant. If they don’t know each other, as suspected, why would they feel any loyalty to the child? They have a tiny guest list.

Your loyalty/the OP’s loyalty is not in question, I don’t think many posters think she should go as she’s so upset, but I don’t understand why it is so heinous that a child they don’t really know hasn’t been invited.

Of course, if it transpires they do know this child and are actually very close, that changes things. But somehow, I doubt that’s the case.

It is disrespectful to his brother. His sister's family get invited but his brother's family doesn't.

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 15:34

billy1966 · 20/04/2023 15:30

No it wouldn't, as loyalty is not an issue in THAT context.

Let me explain it for you.

One child has been left out.
THAT is the issue IMO.

ONE child in the family, that happens to be a step child to the grooms brother, the best man.

The earlier wedding has nothing to do with it🙄.
If it had, neither the OP nor her husband should be invited either.🙄

They have singled out one child and excluded them, when other nieces and nephews HAVE been invited.

It is their choice whom they invite, and I wouldn't dream of questioning THEIR choice of guests.

However, MY loyalty to MY child would mean, I wouldn't dream of attending a wedding, where my child was deemed not a member of a family where my husband was best man and brother of the groom.

Not a chance.

Loyalty to MY child would preclude me from attending.

The relationship between the stepchild and the BIL has not been spoken about. It’s relevant. If they don’t know each other, as suspected, why would they feel any loyalty to the child? They have a tiny guest list.

Your loyalty/the OP’s loyalty is not in question, I don’t think many posters think she should go as she’s so upset, but I don’t understand why it is so heinous that a child they don’t really know hasn’t been invited.

Of course, if it transpires they do know this child and are actually very close, that changes things. But somehow, I doubt that’s the case.

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:32

billy1966 · 20/04/2023 15:30

No it wouldn't, as loyalty is not an issue in THAT context.

Let me explain it for you.

One child has been left out.
THAT is the issue IMO.

ONE child in the family, that happens to be a step child to the grooms brother, the best man.

The earlier wedding has nothing to do with it🙄.
If it had, neither the OP nor her husband should be invited either.🙄

They have singled out one child and excluded them, when other nieces and nephews HAVE been invited.

It is their choice whom they invite, and I wouldn't dream of questioning THEIR choice of guests.

However, MY loyalty to MY child would mean, I wouldn't dream of attending a wedding, where my child was deemed not a member of a family where my husband was best man and brother of the groom.

Not a chance.

Loyalty to MY child would preclude me from attending.

Well put and I agree 100%.

billy1966 · 20/04/2023 15:30

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 14:50

If loyalty is important to you, you’d probably have invited them to your wedding then, wouldn’t you?

OP didn’t, though.

No it wouldn't, as loyalty is not an issue in THAT context.

Let me explain it for you.

One child has been left out.
THAT is the issue IMO.

ONE child in the family, that happens to be a step child to the grooms brother, the best man.

The earlier wedding has nothing to do with it🙄.
If it had, neither the OP nor her husband should be invited either.🙄

They have singled out one child and excluded them, when other nieces and nephews HAVE been invited.

It is their choice whom they invite, and I wouldn't dream of questioning THEIR choice of guests.

However, MY loyalty to MY child would mean, I wouldn't dream of attending a wedding, where my child was deemed not a member of a family where my husband was best man and brother of the groom.

Not a chance.

Loyalty to MY child would preclude me from attending.

Iwasafool · 20/04/2023 15:19

I wouldn't go and neither would my DH, we have 4 children but 2 of them happened to be born before we met. I didn't go to my sibling's wedding, we all have our line in the sand.

ScribblingPixie · 20/04/2023 15:16

He needs to get across the fact that he's not only upset on your DD's behalf, he's really hurt on his own behalf, because his brother's decision to invite the other children implies that his own version of a family is 'not good enough'.

I completely agree with this. Don't let this be about your DC or you. This is something for your DH and his brother to sort out, it's about their relationship.

Justalittlebitduckling · 20/04/2023 15:15

People say things like “it’s their wedding, they can do what they want” but in reality it does have long term implications for relationships. You and your DH are hurt by this and will continue to be.

cheekyffer · 20/04/2023 15:14

I would decline, it sends a terrible message to your child. I hope your husband also declines, difficult as it is, and tells his family it is because his new son is not invited and you come as a family or not at all.

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 15:14

My wedding to my husband was in a registry office with just our parents so the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours. from this I am guessing they see you on the periphery of their family and you see them likewise.

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 15:13

WinterDeWinter · 20/04/2023 14:59

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

I think the point you're making here is that he considers DSD to be the only child he will ever have and that the three of you are a family unit.

I think he needs to explain that to his brother - it doesn't sound as though he has done that yet?

He needs to get across the fact that he's not only upset on your DD's behalf, he's really hurt on his own behalf, because his brother's decision to invite the other children implies that his own version of a family is 'not good enough'.

I don't think the DSD being the only child he'll have is at all relevant and it makes it sound like the child is some kind of consolation prize.

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 15:11

You keep mentioning the venue as if that somehow makes it worse he isn't invited. Would you still feel as upset if it were a tiny wedding in a run down town hall?

LaylaLjungberg · 20/04/2023 15:10

I wish people wouldn’t take things out on children. This whole not your blood relative is so horrible. The kids don’t choose it and I don’t understand why people can’t just treat everyone well. This is from experience as that child.

melj1213 · 20/04/2023 15:09

YABU you have not answered the question of how much of a relationship your DS has with your DHs DB, probably because they don't have much of a relationship.

Presumably the DB has been in his nieces and nephews lives since birth and has a close bond with them which he doesn't have with your DS. It is not unreasonable for him to want those children there as part of their small celebration but not a teenager he hardly knows, especially if it is costing an arm and a leg.

I have 3 siblings - if I was to remarry and not invite any of them to my wedding then they would be very hurt and if any of them got married and didn't invite DD then I'd be hurt if other cousins were invited, but only because my siblings have been involved in DDs life since she was born.

I have aunts and uncles on my mum's side that I have seen on a weekly (if not more frequently) basis since I was born except when I lived abroad, and even then I'd make sure to visit when I came home and kept in contact regularly via phonecalls/WhatsApp/Social media etc.

I have an aunt on my dad's side that I have only seen a couple of times a year (at most) since I was about 5 as that's when she moved to the Highlands of Scotland. Dad and his sister aren't hugely close, they call maybe every 6weeks or so, and I've never really been close to her - she is the most lovely person, as is my uncle and my cousins, but I just don't have the close relationship with her that I do with my maternal aunts and uncles because I only ever saw them at Christmas and Easter, and since my dad's parents died (the reason for their visits) they don't even always visit every year now.

If any of my maternal aunts or uncles had got married and I wasn't invited I'd have been devastated as we are super close, but if my paternal aunt got married without inviting me then I'd probably have felt left out but not enough to be upset about it.

Beccy1990 · 20/04/2023 15:06

I don’t think it’s right that they haven’t invited the step nephew when all the bio nieces and nephews have been invited.

Wheresthebeach · 20/04/2023 15:00

Well I think you're stuck. You've asked - they've refused, and refused to add in if anyone drops out which I think is pretty shitty.

Very hard on your DH, having his family dismiss the role he is playing in your child's life. I do think it's reasonable for your DH to say he's upset that your child has been excluded when others are invited - but calmly, and to say that he views himself as the child's father but that obviously it's their choice who they invite. They may think he's asking on your behalf, not his own volition.

To avoid a complete fall out I'd send DH, and plan a nice day out with child. They've shown you how their view your child...you can't change that. I doubt its due to you not having them to your wedding - excluding a child as payback would be an insanely low thing to do.

WinterDeWinter · 20/04/2023 14:59

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

I think the point you're making here is that he considers DSD to be the only child he will ever have and that the three of you are a family unit.

I think he needs to explain that to his brother - it doesn't sound as though he has done that yet?

He needs to get across the fact that he's not only upset on your DD's behalf, he's really hurt on his own behalf, because his brother's decision to invite the other children implies that his own version of a family is 'not good enough'.